Home: The Second Story

Sheri Scott, Marilyn Moedinger

Everyone ​talks ​about ​how ​hard ​it ​is ​to ​do ​a ​major ​renovation ​or ​custom ​home ​building ​project, but we are here to take the guesswork and fear out of it. Join two veteran architects: Sheri Scott of Spring House Architects, and Marilyn Moedinger of Runcible Studios, as they sit down with folks who have been through the renovation or building process. Our guests will offer their best tips and tricks, and answer the key question: "What do you know NOW that you WISH you'd known when you started?"

  1. 3d ago

    What a Brooklyn Property Owner Learned The Hard Way

    We’re joined by Elliott, a Brooklyn property owner with years of experience renovating brownstones, for a conversation about spending wisely, planning ahead, and learning from past projects. His work ranges from replacing building systems to reworking kitchens and bathrooms. Those projects have taught him which improvements deserve the extra investment and which decisions can become expensive regrets. One early lesson came from excavating a basement. Elliott chose to dig out only half the space because completing the entire basement would have cost another $5,000. The contractor did the work well, but Elliott wishes he had found a way to finish it all at once. Looking back, that additional investment would have provided more usable space at a much lower cost than returning to the project later. That experience shapes how he approaches renovations today. When walls or ceilings are open, he considers what the building might need next. Additional electrical wiring, plumbing connections, and accessible shutoff valves can make future work easier. During one apartment turnover, he had only a few days to prepare for new tenants. Instead of installing an entire ductless heating and cooling system, he had the concealed lines installed so the remaining equipment could be added during a future vacancy. Elliott also shares how thoughtful changes help older apartments compete with newer buildings. Adding laundry or a dishwasher can make a meaningful difference for tenants. One bathroom renovation involved relocating fixtures to fit a compact washer and dryer without expanding the room. The improvement changed what the apartment offered while working within its existing footprint. Hiring the right people is another recurring theme. Elliott recommends interviewing multiple contractors, getting detailed written proposals, and checking references through completed projects whenever possible. Each conversation can teach a homeowner something useful. Comparing those explanations helps clarify the scope and leads to better questions. Material and appliance selections require similar thought. Appearance is only one part of the decision. Maintenance, repair costs, installation details, and availability all affect the finished project. Inspiration images can help communicate preferences, but turning those images into a working space requires experience. The conversation also highlights how renovation priorities change with the owner’s plans. A rental property, a home being prepared for sale, and a forever home involve different decisions. Understanding how long someone expects to stay can help determine where to invest and how much weight to give resale value. After the interview, Marilyn and Sheri return to the value of professional guidance. Homeowners can research products and collect ideas, but learning every technical detail takes time. An experienced team brings that knowledge to the project. Their takeaway is to think beyond the immediate renovation, communicate clearly, and make decisions that support how the space will be used for years to come. (00:00) Intro(03:25) The basement renovation Elliott would do differently(05:36) Planning electrical and plumbing for future projects(10:08) Why building systems deserve attention(12:21) Renovating between tenants(13:50) Contractor lessons and competing with new buildings(18:11) Interviewing contractors and comparing written proposals(19:53) Checking references and researching materials(22:53) Finding the right professional team(27:13) Fitting laundry into a small bathroom(30:50) Rental investments versus forever home decisions(34:08) Advice for first time renovators(37:42) Meet Priscilla(38:41) Marilyn and Sheri’s takeaways(42:12) Research, time, and the value of expertise Have questions? Want to be on our show? Email us! admin@htsspodcast.com Learn about our hosts: Marilyn: Runcible Studios: https://runciblestudios.com SherI: Springhouse Architects: https://springhousearchitects.com Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.

  2. Nov 10

    Challenges of Building a Home on A Hill

    We’re joined by Ashley, a homeowner in Strasburg, Pennsylvania, who shares what worked, what she would change, and why she still loves her home about a decade after moving in. Ashley and her husband initially searched for an existing house. That search eventually led them to build on wooded land with a steep, 600-foot driveway. Before purchasing the property, they brought their prospective builder out to evaluate it. They also confirmed that the land could support a septic system and well. Those early steps helped them understand what they were taking on. Still, the approval process brought surprises. Stormwater planning, township meetings, and additional reviews stretched the project timeline. The overall process lasted about 18 months, with the family moving in during December 2015. Ashley worked with a builder and designer to adapt an existing floor plan. Touring a home with that layout helped her picture how her family would use the space. Her priority was getting the structure and layout right. Fixtures and finishes could change later. The connected kitchen, breakfast nook, and living room remain some of her favorite parts of the house. Some material choices brought regrets. Ashley selected substantial trim because she knew replacing it later would be unlikely. But she wishes she had asked more questions about what that trim was made from. She also regrets accepting the recommended engineered hardwood without fully investigating solid oak flooring available through her father’s employer. Her experience reinforces the value of asking why a product is recommended and understanding the available alternatives. The exterior deserved more attention, too. Ashley wanted a new house with the character of an older home. Looking back, she would have spent more time studying the details and refining the front elevation instead of accepting familiar building conventions. Phasing the project helped the family focus its initial budget. The house, driveway, well, and septic system came first. A simple concrete slab served as the patio until they could create the outdoor space they wanted, including a fireplace, pergola, and pavers. The basement remains unfinished and works well as a place for the children to play sports. Family members and other homeowners provided useful second opinions throughout the process. Choosing a builder also involved more than comparing prices. Ashley considered workmanship, availability, communication, and willingness to handle the property’s challenges. Her biggest source of satisfaction is the setting. The privacy, wildlife, and room for her children to grow made the difficult site worthwhile. Her story is a reminder to understand the land before buying, invest in decisions that are difficult to change, and speak up when something matters. A home can keep evolving while serving a family well from the start. (00:00) Intro(02:01) Finding land and navigating township approvals(05:24) Adapting a builder’s floor plan(08:19) Trim materials and exterior design regrets(11:13) The flooring decision she would reconsider(14:14) Building in phases and setting priorities(18:49) Getting advice and reviewing the plans(22:26) Evaluating a challenging building site(25:29) Testing the land before buying(26:20) Choosing a builder beyond the price(30:53) What Ashley loves most about her home(32:44) Sheri and Marilyn’s takeaways(36:01) Waiting for the right property and speaking up(37:35) Exterior design and architectural expertise(40:35) Share your story and follow the show Have questions? Want to be on our show? Email us! admin@htsspodcast.com Learn about our hosts: Marilyn: Runcible Studios: https://runciblestudios.com SherI: Springhouse Architects: https://springhousearchitects.com Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.

  3. Nov 3

    Projects Without General Contractors

    A homeowner asked Marilyn whether she could act as the general contractor on a project. We use that question to explain what a general contractor does and what happens when an owner chooses a different arrangement. A general contractor hires and manages the specialists needed for the job. That includes checking subcontractors’ insurance, coordinating schedules, handling payments and keeping work moving between trades. Those gaps between trades matter. If a plumber needs blocking installed in a wall, someone has to arrange for it before the plumber can finish. A contractor’s established relationships can also affect pricing and availability. Marilyn cannot simply take on the general contractor role as an architect. It calls for different licenses and insurance. She could, in some circumstances, serve as a construction manager advisor or an owner’s representative. In that setup, the homeowner holds the contracts and pays the trades, while the advisor helps manage the work. The exact duties need to be clear in a separate agreement. An owner’s representative can also work alongside a general contractor on a larger project. We talk through why that arrangement might fit Marilyn’s client. The client has experience running projects but is busy, knows Marilyn well and has a project close to her office. If Marilyn also provides architectural services during construction, some duties would overlap. She would account for that overlap in her fees rather than charge twice for the same meeting or task. They have not decided how this project will proceed. The owner still takes on more responsibility when there is no general contractor. Renovations bring deliveries, schedule changes and problems that need quick decisions. Sheri shares a project where painters left after another crew arrived. Because she had a general contractor, she could call him to get the painters back and finish the work. Our advice is to choose the arrangement based on the people, their experience and the work involved. Interview anyone who would manage the project, understand the contract and be realistic about the owner’s role. Trying to save a contractor’s fee can cost more time and money if the team is unprepared.  (00:00) Intro(00:50) What a general contractor does(02:47) Coordinating subcontractors and the work between them(04:00) Construction manager advisors and owner’s representatives(06:18) How project roles can overlap(07:24) Why saving money is not the only consideration(08:40) Separate contracts and overlapping architect duties(10:30) Choosing someone with the right experience(11:42) The owner’s added responsibilities(14:28) A scheduling problem on Sheri’s project(16:03) Questions and guest invitations Have questions? Want to be on our show? Email us! admin@htsspodcast.com Learn about our hosts: Marilyn: Runcible Studios: https://runciblestudios.com SherI: Springhouse Architects: https://springhousearchitects.com Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.

  4. Oct 27

    Resale, Change Orders, and Designing for Real Life (Mailbag 5)

    We answer three homeowner questions that come up often during design and construction: how to handle change orders, how to design a house around real life, and how much resale value should influence personal design decisions. We start with an ADU owner who has received several change orders, including a $7,000 increase for tile and fixtures selected from the builder's own options. We explain that allowances need to be realistic and itemized from the beginning. A single $52,000 finish allowance does not tell an owner whether the budget for plumbing, lighting, appliances, tile, or other finishes is reasonable. When a change order arrives, it should also be written and itemized clearly enough for the owner to understand what changed and why. We also stress that owners should not feel pressured into approving changes immediately or agreeing verbally because of schedule concerns. Taking time to understand the cost is reasonable. When several change orders have already appeared, it can be helpful to sit down with the contractor, review the past changes, understand the current one, and ask what additional changes may still be coming. Homeowners should also understand the consumer protection requirements that apply in their state and make sure payments remain connected to work actually completed. Our second question is about designing for real life instead of designing from attractive images. We explain that homeowners do not need to arrive at an architect's office with every answer. A large part of the design process is figuring out how people actually live. That includes when they work, how they entertain, how they exercise, whether guests stay overnight, what pets need, and how spaces might need to change over time. We also talk about inspiration images. The important question is not simply whether someone likes a photo. It is what they like about it. The answer might be the light, materials, layout, color, or relationship between spaces. Images of things people dislike can be just as useful. AI generated images require additional caution because they may show rooms or proportions that could not actually work in a real building. Finally, we consider resale. We believe a home should first support the people living in it. If someone expects to stay for many years, personal finishes do not always need to be selected around a future buyer. There is a difference, however, between a distinctive tile choice and a fundamental layout decision that limits how the house can function. The bones of the house deserve more consideration. Finishes can be more personal. (00:00) Intro(00:13) ADU contractor change orders(03:05) Why allowances should be itemized(05:23) Do not rush to approve a change order(06:58) When builder option lists exceed the budget(09:12) Having a clear the deck meeting with your contractor(10:27) Consumer protections and homeowner leverage(12:27) How to design a home for real life(13:23) Why homeowners do not need everything figured out(16:50) Balancing specific needs with flexible spaces(18:47) What does entertaining actually mean?(20:00) How architects use inspiration images(21:33) The problem with AI generated design images(23:05) How much should resale matter?(26:53) Personal finishes versus major layout decisions(29:11) Designing for yourself while protecting the home's bones(30:17) First floor primary bedrooms and aging in place Have questions? Want to be on our show? Email us! admin@htsspodcast.com Learn about our hosts: Marilyn: Runcible Studios: https://runciblestudios.com SherI: Springhouse Architects: https://springhousearchitects.com Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.

  5. Oct 20

    Who Owns Your Architect's Design?

    A homeowner does not need a finished plan before calling an architect. In this snack-sized episode of Home: The Second Story, we start with a Springhouse Architects client who knew they wanted to change their home but could not yet say what problem they were trying to solve. We walked through the house with them, learned how their family uses it, and developed a master plan. After considering several ideas and pricing different options, the clients chose a porch addition. It would give them outdoor space and change the front of the house without committing to a larger renovation. That decision took months. Once they were ready to move ahead, though, they wanted drawings quickly. Our schedule put the work about six weeks out, so they found someone who could do it in two. We agreed to release the porch design. That outcome raises two useful points. First, the time spent considering a larger renovation was still valuable. The clients could move forward knowing they had examined the alternatives and chosen what made sense for their home and budget. Those decisions affect daily life and finances, so it is reasonable to give them time. At the same time, an architect may be working on other projects by the time a client is ready for the next step. Second, changing professionals after design work begins calls for a direct conversation. We explain that clients hire an architect for services, while drawings are generally provided for use on a specific project under the terms of their agreement. Paying for the work does not automatically mean receiving the CAD files or the right to take a design elsewhere. In this case, the client asked, and we found a solution that worked for both sides. Other arrangements should be discussed with the architect before anyone uses the work. The best time to ask how drawings, files, and design rights will be handled is at the start of a project. A good architect can also help you work through the bigger question: what should you build in the first place? If you have a question, a topic idea, or an interest in joining us as a guest, we would love to hear from you. (00:00) Intro(00:29) A renovation plan becomes a porch addition(03:40) Why another professional took on the drawings(04:10) When to bring an architect into the conversation(05:32) The value of considering your options(06:14) Why major home decisions take time(08:00) Taking an architect’s design elsewhere(09:35) What clients receive when they hire an architect(12:40) Custom designs and reusable details(13:36) Discussing design rights up front  Have questions? Want to be on our show? Email us! admin@htsspodcast.com Learn about our hosts: Marilyn: Runcible Studios: https://runciblestudios.com SherI: Springhouse Architects: https://springhousearchitects.com Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.

  6. Oct 13

    The Cost of Not Speaking Up During a Build

    In this episode of Home: The Second Story, Sheri Scott and Marilyn Moedinger talk with Jenn, a homeowner in Farmersville, Ohio, who built a custom home on 10 acres near Dayton. Jenn’s project moved quickly. The build took about eight months, and the whole process from plans to move-in was about 10 months. Jenn had a unique perspective because she works for Sheri at Springhouse Architects. She did not go through the full architecture process in the usual way. Looking back, she says she would have paid for the full experience. She saw firsthand how much architects help clients think through details, communicate with builders, and avoid problems before they happen. One of Jenn’s biggest lessons was that she should have written down the specific things she wanted before design began. She had ideas in her head, but the speed of the project and the stress of decisions made some of them easy to forget. The biggest example was her primary suite. She wanted the bathroom, closet, and laundry to work together in a more efficient layout. She remembered this early enough to change it, but she did not speak up because she felt guilty asking for more help from people who were giving her discounts or favors. This became a major theme of the conversation. Working with friends or professional contacts can be helpful, but it can also make the relationship harder to manage. Jenn says she would have defined the relationship earlier. When discussing the project, she would want the roles to be client and architect or client and builder. Then they could return to being friends outside of that process. Jenn also talks about making selections herself, including tile, cabinets, lighting, and custom wood countertops made from trees cut down on their property. The countertops became one of her favorite parts of the house, though there was a stressful moment when the island was installed without the seating overhang she had planned. The woodworker was able to fix it, but Sheri points out that full architectural services could have caught that issue through shop drawings before installation. The episode also covers the end of the build. Jenn’s project stayed close to budget except for additions they chose, but the schedule became stressful. She and her family were renting, had to move belongings around, and eventually needed the builder to finish quickly so they would not be without a place to live. Sheri and Marilyn use that story to stress how important it is to ask builders how their projects finish, not just how they start. (00:00) Intro(01:20) Working With an Architect You Know(04:25) What Jenn Would Do Differently(06:56) The Primary Suite Regret(10:27) How Discounts and Friendships Changed the Process(13:07) Defining the Client Relationship Early(15:51) Making Selections Without Full Services(20:34) The Island Overhang Mistake(23:16) How Full Services Could Have Helped(24:18) The Value of a Third Party Advocate(27:20) Budget, Schedule, and the End of the Build(32:19) Why Project Closeout Matters(34:46) Jenn’s Favorite Part of the House(36:30) Sheri and Marilyn’s Recap Have questions? Want to be on our show? Email us! admin@htsspodcast.com Learn about our hosts: Marilyn: Runcible Studios: https://runciblestudios.com SherI: Springhouse Architects: https://springhousearchitects.com Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.

  7. Oct 6

    Built-Ins: Design, Costs, and Fun Ideas

    Built-ins are one of the most loved parts of a custom home, and for good reason. They are furniture, cabinetry, shelving, storage, and architectural features that become part of the house itself. Kitchen cabinets and bathroom vanities count, but when most people talk about built-ins, they mean the fun pieces: bookcases, mudroom storage, pantry systems, bars, room dividers, fireplace walls, hidden doors, and custom storage moments. A good built-in solves more than one problem. Sometimes it hides structure, a chase, or a mechanical need. Other times it turns an awkward space into something useful. In older homes, tight townhouses, and renovations where adding square footage is not possible, built-ins can make every inch work harder. Storage can be hidden in plain sight, so board games, extra blankets, shoes, bathroom supplies, and pantry items all have a place without cluttering the room. Custom built-ins are especially helpful when they are designed around the way people actually live. A mudroom drop zone can include a place for mail and a shredder. A narrow wall can become a shallow can pantry. Eaves can become dressers. A hallway can be lined with closets. A finished basement closet can be sized around storage tubs instead of default dimensions. These details are small, but they make the home easier to use every day. Built-ins can also add flexibility. One small apartment used a single custom wall to hold a Murphy bed, dining chair storage, folding screens, a laptop station, a printer, and hidden HVAC. That one built-in allowed the space to work as a guest room, office, dining room, and party space. It was not cheap, but it made the apartment live much larger than its square footage. The episode also looks at cost. Built-ins are often one of the first things cut from a project because they can be done later, but they often do not get added later. Some built-ins need to be planned early, especially pocket gates, hidden doors, fireplace walls, or anything built into framing. Others can be discovered during construction, especially in renovations, when an odd leftover space becomes ski storage, a cubby, or a secret kid fort. The main point is that built-ins should support real life. They can be simple or elaborate. They can be made by a cabinet shop or built on site by a finish carpenter. They can serve kids, pets, storage, work, entertaining, or daily routines. With thoughtful planning, built-ins make a house feel more personal, more useful, and more fun. (00:00) Intro (01:10) Built-ins as part of the architecture (02:22) Functional built-ins for pantries and mudrooms (03:45) Storage in plain sight (05:51) Built-ins that replace furniture (06:27) Cost and why built-ins get cut (09:51) Hallway closets and hidden storage (10:30) Custom dimensions for real storage needs (12:51) Kid forts, pet storage, and secret compartments (15:00) Simple built-ins versus custom cabinetry (16:47) Planning ahead for built-ins (18:04) Custom projects and discoveries during construction (19:48) Built-ins as creative design moments (20:30) Personal details that support daily life Have questions? Want to be on our show? Email us! admin@htsspodcast.com Learn about our hosts: Marilyn: Runcible Studios: https://runciblestudios.com SherI: Springhouse Architects: https://springhousearchitects.com Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.

  8. Sep 29

    The Kitchen Was Perfect. The Process Wasn't.

    Homeowner Beth joins us with her designer Linda to talk about a kitchen renovation that turned out beautifully, even though the process was far more difficult than expected. Beth had lived in her Lancaster, Pennsylvania home for 29 years and had wanted to remove the wall between her small kitchen and dining room for a long time. Once her husband agreed, she and Linda began interviewing builders. Beth chose the builder who seemed calm, reasonable, and willing to listen. The initial pricing was also lower than the other quotes. Problems started once design began. Beth believed the builder would provide design support, but the person presented as the designer  did not provide the comprehensive kitchen design Beth expected. Beth and Linda arrived with mood boards, colors, and clear ideas, but felt those preferences were largely ignored. The proposed layout prioritized symmetry instead of the functionality Beth wanted. She and Linda eventually realized they would need to design much of the kitchen themselves. Budgeting added another layer of stress. The final number jumped about $40,000 above the original estimate before Beth had even made many selections. She also kept hearing that items she had requested from the beginning, including finishes without stainless steel, could be upgrades. The lack of clear allowances and coordination made it difficult to understand what was included and where different selections needed to be made. One bright spot was the appliance salesperson. He listened, understood Beth's budget, and helped her find the creamy white appliances and double ovens she wanted without exceeding the appliance allowance. That experience showed what the rest of the process could have been. Clear communication, a defined budget, and someone willing to work through alternatives made the experience enjoyable. Construction moved quickly and was completed on schedule, but Beth still felt she became the general contractor. She and her husband had to coordinate trades, solve problems, track installations, and make sure decisions were implemented. At one point, Beth learned that an appliance installation shown on the project schedule had never actually been arranged! Fortunately, the kitchen itself is now everything Beth wanted. It includes a bar displaying her collection of 1950s and 1960s glassware, gold details, a coffee bar, a banquette, wallpaper, double ovens, and a layout built around how she actually cooks and lives. The result feels personal, glamorous, and highly functional. Our biggest takeaway is that homeowners need to understand exactly what “design included” means. A builder arranging appointments with cabinet, appliance, and plumbing vendors is not the same as having someone manage the entire design. A good architect or designer looks across the whole project, coordinates selections, balances the budget, and makes sure individual decisions work together. Beth ultimately got the kitchen she wanted because she stayed involved, stood her ground, and had Linda beside her throughout the process. But when firends ask her who did her kitchen, she won't share the name. While the end result was the kitchen of her dreams, she wouldn't want anyone else to go through the same trials and tribulations of that process. (00:00) Intro (00:28) Beth's Lancaster Kitchen Renovation (06:54) The Promised Designer (07:27) Mood Boards and Design Ideas Get Ignored (09:37) Linda Steps Into the Design Role (11:09) Custom Builder vs. Custom Kitchen (11:35) The Budget Jumps by $40,000 (16:15) Choosing Fixtures, Sinks, and Appliances (19:00) The One Vendor Who Made the Process Fun (20:35) Fighting to Keep the Double Ovens (23:08) Beth Becomes the General Contractor (24:06) Being a Woman on the Job Site (26:02) Making Every Selection Before Construction (28:58) Why the Project Succeeded Anyway (31:14) What Beth Would Tell Other Homeowners (33:28) The Bandwidth Required for Renovation (34:51) Beth's Favorite Kitchen Details (37:09) Marilyn and Sheri Debrief (38:35) Why “Design Included” Can Be a Red Flag (40:08) The Problem With Disconnected Showroom Decisions (41:49) Why the Renovation Process Should Have Been Fun (43:07) Why Homeowners Need to Stand Their Ground (44:50) Would an Architect Have Cost More? (45:30) Closing Thoughts Have questions? Want to be on our show? Email us! admin@htsspodcast.com Learn about our hosts: Marilyn: Runcible Studios: https://runciblestudios.com SherI: Springhouse Architects: https://springhousearchitects.com Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.

Trailer

Ratings & Reviews

5
out of 5
9 Ratings

About

Everyone ​talks ​about ​how ​hard ​it ​is ​to ​do ​a ​major ​renovation ​or ​custom ​home ​building ​project, but we are here to take the guesswork and fear out of it. Join two veteran architects: Sheri Scott of Spring House Architects, and Marilyn Moedinger of Runcible Studios, as they sit down with folks who have been through the renovation or building process. Our guests will offer their best tips and tricks, and answer the key question: "What do you know NOW that you WISH you'd known when you started?"

You Might Also Like