My Sister Made Me Watch This

Michelle
  • 4.3 (4)
  • TV REVIEWS

Sisters Michelle and Cherie revisit TV shows and movies from their childhood and their different perspectives on them. As the older sister, Cherie most often controlled the television and subjected Michelle to shows that she would never have chosen to watch on her own.

Episodes

  1. 1D AGO

    028 Holiday Movie Hall of Fame: White Christmas and Why We Still Love It

    It’s officially the holiday season, and that means one thing: White Christmas 🎄 This week on My Sister Made Me Watch This, sisters Michelle and Cherie dive into the 1954 holiday musical classic Irving Berlin’s White Christmas, starring Bing Crosby, Danny Kaye, Rosemary Clooney, and Vera-Ellen. We talk about: Why White Christmas has outlasted Holiday InnDanny Kaye’s improvised comedy and the iconic “Sisters” numberThe magic of Technicolor and VistaVisionBob Fosse’s uncredited choreography (yes, that Bob Fosse)Edith Head’s legendary costumes and all the swishy dressesVera-Ellen’s astonishing dancing (and why she’s always in scarves)That one plot hole that could’ve been solved with a single conversationAsbestos snow (😬), overheated velvet costumes, and behind-the-scenes triviaWhy this movie should never be remadeWe also ask the big questions:  👉 Does White Christmas still hold up today? 👉 Is Bing Crosby’s version of the song the ultimate Christmas recording? 👉 And why does Rosemary Clooney just… leave?! Whether this movie is a yearly tradition or a holiday blind spot, we’re breaking down why White Christmas remains one of the most beloved Christmas movies of all time. 🎶 Grab some cocoa, admire the costumes, and join us for a festive deep dive into a true holiday classic.

    50 min

  2. DEC 18

    027 Why We Watch Christmas Vacation Every Year (And Always Will)

    In this very festive and very fresh episode, sisters Michelle and Cherie revisit one of their most cherished holiday traditions: watching National Lampoon’s Christmas Vacation together. Having just watched it the night before recording (birthday tradition alert!), they break down why this 1989 classic continues to resonate more than three decades later. They talk favorite moments (Aunt Bethany forever), unforgettable characters like Cousin Eddie, and the surprisingly emotional beats that keep the chaos grounded. Along the way, they unpack behind‑the‑scenes trivia, including John Hughes’ original short story, the casting that almost was, and how this film fits into the larger Vacation universe. Michelle and Cherie also have a little fun poking holes in the logic—Clark trapped in the attic, that massive Christmas tree, the bonus math that simply doesn’t math—but ultimately agree that suspension of disbelief is part of the joy. From Betty Boop connections to Big Bang Theory revelations, Griswold‑level decorations to why this movie still works for younger generations, this episode is a cozy, laugh‑filled love letter to one of the most quoted Christmas movies of all time. So grab some eggnog (watch the plugs), cue up the theme song, and settle in—because it’s Christmas Vacation season.

    46 min

  3. DEC 11

    026: From Dickens to Kermit: How The Muppet Christmas Carol Became a Holiday Classic

    In this festive episode, Michelle and Cherie unwrap one of the most beloved holiday films ever made — The Muppet Christmas Carol. Cherie reveals her firsthand experience working on the film’s production (yes, really!), sharing incredible behind-the-scenes stories about the creation of the Ghost of Christmas Present, technical puppet wizardry, and what it was like in the New York Muppet Workshop in 1992. The sisters dive into: The surprising origins of The Muppet Christmas Carol — it almost wasn’t a theatrical film!Why Brian Henson’s directorial debut was a heartfelt tribute to his father, Jim Henson.The song “When Love Is Gone” and why it was cut from the original release (and where to find it now).Fun facts about Kermit’s first full-body walking scene, hidden Easter eggs, and Michael Caine’s dead-serious (and brilliant) Scrooge.Plus: a side trip to Emmet Otter’s Jug-Band Christmas, Disney castles, and why Miss Piggy’s gloves matter.Warm, witty, and packed with Muppet magic, this episode is the perfect companion for your holiday movie marathon. 🎄 Available now wherever you get your podcasts. Keywords: Muppet Christmas Carol, Jim Henson, Brian Henson, Michael Caine, Christmas movies, Muppets, behind the scenes, Emmet Otter, holiday classics, Disney Plus, When Love Is Gone, Paul Williams

    39 min

  4. DEC 4

    025 Is This the Ultimate Twin Movie? A Sisterly Look Back at The Parent Trap

    In this nostalgic episode, Michelle and Cherie finally dive into one of Michelle’s all-time favorite comfort movies — the original 1961 Walt Disney classic, The Parent Trap, starring Haley Mills… and Haley Mills.  We revisit the twin-swapping plot, the summer-camp chaos, and the still-impressive split-screen effects that made Disney history. Michelle shares her lifelong love for the film (and her daughter’s strategic willingness to watch it when she wants to get on Mom’s good side), while Cherie recalls being mesmerized by the technology even as a kid.  Together, we unpack:  ✨ The real story behind the movie — including the German children’s book it was based on 🎬 Disney’s early split-screen tech and how The Parent Trap pushed it further ⭐ Hollywood drama you never knew — like Maureen O’Hara losing top billing and vowing never to work with Disney again 🎵 The Sherman Brothers’ first-ever Disney film score 🏡 The California ranch everyone wrote letters about 📚 Hayley Mills’ behind-the-scenes revelations 🎭 Other iconic double-role performances from Patty Duke, Elizabeth Montgomery, Eddie Murphy, and even Dove Cameron 🎥 The 1998 remake — why Michelle (a self-professed film purist) still begrudgingly admits it’s good 🐴 And yes… how badly we both wanted to live on Mitch Evers’ California ranch  We also talk about:  – why 1960s camp apparently included formal dances  – the curious hostility of Susan’s cabin-mates  – the very real twin friends who introduced Michelle to the film  – a classmate who may or may not have claimed she was living The Parent Trap in real life  Does the 1961 film hold up today? We think so — especially with its gorgeous California scenery, charming performances, and surprisingly fresh comedic timing.  Grab your peanut butter and jelly on saltines (you know you want to), settle into your metaphorical ranch house, and join us for a double-dose of nostalgia.

    42 min

  5. NOV 27

    024 How Zorro the Gay Blade Ages in 2025: Representation, Humor & Swordplay

    In this episode of My Sister Made Me Watch This, Michelle and Cherie go full swashbuckler as they revisit the 1981 parody film Zorro the Gay Blade — a movie Cherie remembers fondly for its swordplay and costumes, and a movie Michelle… barely remembers at all. Together, the sisters break down: George Hamilton’s double performance as Don Diego and his flamboyant twin Ramon (“Bunny” if you insist, but Michelle refuses).The Errol Flynn influence, classic Hollywood swashbucklers, and how this film parodies the genre.The surprisingly impressive costuming and sword choreography — including why Cherie owns a whip and how that shaped Michelle’s childhood trauma.The use of split-screen twin technology that was everywhere in late-70s/early-80s productions.Lauren Hutton’s role, the supporting cast, and all the nostalgic Hollywood connections.Whether the film is more offensive to the LGBTQ+ community… or the Hispanic community. (Spoiler: we have thoughts.)Why this is definitely a movie that would not be made today.And whether younger generations — including Michelle’s 20-year-old son — would have any idea who Zorro even is anymore.The sisters also dive into the film’s legacy, how it fits into early-80s comedy, and how their own generation can appreciate the movie while still cringing through certain moments. Is Zorro the Gay Blade worth watching in 2025? We break it down with humor, honesty, and just a sprinkle of gold lamé. If you enjoy the show, please leave us a 5-star rating and review! It helps other podcast listeners find us.

    40 min
  • 5 Episodes

Ratings & Reviews

4.3
out of 5
4 Ratings

About

Sisters Michelle and Cherie revisit TV shows and movies from their childhood and their different perspectives on them. As the older sister, Cherie most often controlled the television and subjected Michelle to shows that she would never have chosen to watch on her own.

Information