The Murder Record

Kelley Amstutz

Discover expert tips, research tools, and inspiring stories to help you explore your family history and bring your ancestors to life. thegenealogyinvestigator.substack.com

  1. 12/12/2024

    THE MURDER RECORD: Desperate Man-killers - PART 1

    DESPERATE MAN-KILLERS (a.k.a. Bloody Riot) Our story takes place on March 25, 1899 when our parties are leaving the office of Justice Burgoon, where they just had a case on trial. Our criminal(s) are: John and Paul Zeltner, German Immigrant brothers who shot and killed in cold-blood Attorney E. S. Westenhaver of North Baltimore in Hoytsville, Wood County, Ohio. The murder was a result of money owed to Attorney Westenhaver by the Zeltners' for attorney fees. The Genealogy Investigator is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. Newspaper: The Daily Sentinel-Tribune - Sat. 25 Mar 1899, Page 1 Link: https://www.newspapers.com/image/882570694/?match=1&terms=%22Paul%20Zeltner%22 Clipping: 16 Mar 1899 (Thursday) BLOODY RIOT Headline: “Bloody Riot” Rampant in Wood County and Lynching Probable. Saturday evening, Governor Bushnell in response to an appeal for aid made by Sheriff Kingsbury of Wood County ordered the Toledo volunteers commanded by Captain A. D. James to Hoytsville, Wood County, to prevent mob law. Conflicting Dates as to WHEN this happened - some state 25 Mar 1899??? The trouble was the outcome of the cold-blooded murder at Hoytsville, Saturday at noon, when E. S. Westenhaver, of North Baltimore, a promising lawyer and Democratic politician, was shot and killed by Paul and John Zeltner. The murdered man was trying a case before the justice of the peace BURGOON in which Zeltners were defendants in a suit for attorney’s fees. After the adjournment of the court John Zeltner demanded certain papers of Westenhaver, Westenhaver had letters in his pocket which the latter refused. Thereupon Zeltner [demanded] drew a revolver and shot the attorney in the arm in the side. As the wounded ran screaming from the room four more shots were fired at him, but none took effect. Westenhaver turned to escape, and as he ran Zeltner fired a second shot and the bullet grazed his head. Upon turning a corner a few yards away the doomed man ran up against Paul Zeltner, who also had a revolver and opened fire at close range into the fleeing man’s breast the first ball entering his arm and the second shot penetrating the forehead and causing death a few minutes later. THE SHOT WAS FATAL! The Zeltners coolly mounted their horses and loaded their revolvers in the presence of an angry crowd. They then rode away toward their home five miles away. The news spread like wildfire. W. G. Elliott, of Bloomdale, was in Bowling Green and expected to be present at the office of Justice Burgoon at Hoytsville in the afternoon to testify on behalf of fees to which the latter was entitled in the case on trial. Shortly after the shooting of Mr. Westenhaver he received a telephone message from Attorney E. D.Bloom, also a witness, for some purpose in the case. Mr. Bloom recounted the following story to Mr. Elliott of the terrible affair: The court had just adjourned for noon, and Mr. Westenhaver, Mr. Bloom and one or two others were standing talking over the matter when Mr. John Zeltner stepped up and asked Mr. Westenhaver for some papers. The latter’s response was that he would give them to him as soon as he was through with them. Without further controversy Zeltner pulled a revolver out and shot Westenhaver in the breast. The latter ran out of the squire’s office and across the lot, when he fell. Zeltner fired a second shot, which struck him in the arm after he had fallen. A third shot was fired, but whether it struck the already mortally wounded man was not known. The Zeltner brothers had their horses in a nearby barn. When they had completed their deadly work they ran to their horses, secured them, and struck out into the country. The particulars of the affair leading up to the lawsuit were in brief as follows: The Zeltners employed Mr. Westenhaver some time ago as counsel in a case which they settled before it came to a final issue. They refused to pay him for his services. He finally brought suit to recover $100 as his fees. The case was in progress of trial when the terrible shooting affray and murder took place. Another story of the murder says that the court had convened, sworn into service a jury and one or two witnesses had been examined. Mr. Westenhaver had introduced some papers as testimony in the case, which are said to be the letters that the Zeltners had written to him concerning the previous case. It appears that the letters were very damaging testimony against the Zeltners, and when the court had adjourned for dinner they asked to be given the letters. Mr. Westenhaver refused them, and John Zeltner drew a pistol and shot at him four (4) times. One bullet struck Mr. Westenhaver in the side, and was the fatal shot. He ran out and fell a short distance from the squire’s office. While fleeing, Paul Zeltner fired several shots at him, one of which struck him in the arm. The Zeltners then jumped on their horses which were not far away, and took to the country. The outraged citizens quickly grasped the situation and organized a posse started in pursuit. Deputy Sheriff Andy Roach responded to a telegram calling for the sheriff, and arrived at Hoytsville shortly after noon. Around 2:30 PM a large posse of citizens from both Hoytsville and Deshler gathered in the vicinity of the Zeltner home. The Zeltners lived about two miles northwest from Hoytsville. When they reached the Zeltners’ home they found it barricaded and the murderers and a hired man armed to fight. Neighbors warned the crowds to keep at a safe distance, as the Zeltners have two Winchester rifles which they threatened to use in case the pursuers approached their place. They refused to surrender and after much parlaying the feelings of the people maddened by the desperation of the men, an assault was made on the house and several volleys from each side were fired. In this one of the posse a young man from Hoytsville, Mr. Clarence Weidmeyer, was shot through the brain and killed by the Zeltner firing. The Zeltners were fortified, however and held their own. In the meantime the crowd surrounding them had reached hundreds and the excitement was intense. They threatened to lynch the men, and it is this state of affairs that led the sheriff to ask for aid. The company was to reach the scene at midnight. The Zeltners say they will surrender IF given protection from the MOB. The Zeltners have some reputation as quarrelsome persons and are known to be determined men, as the actions yesterday inculcate. The Zeltner family came to the Bowling Green area five (5) years ago from Germany, where they were German sharpshooters. The brothers went to the trial fully armed and had ammunition at home for continued fusillades, keeping up constant firing the rest of the day and night while barricaded in the home. Before the arrival of the troops during the night, a cannon used in shooting oil tanks when they were on fire and a quantity of nitro-glycerine had been secured so there would have been trouble after sunrise if the troops had not arrived. The Zeltner brothers and their families were no doubt saved by the prompt arrival of the troops under the orders of Governor Bushnell. The Bloomdale militia company reached the neighborhood of the Zeltners home at 1:30 AM. It found the MOB of citizens had pickets posted and were opposing all approaches to the house. On challenge by the captain of the company a reply in the nature of a volley from revolvers was sent. The troops were withdrawn a short distance so that a temporary truce was declared. It was stated that about 5:30 on Sunday Morning, ex-sheriff Riggs, accompanied by a neighbor named Brown, started towards the house. They walked the distance alone. The Zeltners offered no resistance to their approach and they were admitted to the house. Mr. Riggs told them that the militia was ready to make an attack on the house and that they would be compelled to surrender and they had better give up peacefully. The Zeltners seemed not disposed at first to give up and said they feared the mob which remained outside of the militia lines. They tried to induce Mr. Riggs to accompany them through the timber, but he refused and they were told they would not be molested if they gave up their arms and accompanied him to the jail. After half an hour’s talk, they finally agreed. The desperados were captured by the troops, but also protected from violence from the crowd, surrendered to the sheriff on Sunday morning (March 12, 1899), and under protection of the Military were safely landed in the Bowling Green jail, which is a distance of over 20 miles from the Zeltner home. Two women and four children were also barricaded in the Zeltner home and as a side note the Zeltner transferred their farms and other property a few days prior to the shooting to Mrs. John Zeltner. The murdered attorney is the grandson of Harry Westenhaver, one of the pioneers of Hocking county. He was a young man of excellent promise, and the recent law pardner of Mr. Cart Bright of Logan, Wood County, Ohio. 27 Mar 1899 (Monday) LANDED IN JAIL Newspaper: The Akron Beacon Journal Monday, 27 Mar 1899 | Page 2 https://www.newspapers.com/image/228092891/?match=1&terms=%22Paul%20Zeltner%22 “LANDED IN JAIL” Pair of Desperadoes Surrender to OHIO MILITIA Murdered a Lawyer Then They Held a Mob at Bay for Several Hours BARRICADED THEIR HOUSE. While Entrenched in their home one of the besieging party was shot and killed by one of the brothers who had fortified themselves. 28 Mar 1899 - The Cincinnati Post - Tue | Page 4 https://www.newspapers.com/image/761090582/?match=1&terms=%22Paul%20Zeltner%22 30 Mar 1899 From The Daily Sentinel-Tribune | Bowling Green, Ohio | TH Mar 30 1899 | Page 1 https://www.newspapers.com/image/882570779/?match=1&terms=%22Paul%20Zeltner%22 Headline: $10,000 DAMAGES Suit Filed by Mrs. Westenhaver to Recover From the Zeltner Brothers Arsula E. Westenhaver, as administratrix of Elia

    57 min
  2. 11/14/2024

    The Murder Record

    As many of you know… I started a PODCAST, The Murder Record - and ran that (with old episodes here) for a year and a half before taking a bit of a break. We all LOVE true-crime and I just can’t seem to put it down — so I am taking the Podcast and putting a bit of a spin on things with The Murder Record Thursdays - to mix things up. But, don’t hesitate to click the button below and let me know if you LIKE or DISLIKE. YOU matter to me and I want to ensure I am putting great content out that you WANT to read! Let’s DIVE in… (the video is above - so you can always WATCH if you wish!) A BRUTAL WIFE-MURDER Our story was originally published in the Toledo Weekly Blade, Toledo, Ohio on November 9th, 1882. The fate of a Young Wife who had Left her Husband Because of his Cruelty Special to the Blade. Clyde, Ohio - November 4, 1882 John Radford, living between Clyde and Bellevue, shot his wife this afternoon. (Nov 4) She had left him about two weeks ago, on account of cruel treatment, and had gone home to her father’s house. He went there this afternoon and broke down two doors, dragged her out into the yard and shot her twice, once in the wrist and once in the head, killing her instantly. She leaves three small children. He started west, but was overtaken and lodged in Fremont jail. He will probably get clear on the insanity dodge. After reading this… the next story continues… Bellevue, Ohio - November 4, 1882 This town was thrown into most intense excitement this afternoon about 3:30 by the announcement that there had been a murder committed in our midst. Your correspondent proceeded immediately to the scene, and there a sight met his eyes that he wished never to se again. On the ground, a few feet from a door of the house, lay the beautiful form of Annie, wife of John Radford, with a bullet hole through her right wrist and another through the right temple, from which the blood was oozing in a clotted mass. The coroner arrived at the same time, and learning that there had been witnesses to the sad affair deemed an inquest unnecessary, and her lifeless form was borne into the house that she had left but a few minutes before in the prime of health. Owing to the cruel and unnatural treatment of the husband of the murdered woman, she was compelled to leave him about four weeks ago and was staying with her parents, who lived nearly opposite their old home. She had recently applied for a divorce, but previous to that time had had an injunction placed on the property to prohibit his disposing of any of it. This morning the murderer, John Radford, went to Fremont, and while there had the papers served on him notifying him of these facts. He returned on the noon train and proceeded to go home. From there he crossed over to where his wife was stopping, knocked on the door, and not gaining admission, began kicking in the panels, and at this his wife came out. He grabbed her by the arm, knocked her down, placed the revolver at her head, and as she threw up her right arm it received the first shot. He then, placing the revolver so close to her right temple that it burned her skin, fired the fatal shot. He was seen to get up and coolly walk out of the gate, stopping to look back a second as if to make sure of his work. Then before going further he picked the two empty shells out of the revolver, placing it in his pocket, and ran across a field until he struck the railroad track and then started west. The news by this time so aroused the people that they by the hundreds, accompanied by the officers, started in pursuit of the fugitive. Jerry Korner, the Constable, overtook him about four miles west and demanded his surrender. He complied gracefully, and said, “Take me to Fremont quick.” Upon getting into the buggy previous to starting, Radford said, “Is she dead?” Being answered in the affirmative, he then replied, “I thought so, I gave her two good ones and I am glad of it.” He was taken to Fremont and now lies in the County Jail to await his trial. The murdered woman leaves two beautiful little girls, aged seven and three, to mourn the loss of their mother. And the story continues… Fremont, Ohio - November 5, 1882 Your correspondent called at the jail this afternoon to see John Radford, the man who murdered his wife at Bellevue yesterday afternoon. He was walking around with his hat on smoking a cigar, and appeared calm. He asked for a Sunday Leader, and being handed one he sat down and read the account of the murder. He remarked to another prisoner that they “gave it a hell of a head.” When asked if he had anything to say about it, he said there was not a bit of truth to it. “My name is Radford, but there must be another John Radford.” He asked to keep the paper and your correspondent left. He has been very reticent, and would give no satisfactory answer to questions. Everything was quiet around the jail last night. So, if you know me …. you know I NEED to know more about WHAT happened to John Radford… Don’t worry - I have more to this story for you: From The Weekly Jeffersonian - Th, 23 Nov 1882 (Page 3) BOUND OVER John Radford, who murdered his wife at Bellevue last week, was on Thursday taken before Squire Tyler at Fremont for a preliminary examination. Several witnesses for the prosecution were examined, the defendant waved his defense, and was bound to answer to a charge of murder in the first degree. It is expected that the defense will be temporary insanity. The prosecuting attorney, Kinney, will be assisted by John L. Lemon, of Clyde, and Col. J. R. Bartlett. Radford for his attorneys, T.R. Strong, and Judge Finnefock. But… I have more… The Verdict… From The Clyde Enterprise - Th, 7 Jun 1883 (Page 2) The Radford Verdict Late Thursday afternoon last the jury in the case of Radford, the Bellevue wife-slayer, came into Court with a verdict of GUILTY OF MURDER in the FIRST DEGREE. They had been out forty-six hours in all, having been once sent back after coming in for the purpose of reporting a disagreement. It is understood that on the first ballot ten of the jury voted for the verdict finally rendered, and two for murder in the second degree only; and further, that on a second ballot taken five minutes later, the vote stood eleven to one. That one jury man stood out until the whole number came in to report a disagreement and sought to be discharged; when Judge Wickham, learning the situation of things, inquired out the doubting man, and asked if there were any points of law, any question as to the admissibility of testimony, or anything else on which the Court could enlighten him, that stood in the way of his making up his mind. The juryman said there was not, and the twelve were sent back for further consultation. A few hours later they returned the unanimous verdict stated above, and on a pol of the jury each man confirmed it as his verdict. How any other was possible under the evidence, no ordinary mind can comprehend. That John Radford had murder in his heart when he went to the house of his wife’s parents is beyond any sort of doubt. He probably meant to kill both his wife and her father, possibly the latter only; in either event the murderous intent was there, and had the father been at home the chances are that Radford’s well-loaded pistol would have scored two victims instead of one. The killing was cold-blooded, designed and brutal. Radford had not even intoxication, in itself a crime, to plead in false extenuation of his greater crime; for he was not drunk. All the evidence showed this; he himself admitted it. The truth in a nutshell is this: John Radford had lived ten years with a lovely, amiable woman, whom he had married and then systematically ill-treated and abused. His own conjugal infidelity was not brought out in evidence at the trial, but it was notorious both at Bellevue and Clyde. After ten years of patient endurance, his wife could submit no longer, took her children and went to the home of her father, seeking through the Courts divorce from the man who had violated every duty of a husband, and alimony for the support of herself and children. Incensed at this, he resolved to compel her to return to him, withdraw the legal action she had taken, or, if she refused, to kill both her and the father whom he believed to have been her adviser. The latter was not a home, but Radford did find his wife, dragged her by force down stairs, poured out a torrent of abuse upon her as he did so, threw her outdoors and then deliberately fired two shots into her body, threatening her mother and sister with a similar fate if they should attempt to interfere. No more cowardly, brutal act of murder can be conceived of, nor one perpetrated with more fiendish deliberation. Not a single mitigating circumstance appears in the transaction, from beginning to end. Radford’s counsel have filed a motion for a new trial, which is to be argued June 15th, and which it is at least safe to hope may be overruled. If so, they will doubtless then attempt to secure the same end through a bill of exceptions to a higher Court. This out to fail also. By the statues of Ohio not less than one hundred days must intervene between the time of pronouncing a capital sentence and its execution. The voice of the people of Sandusky county, which in this instance may be truly said to be the voice of strict justice, demands that as soon as the obstructive preliminaries, which his counsel ought to be ashamed of, shall be gotten out of the way, these hundred days of life be measured out to John Radford, and that at their expiration he expiate his awful act upon the gallows. There should be no waiting even for the traditional hangman’s day to come round. Any other day is just as good as Friday for putting adulterous wife-slayers out of the way; and if the limitation should happen to expire on a Sunday, let the gallows bear its fruit as early as possible

    21 min
  3. Brawling At The Brewery

    01/31/2024

    Brawling At The Brewery

    Brawling At The Brewery Tonight we investigate THE HADDOCK ASSASSINATION that took place on August 3rd, 1886 about 10:00 PM in Sioux City, Iowa. This story has nine (9) criminals surrounding the MURDER of Rev. George C. Haddock. The killing of Rev. Haddock was one of the sensational mysteries of the YEAR in 1886, and baffled authorities in Iowa... and the details that unfold from these criminals is nothing short of astonishing. Join me on this fantastical journey of whodunits as each part of the story begins to unravel to learn WHO took the life of Rev. Haddock, the prohibition crusader. ***VIEWER DISCRETION IS ADVISED*** Rather read this episode? Check out the BLOG post: www.thegenealogyinvestigator.com/blog/brewery ************************************************************************************* WANT TO LEARN MORE ABOUT ME? Visit my WEBSITE:   www.thegenealogyinvestigator.com  to learn MORE about me, Kelley Amstutz, The Genealogy Investigator and my business. Email me for your FREE Consultation for Genealogy Services: MetaphysiKel@gmail.com ************************************************************************************* And, check out my courses: THE GENEALOGY ACADEMY - featuring: - My introduction to Genealogy Course - THE GENEALOGY ACADEMY - which is a 6-week, fully comprehensive certificate course giving you everything from A to Z on how to START your GENEALOGY business! - DNA & Genetic Genealogy Academy - my NEWEST edition to my self-paced courses features a 29-MODULE, 12-WEEK CERTIFICATE course to help newbies and seasoned Genealogist LEARN about DNA and Genetic Genealogy to level up your business and help your clients FIND their ancestors using traditional genealogy methods -and- DNA methodologies.  This course is JAM PACKED with a TON of content to get you no your way to offering DNA services (or just analyzing your OWN DNA results!). - MINI WORKSHOPS  are individual workshops on HOT TOPICS in the genealogy industry to help you keep up! PLUS, I have several PRINTABLES and EBOOKS available through this LINK for purchase to give you the TOOLS to succeed within your own GENEALOGY business!  ************************************************************************************** ****LISTENER SPECIAL**** Have you HIT a BRICK WALL?  A brick wall in genealogy is a ROADBLOCK!!! It's a question we can't seem to answer - no matter where we look. But... there's a WAY to overcome the barriers ... and FIND ANSWERS!!! --- INTRODUCING the BRICK WALL BUSTER CARDS SYSTEM --- Support the show DISCLAIMER: This episode is subject to graphic content due to the nature of the true crime stories as told by newspaper articles in this era and reiter Support the Show. DISCLAIMER: This episode is subject to graphic content due to the nature of the true crime stories as told by newspaper articles in this era and reiterated by Kelley Amstutz, Crime Travel host. View discretion is advised for younger listeners. Get full access to The Genealogy Investigator at thegenealogyinvestigator.substack.com/subscribe

    1h 20m
  4. ANOTHER HORRIBLE MURDER in Toledo, Ohio

    12/19/2023

    ANOTHER HORRIBLE MURDER in Toledo, Ohio

    ANOTHER HORRIBLE MURDER in Toledo, Ohio We find ourselves in Sylvania, Ohio in 1857 where we are introduced to Mr. Return J. M. Ward who is assumed to have killed his wife and burned her body in a truly horrific manner.  I take us through the gruesome crime, confession, and trial with one of Toledo, Ohio's most horrible crimes. ***VIEWER DISCRETION IS ADVISED*** Rather read this episode? Check out the BLOG post: http://www.thegenealogyinvestigator.com/blog/anotherhorriblemurder ************************************************************************************* Visit my WEBSITE:   www.thegenealogyinvestigator.com  to learn MORE about me, Kelley Amstutz, The Genealogy Investigator and my business. Email me for your FREE Consultation for Genealogy Services: MetaphysiKel@gmail.com - I have some GREAT specials going on NOW! And, check out my courses: THE GENEALOGY ACADEMY - featuring: - My introduction to Genealogy Course - THE GENEALOGY ACADEMY - which is a 6-week, fully comprehensive certificate course giving you everything from A to Z on how to START your GENEALOGY business! - DNA & Genetic Genealogy Academy - my NEWEST edition to my self-paced courses features a 29-MODULE, 12-WEEK CERTIFICATE course to help newbies and seasoned Genealogist LEARN about DNA and Genetic Genealogy to level up your business and help your clients FIND their ancestors using traditional genealogy methods -and- DNA methodologies.  This course is JAM PACKED with a TON of content to get you no your way to offering DNA services (or just analyzing your OWN DNA results!). - MINI WORKSHOPS  are individual workshops on HOT TOPICS in the genealogy industry to help you keep up! PLUS, I have several PRINTABLES and EBOOKS available through this LINK for purchase to give you the TOOLS to succeed within your own GENEALOGY business!  ************************************************************************************** ****LISTENER SPECIAL**** Have you HIT a BRICK WALL?  A brick wall in genealogy is a ROADBLOCK!!! It's a question we can't seem to answer - no matter where we look. But... there's a WAY to overcome the barriers ... and FIND ANSWERS!!! --- INTRODUCING the BRICK WALL BUSTER CARDS SYSTEM --- Support the Show. DISCLAIMER: This episode is subject to graphic content due to the nature of the true crime stories as told by newspaper articles in this era and reiterated by Kelley Amstutz, Crime Travel host. View discretion is advised for younger listeners. Get full access to The Genealogy Investigator at thegenealogyinvestigator.substack.com/subscribe

    42 min
  5. LAD KILLED HIS MOTHER in TOLEDO, OH

    12/05/2023

    LAD KILLED HIS MOTHER in TOLEDO, OH

    LAD KILLED HIS MOTHER in Toledo, Ohio We are diving into one of Toledo's MOST NOTED MURDER MYSTERY CASES with the murder of Mrs. John F. Hazel by her seventeen year old son, Harvey Hazel. Rather read this episode? Check out the BLOG post: http://www.thegenealogyinvestigator.com/blog/hazel ************************************************************************************* Visit my WEBSITE:   www.thegenealogyinvestigator.com  to learn MORE about me, Kelley Amstutz, The Genealogy Investigator and my business. Email me for your FREE Consultation for Genealogy Services: MetaphysiKel@gmail.com - I have some GREAT specials going on NOW! And, check out my courses: THE GENEALOGY ACADEMY - featuring: - My introduction to Genealogy Course - THE GENEALOGY ACADEMY - which is a 6-week, fully comprehensive certificate course giving you everything from A to Z on how to START your GENEALOGY business! - DNA & Genetic Genealogy Academy - my NEWEST edition to my self-paced courses features a 29-MODULE, 12-WEEK CERTIFICATE course to help newbies and seasoned Genealogist LEARN about DNA and Genetic Genealogy to level up your business and help your clients FIND their ancestors using traditional genealogy methods -and- DNA methodologies.  This course is JAM PACKED with a TON of content to get you no your way to offering DNA services (or just analyzing your OWN DNA results!). - MINI WORKSHOPS  are individual workshops on HOT TOPICS in the genealogy industry to help you keep up! PLUS, I have several PRINTABLES and EBOOKS available through this LINK for purchase to give you the TOOLS to succeed within your own GENEALOGY business!  ************************************************************************************** ****LISTENER SPECIAL**** Have you HIT a BRICK WALL?  A brick wall in genealogy is a ROADBLOCK!!! It's a question we can't seem to answer - no matter where we look. But... there's a WAY to overcome the barriers ... and FIND ANSWERS!!! --- INTRODUCING the BRICK WALL BUSTER CARDS SYSTEM --- Support the Show. DISCLAIMER: This episode is subject to graphic content due to the nature of the true crime stories as told by newspaper articles in this era and reiterated by Kelley Amstutz, Crime Travel host. View discretion is advised for younger listeners. Get full access to The Genealogy Investigator at thegenealogyinvestigator.substack.com/subscribe

    27 min
  6. A DEED OF BLOOD

    11/21/2023

    A DEED OF BLOOD

    A DEED OF BLOOD Join me as we take a walk back in time to 1854 when a murder takes place between two women of the night over a pair of gloves.  We will learn about one notorious BIDDY FURY, and her multiple brushes with the law over her lifetime. Rather read this episode? Check out the BLOG post: http://www.thegenealogyinvestigator.com/blog/guilt ************************************************************************************* Visit my WEBSITE:   www.thegenealogyinvestigator.com  to learn MORE about me, Kelley Amstutz, The Genealogy Investigator and my business. Email me for your FREE Consultation for Genealogy Services: MetaphysiKel@gmail.com - I have some GREAT specials going on NOW! And, check out my courses: THE GENEALOGY ACADEMY - featuring: - My introduction to Genealogy Course - THE GENEALOGY ACADEMY - which is a 6-week, fully comprehensive certificate course giving you everything from A to Z on how to START your GENEALOGY business! THIS COURSE IS 75% OFF RIGHT NOW (I'm going CRAZY) FOR BLACK FRIDAY!  GRAB YOUR SEAT UNTIL FRIDAY, NOVEMBER 24TH, 2023 AT 11:00 pm FOR ONLY $37.99 WHEN YOU USE THE SECRET CODE: BLACKFRIDAY AT CHECKOUT! - DNA & Genetic Genealogy Academy - my NEWEST edition to my self-paced courses features a 29-MODULE, 12-WEEK CERTIFICATE course to help newbies and seasoned Genealogist LEARN about DNA and Genetic Genealogy to level up your business and help your clients FIND their ancestors using traditional genealogy methods -and- DNA methodologies.  This course is JAM PACKED with a TON of content to get you no your way to offering DNA services (or just analyzing your OWN DNA results!). - MINI WORKSHOPS  are individual workshops on HOT TOPICS in the genealogy industry to help you keep up! PLUS, I have several PRINTABLES and EBOOKS available through this LINK for purchase to give you the TOOLS to succeed within your own GENEALOGY business!  ************************************************************************************** ****LISTENER SPECIAL**** Have you HIT a BRICK WALL?  A brick wall in genealogy is a ROADBLOCK!!! It's a question we can't seem to answer - no matter where we look. But... there's a WAY to overcome the barriers ... and FIND ANSWERS!!! --- INTRODUCING the BRICK WALL BUSTER CARDS SYSTEM --- The Brick Wall Buster Cards system has been a GAME CHANGER in my own research and I am so excited to team up with Kim Richardson, the creator of this unique system and a TO Support the show DISCLAIMER: This episode is subject to graphic content due to the nature of the true crime stories as told by newspaper articles in this era and reiterated by Kelley Amstutz, Crime Travel host. Vi Support the Show. DISCLAIMER: This episode is subject to graphic content due to the nature of the true crime stories as told by newspaper articles in this era and reiterated by Kelley Amstutz, Crime Travel host. View discretion is advised for younger listeners. Get full access to The Genealogy Investigator at thegenealogyinvestigator.substack.com/subscribe

    25 min
  7. TIME POINTS OUT A GUILTY MAN

    11/08/2023

    TIME POINTS OUT A GUILTY MAN

    TIME POINTS OUT A GUILTY MAN This story is sure to stir a bit of intrigue... and controversy for my listeners this week as we dive into a 37-year old cold case murder and a confession from an unlikely suspect with a twist that even I didn't expect to uncover! Rather read this episode? Check out the BLOG post: http://www.thegenealogyinvestigator.com/blog/guilt ************************************************************************************* Visit my WEBSITE:   www.thegenealogyinvestigator.com  to learn MORE about me, Kelley Amstutz, The Genealogy Investigator and my business. Email me for your FREE Consultation for Genealogy Services: MetaphysiKel@gmail.com - I have some GREAT specials going on NOW! And, check out my courses: THE GENEALOGY ACADEMY - featuring: - My introduction to Genealogy Course - THE GENEALOGY ACADEMY - which is a 6-week, fully comprehensive certificate course giving you everything from A to Z on how to START your GENEALOGY business! - DNA & Genetic Genealogy Academy - my NEWEST edition to my self-paced courses features a 29-MODULE, 12-WEEK CERTIFICATE course to help newbies and seasoned Genealogist LEARN about DNA and Genetic Genealogy to level up your business and help your clients FIND their ancestors using traditional genealogy methods -and- DNA methodologies.  This course is JAM PACKED with a TON of content to get you no your way to offering DNA services (or just analyzing your OWN DNA results!). - MINI WORKSHOPS  are individual workshops on HOT TOPICS in the genealogy industry to help you keep up! PLUS, I have several PRINTABLES and EBOOKS available through this LINK for purchase to give you the TOOLS to succeed within your own GENEALOGY business!  ************************************************************************************** ****LISTENER SPECIAL**** Have you HIT a BRICK WALL?  A brick wall in genealogy is a ROADBLOCK!!! It's a question we can't seem to answer - no matter where we look. But... there's a WAY to overcome the barriers ... and FIND ANSWERS!!! --- INTRODUCING the BRICK WALL BUSTER CARDS SYSTEM --- The Brick Wall Buster Cards system has been a GAME CHANGER in my own research and I am so excited to team up with Kim Richardson, the creator of this unique system and a TO Support the Show. DISCLAIMER: This episode is subject to graphic content due to the nature of the true crime stories as told by newspaper articles in this era and reiterated by Kelley Amstutz, Crime Travel host. View discretion is advised for younger listeners. Get full access to The Genealogy Investigator at thegenealogyinvestigator.substack.com/subscribe

    33 min
  8. GHOST STORY

    10/25/2023

    GHOST STORY

    GHOST STORY Let's dig into another SPOOKY SEASON? I LOVE 'digging' up these OLD stories that haven't seen the light of day in so long... Our first story - CHANGE IN GHOST STORIES is from THE NEWS-HERALD from 11 Feb 1897, page 3. It's a twist on a traditional ghost story that was written (and published) way... way... back in 1897. Forgive my mispronunciation on some things... I was battling not only proper English... but smudges within the newspaper. (personally, it only makes it that much MORE fun!) Our second story, "Farm for Sale" is different... and in my opinion, a literary work of art from The Somerset Press published on the 13th of March 1874. This story made PAGE 1 and states that it is "From Hearth and Home." My inquiring mind wanted to know... what the heck is "HEARTH and HOME"?  With a little rabbit hole digging... I wasn't able to figure it out... I assume it was a publication (but we know what they say about assuming!)... We are faced with all the questions about WHY the Farm is for sale... So, sit back and relax and let's have a little pre-Halloween FUN! Rather read this episode? Check out the BLOG post: http://www.thegenealogyinvestigator.com/blog/jockbrownsghost ************************************************************************************* Visit my WEBSITE:   www.thegenealogyinvestigator.com  to learn MORE about me, Kelley Amstutz, The Genealogy Investigator and my business. Email me for your FREE Consultation for Genealogy Services: MetaphysiKel@gmail.com - I have some GREAT specials going on NOW! And, check out my courses: THE GENEALOGY ACADEMY - featuring: - My introduction to Genealogy Course - THE GENEALOGY ACADEMY - which is a 6-week, fully comprehensive certificate course giving you everything from A to Z on how to START your GENEALOGY business! - DNA & Genetic Genealogy Academy - my NEWEST edition to my self-paced courses features a 29-MODULE, 12-WEEK CERTIFICATE course to help newbies and seasoned Genealogist LEARN about DNA and Genetic Genealogy to level up your business and help your clients FIND their ancestors using traditional genealogy methods -and- DNA methodologies.  This course is JAM PACKED with a TON of content to get you no your way to offering DNA services (or just analyzing your OWN DNA results!). - MINI WORKSHOPS  are individual workshops on HOT TOPICS in the genealogy industry to help you keep up! PLUS, I have several PRINTABLES and EBOOKS available through this LINK for purchase to give you the TOOLS to succeed within your own GENEALOGY business!  ************************************************************************************** ****LISTENER SPECIAL**** Have you HIT a BRICK WALL?  A brick wall in genealogy is a ROADBLOCK!!! It's a question we can't seem to answer - no matter where we look. But... there's a WAY to overcome the ba Support the Show. DISCLAIMER: This episode is subject to graphic content due to the nature of the true crime stories as told by newspaper articles in this era and reiterated by Kelley Amstutz, Crime Travel host. View discretion is advised for younger listeners. Get full access to The Genealogy Investigator at thegenealogyinvestigator.substack.com/subscribe

    25 min

About

Discover expert tips, research tools, and inspiring stories to help you explore your family history and bring your ancestors to life. thegenealogyinvestigator.substack.com