Cognitive Justice

Stephen and Alyssa

Cognitive Justice is about how mental health and the law overlap and what that means for real people. We’re Stephen and Alyssa, two students who want to figure out what really happens when these worlds meet. We talk openly about why mental health matters in the justice system and why things don’t always feel fair. We share stories and perspectives you don’t usually hear, and we make sure our research comes from solid, peer reviewed sources so you know it’s backed by real evidence. At the heart of it, we’re here to listen, learn, and help build a system that sees the person before the problem

Episodes

  1. 09/30/2025

    Where the Mind Meets Law

    What happens when mental illness meets the courtroom? In this episode, hosts Stephen Atkins and Alyssa Amaral explore how mental health shapes the justice system — and how the justice system, in turn, shapes mental health. From forensic psychological assessments that influence sentencing, to the rise of Mental Health Courts in Canada, the conversation digs into the promise and pitfalls of trying to bring care into a system built on punishment. Together, they unpack: The eight best practices for reliable forensic assessments — and why they matter. How Mental Health Courts use therapeutic jurisprudence to approach justice differently. The tension between “voluntary” participation and hidden coercion in mandated treatment. Why housing, social supports, and accessible mental health care are essential for real rehabilitation. The ethical dilemmas facing psychologists who serve the courts versus the individuals they assess. Stephen and Alyssa highlight real-world challenges — from inconsistent eligibility rules to resource shortages — but also spotlight the opportunities for meaningful reform. The central question remains: Can Canada build a justice system that treats mental illness with evidence, ethics, and empathy? Cognitive Justice invites you to think critically about how law and mental health collide — and how we might design systems that heal, rather than harm. References: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1Nrbamr47bmWZ0pj5MfmojuMWy9b8hIVYDmEU4q8lTlY/edit?usp=drivesdk

  2. 09/24/2025

    What Psychotherapy can teach the courts

    What happens when therapy isn’t a choice, but a court order? In this episode, hosts Alyssa Amaral and Stephen Atkins explore the complex world of Mental Health Courts — specialized courts designed to address the overlap between mental illness and the criminal justice system. Instead of defaulting to incarceration, these courts aim to connect people with treatment and supports. But do they empower participants, or do they risk turning therapy into another form of control? Together, Alyssa and Stephen unpack the promise and pitfalls of court-mandated treatment, covering: Why Mental Health Courts exist and how they fit within “problem-solving courts.” The role of Therapeutic Jurisprudence in shaping more compassionate legal processes. The delicate balancing act for Court-Involved Therapists (CITs) who must both support participants and report to the court. Real-world examples from Ontario, New Brunswick, and Yukon — where these courts show both successes and limitations. Systemic barriers, including funding gaps, cultural inequities, and lack of long-term community supports. Ethical dilemmas: Can mandated therapy ever feel like healing when choice is limited? This episode highlights both the hope and the challenges of a justice system that tries to be therapeutic. While Mental Health Courts can reduce recidivism and foster recovery, their success hinges on collaboration, trauma-informed care, and respect for participants’ dignity. Cognitive Justice asks: Can law and mental health truly work together to heal — or are we just reshaping old systems of control? References https://docs.google.com/document/d/1m_6P5zKbcU_NrTmby3FwAWtNvjdRNeqNJn6r061b-YA/edit?usp=drivesdk

  3. 08/31/2025

    Rehabilitation or Retraumatization?

    “If you do the crime, you do the time.” It sounds simple… but is it really? In this episode of Cognitive Justice, we (Stephen Atkins and Alyssa Amaral) dive into what prison actually does to people. Behind the walls, so many folks are already carrying layers of trauma — childhood abuse, racism, poverty, foster care, intergenerational wounds. Instead of helping, prison often piles on more harm: isolation, violence, and almost no real mental health support. We’re asking the big question: are prisons places of rehabilitation, or do they just retraumatize? Together, we explore: ​What mental health and trauma look like inside Canadian prisons​The devastating impact of solitary confinement​Gladue principles — and whether they actually make a difference for Indigenous offenders​Trauma-informed correctional care (TICC) and healing programs like Seeking Safety, STAIR, and APIC​Why gender-responsive and culturally rooted approaches matter for real change We don’t shy away from the hard truth: punishment-driven prisons rarely reduce harm. But we also highlight the hope — programs and frameworks that prove healing is possible when trauma is recognized and addressed. Cognitive Justice is about shifting the conversation. Instead of asking, “How do we punish?” maybe the better question is: How do we heal? References: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1f404l92AHTSfLWmlImpwBHA8s67PyvxEk2X55Fk1_3g/edit?usp=drivesdk

  4. 08/21/2025

    Trauma, Crime, and the Cycle of Violence

    What happens when people carrying deep trauma come face to face with a justice system that often pretends trauma doesn’t exist? Hosted by Stephen Atkins and Alyssa Amaral, two students exploring the intersections of law, psychology, and human behavior, Cognitive Justice asks hard questions about fairness, healing, and accountability. Each episode unpacks research, real-world cases, and lived experiences to explore how trauma shapes people’s paths into — and through — the Canadian justice system. From the impacts of childhood adversity to the legacy of colonialism and intergenerational trauma in Indigenous communities, Stephen and Alyssa dig into what it would mean to create a truly trauma-informed justice system. Along the way, they highlight tools like restorative justice, Gladue principles, and trauma-informed policing — not as abstract policies, but as practices that can change lives. This is not about excusing harm. It’s about asking better questions: ​Instead of “What’s wrong with this person?” what if we asked, “What happened to them?”​Can the justice system rehabilitate, or does it mostly re-traumatize?​And what role do we all play — as neighbors, educators, or frontline workers — in interrupting cycles of harm before they reach the courts? Gentle, thoughtful, and grounded in curiosity, Cognitive Justice invites listeners to rethink justice not as a machine, but as a human system — one that can either deepen wounds or help begin to heal them. References: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1VHhZxaQskwFvnPoT5IYgxp9PBpwumW_csgipxgR1AmQ/edit?usp=drivesdk

About

Cognitive Justice is about how mental health and the law overlap and what that means for real people. We’re Stephen and Alyssa, two students who want to figure out what really happens when these worlds meet. We talk openly about why mental health matters in the justice system and why things don’t always feel fair. We share stories and perspectives you don’t usually hear, and we make sure our research comes from solid, peer reviewed sources so you know it’s backed by real evidence. At the heart of it, we’re here to listen, learn, and help build a system that sees the person before the problem