The Rule of Law Brief

Nathan M. F. Charles — Former federal prosecutor and Navy SEAL officer; Managing Partner at Charles International Law.

A principled defense of constitutional governance, civil liberties, and professional ethics in the face of rising authoritarianism—anchored in legal rigor, national security insight, and a commitment to nonviolent resistance. natecharles.substack.com

  1. Nov 11

    The Legal Case for Impeaching Pete Hegseth

    Impeachment does not require a criminal conviction. It requires Congress to determine whether an official’s conduct amounts to a grave abuse of office and a betrayal of public trust. In this episode of The Rule of Law Brief, I examine all eight articles of impeachment introduced by Representative Thomas Massie against Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth. I explain which allegations I find compelling, where I disagree with the resolution, and which questions require evidence the public cannot currently assess. My strongest conclusions concern the Iran war, the lethal strikes against suspected drug-trafficking boats, and Hegseth’s retaliation against Senator Mark Kelly. I argue that the boat strikes, on the facts alleged, constitute murder, and that threatening Kelly’s retired rank and pay for protected speech is a particularly clear abuse of government authority. I also explain why I find Article II legally vulnerable, why I disagree with treating the Maduro capture operation as a sufficient basis for impeachment, and why the Yemen allegations require congressional examination of classified evidence. Chapters * 00:00 — What counts as a high crime or misdemeanor? * 01:32 — Article I: Iran, preventive war, and self-defense * 02:54 — Article II: Congress’s withdrawal demand * 03:49 — Article III: The sixty-day deadline and claims that hostilities ended * 04:58 — Article IV: Dismantling civilian-protection safeguards * 05:48 — Article V: Why I regard the boat strikes as unlawful killings * 07:07 — Article VI: Retaliation against Mark Kelly * 08:01 — Article VII: Where I disagree on the Maduro operation * 08:36 — Article VIII: Yemen and the need for classified evidence * 09:22 — Impeachment and the public trust Related episodes * Are Trump’s Rants a War Crime? — Targeting civilian infrastructure * When Are Civilian Deaths a War Crime? * FTO Designations Are Not War Powers * What “No Quarter” Really Means—and Why It’s Illegal Legal references and context * Cass Sunstein, Impeachment: A Citizen’s Guide * War Powers Resolution * United Nations Charter * 2001 Authorization for Use of Military Force * Kelly v. Hegseth: preliminary-injunction opinion A clarification on Article II: Section 5(c) expressly provides for withdrawal by concurrent resolution. The legal controversy concerns whether that mechanism remains constitutionally enforceable after INS v. Chadha; the Supreme Court has not directly resolved that question. My assessment of Article II reflects that vulnerability. Congressional Research Service discussion. Government power deserves scrutiny, regardless of who exercises it. Subscribe to The Rule of Law Brief for my analysis of constitutional rights, national security, and the legal limits on executive authority—delivered directly to your inbox. Get full access to The Rule of Law Brief at natecharles.substack.com/subscribe

    The Legal Case for Impeaching Pete Hegseth
  2. Nov 9

    Soapbox 2026: Free Speech Shouldn’t Depend on Your Passport

    I left FIRE’s Soapbox 2026 conference encouraged—and thinking about where Charles International Law can do more to defend freedom of expression. Immigration and First Amendment litigation increasingly overlap, especially when international students face visa revocation, detention, or removal after expressing political views. In this episode * My Soapbox experience: exceptional speakers, facilities, food, and production; programming accessible to nonlawyers; and an admission price that made attending a stretch. * Speech rights and immigration power: why constitutional protections for noncitizens coexist uneasily with broad government authority over admission and immigration enforcement. * The Rümeysa Öztürk case: the Turkish Tufts doctoral student whose detention raised fundamental questions about retaliation for political expression. * Where to draw the line: distinguishing independent advocacy and academic debate from unlawful military recruitment or prohibited material support. * What comes next: why Charles International Law expects to become more involved in litigation at this intersection. The legal tension The government has legitimate national security interests. Those interests do not make every unpopular opinion a security threat. Criticism of Israel or support for Palestinian rights does not, by itself, establish support for terrorism. International students should be able to challenge assumptions and participate in academic debate without fearing immigration retaliation. Denying admission, revoking a visa, and deporting someone already in the United States are distinct legal actions. The cases below address different circumstances; none supplies a universal rule for every noncitizen or immigration decision. Cases and further reading * Bridges v. Wixon, 326 U.S. 135 (1945): the majority recognized speech and press protections for noncitizens residing here, while overturning the deportation order on statutory and procedural grounds. * Kleindienst v. Mandel, 408 U.S. 753 (1972): substantial deference to an admission decision supported by a facially legitimate and bona fide reason. * Harisiades v. Shaughnessy, 342 U.S. 580 (1952): an older decision upholding deportations based on past Communist Party membership. * Holder v. Humanitarian Law Project, 561 U.S. 1 (2010): restrictions on specified coordinated support for designated foreign terrorist organizations, with independent advocacy outside the statute’s prohibition. * 18 U.S.C. § 959: federal restrictions on enlistment and hiring others for foreign military service, subject to statutory exceptions. * FIRE’s Stanford Daily litigation: an August 2026 district court victory concerning immigration penalties for protected speech; the government has appealed. * Öztürk case update: after her release and completion of her doctorate, she voluntarily returned to Türkiye in April 2026 under a settlement. * Soapbox 2026: learn more about FIRE’s conference. Subscribe for plain-language analysis of immigration, civil rights, and free expression—and updates on the work Charles International Law is taking on to defend them. Get full access to The Rule of Law Brief at natecharles.substack.com/subscribe

    Soapbox 2026: Free Speech Shouldn’t Depend on Your Passport
  3. Nov 3

    The Republic Is Worth Defending. Get Out and Vote.

    Today is Election Day, and the message is simple: Get out and vote. After a brief hiatus from the Rule of Law Brief—thanks to a welcome period of growth and activity at Charles International Law—Nathan Charles returns with an urgent reminder that voting is more than a constitutional right. It is a civic responsibility essential to the survival of the American republic. In this brief episode, Nathan examines the increasingly prominent role of fear, anger, and outrage in American electoral politics, particularly the Republican Party’s exploitation of social media and the troubling displacement of substantive policy debates by the pursuit of political power. The stakes extend well beyond any single election. When political movements abandon principled debate in favor of emotional manipulation and power for its own sake, the institutions that sustain constitutional democracy are placed at risk. Drawing on Abraham Lincoln’s appeal to the “better angels of our nature,” Nathan calls on Americans to reject fear and hatred, demand accountability from their elected representatives, and exercise their most fundamental democratic responsibility. Whatever your political persuasion, make your voice heard. Vote. Rule of Law Brief examines law, government, public policy, and the constitutional principles that sustain American democracy. Our republic is worth defending. On Election Day, a reminder that voting is a civic duty—and that democracy cannot survive on fear, hatred, and the pursuit of power for its own sake. Reject the politics of outrage. Appeal to the better angels of our nature. Get out and vote. Get full access to The Rule of Law Brief at natecharles.substack.com/subscribe

    The Republic Is Worth Defending. Get Out and Vote.
  4. Oct 26

    There Are Leaders Walking Among You

    After a quarter century marked by war, economic upheaval, a pandemic, and repeated uncertainty, the U.S. Naval Academy Class of 2001 has become very comfortable operating in crisis mode. Advance planning remains a work in progress—as our class president, Jen, can probably attest. But returning to Annapolis for our 25-year reunion gave me something I badly needed: renewed resilience. My classmates have carried their commitments to service into military careers, businesses, religious vocations, and communities across the country. Seeing them again reminded me how many people we have who understand responsibility and continue to honor it. In this episode of the Rule of Law Brief, I reflect on that reassurance and what it means as America approaches consequential midterm elections. The results will matter enormously, and so will the administration’s response to them. I also invite service academy graduates from every academy and every class to introduce themselves in the comments. Share your academy, class year, and town or region, and let your neighbors know you’re there and willing to help. Leadership carries responsibilities even when you aren’t in charge. If someone you know is anxious about America’s future, share this episode with them. My Naval Academy reunion reminded me that there are leaders walking among us—and that we have people we can turn to when the way ahead is uncertain. Get full access to The Rule of Law Brief at natecharles.substack.com/subscribe

    There Are Leaders Walking Among You
  5. Oct 1

    When Military Expertise Becomes an Illegal Export

    Recent reports have raised questions about whether Western military veterans—including potentially former U.S. Navy SEALs—provided military training to Russian nationals who later fought in Ukraine. The underlying allegations remain disputed, and I have no inside information about whether they are true. But the reports highlight a serious legal issue that every veteran working in overseas defense, security, aviation, or military training should understand. During my time as a Trial Attorney in the Counterintelligence and Export Control Section of the Justice Department’s National Security Division, export-control cases—and particularly cases involving “defense services”—were a significant part of my work. Under the Arms Export Control Act and the International Traffic in Arms Regulations (ITAR), military expertise can itself become a controlled export. In this episode of the Rule of Law Brief, I explain what the ITAR means by a “defense service,” why overseas military training can require State Department authorization, the special restrictions applicable to Russia, and the potentially severe criminal and regulatory consequences of getting this wrong. For veterans entering the private defense and security industry, the central lesson is simple: leaving military service does not necessarily mean leaving national-security law behind. The Rule of Law Brief examines national security, constitutional law, immigration, and the legal issues behind the headlines—drawing on experience from the military, federal prosecution, and private practice. Subscribe for analysis that goes beyond the headline and explains what the law actually says. Get full access to The Rule of Law Brief at natecharles.substack.com/subscribe

    When Military Expertise Becomes an Illegal Export

Ratings & Reviews

5
out of 5
3 Ratings

About

A principled defense of constitutional governance, civil liberties, and professional ethics in the face of rising authoritarianism—anchored in legal rigor, national security insight, and a commitment to nonviolent resistance. natecharles.substack.com