Two Girls in the Dark

Chel Petz

Join your hosts Rachel Petzinger and Pooja Kolluri as they dive into some of the world's most intriguing crimes and mysteries. If it’s strange, spooky, or unsolved, your girls of two vastly different heights are on the case.

Episodes

  1. Jun 7

    The Night Three Women Vanished Without a Trace | The Springfield Three

    On the anniversary of the night they vanished, your girls are diving into one of the most perplexing mysteries of our time: the case of Suzie Streeter, Stacy McCall, and Sherrill Levitt, better known as the Springfield Three. In the early morning hours of June 7, 1992, these three women seemingly vanished without a trace. Their purses, keys, clothing, and even their dog were left behind inside the home. There were no signs of a struggle, no clear suspects, and no explanation for where they went. More than 30 years later, the case remains unsolved. What do you think happened to them that night? Follow us on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@ChelPetz Follow us on Apple Podcasts: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/two-girls-in-the-dark/id1841415733Let us know your theories in the comments — and don’t forget to send any case suggestions to: twogirlsinthedarkpodcast@gmail.com

    49 min

  2. Jan 30

    The Death of Kurt Cobain

    In our season 1 finale, your girls discuss the life and death of Nirvana frontman Kurt Cobain. Join us as we explore Kurt’s rise to fame, the pressures he faced, the tragic circumstances surrounding his death, and how his legacy continues to shape music and culture decades later. Follow us on YouTube:https://www.youtube.com/@ChelPetz Follow us on Apple Podcasts: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/two-girls-in-the-dark/id1841415733Let us know your theories in the comments — and don’t forget to send any case suggestions to: twogirlsinthedarkpodcast@gmail.com

    46 min

  3. 11/28/2025

    The Bizarre Case of Cindy James: Stalking Victim or Something More Sinister?

    Note: This episode discusses themes related to self-harm. Please take care while listening. Cindy James was a nurse living in British Columbia who, after getting divorced, began reporting terrifying accounts of harassment and stalking. But because investigators could never locate a single suspect over seven years, they started to consider the unthinkable… was Cindy staging these incidents herself? When her body was later discovered under strange and unsettling circumstances, the mystery only deepened. In this episode of Two Girls in the Dark, your girls break down the timeline, the evidence, the theories, and the contradictions. Was Cindy really being stalked? Or was someone closer to home behind her tragic and mysterious death? Connect with us! Subscribe to my channel: https://youtube.com/@ChelPetz?si=Kkl6v_w3VW7rUVWx Follow us on Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/0mGbX1U0awUM37xOBUJIvv?si=58fdfba3a08e451b Let us know your theories in the comments — and don’t forget to send any case suggestions to: twogirlsinthedarkpodcast@gmail.com

    49 min

  4. 10/10/2025

    She Was Last Seen the Night Before 9/11 - What Happened to Sneha Philip?

    Note: This episode discusses the events of September 11, 2001. Sneha Philip was a physician living in New York City who was last seen on September 10th, 2001. When the World Trade Center was attacked the next morning, her story was lost in the midst of the chaos - sparking years of debate. Was she a victim of the attacks, or did something happen to her the night before? Join us as we breakdown the theories behind one of the most haunting disappearances connected to 9/11. Follow us on YouTube:https://www.youtube.com/@ChelPetz

    50 min

  5. 09/19/2025

    The Disappearance of Frederick Valentich

    In this episode, your girls dive into the disappearance of 20-year-old Australian pilot Frederick Valentich. In 1978, Valentich took off on what should have been a routine flight across the Bass Strait - but instead, he radioed air traffic control with a chilling report: a strange craft was hovering above him and following his plane. Minutes later, his final transmission cut off, and neither he nor his aircraft were ever seen again. What really happened to Frederick Valentich? Was it a tragic accident, an elaborate hoax, or something not of this world? Join us as we unravel the timeline, explore the theories, and uncover why this case still fascinates UFO enthusiasts decades later.

    33 min

  6. 09/05/2025

    Amy Lynn Bradley : Vanished at Sea

    Your girls are back with a chilling new case! This week, we’re diving into the baffling disappearance of Amy Lynn Bradley - a 23-year-old who vanished while on a family vacation aboard a Royal Caribbean cruise ship in 1998. Since that night, there have been reported sightings and even photographs that some believe show Amy, fueling her family’s conviction that she was taken against her will and may still be alive. So what really happened? Did Amy fall overboard, as Royal Caribbean claims - or is she still out there somewhere, unable to get home? Join us as we piece together the evidence, rumors, and unanswered questions surrounding one of the most haunting missing persons cases of the 1990s.

    44 min

  7. 07/25/2025

    Where Is Shelly Miscavige | Missing Wife of Scientology's Leader

    In this episode, your girls explore their thoughts behind one of the craziest rabbit holes out there - the disappearance of Shelly Miscavige, wife of Scientology leader David Miscavige. Shelly Miscavige hasn't officially been seen in public since 2007, sparking questions, investigations, and a whirlwind of conspiracy theories. Was she killed and had her death covered up? Is she being held captive by the church under her husband's orders? Or is she really fine and working on a secret project like the church has claimed? Join us as we walk through the timeline, explore theories, and ask the question: where is Shelly? Let us know where you think Shelly is in the comments — and don’t forget to send any case suggestions to: twogirlsinthedarkpodcast@gmail.com Follow us on YouTube! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Lq6zvwnMfE0&list=PLoXDK07IeuoBZCkh-c907HPqpsNZXk8FZ&pp=gAQB

    1h 11m

  8. 07/09/2025

    The Chilling Disappearance of the Yuba County 5

    In this episode, your girls dive into one of the most baffling mysteries of all time: the disappearance of the Yuba County Five. What started as an ordinary night for five young friends (each with varying intellectual disabilities) returning home from a basketball game turned into a bone-chilling mystery when their car was found abandoned and four of their bodies were discovered months later in the remote Plumas National Forest. What happened to the Yuba County Five? Why did they leave a perfectly functioning car behind? Were they victims of foul play, or caught in a tragic accident? Let us know your theories in the comments — and don’t forget to send any case suggestions to: twogirlsinthedarkpodcast@gmail.com

    41 min

  9. 06/25/2025

    The Disappearance of the Sodder Children

    Note: This episode contains discussions about possible child abduction. Join your hosts, Rachel Petzinger and Pooja Kolluri, as they discuss one of the most haunting mysteries in American history — the disappearance of the Sodder children. Was their case the tragic result of a house fire, or were they kidnapped from their home on Christmas Eve, 1945? The children's Charley Project pages:https://charleyproject.org/case/maurice-antonio-sodderhttps://charleyproject.org/case/martha-lee-sodderhttps://charleyproject.org/case/louis-erico-sodderhttps://charleyproject.org/case/jennie-irene-sodderhttps://charleyproject.org/case/betty-dolly-sodderSend your episode suggestions to: twogirlsinthedarkpodcast@gmail.com

    42 min

  10. 06/11/2025

    The Circleville Letters

    Join your hosts Rachel Petzinger and Pooja Kolluri as they explore possible theories behind Circleville Letters - a series of chilling anonymous letters sent to Circleville, Ohio residents in the 70s and 80s. These letters may have driven one man to his death and sent another to prison for a crime he may not have committed. Send your episode suggestions to: twogirlsinthedarkpodcast@gmail.com

    37 min

  11. 05/28/2025

    Anthonette Cayedito: Abducted in the Night

    Note: This episode contains discussions about child abduction.  Join your hosts Rachel Petzinger and Pooja Kolluri as they explore the abduction of Anthonette Cayedito from her home in Gallup, New Mexico in 1986 and possible theories behind her disappearance.  Anthonette Cayedito's Profile on NCMC: https://www.missingkids.org/poster/NCMC/600709/1 Reach out to us with episode suggestions: twogirlsinthedarkpodcast@gmail.com

    28 min
  • 11 Episodes

About

Join your hosts Rachel Petzinger and Pooja Kolluri as they dive into some of the world's most intriguing crimes and mysteries. If it’s strange, spooky, or unsolved, your girls of two vastly different heights are on the case.

Information

  • Creator
    Chel Petz
  • Years Active
    2025 - 2026
  • Episodes
    11
  • Rating
    Explicit
  • Copyright
    © Chel Petz
  • Show Website
    Two Girls in the Dark