The Critical Debrief

Dr Caroline Wilson, Dr Kit Rowe, Dr Pramod Chandru, Dr Samoda Mudalige, Dr Shreyas Iyer

The team from Network Five Emergency Medicine present a fresh new podcast with clinical updates, analysis and deep dives into the world of Emergency Medicine!

Episodes

  1. The Pitt S1E03 Debrief

    5h ago

    The Pitt S1E03 Debrief

    Three rapid clinical updates — tenecteplase for stroke, the danger of overshooting blood pressure after ICH, and the new Surviving Sepsis guidelines ACEP won’t endorse — then The Pitt S1E03 on death, grief, hot debriefs and caring for culturally diverse patients in the ED. Hosts: Dr Shreyas Iyer, Dr Caroline Wilson, Dr Pramod Chandru, Dr Mariez Gorgi 🎞️ Episode Synopsis (AI) The team opens with three rapid clinical updates. Caroline covers the shift in acute ischaemic stroke care towards tenecteplase as the preferred thrombolytic in place of alteplase, prompted by the NSW ACI clinical practice guide, and discusses the extended 4.5–9 hour and wake-up stroke windows, the role of perfusion imaging, and the value of the Telestroke service in regional NSW. Pramod presents a recent paper showing that overshooting blood pressure targets after intracerebral haemorrhage is associated with worse outcomes, using it as a springboard into a broader, sceptical discussion of evidence standards, trial design, and the harms of overzealous blood pressure lowering. Pramod closes the updates with breaking news: the release of the 2026 Surviving Sepsis Campaign guidelines and ACEP’s decision not to endorse them, unpacking the three stated concerns. The conversation then turns to The Pitt’s third episode, which the team uses to explore death and grief in emergency practice — first deaths, the weight of decision-making as a junior, and the experiences that stay with clinicians for years. They examine the role and limits of the hot debrief, how senior and junior staff draw different value from it, and practical ways to look after a team after a difficult case. The episode finishes on the show’s portrayal of an interpreter transforming care for a culturally and linguistically diverse patient, and the team’s reflections on advocating for diverse communities in a time-pressured ED. ⏱️ Episode Timestamps00:00 — Disclaimer & intro00:28 — Welcome & introductions (first-time guest Mariez Gorgi)01:06 — Update 1: Stroke thrombolysis — Tenecteplase replacing alteplase (Caroline)11:43 — Update 2: Blood pressure control after ICH — overshooting and harm (Pramod)21:30 — Update 3: 2026 Surviving Sepsis guidelines & ACEP non-endorsement (Pramod)25:48 — The Pitt S1E03 — episode recap (Mariez)27:51 — Death & grief in emergency medicine42:31 — Hot debriefs: value, pitfalls, and looking after staff57:12 — Interpreters & culturally and linguistically diverse patients62:20 — Wrap-up & what’s coming 📚 References & Resources (in order of discussion) NSW Agency for Clinical Innovation (February 2026) — Intravenous thrombolysis for adult patients with acute ischaemic stroke: clinical practice guide.🔗 ACI clinical practice guide (PDF)⏱️ ~01:06Names tenecteplase as the preferred first-line IV thrombolytic; alteplase remains an effective TGA-approved alternative. Also addresses the extended 4.5–9 hour / wake-up window (beyond 4.5 h is outside TGA approval and reserved for specialist-led decisions). Primary source for Caroline’s update, including the small functional-outcome benefit cited from its underpinning evidence base. Shi AC, Taylor T, Huang C-C, Singhal AB, Goldstein JN, Bevers MB, Hou PC (2025) — Early Intensive Blood Pressure Reduction After Intracerebral Hemorrhage Is Associated With Worse Functional Outcome: The Risk of Overshooting Blood Pressure Goals. Annals of Emergency Medicine.🔗 Annals of Emergency Medicine⏱️ ~11:43Retrospective cohort (two academic centres, 2017–2023). Overshooting to 120 mmHg systolic associated with worse functional outcome — the paper Pramod presents. Anderson CS, et al. (2013) — Rapid Blood-Pressure Lowering in Patients with Acute Intracerebral Hemorrhage (INTERACT2). New England Journal of Medicine.🔗 NEJM⏱️ ~15:24Foundational RCT on early intensive BP lowering in ICH. INTERACT3 (Lancet 2023) and the Moullaali et al. preplanned pooled individual-patient-data analysis (referenced as “a pooled analysis”) extend this evidence base. Préterre C, Gaultier A, Obadia M, et al. (2025) — Intravenous alteplase versus oral aspirin for acute central retinal artery occlusion within 4·5 h of severe vision loss (THEIA): a multicentre, double-dummy, patient-blinded and assessor-blinded, randomised, controlled, phase 3 trial. The Lancet Neurology.🔗 The Lancet Neurology⏱️ ~16:40The trial Pramod uses to illustrate trial-design and power pitfalls. Visual-acuity improvement was 66% with alteplase vs 48% with oral aspirin — an ~18-point difference that did not reach significance, in a trial the authors judged underpowered (improvement in both arms ran well above the ~40% vs ~10% the study was designed to expect). Surviving Sepsis Campaign (2026) — Prescott H, Antonelli M, Alhazzani W, et al. International Guidelines for Management of Sepsis and Septic Shock 2026. Critical Care Medicine / Intensive Care Medicine.🔗 Surviving Sepsis Campaign 2026 (SCCM)⏱️ ~21:30The new SSC guidelines; for the first time, separate adult and paediatric documents — central to the discussion. American College of Emergency Physicians (2 February 2026) — ACEP Will Not Endorse New Sepsis Guidelines from the Surviving Sepsis Campaign.🔗 ACEP statement⏱️ ~21:48ACEP’s formal statement citing three concerns: conflicting adult vs paediatric guidance, guidelines not reflecting the reality of emergency care, and the absence of emergency-physician governance in the SSC. The Pitt — Season 1, Episode 3 (Max, 2025).⏱️ ~25:48The episode under discussion; basis for the death/grief, hot-debrief and interpreter themes. 📬 Contact the TeamWe value your feedback and would love to hear from you! Email us at hello@n5em.com

    1h 4m
  2. Mar 18

    The Pitt S1E02 Debrief

    🎙️ The Critical Debrief – The Pitt S1E02 Debrief Duration: ~65 minutes Hosts: Shreyas Iyer, Pramod Chandru, Caroline Wilson Topic: Clinical updates in cardiology, antimicrobial stewardship, and febrile infants, followed by a case-based discussion of The Pitt Episode 2. Show notes generated with AI assistance. 🎞️ Episode Synopsis (AI) In Episode 2, the team explores ACS updates, AI ECG interpretation, antibiotic stewardship, and febrile infant risk stratification. The second half applies these principles through a discussion of The Pitt Episode 2, focusing on ethical decision-making, paediatric toxicology, mandatory reporting, and airway management in trauma. ⏱️ Episode Timestamps 00:00 – Intro / housekeeping 02:04 – Cardiology update: ACS, OMI concepts 10:28 – AI ECG (Queen of Hearts) 18:42 – Antibiotic duration 26:10 – Febrile infants (61–90 days) 35:23 – The Pitt Episode 2 recap 39:50 – End-of-life care 46:30 – Paediatric THC ingestion 54:40 – Mandatory reporting 1:02:10 – Airway management in trauma 📚 References & Resources (in order of discussion) 1. Heart Foundation & CSANZ (2025) – ACS Guideline - https://www.heartfoundation.org.au/for-professionals/acs-guideline-overview - Referenced during ACS discussion; outlines modern troponin and risk pathways. 2. Meyers HP et al. (2025) – Accuracy of cath lab activation decisions for STEMI-equivalent and mimic ECGs: Physicians vs. AI (Queen of Hearts by PMcardio) - https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/40763602/ - Validation study of Queen of Hearts AI detecting occlusion MI. 3. Zahavi A et al. (2025) – Short vs. long antibiotic treatment for pyelonephritis and complicated urinary tract infections: a living systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials - https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/40228579/ - Short-course antibiotics non-inferior for pyelonephritis. 4. Aronson PL et al. (2025) – Prediction Rule to Identify Febrile Infants 61–90 Days at Low Risk for Invasive Bacterial Infections - https://publications.aap.org/pediatrics/article-abstract/156/3/e2025071666/203219/Prediction-Rule-to-Identify-Febrile-Infants-61-90?redirectedFrom=fulltext - Low-risk stratification for febrile infants. 5. Aronson PL et al. (2025) – Risk of Bacterial Infections in Febrile Infants 61 to 90 Days Old With Respiratory Viruses - https://publications.aap.org/pediatrics/article-abstract/156/1/e2025070617/202105/Risk-of-Bacterial-Infections-in-Febrile-Infants-61?redirectedFrom=fulltext - Lower bacterial infection risk in viral-positive infants. 6. Pantell RH et al. (2021) - https://publications.aap.org/pediatrics/article/148/2/e2021052228/179783 - Foundational AAP febrile infant guideline. 7. Wang GS et al. (2016) - https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamapediatrics/fullarticle/2534480 - Paediatric cannabis toxicity data. 8. NSW Mandatory Reporter Guide - https://dcj.nsw.gov.au/children-and-families/protecting-our-kids/mandatory-reporters/mandatory-reporters--what-to-report-and-when/the-mandatory-reporter-guide--mrg-.html - Framework for reporting child safety concerns. 9. Difficult Airway Society Guidelines - https://das.uk.com/guidelines/das_intubation_guidelines/ - Principles of difficult airway management. 10. ATLS – American College of Surgeons - https://www.facs.org/quality-programs/trauma/atls/ - Trauma airway management principles. 📬 Contact the Team 📧 hello@n5em.com We’d love your feedback or suggestions!

    1h 2m
  3. 09/23/2025

    Pilot - The Pitt Debrief

    🎙️ Episode 1: The Pitt Debrief  Duration: ~74 minutes Hosts: Shreyas, Pramod, and Caroline Topic: Podcast relaunch, clinical updates, and our review and take-homes from The Pitt, Episode 1.Show notes generated with AI assistance. 🎞️ Episode Synopsis  In this debut of The Critical Debrief, the team reflects on personal changes and the transition from Network 5 to a more independent, creative podcasting approach. The core of the episode unpacks the clinical realism and challenges featured in The Pitt, using it as a springboard for nuanced discussions about real emergency medicine, ethics, teamwork, and clinical procedures. ⏱️ Episode Timestamps 00:00 – Intro14:00 – Updates segment: Staff turnover and patient mortality23:00 – Chance fractures in children38:00 – NGT insertion in children – NSW Health policy45:00 – Main segment: The Pitt – Is it real?50:00 – Involuntary detention – ethics and law57:00 – Hyperkalaemic arrest1:05:00 – Tamponade and pericardiocentesis1:12:00 – Rhabdomyolysis and renal failure📚 References & Resources (in order of discussion) 1. BMJ Open (2023) – Nurse and doctor turnover and patient outcomes in NHS acute trusts in England 🔗 Nurse and doctor turnover and patient outcomes in NHS acute trusts in England: retrospective longitudinal study | The BMJ ⏱️ ~14:00 2. Meta-analysis: Intra-abdominal injuries in Chance fractures 🔗 A meta-analysis of the incidence of intra-abdominal injuries associated with thoracic or lumbar flexion-distraction injuries - PubMed ⏱️ ~23:00 Summary of 8 retrospective studies (no direct source linked)Key figure: 55% intra-abdominal injury rate in paediatrics3. NSW Health Policy (2025) – Nasogastric and Orogastric Tube Insertion and Management in Neonates, Infants and Children 🔗 Nasogastric and Orogastric Tube Insertion and Management in Neonates, Infants and Children ⏱️ ~38:00 Confirm NGT position based on pH 4 with approved stripsX-rays not routinely required4. The Pitt – TV Series ⏱️ ~45:00 Used as a case-based teaching tool for this episodeDiscussion includes realism, pace, portrayals of ED culture5. NSW Mental Health Act (2007) 🔗 https://legislation.nsw.gov.au/view/html/inforce/current/act-2007-008 ⏱️ ~50:00 Discussed in the context of involuntary detention criteria6. NSW Capacity Toolkit 🔗 Capacity Toolkit | Communities and Justice ⏱️ ~50:00 7. ACI Emergency Procedures App 🔗 https://app.emergencyprocedures.org/ ⏱️ ~1:05:00 Referenced during the pericardiocentesis segmentContains guidance, videos, and checklists8. Press Ganey Patient Satisfaction Scores 🔗 https://www.pressganey.com/ 🔗 JAMA Study – Fenton et al. (2012) ⏱️ ~47:00 Debated as a metric for quality careStudy showed association with increased hospitalisation and mortality📬 Contact the Team We’d love your feedback or suggestions! 📧 hello@n5em.com Want to hear about a paper?  Have a topic that you want us to discuss? Let us know — your ideas shape this podcast!

    1h 15m

About

The team from Network Five Emergency Medicine present a fresh new podcast with clinical updates, analysis and deep dives into the world of Emergency Medicine!