True Crime: America’s Most Chilling

Pickle Publishing
  • 0.0 (0)
  • TRUE CRIME
  • UPDATED WEEKLY

Dive into the darkest corners of America in True Crime: America’s Most Chilling. From baffling disappearances to shocking crimes that shook entire communities, each episode explores real cases that continue to haunt the nation. Hear the stories behind the headlines, the investigations that followed, and the enduring mysteries that refuse to be solved. Perfect for true crime enthusiasts, armchair detectives, and anyone captivated by the pursuit of justice, this podcast takes you into the chilling and unforgettable world of America’s most notorious cases.

  1. Vanished Without a Trace: The Grimes Sisters

    JAN 11

    Vanished Without a Trace: The Grimes Sisters

    The tragic case of Barbara and Patricia Grimes remains one of Chicago’s most haunting unsolved mysteries. After disappearing one winter night, the sisters were found six weeks later in a remote area—brutally murdered, with no clear answers as to what happened in the days they vanished. Their deaths shook the city, sparked fear, and left investigators, family, and the public searching for the truth. Decades later, the mystery still endures. Who took the Grimes sisters? What really happened between their disappearance and their deaths? This episode explores the chilling details, unanswered questions, and lasting impact of one of the most disturbing cold cases in Chicago history. Barbara and Patricia Grimes, the Grimes sisters case, remains one of the most infamous Chicago unsolved murders and chilling cold cases in true crime history. This story explores an unsolved disappearance that became a brutal homicide, captivating the city of Chicago and leaving behind decades of unanswered questions. Often cited among famous unsolved cases, this historic true crime mystery from the 1950s continues to haunt investigators and true crime audiences alike. As a classic cold case investigation involving missing persons, unsolved homicide, and real-life mystery, the Grimes sisters’ story stands as a powerful example of unresolved tragedy and enduring uncertainty in Chicago crime history and true crime storytelling. #TrueCrime #UnsolvedMystery #ColdCase #ChicagoCrime #TrueCrimePodcast

    12 min
  2. The Black Dahlia: A Mystery That Refuses to Die

    12/28/2025

    The Black Dahlia: A Mystery That Refuses to Die

    Dive into the chilling story of the Black Dahlia murder and the unsolved case of Elizabeth Short in this gripping true crime podcast. Explore one of the most infamous unsolved murders in 1940s Los Angeles, from the brutal details of the crime to its lasting impact on Hollywood, pop culture, and media sensationalism. We examine the James Ellroy novel The Black Dahlia, the 2006 film adaptation, and other true crime documentaries that keep this dark mystery alive. Uncover the forensic investigation challenges, the role of psychological profiling, and the fascination with cold cases that continue to captivate audiences. Learn how amateur sleuths and citizen investigators have reexamined evidence, contributing to ongoing theories and discussions across podcasts and online communities. The series also highlights similar post-war American murder mysteries, the media’s influence on crime reporting, and the cultural obsession with tragic Hollywood starlets and violentunsolved crimes. Whether you’re drawn to criminal psychology, infamous cold cases, or the mystique of unsolved murders, this podcast dives deep into the story, exploring why the Black Dahlia remains a symbol of Hollywood ambition, tragedy, and mystery.     Black Dahlia murder podcast, Elizabeth Short unsolved case,true crime Hollywood murders, 1940s Los Angeles crime, infamous unsolved murders, historical American crime stories, Black Dahlia James Ellroy novel, 2006 Black Dahlia movie analysis, forensic investigation cold cases, psychological profiling unsolved murders, amateur sleuth true crime investigations, Unsolved and Unforgotten podcast, post-war American murder mysteries, media influence on true crime, sensationalized crime stories, Hollywood starlet murder mysteries, true crime documentaries, infamous cold cases in America, unsolved serial killings, Black Dahlia pop culture impact, fascination with unsolved mysteries, violent unsolved crimes, true crime storytelling, criminal psychology and profiling, true crime podcasts 2025, exploring cold caseinvestigations, infamous female murder victims, legendary unsolved crimes

    15 min
  3. The Axeman of New Orleans: The Killer Who Loved Jazz

    12/21/2025

    The Axeman of New Orleans: The Killer Who Loved Jazz

    On a sweltering summer night between 1918 and 1919, New Orleans became the hunting ground of a killer who vanished as mysteriously as he appeared. Known only as The Axeman, he crept into homes under cover of darkness, wielding a weapon often taken from his victims’ own houses, leaving behind devastation, terror, and unanswered questions. In this immersive episode of True Crime: America’s Most Chilling, I guide you through the full story of the Axeman of New Orleans — from the brutal murders that shattered a city’s sense of safety, to the deeply flawed investigation hampered by the limitations of early 20th-century policing, public hysteria, media sensationalism, and political corruption. We explore the chilling letters sent to newspapers, the infamous jazz ultimatum that plunged the city into collective fear, and the haunting silence that followed when the murders abruptly stopped. Blending historical reporting, emotional depth, and cinematic storytelling, this episode examines why the Axeman was never caught, what may have caused the killings to end, and how the legend of the murderer became permanently woven into the culture, folklore, and music of New Orleans. More than a century later, the Axeman remains one of America’s most baffling unsolved serial killer cases — a mystery that continues to echo through the city’s streets like a distant jazz melody fading into the night. Axeman of New Orleans, New Orleans Axeman murders, Axeman true crime podcast, unsolved serial killer cases, early 20th century murders, historic American true crime, jazz and murder mystery, New Orleans unsolved crimes, cold cases America, real life serial killer stories, unsolved murder investigations, true crime documentary narration, America’s most chilling crimes, historic crime mysteries, unsolved crimes New Orleans, true crime storytelling podcast, haunting unsolved mysteries, American crime history, serial killer folklore, true crime immersive narration

    11 min
  4. The Villisca Ax Murders: A Night of Terror in America’s Heartland

    12/09/2025

    The Villisca Ax Murders: A Night of Terror in America’s Heartland

    On a warm June night in 1912, the quiet farming town of Villisca, Iowa, slept beneath a blanket of summer calm. Families rested behind unlocked doors, crickets droned their peaceful midnight chorus, and nothing hinted at the horror about to unfold. Inside the Moore residence—where Josiah and Sarah Moore, their four children, and two visiting Stillinger girls lay sleeping—an unseen presence slipped through the shadows with chilling intent. By dawn, Villisca would awaken to one of the most brutal and perplexing crimes in American history: eight lives taken in silence, a home turned into a crime scene that continues to baffle investigators more than a century later. No forced entry. No confession. No justice. This episode reconstructs the final peaceful hours before the massacre, explores the evidence and suspects that shaped the case, and examines why the Villisca Ax Murders remain one of America’s most haunting unsolved mysteries. Atmospheric, immersive, and deeply human, this story pulls you into the darkness at the center of a small town forever changed. Step inside the house where time stopped. Listen closely. In Villisca, the shadows still whisper. Villisca Ax Murders, Villisca true crime podcast, Moore family murders, 1912 Villisca unsolved case, Iowa historical true crime, Villisca murder house story, Iowa cold cases, unsolved American murders, Villisca Stillinger sisters, true crime documentary podcast, haunting unsolved mysteries, historical murder mystery, creepy small town crimes, true crime storytelling, Midwest true crime case, Villisca investigation, crime scene reconstruction podcast, early 1900s unsolved murders, American true crime history, atmospheric true crime narration

    11 min
  5. Vanished in East St. Louis: The Disappearance of Phoenix Coldon

    11/23/2025

    Vanished in East St. Louis: The Disappearance of Phoenix Coldon

    On a quiet December afternoon in 2011, 23-year-old Phoenix Coldon walked out her front door in Spanish Lake, Missouri — and was never seen again. Hours later, her SUV was discovered abandoned in East St. Louis with the engine still running, the keys left in the ignition, and her personal belongings still inside. What happened in the missing gap between her safe suburban life and that mysterious roadside? In this gripping deep-dive investigation, we explore Phoenix’s final known movements, the fractured relationships, hidden struggles, conflicting clues, and the puzzling trail that raised more questions than answers. Through emotional storytelling and investigative detail, this episode confronts the haunting silence surrounding Phoenix’s disappearance — a case that remains unsolved more than a decade later. For more mysteries like this one, including expanded chapters, behind-the-scenes reporting, and long-form case files, explore The Unsolved and Unforgotten Series, available on Amazon, Spotify, Google Books, and most major platforms. Phoenix Coldon, Phoenix Coldon disappearance, Phoenix Coldon missing case, East St. Louis cold case, Missouri missing persons, unsolved disappearance Phoenix Coldon, vanished without a trace, true crime Phoenix Coldon, Spanish Lake Missouri mystery, abandoned SUV East St. Louis, missing Black women cases, unsolved true crime 2011, mysterious disappearance podcast, cold case investigation Phoenix Coldon, true crime documentary podcast, missing person deep dive, The Unsolved and Unforgotten Series, Phoenix Coldon search efforts, unsolved Missouri cases, true crime storytelling, missing persons awareness, unresolved disappearance Phoenix Coldon, true crime Spotify podcast, Phoenix Coldon investigation timeline, criminal mystery podcast episode, long-form true crime narrative, unsolved missing woman case

    14 min
  6. The Vanishing of Maura Murray: A Mystery Frozen in Time

    11/16/2025

    The Vanishing of Maura Murray: A Mystery Frozen in Time

    In this episode, we travel deeper into the mystery surrounding Maura Murray’s disappearance. We explore the swirling theories, the rise of online sleuthing, and the profound emotional impact on her family and community. From speculation about voluntary disappearance, accident, or abduction, to the unprecedented digital investigation that made Maura one of the internet’s first true missing persons cases, this chapter unveils how uncertainty shaped every narrative. We also look at the lasting weight her disappearance placed on loved ones, the resilience of a community, and the haunting legacy of Route 112. This is a story of theories, technology, grief, and the relentless search for answers in a case that refuses to fade. Maura Murray, disappearance case, Route 112 mystery, true crime investigation, cold case analysis, voluntary disappearance theory, accidental death theory, stranger abduction theory, person of interest review, digital sleuthing, online investigation, internet detectives, early true crime forums, Websleuths era, digital-age mystery, crowdsourced investigation, false leads, missing persons cold case, online speculation, unresolved disappearance, psychological impact, ambiguous loss, family grief, community response, rural New Hampshire mystery, emotional toll, search efforts, cold case re-examination, forensic update, modern true crime culture, internet’s first missing girl, unresolved true crime case, haunting mystery, missing persons awareness, community vigilance, family advocacy, enduring mystery, unsolved case legacy, true crime podcast episode

    13 min
  7. The Girl Who Walked Into the Dark — The Disappearance of Asha Degree

    11/09/2025

    The Girl Who Walked Into the Dark — The Disappearance of Asha Degree

    In the early hours of Valentine’s Day 2000, nine-year-old Asha Degree stepped out of her home in Shelby, North Carolina, and disappeared into the darkness. What could drive a cautious, sheltered child to walk alone down a storm-soaked highway before dawn? This haunting episode of True Crime: America’s Most Chilling takes you deep into one of the South’s most enduring mysteries — the disappearance that shattered a small town and redefined how America searches for its missing children. Through firsthand accounts, investigative detail, and emotional storytelling, we trace the desperate search, the decades of silence, and the unwavering hope of a family who refused to let the world forget their daughter. A story of loss, faith, and unanswered questions — this is the mystery of Asha Degree, the girl who walked into the dark and was never seen again. Asha Degree disappearance, missing child Shelby NC, North Carolina cold case, Valentine’s Day 2000 mystery, True crime podcast, Unsolved missing persons, Child abduction investigations, Cold case true crime stories, FBI Asha Degree case, African American missing children, Parents searching for missing daughter, Highway 18 disappearance, Unsolved mysteries podcast, Real life true crime stories, Asha Degree case update, Enduring hope and loss, Small town true crime, America’s Most Chilling True Crime

    12 min
  8. Tara Calico: The Girl in the Polaroid

    10/30/2025

    Tara Calico: The Girl in the Polaroid

    In 1988, 19-year-old Tara Calico vanished while riding her bike along a quiet stretch of Route 47 in Belen, New Mexico. Nine months later, a chilling Polaroid surfaced showing a bound young woman and a boy—sparking nationwide attention, endless speculation, and a case that remains unsolved. In this episode of True Crime: America’s Most Chilling, we dive deep into Tara’s disappearance, exploring the initial investigation, persons of interest, the haunting Polaroid, and the decades-long impact on her family and the community. From rumors and fringe theories to the psychological toll of ambiguous loss, we uncover how one small-town case became a cautionary tale, highlighting the vulnerabilities of rural communities and the enduring power of memory. Join us as we navigate the mystery, the grief, and the legacy of a girl who pedaled freely one day—and vanished the next. Tara Calico, missing person case, unsolved mystery, Polaroid photograph, Belen New Mexico, stranger abduction, cold case investigation, ambiguous loss, true crime podcast, 1980s disappearances, interstate trafficking theory, serial predator theory, rural crime, family advocacy, unresolved mystery, Route 47 disappearance, emotional impact of missing persons, missing young woman, true crime storytelling, vanished teenager

    11 min
See All (14)

About

Dive into the darkest corners of America in True Crime: America’s Most Chilling. From baffling disappearances to shocking crimes that shook entire communities, each episode explores real cases that continue to haunt the nation. Hear the stories behind the headlines, the investigations that followed, and the enduring mysteries that refuse to be solved. Perfect for true crime enthusiasts, armchair detectives, and anyone captivated by the pursuit of justice, this podcast takes you into the chilling and unforgettable world of America’s most notorious cases.

Information