Ask Allison

Allison McElroy

The Ask Allison Podcast with Allison McElroy brings nonprofit pros together for real talk, big laughs, and aha moments! Through honest conversations, shared stories, and fresh takes on trends and best practices, Allison keeps it fun, encouraging, and full of heart. Allison McElroy is a bubbly encourager, nonprofit strategist, and proud Arkansan who loves helping people reach big goals. Founder of The McElroy Group, she mixes heart, humor, and hard-won experience to lift others up. Fundraiser, singer, speaker, cheerleader—when in doubt, just Ask Allison!

  1. Aug 7

    Ep. 10 - A Lifetime in Fundraising: Lessons from a Fundraising Pioneer with Andrea Kihlstedt

    Artificial personalization is quietly destroying donor trust across the nonprofit sector. Fundraisers are moving so fast with automated outreach that they are actively alienating the people funding their missions, making it critical to step back and evaluate how we actually build real connections. Andrea Kihlstedt joins the show to share her decades of capital campaign expertise and deep understanding of donor psychology. We sit down to dissect exactly what has changed in the industry since the days of index cards and what absolutely remains the same. The conversation moves through the mechanics of modern stewardship, the inherent flaws of traditional feasibility studies, and the necessity of direct mentorship for new development officers. Andrea also unpacks her unique philosophy on the superproductive third quarter of life, challenging the outdated notion that a career slows down after fifty. The reality of this work is that not every organization is set up for success, and recognizing a toxic or stagnant environment is just as important as mastering a campaign ask. We tackle the heavy toll of waking up dreading the workday and why time is the single resource you cannot afford to waste on a bad fit. Listeners will walk away with a clear metric for knowing when it is time to pack up and leave a role, alongside a practical framework for empowering internal leadership to handle major donor conversations instead of hiding behind outside consultants. If you care about authentic donor stewardship, capital campaign strategy, and navigating career transitions, you’ll get a lot from this. Please take a moment to subscribe to the channel and share this episode with a fellow fundraiser who might need a fresh perspective. What is the biggest fear holding you back from sitting down face-to-face with your largest donors?

  2. Jul 7

    Ep. 9 - 10+ Things I’ve Learned After 31 Years in Fundraising

    Treating donors like ATMs is a direct resource leak for nonprofits. With grant guidelines constantly shifting and donor retention requiring deeper attention, leaning into authentic human connection is a practical necessity right now. Today, certified fundraising executive Allison McElroy flies solo to share hard-earned lessons from over three decades of boots-on-the-ground nonprofit work. We get into the exact mechanics of why an organization's database is a list of relationships rather than a ledger of transactions. Specifically, this episode breaks down time-blocking for stewardship, why board members should operate as connectors instead of professional fundraisers, and the hard data behind the Giving USA pie chart that proves individual giving eclipses foundation grants. A primary realization from this solo deep dive is the concept of blessing and releasing unaligned donors so you can dedicate time to those who actually share your core values. Fundraising requires facing the harder parts of the industry, including the raw fear of rejection and the logistical realities of special events going up in literal flames. Viewers will walk away with a clear system for mapping out their development plan based on actual return on investment, a framework for handling event catastrophes with grace, and a mindset shift that transforms a dreaded rejection into a strategic "not right now." If you care about donor stewardship, major gift cultivation, and building a sustainable development strategy, you will get a lot from this. Please subscribe to the channel and share this episode with a fellow nonprofit professional who could use a grounded perspective. What is the hardest part of asking for a major grant that you are ready to overcome this year?

  3. Jun 7

    Ep . 8 - Capital Campaign Triumphs: Beating the Deadline with Frankie Rankin

    With shifting economic landscapes and looming federal budget cuts, fundraising leaders must learn how to strategically leverage big opportunities before time runs out. In this episode, Allison McElroy sits down with Frankie Rankin, the CEO of the Single Parent Scholarship Fund of Northwest Arkansas, to uncover how her organization successfully unlocked a major milestone under immense pressure. We sit down to unpack the high-stakes world of challenge grants and the precise strategies required to execute them successfully. Frankie shares the behind-the-scenes realities of managing a massive capital campaign, detail by detail, including the specific rules governing structures like the Tulsa-based challenge framework. The conversation details how to manage dual campaign spreadsheets, navigate public vs. quiet phases, and mobilize board members who are terrified of traditional asking but brilliant at relationship handoffs. The true turning point of the episode centers on a massive $590,000 deficit with only 48 hours remaining on the clock, demonstrating how deep stakeholder trust can inspire a jaw-dropping final hour save. The road to achieving these monumental fundraising milestones is never clean, straightforward, or without immense professional strain. Campaigns rarely move in a straight line, and leaders often face severe plateaus, internal team transitions, and moments of sheer defeat where giving up feels like the only logical choice. Viewers will walk away with a grounded framework for building authentic donor transparency, specific strategies for structuring multi-year pledges, and a reminder that fundraising success relies on methodical planning rather than luck. If you care about non-profit sustainability, strategic capital campaigns, and leveraging board relationships, you’ll get a lot from this episode. Please remember to Subscribe and Share to help us expand our reach. What is the most unexpected breakthrough your team has experienced during a tight deadline? Let us know in the comments below!

  4. May 7

    Ep. 7 - Mission Possible: Solving Your Board Problems with Linda Phillips

    Board member disengagement is a silent profit leak that keeps most nonprofits playing small. Many executive directors feel like they are pulling teeth just to get a board member to share a post or make an introduction, but the reality is that most members are simply intimidated by the "F" word: fundraising. If your board views their role as a monthly meeting rather than a mission-driven partnership, you are missing out on the organic growth that only peer-to-peer influence can provide. In this episode, I sit down with my long-time friend, mentor, and thirty-year fundraising veteran Linda Phillips to discuss how to move past the fear of the "ask." We get into the tactical reality of turning a passive board into a group of high-performing connectors. We sit down to discuss the "spoon-feeding" method for social media, why a clear job description is the foundation of engagement, and how "mission moments" can arm your members with the stories they need to be effective ambassadors. Linda shares her "secret sauce" for identifying natural connectors and explains why a simple cup of coffee or a "porch party" is often more effective than a high-cost gala. We also dive into the technical necessity of 100% board participation for grant applications and building donor trust. The unglamorous truth is that fundraising isn't about being a slick salesperson; it's about the grit of consistent relationship-building and the willingness to be authentic. You’ll walk away with a practical system for arming your board with "Monday Mission Moments" and a specific strategy for asking for just one introduction per month. We break down the myth that hosting events must be elaborate, proving that vulnerability and passion are your most valuable assets when inviting people into your organization's world. If you care about nonprofit sustainability, effective board management, and lowering the cost of donor acquisition, you’ll get a lot from this conversation. Please subscribe to the Ask Allison podcast and share this episode with a board member or executive director who needs a "fundraising therapy" session today.

  5. Apr 7

    Ep. 6 - Legacy Gifts: Impact That Lasts with Amy McGovern

    A lot of people think fundraising is just asking for money. That idea is not only wrong, it can quietly wreck your donor relationships. I’m joined by Amy McGovern, Director of Development for the Methodist Foundation for Arkansas and President of AFP Northwest Arkansas, for a real-world conversation about what actually moves giving: listening, trust, and inviting people into something they already care about. Amy shares her unexpected career path into development, then breaks down how the Methodist Foundation for Arkansas works, from managing charitable funds and endowments to supporting communities through a robust nonprofit grants program. We talk funding priorities, why “Methodist” in the name doesn’t automatically mean “not for you,” and how sponsorships and grants can help nonprofits tackling issues like poverty and food insecurity. If you’ve wondered where to look for nonprofit funding in Arkansas, this will point you in a practical direction. We also get honest about what nonprofits can do better, especially around impact reporting and donor stewardship. Stats matter, but stories stick. You’ll hear why handwritten thanks, clear outcomes, and a real human face can outperform the prettiest annual report. Then we zoom out to professional growth through the Association of Fundraising Professionals, including ethics, mentorship, scholarships, and the community that keeps fundraisers from feeling like they’re doing this work alone. If you enjoyed this conversation, subscribe, share it with a nonprofit friend, and leave a review so more people can find it. What’s one fundraising “rule” you’re ready to unlearn?

Ratings & Reviews

5
out of 5
3 Ratings

About

The Ask Allison Podcast with Allison McElroy brings nonprofit pros together for real talk, big laughs, and aha moments! Through honest conversations, shared stories, and fresh takes on trends and best practices, Allison keeps it fun, encouraging, and full of heart. Allison McElroy is a bubbly encourager, nonprofit strategist, and proud Arkansan who loves helping people reach big goals. Founder of The McElroy Group, she mixes heart, humor, and hard-won experience to lift others up. Fundraiser, singer, speaker, cheerleader—when in doubt, just Ask Allison!