Crime Chats

Lisa Iacoletti and Hilary Morrow

Crime Chats is a casual true crime podcast where we get together and chat about the crimes we can’t stop thinking about. From infamous cases and unsolved mysteries to shocking criminal behavior and courtroom chaos. No scripts, no stiff narration, just casual conversations between real-life best friends. We'll share our honest opinions, theories, and the occasional dark joke every now and then. In each episode, we'll chat about a case that’s been living rent-free in our minds. If you love true crime podcasts, unsolved cases, crime discussion, hearing two friends break down criminal cases in a relatable, conversational way, and you don't mind the occasional colorful language, Crime Chats is for you.

  1. 2d ago

    Synanon: From Addiction Rehabilitation to Abusive Control (Part 2 of 2)

    In Part 2, we follow Synanon's disturbing evolution under Chuck Dederich, from its expansion into communal living and experimental education to its eventual confrontation with the outside world. As children fled its compounds, former members and families began speaking out, journalists investigated, and Synanon's attempts to silence its critics only made things worse. And yes, things get considerably darker. 🔎 What We Cover The organization's expansion into a luxury hotel, rural compounds, and communal living for non-addicts.The evolution of Synanon's infamous Game into 72-hour marathon sessions designed to break down members psychologically.Synanon's experimental school system and the increasingly disturbing treatment of children raised inside the organization.Chuck Dederich's escalating control over members, including mandatory head shaving, forced vasectomies, pressure to undergo abortions, and the dismantling of marriages.Children escaping Synanon's compounds and the local families who helped them.The formation of the Imperial Marines and Synanon's growing willingness to use physical violence against outsiders.The investigations, lawsuits, and media battles that exposed the organization's abuses.The infamous rattlesnake placed in an attorney's mailbox.Synanon's legal and financial collapse, including the loss of its tax-exempt status and eventual dissolution in 1991.The organization's lasting influence on the troubled teen industry and the survivors who continue to speak out.📰 Sources Click here for a full list of the sources used for this episode. 📚 Further Reading Jollett, M. (2020). Hollywood Park: A memoir. Celadon Books. (Memoir by Mikel Jollett describing his childhood inside Synanon's collective nurseries and his escape from the compound.) (click here to purchase through our affiliate link) Montell, A. (2021). Cultish: The language of fanaticism. Harper Wave. (Examines the language of coercive control, featuring firsthand accounts from Montell's father, who was raised in Synanon as a child.) (click here to purchase through out affiliate link) Szalavitz, M. (2006). Help at any cost: How the troubled-teen industry cons parents and hurts kids. Riverhead Books. (Investigates how Synanon's confrontational "attack therapy" and disciplinary tactics were adapted into commercial youth programs.) (click here to purchase through our affiliate link) ☕ Support the Show If you’re enjoying Crime Chats and want to support more deep dives like this: Buy our merch on Amazon!Follow/subscribe so you don’t miss what’s nextbuymeacoffee.com/crimechatsFollow us on Facebook, TikTok, and YouTube for more true crime discussions, clips, and behind-the-scenes content.

  2. 3d ago

    Synanon: From Addiction Rehabilitation to Abusive Control (Part 1 of 2)

    In 1950s California, heroin addiction was devastating lives, and treatment options were few and far between. Then Chuck Dederich came along with a radically different approach: a community built around peer support, personal accountability, and helping addicts get clean. What began as an unconventional rehabilitation program quickly grew into something much bigger. Synanon attracted celebrity visitors, political support, generous donations, and national attention. Its methods were unconventional, its success stories were compelling, and for a while, it seemed like it might actually be changing the way addiction was treated. ⚠️ Trigger Warning This episode discusses drug addiction and cult dynamics, including authoritarian control and exploitation. 🔎 What We Cover Chuck Dederich's early life, struggles with alcoholism, and the experiences that shaped his pathThe creation of Synanon and its beginnings as a peer-led rehabilitation communityLife inside the cult and the three-stage process residents went through The Synanon Game: confrontational group therapy and the bonds it createdSynanon's early success stories and its growing reputationThe legal battles, public support, and political attention that helped Synanon expandThe organization's lucrative promotional products businessCelebrity visitors, national expansion, and the first signs of a major shift in Dederich's vision💬 Join the Conversation Can a program have genuinely positive beginnings but still develop into something harmful, or had Charles Dederich had abusive intentions all along? We want to hear your thoughts! 📰 Sources Click here for a full list of the sources used for this episode. 📚 Further Reading Jollett, M. (2020). Hollywood Park: A memoir. Celadon Books. (Memoir by Mikel Jollett describing his childhood inside Synanon's collective nurseries and his escape from the compound.) (click here to purchase through our affiliate link) Montell, A. (2021). Cultish: The language of fanaticism. Harper Wave. (Examines the language of coercive control, featuring firsthand accounts from Montell's father, who was raised in Synanon as a child.) (click here to purchase through out affiliate link) Szalavitz, M. (2006). Help at any cost: How the troubled-teen industry cons parents and hurts kids. Riverhead Books. (Investigates how Synanon's confrontational "attack therapy" and disciplinary tactics were adapted into commercial youth programs.) (click here to purchase through our affiliate link) ☕ Support the Show If you’re enjoying Crime Chats and want to support more deep dives like this: Buy our merch on Amazon!Follow/subscribe so you don’t miss what’s nextbuymeacoffee.com/crimechatsFollow us on Facebook, TikTok, and YouTube for more true crime discussions, clips, and behind-the-scenes content.

  3. 5d ago

    The Sullivanians: Free Love, Broken Families & Brainwashing (Part 2 of 2)

    What happens when a movement promising freedom, sexual liberation, and a better way to live slowly turns into a system of control and dominance over those who followed it? In 1950s New York City, a group of therapists and their patients began experimenting with an alternative to traditional relationships, marriage, and family life. They called themselves The Sullivan Institute. Their ideas attracted artists, intellectuals, and hundreds of people looking for something different. But what began as an unconventional social experiment eventually became something far more sinister. Under the leadership of Saul Newton, the group developed increasingly rigid rules governing members' relationships, finances, careers, and even their children. We'll unpack how it happened, who was responsible, and how an organization built around challenging traditional family structures ultimately left so many families fractured. ⚠️ Trigger Warning: This episode discusses psychological manipulation, sexual coercion, child separation, emotional abuse, and family estrangement. 🔎 What We Cover The origins of the Sullivan Institute and its founders, Saul Newton and Jane Pearce.The influence of psychoanalyst Harry Stack Sullivan and the group's unconventional approach to therapy.The group's rejection of traditional marriage, monogamy, and the nuclear family.The controversial practices surrounding parenthood and child-rearing.Saul Newton's growing influence and the increasingly authoritarian atmosphere within the group.The group's paranoia, internal conflicts, and the events that contributed to its eventual collapse.The custody disputes and legal battles that helped expose the Sullivanians to the outside world.The lasting impact on former members and their families.📰 Sources Click here for a full list of the sources used for this episode. 📚 Further Reading Stille, A. (2023). The Sullivanians: Sex, psychotherapy, and the wild life of an American commune. Farrar, Straus and Giroux. (Click here to purchase through our affiliate link) Honan, Artie. How Did a Smart Guy Like Me ...: My 21 Years in Sullivanian Therapy and the Fourth Wall Theater Company. Independently published, 2020. (Click here to purchase through our affiliate link) Graves, Alice. Don’t Tell Anyone: A Cult Memoir. Independently published, 31 Oct. 2019. (Click here to purchase through our affiliate link) ☕ Support the Show If you’re enjoying Crime Chats and want to support more deep dives like this: Share this episode with someone who would find it interestingBuy our merch on Amazon!Follow/subscribe so you don’t miss what’s nextbuymeacoffee.com/crimechatsFollow us on Facebook, TikTok, and YouTube for more true crime discussions, clips, and behind-the-scenes content.

  4. Nov 10

    The Sullivanians: Free Love, Broken Families & Brainwashing (Part 1 of 2)

    What happens when a movement promising freedom, sexual liberation, and a better way to live slowly turns into a system of control and dominance over those who followed it? In 1950s New York City, a group of therapists and their patients began experimenting with an alternative to traditional relationships, marriage, and family life. They called themselves The Sullivan Institute. Their ideas attracted artists, intellectuals, and hundreds of people looking for something different. But what began as an unconventional social experiment eventually became something far more sinister. Under the leadership of Saul Newton, the group developed increasingly rigid rules governing members' relationships, finances, careers, and even their children. We'll unpack how it happened, who was responsible, and how an organization built around challenging traditional family structures ultimately left so many families fractured. ⚠️ Trigger Warning: This episode discusses psychological manipulation, sexual coercion, child separation, emotional abuse, and family estrangement. 🔎 What We Cover The origins of the Sullivan Institute and its founders, Saul Newton and Jane Pearce.The influence of psychoanalyst Harry Stack Sullivan and the group's unconventional approach to therapy.The group's rejection of traditional marriage, monogamy, and the nuclear family.The controversial practices surrounding parenthood and child-rearing.Saul Newton's growing influence and the increasingly authoritarian atmosphere within the group.The group's paranoia, internal conflicts, and the events that contributed to its eventual collapse.The custody disputes and legal battles that helped expose the Sullivanians to the outside world.The lasting impact on former members and their families.📰 Sources Click here for a full list of the sources used for this episode. 📚 Further Reading Stille, A. (2023). The Sullivanians: Sex, psychotherapy, and the wild life of an American commune. Farrar, Straus and Giroux. (Click here to purchase through our affiliate link) Honan, Artie. How Did a Smart Guy Like Me ...: My 21 Years in Sullivanian Therapy and the Fourth Wall Theater Company. Independently published, 2020. (Click here to purchase through our affiliate link) Graves, Alice. Don’t Tell Anyone: A Cult Memoir. Independently published, 31 Oct. 2019. (Click here to purchase through our affiliate link) ☕ Support the Show If you’re enjoying Crime Chats and want to support more deep dives like this: Share this episode with someone who would find it interestingBuy our merch on Amazon!Follow/subscribe so you don’t miss what’s nextbuymeacoffee.com/crimechatsFollow us on Facebook, TikTok, and YouTube for more true crime discussions, clips, and behind-the-scenes content.

  5. Nov 4

    Daniel LaPlante: The Boy in the Walls (Part 2 of 2)

    In honor of Halloween, we are taking a break from cults & cons to explore a real-life horror story: the disturbing case of Daniel LaPlante. In 1986, Daniel LaPlante snuck into the Bowen family home and stayed there. For six whole months. But that terrifying incident was only the beginning of a much darker story... Just one year later, LaPlante would be responsible for the murders of Priscilla Gustafson and her two young children, Abigail and William. ⚠️ Content Warning This episode discusses home invasion, stalking, violence, murder, and the deaths of two young children. Listener discretion is strongly advised. 🔎 What We Cover The string of burglaries Daniel LaPlante committed before his stay in the Bowen homeDaniel LaPlante's fixation with Tina Bowen and how that led to the 1986 incidentDaniel LaPlante's second Bowen home invasion and how he was able to stay concealed inside for months on endHow Daniel LaPlante was discovered concealed behind a false wall in the basement.Daniel LaPlante's arrest, time in juvenile detention, and eventual release of bailThe events leading up to the December 1987 murders of Priscilla Gustafson and her children, Abigail and William.The investigation and the evidence that connected LaPlante to the murders.His subsequent flight from police, another terrifying encounter, and eventual arrest.The trial, convictions, and developments in his sentencing.💬 Join the Conversation What would possess someone to live inside the walls of a home and terrorize the family living there? And how was a 16 year old boy able to go missing from his own home for 6 months without raising alarms? 📚 Sources Click here for a full list of the sources used for this episode. ☕ Support the Show If you’re enjoying Crime Chats and want to support more deep dives like this: Share this episode with someone who would find it interestingBuy our merch on Amazon!Follow/subscribe so you don’t miss what’s nextbuymeacoffee.com/crimechats

  6. Nov 3

    Daniel LaPlante: The Boy in the Walls (Part 1 of 2)

    In honor of Halloween, we are taking a break from cults & cons to explore a real-life horror story: the disturbing case of Daniel LaPlante. In 1986, Daniel LaPlante snuck into the Bowen family home and stayed there. For six whole months. But that terrifying incident was only the beginning of a much darker story... Just one year later, LaPlante would be responsible for the murders of Priscilla Gustafson and her two young children, Abigail and William. ⚠️ Content Warning This episode discusses home invasion, stalking, violence, murder, and the deaths of two young children. Listener discretion is strongly advised. 🔎 What We Cover The string of burglaries Daniel LaPlante committed before his stay in the Bowen homeDaniel LaPlante's fixation with Tina Bowen and how that led to the 1986 incidentDaniel LaPlante's second Bowen home invasion and how he was able to stay concealed inside for months on endHow Daniel LaPlante was discovered concealed behind a false wall in the basement.Daniel LaPlante's arrest, time in juvenile detention, and eventual release of bailThe events leading up to the December 1987 murders of Priscilla Gustafson and her children, Abigail and William.The investigation and the evidence that connected LaPlante to the murders.His subsequent flight from police, another terrifying encounter, and eventual arrest.The trial, convictions, and developments in his sentencing.💬 Join the Conversation What would possess someone to live inside the walls of a home and terrorize the family living there? And how was a 16 year old boy able to go missing from his own home for 6 months without raising alarms? 📚 Sources Click here for a full list of the sources used for this episode. ☕ Support the Show If you’re enjoying Crime Chats and want to support more deep dives like this: Share this episode with someone who would find it interestingBuy our merch on Amazon!Follow/subscribe so you don’t miss what’s nextbuymeacoffee.com/crimechats

  7. Oct 28

    The Nine O'Clock Service: From Radical Evangelism to Abusive Control (Part 2 of 2)

    What happens when a movement that promises spiritual connection, community, and a fresh take on religion becomes a place of manipulation and abuse? In the 1980s and 1990s in Sheffield, England, the Nine O’Clock Service attracted hundreds of young people with its unconventional blend of Christian worship, rave culture, electronic music, and multimedia performances. At the center of it all was Chris Brain, a charismatic leader whose influence over the congregation would eventually lead to a devastating scandal. Behind the music, the packed services, and the movement’s progressive image, former members described an increasingly controlling environment in which spiritual authority was used to exert power over followers. When allegations of sexual abuse and manipulation emerged in 1995, the movement collapsed, leaving former members struggling to process what had happened. Decades later, the case returned to the courts, raising difficult questions about institutional accountability and how abuse can flourish within a community built on trust. ⚠️ Content Warning This episode discusses sexual abuse, rape, spiritual abuse, coercive control, and manipulation within a religious community. Listener discretion is advised. 🔎 What We Cover Chris Brain's early life and how he first came into the Christian faithThe pull toward leadership that Chris felt almost immediately upon his conversion and joining a church of his ownHow Chris Brain built a devoted following through charisma, music, and spiritual authorityThe origins of the Nine O’Clock Service and its unconventional approach to Christian worshipThe group’s growing influence and the culture that developed around itThe 1995 scandal that brought the Nine O’Clock Service to an endThe questions surrounding church leadership, oversight, and institutional accountabilityThe criminal proceedings decades later and the convictions against Chris Brain🎙️ Facts First, Hot Takes Later As always, we’re laying out the facts before getting into our opinions. But this episode does include a lot of personal opinions about religion, God, and worship. 💬 Join the Conversation How does a community built around belonging become a place where people feel unable to question its leader? And when warning signs emerge, who is responsible for taking action? At what point does devotion become manipulation, and what responsibility do institutions have when allegations surface? Share your thoughts in the comments! 📰 Sources Click here for a full list of the sources used for this episode 📚 Further Reading Howard, R. (1996). The rise and fall of the Nine O'Clock Service: A cult within the church? Mowbray / Cassell. (Click here to purchase this book using our affiliate link) ☕ Support the Show If you’re enjoying Crime Chats and want to support more deep dives like this: Share this episode with someone who would find it interestingBuy our merch on Amazon!Follow/subscribe so you don’t miss what’s nextbuymeacoffee.com/crimechats

  8. Oct 27

    The Nine O'Clock Service: From Radical Evangelism to Abusive Control (Part 1 of 2)

    What happens when a movement that promises spiritual connection, community, and a fresh take on religion becomes a place of manipulation and abuse? In the 1980s and 1990s in Sheffield, England, the Nine O’Clock Service attracted hundreds of young people with its unconventional blend of Christian worship, rave culture, electronic music, and multimedia performances. At the center of it all was Chris Brain, a charismatic leader whose influence over the congregation would eventually lead to a devastating scandal. Behind the music, the packed services, and the movement’s progressive image, former members described an increasingly controlling environment in which spiritual authority was used to exert power over followers. When allegations of sexual abuse and manipulation emerged in 1995, the movement collapsed, leaving former members struggling to process what had happened. Decades later, the case returned to the courts, raising difficult questions about institutional accountability and how abuse can flourish within a community built on trust. ⚠️ Content Warning This episode discusses sexual abuse, rape, spiritual abuse, coercive control, and manipulation within a religious community. Listener discretion is advised. 🔎 What We Cover Chris Brain's early life and how he first came into the Christian faithThe pull toward leadership that Chris felt almost immediately upon his conversion and joining a church of his ownHow Chris Brain built a devoted following through charisma, music, and spiritual authorityThe origins of the Nine O’Clock Service and its unconventional approach to Christian worshipThe group’s growing influence and the culture that developed around itThe 1995 scandal that brought the Nine O’Clock Service to an endThe questions surrounding church leadership, oversight, and institutional accountabilityThe criminal proceedings decades later and the convictions against Chris Brain🎙️ Facts First, Hot Takes Later As always, we’re laying out the facts before getting into our opinions. But this episode does include a lot of personal opinions about religion, God, and worship. 💬 Join the Conversation How does a community built around belonging become a place where people feel unable to question its leader? And when warning signs emerge, who is responsible for taking action? At what point does devotion become manipulation, and what responsibility do institutions have when allegations surface? Share your thoughts in the comments! 📰 Sources Click here for a full list of the sources used for this episode 📚 Further Reading Howard, R. (1996). The rise and fall of the Nine O'Clock Service: A cult within the church? Mowbray / Cassell. (Click here to purchase this book using our affiliate link) ☕ Support the Show If you’re enjoying Crime Chats and want to support more deep dives like this: Share this episode with someone who would find it interestingBuy our merch on Amazon!Follow/subscribe so you don’t miss what’s nextbuymeacoffee.com/crimechats

About

Crime Chats is a casual true crime podcast where we get together and chat about the crimes we can’t stop thinking about. From infamous cases and unsolved mysteries to shocking criminal behavior and courtroom chaos. No scripts, no stiff narration, just casual conversations between real-life best friends. We'll share our honest opinions, theories, and the occasional dark joke every now and then. In each episode, we'll chat about a case that’s been living rent-free in our minds. If you love true crime podcasts, unsolved cases, crime discussion, hearing two friends break down criminal cases in a relatable, conversational way, and you don't mind the occasional colorful language, Crime Chats is for you.