Asynchrony Podcast

Kevin Shively and Dean Bagley

A podcast featuring regular discussions between a bleeding-heart liberal and a three-time Trump voter. We explore where our perspectives diverge and where they come together. If you are expecting name calling and acrimony, this might not be for you. If, however, you want to better understand the divisions that are causing so much stress in our world today, then you might feel right at home. Subscribe today to join the conversation and help us be a part of the solution rather than a reason for the problem.

  1. 5d ago

    Episode 41 - Dangerous Divisions - From Disagreement to Dehuminizing

    In Episode 41, co-hosts Kevin Shively and Dean Bagley continue their series on political identity, polarization, and race by examining how disagreement can harden into dehumanization and moral permission for hostility. They correct details from the prior episode, then discuss self-censorship, mistaken beliefs about political opponents, and how cross-cutting relationships can interrupt an escalating cycle. In this concluding installment of a five-part series, hosts Kevin Shively and Dean Bagley examine how political narratives about race, immigration, and supremacy can inflate threats, flatten diverse groups, and intensify in-group/out-group hostility. They weigh evidence and caveats on immigration and electoral claims, then discuss how tolerating dissent within one’s own group and including those who bear the costs could help interrupt polarization and authoritarian escalation. Chapters 00:00 Episode 41: the series recap and today’s question 02:03 Dean corrects details from last week 09:18 How disagreement escalates into dehumanization 13:01 Is there still a political middle? 17:20 From group preference to supremacy 21:41 Partisan dehumanization and inaccurate perceptions 27:09 Why correcting misperceptions can lower hostility 29:32 Self-censorship and the cost of public silence 32:02 Cross-cutting relationships and elite resentment 37:48 Separating supremacy from group identity 47:01 Political violence and the limits of the comparison 48:37 Threat inflation and why political narratives are not equivalent 52:45 Immigration, electoral incentives, and the limits of the evidence 57:48 Why incentive alignment need not mean a conspiracy 01:00:09 Great Replacement claims and competing policy explanations 01:05:17 Deportation patterns, census counts, and representation 01:09:25 Temporary protected status as a possible test, with caveats 01:12:14 Who profits when political divisions are amplified 01:13:12 Robbers Cave and the link between group cohesion and hostility 01:18:03 How to interrupt polarization: protect dissent and include those who bear costs 01:20:03 The series’ central finding: identity and in-group outcomes 01:23:39 The shared fear of totalitarianism and the cycle that can produce it 01:27:10 Falsifiable predictions and the episode’s closing conclusions 01:33:16 What comes next and an invitation to challenge the hosts Support our work by subscribing to our Patreon at https://www.patreon.com/c/AsynchronyPodcast and get access to detailed analyses for every episode.

  2. Nov 3

    Episode 40 - Defining Woke - Mega-Identities

    Asynchrony Podcast co-hosts Kevin Shively and Dean Bagley examine how political identities become fused, self-sealing mega-identities, and what that does to discussions of race and racism. They propose a two-layer, politically symmetric definition of “woke,” test how dissent gets punished, and consider the real-world costs when difficult questions are suppressed. Chapters 00:00 Episode 40: identity stacking and the race discussion 05:17 The two-layer framework: ideals and how costs move 09:14 Partisan, ideological, and social sorting create mega-identities 15:32 Cross-cutting identities and political tolerance 17:26 The decision-benefit-cost test for totalization 22:04 How coalition foundations shape self-sealing identities 24:25 Two definitions of racism and the limits of outcome-only claims 29:23 Duke Power, disparate impact, and job-related standards 37:11 Group self-protection and the left’s possible counterparts 47:52 Mirror tests: change the group, keep the principle 56:07 A proposed structural definition of woke 01:09:24 Testing the definition through the cost of dissent 01:16:25 When silencing debate harms the people it aims to protect 01:25:43 Legitimacy capture and the costs of self-sealing politics01:28:14 Why dissent matters, and what the next episode examines Support our work by subscribing to our Patreon at https://www.patreon.com/c/AsynchronyPodcast and get access to detailed analyses for every episode.

  3. Oct 27

    Episode 39 - Symbolic Racism - The Self-Sealing Loop

    Kevin Shively and Dean Bagley continue their conversation about polarization, identity, and race in America. They explore how disagreements can stem from using different definitions of racism, and how in-group and out-group dynamics shape the way people interpret research, policies, and one another. The conversation also looks at symbolic politics, broad identity labels, and the challenge of distinguishing attitudes from behavior. Kevin and Dean close by emphasizing the value of cross-cutting identities and continued conversation, and preview a discussion about supremacy. Chapters 0:00 Season update and the episode’s focus 1:10 How the podcast’s questions develop as new research emerges 2:22 Identity as a source of disagreement3:30 Polarization and political parties becoming enemies 5:14 Civil rights legislation and perceptions of racial hostility 6:45 Changing attitudes toward interracial and interparty marriage 8:05 Two different definitions of racism 11:12 Looking for explanations beyond individual intent 12:35 Symbolic politics and in-group/out-group dynamics 13:37 The Robbers Cave experiment and group hostility 15:33 Symbolic racism and System 1/System 2 thinking 17:36 How socialization shapes political symbols 18:05 School busing and symbolic attitudes 20:20 How researchers measure racial resentment 22:32 The overlap between those measures and conservative ideology 26:31 How accusations can reinforce in-group/out-group conflict 27:57 White identity and group boundaries 29:29 Political labels as team colors and identity markers 30:16 How people adopt views from their in-group 33:25 Broad categories and differences among cultures 37:07 Leaving room for doubt when judging people’s motives 38:45 Why understanding another person’s framework matters 40:16 Aesthetic versus structural explanations 41:24 When labels and symbols shut down discussion 43:06 The difference between academic definitions and public usage 47:19 Gaps in research on racial resentment across political groups 48:41 Moral licensing and communication across racial lines 51:52 Projection, purity, and out-group blame 53:23 How partisans create caricatures of the other side 54:38 Tribalism, belonging, and survival 55:10 The use of broad identity labels 59:53 Testing policy principles by switching beneficiary groups 1:03:25 Attitudes versus behavior in discussions of prejudice 1:06:15 How polarization can lead to dehumanization 1:08:58 Cross-cutting identities and political animosity 1:10:29 Social identity as a driver of conflict 1:12:43 Status, credentials, and political identity 1:15:21 Populism and people’s sense of being unheard 1:16:28 Shared identities and the ability to maintain difficult conversations 1:18:10 Why continuing the conversation matters 1:20:03 The upcoming Heavy Frequency Podcast crossover Support our work by subscribing to our Patreon at https://www.patreon.com/c/AsynchronyPodcast and get access to detailed analyses for every episode.

  4. Oct 20

    Episode 38 - The Identity Stack - Mega-Identities

    This episode continues the Asynchrony Podcast's examination of race and society, but the real focus is how identity stacks form, harden, and start to drive polarization. Kevin Shively and Dean Bagley dig into the difference between aesthetic narratives and structural realities, then use that lens to explain why the left and right often talk past each other on racism. They also compare how identity operates differently on each side, why cross-cutting identities matter for democracy, and how contested definitions of racism shape everything from conversation to law. Chapters 00:00 - Opening the series on race, society, and the limits of this episode 02:48 - Aesthetic layer vs. structural layer in the asynchrony framework 03:50 - Totalization and how organizations or people become self-sealing 04:44 - Identity stacking as a personal version of institutional totalization 06:04 - Centralization, consequence distance, and why race does not explain everything 07:01 - The three questions guiding this part of the discussion 08:14 - Identity binaries, moral judgment, and why the stack matters 09:57 - Liliana Mason, social sorting, and “mega identities” 11:20 - Why the Republican stack is narrower and more homogeneous 13:08 - Why the left appears more identity-focused in practice 14:39 - Coalition logic on the left and why categories multiply 16:01 - Why white identity used to be largely invisible by default 18:18 - How European ethnic conflict shaped the idea of “white” 20:31 - Why the left must consciously manage identity categories 22:14 - Race, gender, sexuality, and education as left-side stack markers 24:23 - How ordinary consumer choices become political symbols 25:45 - Why stacked identities make every challenge feel personal 27:28 - Cross-cutting cleavages and why they stabilize democracy 29:31 - A simpler right-wing stack versus a more complex left-wing stack 31:25 - Progressive stack language and identity signaling in public meetings 32:49 - Cross-cutting exposure and why real conversation lowers animosity 33:33 - Shared background as a practical example of common ground 37:12 - Centralized media, fundraising, and national party branding 38:35 - Engagement incentives as the engine of division 40:22 - What makes an identity high priority in a stack 41:10 - Kimberly Crenshaw, intersectionality, and the academic logic of stacking 47:21 - Place and tradition on the right versus category and status on the left 48:55 - Educated white liberals and the “AWFL” critique 50:37 - Why each side reads the other’s priorities as illegitimate 52:11 - The difference between sincere aims and self-promoting totalization 54:18 - Definition A of racism as individual intent and discriminatory conduct 56:10 - Why equal treatment follows directly from definition A 59:36 - Definition B of racism as structural and systemic hierarchy 1:01:24 - Why the right rejects outcome-based definitions as circular 1:04:36 - How the law uses both equal protection and disparate impact logic 1:06:15 - Why remedial discrimination becomes the next hard question 1:09:18 - Sunset clauses, reevaluation, and exit ramps as anti-totalization tools 1:10:26 - Strengths and weaknesses of both racism definitions 1:12:23 - Why definitions determine burden of proof and what counts as evidence 1:13:29 - Disparate impact as a definitional issue, not just a legal one 1:15:47 - Dean’s concern about causation, correlation, and alternative explanations 1:18:51 - What comes next: symbolic racism, left-wing authoritarianism, and supremacy Support our work by subscribing to our Patreon at https://www.patreon.com/c/AsynchronyPodcast and get access to detailed analyses for every episode.

  5. Oct 13

    Episode 37 - Breaking Down Racism - History and Now

    Kevin Shively and Dean Bagley explore the complex factors behind racial polarization, the impact of historical policies like redlining, and the importance of understanding different perspectives to foster meaningful dialogue. Chapters 00:00 Introduction to the discussion on race and polarization 02:03 Kevin and Dean share social media experiences highlighting societal divides 04:08 The concept of identity stacking and hierarchy in political and racial views 07:57 The progressive stack and its influence on societal conversations 12:10 Analyzing public perceptions and misconceptions about race and racism 15:54 The importance of understanding alternative explanations beyond racism 20:04 The role of moral foundations in shaping attitudes towards race 23:57 Historical context: Civil Rights Act and its impact on societal views 28:10 The evolution of the definition of racism and societal perceptions 31:45 The influence of economic factors and resource scarcity on social divides 36:08 The impact of policies like redlining on racial inequality 40:05 Legislative efforts to address systemic racism and their effects 44:02 The importance of dialogue and understanding in bridging divides 47:48 The role of in-group and out-group dynamics in social perception 51:51 The influence of moral and cultural frameworks on attitudes 56:03 The importance of examining structural causes and incentives 01:00:06 The impact of economic and social crises on polarization 01:04:00 Theories of group behavior and resource competition 01:08:11 The concept of zero-sum thinking and its societal effects 01:12:13 Understanding the role of identity and status in social conflicts 01:16:01 The importance of open dialogue and avoiding moral judgments 01:20:03 Conclusion: Moving towards understanding and constructive conversations Support our work by subscribing to our Patreon at https://www.patreon.com/c/AsynchronyPodcast and get access to detailed analyses for every episode.

  6. Oct 6

    Episode 36 - Prioritizing Race - Identity Stacking

    Kevin Shively and Dean Bagley continue their analysis of political polarization by asking whether race is its primary driver—or one part of a broader system involving identity, messaging, and political incentives. They trace developments from 1964 through the late 1970s, explore how identities become politically aligned, and examine why people often project their own priorities onto the other side. Chapters 00:00 — Recap: political movement and ideological diversity 01:50 — Why the conversation turns to race 03:03 — The Civil Rights Act and the polarization timeline 04:37 — Correlation, causation, and the race question 06:11 — Racial prejudice trends and the growing visibility of race 07:27 — Why acknowledging declining prejudice does not mean racism is gone 09:24 — In-groups, out-groups, and human identity 11:55 — The years between the Civil Rights Act and rising polarization 13:58 — Identity stacking and moralized politics 16:17 — From cross-cutting identities to a political mega identity 18:43 — Identity consolidation and the idea of totalization 20:54 — Class politics and changes in the Democratic Party 21:50 — The McGovern–Fraser Commission and primary reforms 23:38 — The New Left and the evolution of political ideas 27:06 — How race and tribal identity connect in the discussion 28:19 — Why so many issues feel political 30:15 — Intuition, System 1 thinking, and political judgment 31:30 — Identity subsidiarity and political conformity 32:41 — Media and fundraising incentives 36:13 — Identity hierarchies and the “progressive stack” 39:31 — Geography, religion, and identity on the right 42:18 — How projection shapes political interpretation 43:21 — Historical voting patterns and changing coalitions 45:39 — Recent shifts among voters by education and demographic group 47:33 — Class-first and identity-first tensions 49:44 — The perception gap between political sides 55:04 — Race salience, perceived threat, and identity shifts 57:10 — The emergence of white political identity 1:00:23 — In-group cohesion and out-group boundaries 1:02:44 — Group position theory and perceived group standing 1:04:09 — The Confederate flag and competing interpretations 1:07:41 — How identity hierarchies change the meaning of symbols 1:09:27 — Racial prioritization and identity consolidation 1:11:17 — Feedback loops between salience and polarization 1:13:02 — What the evidence does—and does not—show Support our work by subscribing to our Patreon at https://www.patreon.com/c/AsynchronyPodcast and get access to detailed analyses for every episode.

  7. Sep 29

    Episode 35 - Abandoning the Middle Ground - Who Moved?

    This episode of the Asynchrony Podcast asks a deceptively simple question: who actually moved more, the left or the right? Kevin Shively and Dean Bagley use their framework to separate perception from evidence, comparing elite political voting data, voter self-identification, and cultural institution shifts.They also dig into why this feels so personal now, how in-group and out-group identity forms before policy disagreement, and why the same words can mean different things across partisan lines. 00:00 - Opening the series and framing the polarization question 03:14 - The original meme that sparked the discussion 06:03 - “Who actually moved?” as the episode’s core question 09:23 - Introducing DW-NOMINATE and congressional voting data 11:18 - Two-dimensional political sorting and historical issue splits 14:01 - When the political middle started to break apart 16:14 - Republicans moving farther right than Democrats moved left 18:18 - Why the left appears more homogeneous than the right 23:52 - The difference between elite politics and voter behavior 24:29 - Cross-party marriage aversion as a sign of tribal hardening 27:16 - Feeling thermometers and growing hostility across parties 30:25 - In-group and out-group animosity comes before policy 32:04 - Social sorting and the rise of the political mega-identity 34:27 - Tracking the emotional gap from the 1970s to 2020 35:47 - Emotion, rationalization, and Jonathan Haidt’s rider and elephant 38:40 - Group loyalty hardens first, then policy positions follow 40:06 - The Great Awokening and shifts among white liberals 42:29 - Media, academia, and institutional alignment 44:54 - Structural power executed versus cultural visibility achieved 46:27 - Why definitions matter as much as data 51:18 - Concept creep and the broadening of terms on both sides 54:00 - Different meanings of racism in partisan conversation 57:28 - Individualist versus structuralist worldviews 58:04 - The Overton window and how it may have shifted 61:20 - Why hardcore partisans are the least reliable judges of change 62:15 - Most Americans say things have mostly stayed the same 64:46 - Why politics feels so personal now 66:46 - How humans form tribes around almost anything 68:37 - Why the right fears institutional lock-in 71:28 - The rise of alternative institutions and media on the right 73:00 - Credentialed versus non-credentialed language divides 76:31 - What surprised each host most about the analysis 78:42 - The real danger is the loss of overlap81:08 - The Civil Rights Act as a future topic for deeper study Support our work by subscribing to our Patreon at https://www.patreon.com/c/AsynchronyPodcast and get access to detailed analyses for every episode.

  8. Sep 22

    Episode 34 - Split Screens - Trust and the Media

    In this episode, Kevin Shively and Dean Bagley explore the deep roots of media polarization, its historical development, and its impact on societal division. They analyze how structural changes, elite influences, and technological advancements have shaped the current media landscape and polarization dynamics. In this episode, Kevin Shively and Dean Bagley explore the dynamics of media totalization, the impact of social media, and the challenges of misinformation and bias in both legacy and alternative media systems. They analyze historical patterns and predict future trends in media consolidation and polarization. Chapters 00:00 Introduction and overview of media polarization 00:04 Introduction to media totalization cycles 01:55 Media as a downstream symptom of societal split 02:20 Historical overview: print, broadcast, and social media 03:59 Different media realities and their impact on polarization 09:14 Historical perspective on media objectivity and bias 10:01 Impact of low barriers to entry on media diversity 15:09 The rise of credentialism and professional journalism 15:47 Consolidation and control in media industries 20:01 The impact of regulatory changes like the repeal of the fairness doctrine 24:49 Bias, vocabulary, and communication gaps between media silos 26:04 Elite influence and the development of media narratives 32:54 The role of technological change and new media platforms 35:34 Social media's role in accelerating totalization 39:57 Structural causes of polarization and the breakdown of feedback mechanisms 45:05 Case studies: Biden's cognitive decline and suppression narratives 49:56 In-group/out-group dynamics and moral judgments in media 55:00 Accuracy, misinformation, and systemic failure modes 59:56 Implications for society and potential solutions 01:05:09 Predictions for future media trends and reforms 01:14:52 Conclusion: balancing media systems and seeking truth Support our work by subscribing to our Patreon at https://www.patreon.com/c/AsynchronyPodcast and get access to detailed analyses for every episode.

About

A podcast featuring regular discussions between a bleeding-heart liberal and a three-time Trump voter. We explore where our perspectives diverge and where they come together. If you are expecting name calling and acrimony, this might not be for you. If, however, you want to better understand the divisions that are causing so much stress in our world today, then you might feel right at home. Subscribe today to join the conversation and help us be a part of the solution rather than a reason for the problem.