Archer's Line Podcast

Rob Archer

Talking about what's happening to broadcast news, radio, and the people who make them matter. www.therobarcher.com

  1. 6d ago

    The Impeachment Club

    UPDATE — November 10, 2026: The House voted 211–204 Tuesday to send articles of impeachment against Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth to committee, effectively blocking an immediate vote on whether to impeach him over his conduct in office, including his handling of the war in Iran. Americans have become accustomed to impeachment. We impeached Bill Clinton once. Donald Trump twice. Andrew Johnson once, back when the country was still trying to figure out what to do with itself after the Civil War. Richard Nixon resigned before Congress could impeach him. We’ve also impeached a collection of federal judges, including some who actually got kicked out of office. But Cabinet secretaries? In nearly 250 years of American history, only two have been impeached. And now, Pete Hegseth may be joining that exclusive club. Archer's Line is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. The Secretary of Defense faces eight articles of impeachment introduced by Republican Congressman Thomas Massie of Kentucky. The charges involve military operations in Iran, Yemen, and Venezuela, along with allegations involving civilian casualties and constitutional violations. Hegseth denies wrongdoing. The House could vote on impeachment as early as this week. The first time this happened was in 1876. His name was William Worth Belknap, and he was Secretary of War under President Ulysses S. Grant. Belknap was a decorated Civil War veteran who apparently discovered that serving his country wasn’t quite as lucrative as he’d hoped. Military forts on the western frontier had trading posts, where soldiers could buy supplies and other necessities. The people operating these posts could make quite a bit of money. And Belknap controlled who got those appointments. Belknap was accused of accepting kickbacks in exchange for awarding those profitable positions. When Congress investigated, things went badly for him. On March 2, 1876, Belknap hurried to the White House, handed President Grant his resignation, and presumably hoped that would be the end of it. It wasn’t. The House impeached him anyway. Unanimously. It’s awfully hard to imagine the House doing anything of importance unanimously. The Senate held a trial, but couldn’t muster the two-thirds majority needed to convict him, so Belknap went home a free man, although less distinguished than when he arrived in Washington. And for the next 148 years, no other Cabinet secretary was impeached. Then came Alejandro Mayorkas. In 2024, House Republicans impeached President Biden’s Secretary of Homeland Security over his handling of immigration enforcement at the southern border. The vote was 214 to 213. Unlike Belknap, Mayorkas wasn’t accused of taking bribes or personally enriching himself. The charges concerned his administration of immigration laws and what Republicans considered a failure to carry out his responsibilities. Democrats argued that the dispute was about policy, not impeachable misconduct. When the articles reached the Senate, the Democratic majority dismissed them without holding a full trial. And that was that. Two Cabinet impeachments in American history. Neither resulted in a conviction. Which brings us back to Hegseth. The impeachment effort is being led by a Republican against a Republican president’s Defense Secretary. Massie argues that Hegseth has exercised military power in violation of the Constitution and federal law. The House can impeach an official with a simple majority. Removing that person requires a two-thirds vote in the Senate. And the Senate has never convicted and removed a Cabinet secretary. Eight federal officials have been removed after being impeached, and they were all judges. The Founders created impeachment because they knew public officials might abuse their power. They also made conviction difficult because they knew Congress might abuse its power, too. They called it checks and balances. And nearly 250 years later, we’re still trying to get that right. This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.therobarcher.com/subscribe

About

Talking about what's happening to broadcast news, radio, and the people who make them matter. www.therobarcher.com