Kitchen Table College Chats

Gary Stocker, Marc Deboer

We all know that choosing a college is one of the biggest investments your family will ever make, but it doesn't have to be the most stressful. Each and every episode, we pull up a virtual chair to cut through the jargon and tackle the real-world questions about admissions and finances and even the financial health and viability of colleges.

  1. Jun 15

    AI for the high school student on the Kitchen Table College Chat 061126

    In this episode of Kitchen Table College Chat, Gary Stocker and Marc DeBoer take opposing viewpoints on one of the biggest questions facing education today: Should high school students embrace artificial intelligence? Framing the discussion as a debate between an AI skeptic and an AI advocate, they explore whether AI is primarily a learning tool or a shortcut that discourages critical thinking. Gary argues that students need to develop their own reasoning skills before relying on technology, warning that overdependence on AI could weaken creativity, individuality, and the ability to solve problems independently. Marc counters that AI is as transformative and inevitable as the calculator or the internet, arguing that students who learn to use it effectively will gain a significant advantage in college and future careers.  The conversation expands to examine how AI may reshape college admissions, essay writing, workforce preparation, and the future role of higher education itself. The hosts discuss whether colleges should disclose their use of AI in admissions decisions, how students can use AI ethically for brainstorming and studying, and whether schools have a responsibility to teach responsible AI use rather than resist it. While both agree that AI is here to stay, they differ sharply on its long-term impact: Marc believes students who master AI will thrive in an increasingly automated world, while Gary worries that relying on prompts instead of human judgment and experience could erode the critical thinking skills that education is meant to develop. The episode leaves listeners with a central question: in an AI-driven future, how do we balance efficiency with authentic learning?

    AI for the high school student on the Kitchen Table College Chat 061126
  2. Jun 7

    What is a good college decision? on the Kitchen Table College Chat for June 4, 2026

    This episode of Kitchen Table College Chat focuses on a central question for families: What actually makes a “good” college decision? Gary Stocker and Marc DeBoer challenge the traditional ways families evaluate colleges and argue that most students and parents focus on the wrong factors during the college search process. The episode begins with listener questions about college pricing, admissions yield, and college closures. Gary explains that many private colleges heavily discount tuition — citing a recent report showing an average first-year discount rate of 57% at private colleges — meaning families often pay far less than the published “sticker price.” The hosts encourage parents to understand the difference between list price and actual tuition fees charged. They explain the concept of admissions yield, which measures how many accepted students actually enroll. Gary argues that admissions yield reflects market confidence in a college: schools with stronger reputations and student outcomes tend to attract more students who accept their offers. Another major discussion centers on the risk of college closures. Gary emphasizes that no one can predict with certainty whether a college will close, but families should examine financial data, enrollment trends, endowment strength, and graduation rates to assess institutional stability. He frames this as part of the mission of College Viability — helping families “inspect” colleges the same way consumers inspect homes or cars before making major purchases. The core theme of the episode is redefining what “good” means in a college decision. Marc explains that most families focus on prestige, rankings, acceptance letters, and reputation when choosing a college, but after graduation they judge success very differently — based on debt levels, graduation timelines, happiness, and employment outcomes. He argues that families should reverse their priorities and focus on outcomes first, not marketing or rankings. Gary reinforces this argument by emphasizing objective data points families should track, including: Four-year graduation ratesFirst-year retention ratesEnrollment trendsEndowment strengthEndowment per studentHe argues that colleges with weak graduation or retention rates are signaling operational or financial problems that families should not ignore. The hosts also criticize college rankings systems, describing many of them as “beauty pageants” driven more by perception and marketing than meaningful student outcomes. Gary argues that rankings providers are financially connected to colleges and rarely offer truly critical evaluations of institutional risk or student success. Toward the end of the episode, the conversation broadens to the future of higher education. Gary argues that many smaller, financially challenged colleges are struggling in a declining market and cannot compete with major university brands for students. Marc adds that headline enrollment growth statistics may hide deeper challenges, especially among smaller undergraduate institutions facing demographic declines. Overall, the episode encourages families to move beyond prestige and marketing and instead evaluate colleges through the lens of outcomes, financial stability, and long-term student success.

    What is a good college decision? on the Kitchen Table College Chat for June 4, 2026

About

We all know that choosing a college is one of the biggest investments your family will ever make, but it doesn't have to be the most stressful. Each and every episode, we pull up a virtual chair to cut through the jargon and tackle the real-world questions about admissions and finances and even the financial health and viability of colleges.