The Pretend Pros

Jennifer Hoffman

Welcome to The Pretend Pros, the sports podcast where the takes are hot and the expertise is...questionable. We're two die-hard fans breaking down weekly stories in sports, from March Madness and college rivalries to whatever interesting story catches our eyes. One of us might know what we're talking about...the other is just here for the chaos. This is The Pretend Pros -- certified fans, uncertified experts.

  1. Oct 27

    Episode 31: The Pretend Pros Bowl

    One ugly loss, one bragging-rights bet, and one very real question: did Indiana just get sent back to the kids’ table? Beth and Jenny turn their Ohio State vs. Indiana showdown into a high-stakes college football therapy session, complete with scoreboard debates, ranking chaos, and just enough rivalry trash talk. Beth, the devastated IU fan, breaks down why this game felt bigger than a normal loss, from the late-80s drought to the pressure of finally earning respect. Jenny, the Buckeye fan, revels in the win but admits the margin was razor thin, which makes the postgame arguing even better. Together, they unpack the controversial catch, and why the result still left both fan bases with very different emotions. You'll hear them get into: Why Indiana fell while Ohio State climbedThe wild weekend of upsets across the top 25, including chaos in the SECWhy injuries, bye weeks, and quarterback depth could reshape the weeks aheadThe looming Michigan, USC, and conference schedule pressure on both teamsWhat the expanded playoff era means for rankings, bowl games, and recruiting timing Beth also brings the IU perspective on what it means to finally be relevant again, while Jenny gives the Buckeye side of the rivalry and the confidence that comes with surviving a close one. It is funny, petty, and insightful in the way only true sports-fan friendships can be. If you care about college football, rivalry energy, ranking drama, or the kind of sports arguments that never fully end, this one is essential listening. Perfect for fans who want to hear what a one-score game can do to two co-hosts who both think they were right.

  2. Oct 13

    Episode 30: MLB, WNBA, & College Football Collide in a Massive Sports Week

    From the Guardians’ playoff run and MLB’s payroll problem to Indiana’s bowl-clinching football season and a wildly open WNBA championship, Jenny Hoffman and Beth Painter break down the games, the stakes, and the teams you should actually be watching. Jenny brings the Guardians perspective, including the ALCS matchup, and why Cleveland’s low-payroll success is reigniting the old question: should baseball finally put a cap on spending? Beth pushes the conversation beyond one league, weighing in on the WNBA final between the Atlanta Dream and Golden State Valkyries, plus the rise of IU football and what makes this season feel different for Hoosiers fans. You'll discover: Why the Guardians’ run is so much more impressive when you see where their payroll ranksWhat could be next for MLB when the collective bargaining agreement expires in DecemberWhy this WNBA title series feels historic, with first-time finalists, sweep-heavy drama, and star power everywhereHow IU football got to bowl eligibility and why next Saturday’s Ohio State vs. IU matchup is suddenly The Pretend Pros Bowl Game They also hit the weekend’s biggest college football shake ups, including the fallout from Texas vs. Oregon, Georgia vs. Alabama, and Lane Kiffin’s loss, plus a quick tour through the early NFL surprises, from undefeated teams to disappointing starts and breakout quarterbacks. Are the Browns actually good this season? Perfect for fans who want the real conversation behind the scores, not just a box score recap. By the end, you’ll be caught up, entertained, and probably already planning your next rivalry watch party.

  3. Oct 6

    Episode 29: Behind the Camera with Will Tinsley

    What does it take to bring the biggest sports moments on TV to life? Will Tinsley, a freelance camera operator and robotics technician pulls back the curtain on the hidden crew, high-stakes logistics, and split-second decisions behind the games you watch every week. Will is a freelance TV camera operator and robotics technician who works on major national sports broadcasts for networks including ESPN, NBC, CBS, Fox Sports, and the Big Ten Network. He is a two-time Sports Emmy Award winner for his work on the 2018 US Open and the 2025 MLB World Series broadcast team. In this conversation, he breaks down how a totally accidental college job turned into a 20-year career in live sports production, and why being in the right place at the right time only gets you started. You'll discover how robotic cameras work, why they’re used for angles a human operator can’t reach, and what it actually takes to rig and run them in arenas, stadiums, and remote production trucks. Will also explains how crews scale from a 30-person local show to a hundred-plus-person national event, how weather delays and extra innings change everything for the broadcast team, and why the longest nights are often the ones fans remember most. We also get into the career path behind the camera, from grassroots networking in Milwaukee to building a reputation that leads to national assignments. Will shares what it's like working through 18-inning baseball games, six-hour tennis matches, and championship moments where the pressure is real, the drama is unscripted, and the entire broadcast hinges on capturing the shot at exactly the right second. If you’ve ever wondered how live sports actually make it from the field to your screen, this episode is packed with behind-the-scenes insight, industry stories, and a whole new appreciation for the people who make the magic happen. Essential listening for sports fans, aspiring broadcast pros, and anyone who loves seeing how big moments get built behind the scenes.

  4. Sep 29

    Episode 28: Confessions of an Uno Champion with Matt Eckert

    The best sports story in this episode has nothing to do with a stadium. It starts with a 30-year Uno grudge, a framed check, and a friend group that takes card games way more seriously than it should. Jenny and Beth are joined by Beth's longtime friend, Matt Eckert, for a fast, funny, all-over-the-map conversation that turns into a surprisingly revealing look at competition, family, and why some people are built to keep score forever. If you love sports banter, sibling-level friendship chaos, and the kind of inside jokes that only come from decades of history, this one is for you. You'll discover: How a casual Uno rivalry turned into a decades-long bet with a very petty endingWhy Matt insists "ping pong" is still the right name, no matter how elite the table getsThe hilarious sports Matt would actually consider pretending to play, from badminton to bobsledHow he became a full-on sports pipeline for The Pretend ProsWhy IU fandom is basically a family trait, complete with campus-size debates, football optimism, and plenty of Purdue shadeMatt also shares the reality of raising kids who live and breathe sports, from dance competitions that eat entire Saturdays to the emotional shift that comes when the last season ends. Along the way, the trio swaps stories about school boards, club sports, archery, lacrosse, and the strange joy of finding an Indiana connection in almost anything. At the center of it all is a bigger truth: sports are often just the excuse. The real story is the people, the rituals, the rivalries, and the lifelong friendships built in bleachers, living rooms, and on the losing end of a very memorable Uno game. Perfect for anyone who loves college sports, family sports stories, and episodes that feel like hanging out with friends who have been roasting each other for 30 years.

  5. Sep 22

    Episode 27: Stopping the Run with Kolten Gajewski

    Football gets a lot easier to understand when you hear it from a team captain who actually lives in the trenches. Indiana State defensive lineman, Kolten Gajewski, breaks down the hidden mechanics of the game, from the quarterback-to-D-line transition that forced him to rebuild his body to the technique behind stopping the run. If you think football is just size and speed, this conversation changes that fast. Jenny and Beth dig into how Kolten went from a record-setting high school quarterback in a tiny Illinois town to a Division I defensive lineman, team captain, and future grad juggling football and school. You'll discover:Why playing quarterback helped Kolten read offenses from the defensive sideWhat an RPO really is, and why it mattersHow defensive line rotations work and why fresh bodies are everythingThe difference between looking strong and playing with true pad level and leverageWhy run defense is the part of the D-line most fans completely underestimate Beth and Jenny also get Kolten talking about his family football legacy, including his dad's Indiana State connection and the experience of playing alongside his brother, a linebacker. He explains what being voted one of just six team captains means inside a 105-man locker room, what coaches actually expect from leaders, and why big-money games against programs like Purdue are about more than just showing up for the paycheck. Kolten also opens up about the offseason grind, the weirdly specific obsession with uniforms and jersey numbers, the music that actually gets him fired up, and the kind of trash talk that hits hardest. If you love football, hidden details, and the kind of insights that make you watch the trenches differently, this episode is for you.

  6. Sep 15

    Episode 26: US Open Tennis, World Cup Basketball, & Football is Back

    The Pretend Pros are on a roll of heartbreak and hot takes, and this week Jenny and Beth cover the sports moments that had everyone talking. From the US Open’s emotional finish and the rise of American tennis talent to the U.S. women’s basketball team reclaiming gold and a brutal college football weekend, this episode is packed with the wins, losses and everything in between. Jenny brings her tennis obsession to the table, breaking down why this year’s US Open felt different, what made the American men’s run so compelling, and why Ben Shelton, Francis Tiafoe, and Coco Gauff are so much fun to watch. Beth adds her usual sharp commentary, from the significance of the tournament’s sportsmanship and player camaraderie to the bigger-picture questions around who is really emerging as the future of the sport. Then the conversation shifts to women’s basketball, where Beth walks through the U.S. team’s path through the World Cup, the tight early games, the standout performances from Breanna Stewart and Jackie Young, and the tension of facing France with gold on the line. You’ll also hear why Caitlin Clark and Angel Reese are becoming must-watch teammates, how Sue Bird is thinking about the next Olympics, and what this roster says about the future of USA Basketball. The final stretch goes full college football and NFL, with Ohio State’s painful loss to Texas, the weird magic of live mascots like Colorado’s Ralphie, and the kind of first-week NFL optimism that disappears fast. Jenny and Beth also get into the 49ers-Rams showdown in Australia, Myles Garrett’s injury concerns, and what early-season chaos means for the Browns, Panthers, and everyone else still pretending this is their year for the Super Bowl. Perfect for sports fans who love smart banter, real opinions, and the kind of commentary that flips between hilarious and heartfelt in the same breath. Music licensed through Soundstripe. Code: ZMNP86BKBETTLJV1

  7. Sep 8

    Episode 25: A League of Her Own with Veronica Peitersen

    Softball looks simple until you hear what elite outfielders are actually tracking in real time. Veronica Peitersen, a Ball State outfielder and former New Braunfels Unicorn softball and track standout, breaks down the hidden strategy behind the game of softball, from tracking spin, wind, and sunballs to decoding slap hitters, rise balls, and the split-second decisions that separate a highlight reel play from a disaster. Beth Painter and Jenny Hoffman guide the conversation with Veronica, whose path from Texas softball and track to Division I competition is packed with lessons on speed, versatility, and mental toughness. Veronica shares what it took to play every inning in center field without an error, how a coach-built culture turned a five-year playoff drought into a regional semifinal run, and why being a great teammate matters just as much as being a great athlete. You'll discover: Why outfield play is more like route-running than casual catchingHow slap hitters change the entire defensive pictureThe difference between softball and baseball strike zones, pitches, and timingWhat “competitive excellence” actually looks like inside the locker room of a winning teamWhy playing a second sport can make you better, not busier Veronica also opens up about leadership, the grind of balancing training and academics, and the mindset that carried her through years of two-sport competition. If you’ve ever wondered what makes softball so fast, so technical, and so much harder than it looks, this episode will completely change how you watch the game. Perfect for softball fans, young athletes, parents, and anyone who loves hearing how confidence, culture, and sisterhood turn talent into real results. Music licensed through Soundstripe. Code: O2XR3HOGB8ZGDOCO

Ratings & Reviews

5
out of 5
3 Ratings

About

Welcome to The Pretend Pros, the sports podcast where the takes are hot and the expertise is...questionable. We're two die-hard fans breaking down weekly stories in sports, from March Madness and college rivalries to whatever interesting story catches our eyes. One of us might know what we're talking about...the other is just here for the chaos. This is The Pretend Pros -- certified fans, uncertified experts.