A Messy Amen

Shelly Torrey

A Messy Amen welcomes you into the conversations you might not be having on Sundays. Do you ever feel like you want to get to know people more but you get the weird sense that no one can relate to your struggle? You show up to church, sing, listen to the sermon, and go home feeling forgotten, isolated, and frustrated? Here we will be sharing stories that help people feel less alone. We will be honest in ways that may normally feel foreign and share how we hold on to faith and trust God in the ups and downs. 

  1. 17h ago

    Holding onto Hope in Hardship

    Send us Fan Mail What do you say to someone whose whole world just stopped? And what do you do when everyone else goes back to normal and you never really do? This one is personal. My friend Walker Donaldson is the inventory manager at Disc Replay in Saginaw, which, if you know our family, is basically our second living room 😂 We start out light, talking DVDs, the 13th copy of Hitch, his top two game systems of all time, and a Pokemon football game I can’t believe exists. Then we get into the conversation I have been waiting since April to have on this show. Walker lost his sister in 2023. I lost my sister, Kat last fall. Two sisters gone way too soon, and two very different ways of grieving them. We talk about why “sorry for your loss” can feel so empty and what actually helps instead, the grief ball in a box, cherries and sunsets and the little things that sneak up on you, the “why” that never gets answered, how Walker’s faith got harder without ever letting go, how movies and art gave him words for what he couldn’t say, and why “God gives His toughest battles to His strongest soldiers” just isn’t true. I also share the verses that have kept me going. Psalm 147:3, He heals the brokenhearted and binds up their wounds. Isaiah 25:8 and Revelation 21:4, the promise that one day He will wipe every tear from our eyes. There is a whole book of Lamentations in the Bible, friends. You are allowed to sit in it for a minute. If you are grieving this holiday season, or you love someone who is, I think this episode will meet you right where you’re at. Season 3 Episode 2 is live now on YouTube, Buzzsprout, and wherever you listen. Swing by Disc Replay Saginaw and tell Walker hi, and grab a mug or a tee at amessyamenpod.com. I’m so glad you’re here. You are not alone here. 🙏

    Holding onto Hope in Hardship
  2. Nov 9

    Controlled Chaos: Finding Peace When You’re Not in Control

    Send us Fan Mail What do you do when you look like the good kid on the outside, but on the inside you feel like a total disaster? Welcome to Season 3! 😍 I am kicking things off with my friend Emily Johnston, and the way this one came together still makes me laugh. We hadn’t talked in years, and then out of thousands of people walking out of Little Caesars Arena, there she was in the parking lot crowd. So of course I asked her to come on the show. Emily grew up in the Catholic Church, doing all the right things and looking the part, but always feeling like the gospel had to be for the people who had it together. Spoiler, the people who don’t have it together are exactly who Jesus came for. In this conversation we talk about: Fostering a boy she had known since he was six, right as COVID shut everything downThe 12 hour drives her now husband Will made so she could keep seeing himLoving someone through a placement that didn’t end the way you hopedA toddler who went nonverbal and a newborn who refused every single bottle, both at the same timeTrading places at work, burnout, and what kept their marriage grounded through seven years of changeEmily also gets really honest about being in an apathetic faith season while watching her husband grow, and why that isn’t something to drown in guilt over. Emily opens up Philippians 3:12-14 and Philippians 4:11-13, and we read them side by side in the NIV and NLT. If Paul could write about contentment from a prison cell, we can find it in a tiny house that’s busting at the seams. You don’t have to clean yourself up before you show up. You come as you are, and God does the cleaning up in the process. Season 3 Episode 1 is live now on YouTube, Buzzsprout, and wherever you listen. I’m so glad you’re here. You are not alone here. 🙏

    Controlled Chaos: Finding Peace When You’re Not in Control
  3. Oct 16

    Joy, Sweat, and the Walls That Finally Came Down

    Send us Fan Mail What do you do when you have walked away, the door is shut, and you are sure there is no going back? My friend Mandy Shindorf has been teaching Zumba since 2012, and if you have ever been in her class, you know she prays over every single person in that room before the music even starts. But that joy did not come easy. After 12 years of marriage, feeling unseen and caught up in chasing the popular life, Mandy walked away from her husband. She found her way back to the Lord, and every night she and her kids prayed for his salvation. Then one Sunday he called and asked to come to church with them... and he went forward that day. That was not the end of the story though. When her landlord needed his house back and every other door stayed shut, Mandy had to humble herself and move into the other side of her ex-husband's house. For two and a half years she wanted nothing to do with him. Then God broke down a wall she had been building since she was a little girl, and she finally saw the love that had been there all along. We talk about expecting a person to fill a need only God can fill, love languages, forgiving someone without automatically letting them back into your circle, the son she lost and the four kids God gave after, and why sweating it out in a dance class can make the worship music on the drive home hit different. Mandy leans on John 10:10. The enemy comes to steal, kill, and destroy, but Jesus came to give life, and God is in the business of restoration. Nine years back together now, and her husband does Zumba with her. 😂 The joy of the Lord really is our strength (Nehemiah 8:10). You can catch Mandy's Zumba classes in Vassar, MI!!! If you have been carrying a wall you did not even know was there, I think this episode will meet you right where you are at. It is live now on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and YouTube, and you can find mugs, journals, and more at amessyamenpod.com. I am so glad you are here.

    Joy, Sweat, and the Walls That Finally Came Down
  4. Oct 9

    A Mackinac Mission Field

    Send us Fan Mail What does it look like to say yes to God when your life is already going really well? For our first ever episode outside the studio, I'm sitting on the back deck of a parsonage on Mackinac Island with Ken and Lori Straight, pastors of Mackinac Island Bible Church. Back in 2002, their kids were nine and twelve, their church back home was thriving, and they had nothing to complain about. Then a Mother's Day weekend trip to the island turned into an invitation to speak, then a call, and their whole life got turned upside down. Twenty four years later, they're still here. 😂 We talk about what it's really like to live and pastor year round on an island with no cars, about 500 residents, and a church that has never had its own building. Grocery runs by ferry and bike cart, boats that stop when the ice gets too thick, Friday night Coffee House meals for 60 to 80 seasonal workers (51 nations in one summer!), and yes, what happens to all that horse poop after October. But underneath the fun questions is a real mission field. Workers come for six months, a lot of them lonely and away from home for the first time, and Ken and Lori have about three weeks to meet them before they find their crowd. Instead of guarding their hearts because people leave, they've chosen to seize the moment and open their home to strangers. That's their messy amen, a yes to God that was messy and still worth it. Ken shares Romans 8:9-10 and the reminder that the Spirit is life because of righteousness, so we don't have to strive the way we think we do. Lori's life verse since her senior year of high school is still Matthew 6:33, seek first the kingdom of God. If you're on the island this season, Mackinac Island Bible Church meets Sundays at 9:30 at Community Hall on Market Street. The episode is live now wherever you listen. I'm so glad you're here.

    A Mackinac Mission Field
  5. Oct 2

    Fortnite, Faith, and a Love Story Only God Could Write

    Send us Fan Mail What do you do when you've prayed the same prayer so many times you're not sure anyone is listening? This week I'm sitting down with Rae Brown, a friend from church and one of the newest faces in our Bible journaling small group. Rae grew up in Parkersburg, West Virginia, in a church that fell apart right as she left for college. She spent most of her adult life church hopping and carrying a lot of church hurt. Then COVID hit one week after a hard breakup, and she spent six months completely alone. By her mid twenties she was in the darkest place of her life. One night on her bathroom floor she prayed a prayer she had never prayed before. Change my heart, heal whatever is broken, I'm all in. Two weeks later she met David. On Twitch. They fell in love over Fortnite, both terrible at it 😂, and then God started nudging her toward Michigan, which she fought for a long time. We talk about church hurt and remembering pastors are human too, the difference between confronting someone and condemning them, why marriage is supposed to be us against the problem and not us against each other, learning to tell what's your feeling and what's your faith, and what she would tell her younger self. Rae also tells the story of how she and I actually met, and I'll just say God's timing is something else. Rae holds onto Isaiah 43:2, that when you go through deep waters He will be with you, and 2 Kings 20:5, I have heard your prayer and seen your tears. If you have ever wondered whether God hears you on the bathroom floor, He does. A heads up, Rae shares honestly about a season when she came close to ending her life. If that's where you are right now, please reach out to someone today. In the US you can call or text 988. Episode is live now wherever you listen, and on YouTube. Find every episode & the merch at amessyamenpod.com.

    Fortnite, Faith, and a Love Story Only God Could Write
  6. Sep 25

    From the Party House to the Front Porch

    Send us Fan Mail What do you do when the room you are standing in is loud, and God shows up in it anyway? This week I'm sitting down with Ashley Sprunger, someone I have known for almost twenty years through the Christian Motorcyclists Association. Ashley and her husband Nathan went down a road that cost them almost everything. Addiction, jobs they could not keep, housing they could not hold onto, CPS involvement, and close to two years without their daughter Brooklyn at home. Nathan got sober first. Ashley wasn't ready, and she told him so. Then came her birthday party. Sitting in a house full of people she had partied with for years, she looked around and felt the whole thing go hollow. She walked out that night, never went back, and nobody came looking for her. What breaks her open even now is what that moment meant. If God met her there, then God was in that house all along, with the stuck and the hopeless. We talk about what came next, which was not a tidy happy ending. They lost their place, moved back to Lansing, and had to start over from nothing. Ashley leans hard on John 13:7, where Jesus says what I am doing you do not understand now, but afterward you will understand. Losing everything is what put her back near her older boys, where she got to rebuild trust by telling them, don't believe my words, just watch my actions. Devin got baptized. Colin is asking questions again. Nathan is in classes at Great Lakes training to be a pastor, the calling he was told he had as a kid. And they started a small group called Anchored for the students who fall through the cracks after high school. Ashley is currently doing more Bible studies than most of us can keep up with, and her joy about the kinsman redeemer in Ruth is worth the listen all by itself. Episode is live now wherever you listen, and on YouTube. If you have been telling yourself you are too far gone, I think this one will meet you right where you're at. You are not alone here. 🙏

    From the Party House to the Front Porch
  7. Sep 18

    Watch Me: Faith, a Wheelchair, and the Joy of the Lord

    Send us Fan Mail What would you say if someone told you there was no way you could ever live on your own? My friend Rebekka Welsh has heard some version of that her whole life, and her answer has always been the same... watch me. Rebekka was born with arthrogryposis multiplex congenita, a muscle and joint disorder that kept her leg muscles from fully developing, and she has used a wheelchair since she was three or four years old. Her scary first hours of life are actually what brought her parents to Jesus. Growing up she was lonely, pitied by adults and left out by other kids, and she spent a lot of nights asking God why. Over and over, He showed her she was never alone. We cover a lot of ground in this one. We talk about the budget binder that has helped Rebekka and her husband Jeremiah pay off about $8,000 in credit card debt. We talk about the one year she walked away from God and how He welcomed her back with open arms. And we talk about the wild way God provided an accessible van with hand controls... through pop cans. Yes, POP CANS. Rebekka also shares the rude and the ridiculous things people have said to her in public, what she wishes people would say instead, and the sweet way she explains her wheelchair to curious kids at the grocery store. Rebekka is quick to say none of it happens in her own strength. Psalm 91:4 has been her verse for as long as she can remember, "He shall cover you with His feathers, and under His wings you shall take refuge." And on the heavy days, she holds onto Nehemiah 8:10, the joy of the Lord is your strength. Rebekka shares a daily devotional Monday through Thursday, go give her a follow at @Rebekkajean on Tik Tok. The episode is live now wherever you listen, and on YouTube. You can learn more about the show and check out the merch at amessyamenpod.com. If you need a reminder that God is not done with your story, I think this episode will meet you right where you're at. I'm so glad you're here. You are not alone here. 🙏

    Watch Me: Faith, a Wheelchair, and the Joy of the Lord
  8. Sep 11

    From Hurt to Heartfelt Worship

    Send us Fan Mail What do you do when the place that was supposed to heal you is the place that hurt you the worst? Monica Brown grew up a preacher's kid. Her mom was the Sunday school superintendent, she knew every Bible story by heart, and she remembers sitting in the pews as a little girl just bawling while her mom sang. She was six going on seven when her dad died in a boating accident, and she and her siblings were there when it happened. It was the seventies, so nobody sent them to counseling. They went back to church and healed on their own, which is really another way of saying they did not heal at all. Decades later, Monica had been through deliverance ministry, prophetic ministry, word of faith ministry, and church hurt to the uttermost. She lost a marriage, watched a ministry split, had her name dragged through the mud, and came out the other side asking God how she ended up there twice. His answer was not the one she wanted. He told her He allowed it, because He was building her character. And then He asked her the question she had been dodging her whole life. When are you going to let me be a father to you? We get into a lot in this one. Why moving in your gifts is not the same thing as having a relationship with God. Why wisdom comes with responsibility and not with age. Why there are no big I's and little you's in the body of Christ. How to pray when you never had a dad to model it. She lands on Psalm 51, create in me a clean heart, O God, and renew a right spirit within me. She prays it almost every day. Monica sings on the worship team at GraceValley and believes God has a delivering ministry for her that He is still shaping. She is 55, and she will remind you that Moses did not start his until late either. 😍 New episodes drop weekly. Listen wherever you get your podcasts, and find us at amessyamenpod.com. You are not alone here. 🙏

    From Hurt to Heartfelt Worship

About

A Messy Amen welcomes you into the conversations you might not be having on Sundays. Do you ever feel like you want to get to know people more but you get the weird sense that no one can relate to your struggle? You show up to church, sing, listen to the sermon, and go home feeling forgotten, isolated, and frustrated? Here we will be sharing stories that help people feel less alone. We will be honest in ways that may normally feel foreign and share how we hold on to faith and trust God in the ups and downs.