Conversations With Gabriel

The Common Sense ZA

The Common Sense's one-on-one interviews with politicians, businesspeople and other fascinating South African commentators

  1. 23h ago

    Voters Rejected the ANC. ActionSA Wants to Bring It Back.

    Freedom Front Plus leader Corné Mulder says ActionSA is making the wrong calculation by negotiating with the ANC after voters rejected it. The FF Plus went from about 550,000 votes in 2021 to 890,000 in this election, up 62%, and from 221 to 269 councillors. Hung councils went from about 70 to 139. Mulder calls the result a referendum on the ANC, which fell from about 45% to 30%. ActionSA asked Mulder to mediate its talks with the DA. He says the DA, ActionSA and the FF Plus could govern Johannesburg, Tshwane and Ekurhuleni with clear majorities, as well as Emfuleni and Mogale City, but that the deal now looks like a bridge too far. In Tshwane, about 180,000 former ANC voters voted for ActionSA this time, and he asks why ActionSA would take them straight back to the ANC. His warning: the party that revives the ANC will be punished in 2029. Gabriel and Corné also discuss an ANC and DA deal under the GNU, Frans Cronje's case for a national deal first, and breaking South Africa's metros into smaller councils, including Herman Mashaba's response. Read: How Johannesburg Could be Broken up to be Saved https://www.thecommonsense.co.za/economics/how-johannesburg-could-be-broken-up-be-saved Become a member for all the facts and analysis (R99/month): https://www.thecommonsense.co.za/subscribe Chapters:0:00 "Don't overestimate your position"0:16 Introduction0:42 The FF Plus result: 890,000 votes, up 62%2:21 Township wards and the traditional base4:06 From 70 to 139 hung councils5:56 A referendum on the ANC7:59 DA, ActionSA and the FF Plus in Gauteng8:53 Mediating between ActionSA and the DA10:02 ActionSA's conditions, and its offer to the ANC12:08 The ANC bloc falls below 50%14:16 What about an ANC and DA deal?16:00 Gauteng and the rest of the country18:30 Frans Cronje's case for a national deal20:45 Should the metros be broken up?23:23 Herman Mashaba's response25:29 Sub-councils and what works abroad28:20 If ActionSA goes with the ANC30:02 If ActionSA and the DA find each other32:16 Never give up If this was useful, subscribe so you don't miss next week's conversation.

  2. 3d ago

    Zama Zamas, Flooded Mines and Lost Gold: Lloyd Birrell on What Went Wrong

    South Africa was once the world's biggest gold producer. It is now 10th. Lloyd Birrell, CEO of Lions Bay Resources, tells Gabriel Makin that the country's gold output has fallen 80% in 30 years. He traces it to the central bank gold sales of the late 1990s, the MPRDA and its unintended consequences, electricity that went from 5% to 35% of a mine's costs, and deep mines that flooded when the pumps were switched off. Grootvlei alone now pumps 100 million litres of water a day at the taxpayer's expense. In the second half, Lloyd explains how illegal mining works: zama zamas mining out the pillars that hold up abandoned shafts, the armed enforcers and money men above them, and the cash economy that sells the gold. He argues the damage falls on communities and the environment rather than the fiscus, that the ordinary zama zama is being exploited as cheap labour again, and that only properly resourced police task teams can deal with it. He ends bullish: with faster permitting, local investment and cheaper power, South African mining can climb back. Become a member for all the facts and analysis (R99/month): https://www.thecommonsense.co.za/subscribeWatch on YouTube: https://youtu.be/LwXzIh6UgwM Chapters:0:00 Who is Lloyd Birrell?0:52 How South African gold mining declined7:12 Beyond gold: power costs and the rest of mining9:22 The flooded mines of the Witwatersrand12:01 What load shedding did to the mines14:09 Did policy create the zama zama problem?23:15 How a zama zama operation works24:50 Where the illegal gold goes26:41 What illegal mining does to communities and rivers33:00 When the pillars are mined out38:11 How to solve the zama zama problem41:36 Can South Africa get back to number one in gold? Follow the show so you don't miss next week's conversation.

  3. Oct 20

    Bozell Says South Africa Could Be One of the Biggest Economies on Earth

    US Ambassador Leo Brent Bozell III says South Africa could become one of the biggest economic powers in the world, and every bit as successful as the United States, with the right policies. He points to the country's natural resources and tourism, and to the way it ended apartheid without a war. He also says Pretoria has refused to condemn "Kill the Boer", to make rural crime a national priority, and to give mining and telecoms the same BEE equity-equivalent option as every other sector. Those were three of the five things Washington asked South Africa to do. South Africa agreed to the other two. It will not interfere with the US refugee programme for Afrikaners, and the fight over the Expropriation Act has been left to the courts. Bozell says South Africa now has to make the next move, and that the next steps from the United States will not be good for South Africa. He explains why Starlink's offer to connect 500 schools for free was turned down, and why he says South Africa is siding with America's adversaries. Become a member for all the facts and analysis (R99/month)The Common SenseWatch on YouTube Chapters:0:00 Coming up0:29 Why Trump hand-picked Bozell for South Africa3:10 Why America should never have existed9:33 How America became the strongest nation12:03 Freedom, responsibility and American exceptionalism15:19 Life in a country that celebrates success20:04 Good guys, bad guys and spheres of influence25:34 South Africa first, and inequality since apartheid29:57 The three concerns and why Pretoria won't budge33:10 What Washington wanted, and what Pretoria refused38:54 Lurching toward America's adversaries44:16 Starlink, 500 schools and the 30% demand48:21 Haiti or America

  4. Oct 16

    Helen Zille: Johannesburg Is Over the Edge, and the DA Won't Stay in Power at All Costs

    Helen Zille, the DA's mayoral candidate for Johannesburg, tells Gabriel Makin that the city is not at the brink of the abyss but already over the edge, and that the DA will not stay in power at all costs. She explains why the least bad option after the 4 November election may be opposition rather than a coalition, why she does not believe corruption can be removed from Johannesburg with the ANC in government, and why she wants voters to consolidate behind the DA on both ballots so that the party can win 136 of the council's 270 seats. She also describes the city's finances, with residents owing Johannesburg R81 billion while the city owes its creditors R25 billion. The episode opens with the campaign, the Blue Brigades and the WaterWaxx borehole in Protea, which the DA finished for R2.6 million after Joburg Water abandoned it. Helen and Gabriel then discuss whether she feels vindicated after years of being called a liability to the DA, her fight against critical race theory inside the party, and why the DA's support base is now roughly a third Black, a third white and a third coloured and Indian. She recalls Henry Kissinger's visit in 2010 and what it taught her about the DA's growth from 1.7% in 1994. The conversation then turns to the drug crisis in Johannesburg, the "doomsday coalition" already running the city, her account of why Herman Mashaba turned against her, the MK Party's crimen injuria case, and her role in breaking the story of Steve Biko's death. Become a member for all the facts and analysis (R99/month): https://www.thecommonsense.co.za/subscribeThe Common Sense: https://www.thecommonsense.co.za Chapters:0:00 Coming up0:31 The campaign and the Blue Brigades2:31 WaterWaxx: water for R2.6 million, not R37 million7:59 Does Helen Zille feel vindicated?15:50 Why the stakes for South Africa were so high21:21 A third, a third, a third: who votes DA22:56 From 1.7% in 1994: Henry Kissinger's question26:41 Why critics still call the DA a white party28:00 The drug crisis breaking Johannesburg's families31:30 Joburg is broke, and owed R81 billion36:14 Coalition or opposition after the election?38:55 Wealthy donors and the 136-seat majority40:47 Should voters see a doomsday coalition govern?44:27 ActionSA, Herman Mashaba and the EFF49:42 The MK Party's crimen injuria case51:45 Steve Biko and fighting apartheid53:31 South Africa as humanity's pathbreaker

  5. Oct 15

    Mlondi Mdluli: Township Businesses Don't Lack Ambition. Red Tape Is Locking Them Out

    DA MP Mlondi Mdluli, the party's spokesperson on small business development, returns to Conversations with Gabriel, this time in the studio. He walks Gabriel Makin through the five reforms from his piece for The Common Sense: working capital that is not a bank loan, a real foothold in formal retail space, by-law enforcement that does not ruin livelihoods, a single front door for support, and a better-resourced competition watchdog. Gabriel presses him on whether the state should help small business or simply get out of its way. They turn to the October fuel price increase and a shrinking economy, and Gabriel asks why no party has claimed offshore oil and gas exploration as its cause. In the second half Mlondi describes life as a DA MP with a DA deputy minister inside the department he oversees, and running the DA's local election campaign in the Umzinyathi district of KwaZulu-Natal: the doorstep, the hung Endumeni council, why KZN has not followed the shift in black support seen elsewhere, and his predictions for 4 November. Read Mlondi's article: https://www.thecommonsense.co.za/economics_and_policy/township-businesses-do-not-lack-ambition-government-redBecome a member for all the facts and analysis (R99/month): https://www.thecommonsense.co.za/subscribeThe Common Sense: https://www.thecommonsense.co.za Chapters:0:00 Township businesses and how South Africa defines a small business3:20 Five reforms: capital, retail space, by-laws and one front door8:42 Can a competition watchdog protect small business?14:55 The October fuel price hike, the Strait of Hormuz and a shrinking economy20:23 Offshore oil and gas: why no party claims it22:55 A DA MP outside the department, a DA deputy minister inside it, and the KZN campaign32:22 Why KwaZulu-Natal bucks the shift in black support for the DA37:14 MK, coalitions and predictions for the 4 November election

  6. Oct 14

    Princy Mthombeni: 95% Of Asylum Seekers Don't Qualify. So Why Aren't They Deported?

    Princy Mthombeni, chair of South Africans for Constitutional Reform, is back with Gabriel Makin for the third episode of The Royal Sense. Home Affairs is moving asylum applications online after the Constitutional Court ruling, and the minister says 95% of applications are rejected as unfounded. So why do so few people leave? Princy argues that South Africa's borders are wide open, that deportation is the law and is cheaper than keeping people here, and that the country needs refugee camps and a state of emergency on deportations. She defends Jacinta Ngobese-Zuma as "the messenger" of frustrated South Africans, asks what happens to the MK Party if Jacob Zuma's health fails, and argues the ANC's problems run deeper than any one leader. Read The Common Sense on Jacob Zuma's health and the implications: https://www.thecommonsense.co.za/Politics/what-has-happened-jacob-zuma-these-are-implicationsBecome a member for all the facts and analysis (R99/month): https://www.thecommonsense.co.za/subscribeThe Common Sense: https://www.thecommonsense.co.za Chapters:0:00 Coming up0:27 Inside Koeberg: the first media tour in 40 years4:51 Meltdown fears, emergency drills and how a reactor works10:27 Clean steam, nuclear waste and why one plant isn't enough13:45 Jacinta Ngobese-Zuma: the problem or the messenger?20:01 Jacob Zuma's health and the future of the MK Party24:30 Is Zuma to blame, or is the ANC rotten?25:47 Online asylum applications after the court ruling29:57 95% rejected, so why aren't they deported?31:53 Refugee camps, NGOs and a state of emergency

  7. Oct 13

    David Ansara: Why America's Five Asks Would Free South Africans, and the ANC Won't Budge

    David Ansara, CEO of the Free Market Foundation, sits down with Gabriel Makin days after returning from Washington, where he and Dr Martin van Staden presented the FMF's Don Caldwell Memorandum on Socialism and Racial Engineering at the White Cross Project conference, and attended the vigil of 3,000 named crosses on the National Mall for South Africa's farm-murder victims. He explains why the FMF thinks the US government's five asks of South Africa are valid, and what they would mean for property rights, investment and race law here. They cover the Expropriation Act's nil-compensation clause, the FMF's Khaya Lam project and its 26,000 title deeds, what the 2017 land audit really shows, the 136 race-based laws on the statute books, Starlink and the 30% ownership rule, the media's "white genocide" framing of the trip, the US visa restrictions, and why David believes South Africa is heading for a point of deep conflict with America unless the government changes course. Read David Ansara's column, The FMF's Memorandum to the Americans: https://www.thecommonsense.co.za/columns/fmf-s-memorandum-americansThe Free Market Foundation: https://freemarketfoundation.comBecome a member for all the facts and analysis (R99/month): https://www.thecommonsense.co.za/subscribeThe Common Sense: https://www.thecommonsense.co.za Chapters:0:00 The White Cross Project: 3,000 crosses in Washington4:47 Property rights, the Expropriation Act and the Don Caldwell Memorandum8:32 Why the FMF backs America's five asks12:48 Eminent domain vs nil compensation, Khaya Lam and the land audit18:12 136 race laws and the Population Registration Act21:24 Starlink, BEE and the cost of race law26:16 The public backs the American position. Why doesn't the ANC?31:25 Farm attacks and the 'white genocide' smear35:24 Why rural violence is not just crime37:37 Visa restrictions, the GNU and a point of deep conflict

About

The Common Sense's one-on-one interviews with politicians, businesspeople and other fascinating South African commentators

You Might Also Like