Stuff That Scares Me

Wallace Cole

I heard something move in the dark. And I wanted to hear it again. That's the problem. That's always been the problem. Some people hear a sound in the woods and walk the other way. I'm the kind who stands still and listens. I'm Wallace Cole. I grew up in the mountains of West Virginia, where the old folks knew things they wouldn't say out loud. Not because they didn't believe them. Because they did. I carried that with me. Into the hollows and the abandoned places. Into the fog that lays long and doesn't lift when it should. Into rooms where I was absolutely alone — until something moved at the edge of what I could see, and alone stopped being the right word. I collect the stories that people carry but don't tell. Appalachian folklore. Unsolved disappearances. Encounters that never made it into a report. Warnings that have survived for generations without anyone remembering why. I've followed the footprints. I've sat across kitchen tables from people who shook while they told me what they saw. I've studied the evidence and the closed investigations and the ground where the truth sits waiting for someone willing to look at it. Some of what you'll hear is documented. Some is drawn from real events. Some is simply possible. All of it is the kind of thing that stays with you after dark. This is Stuff That Scares Me.

Episodes

  1. Jul 6

    Don't Whistle After Dark: An Eerrie Appalachian Rule

    Like Wallace Cole stories? 📚 Find more Appalachian horror by Wallace Cole on Amazon - Click Here ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- The Fox Is Still On Fire, Episode 1: Don't whistle after dark. Where I grew up in  West Virginia, that wasn't advice. It was a rule — and the old people who passed it down couldn't always tell you where it came from. They only knew you followed it. In this  episode, Wallace Cole reads Chapter 1 of his book, The Fox Is Still On Fire, a book of warnings common across Appalachia. What he finds isn't a simple superstition. It's a pattern — one that stretches across cultures, across continents, and across centuries, carried by people who had no way of knowing they were all saying the same thing. Why did so many unconnected communities arrive at the same warning? What were the old people trying to protect their children from? And why does the rule survive long after the explanation has been forgotten? The story begins with a whistle in the dark. In This Episode The rule Wallace heard before he was old enough to question itWhy Monroe County grandmothers repeated it — and why they couldn't always say whyThe night Wallace whistled in the woods and something answeredAppalachian oral tradition and the difference between explanation and instructionStrikingly similar warnings from cultures that never had contact with one anotherWhy some warnings outlast the civilizations that created them"The story may disappear. The warning remains." Follow the Podcast New episodes are coming. If you love Appalachian storytelling, folklore, and the questions that linger in old places, follow the show so you don't miss what's next. And if you know someone who grew up hearing rules nobody could explain, send them this episode. They'll know exactly what Wallace is talking about. Pay attention to what is paying attention to you. To check out The Fox Is Still On Fire, Click Here

  2. Jun 10

    Four Nights at the Stanley Hotel. The Bathroom Light Was On (I'd Turned It Off). (Ep. 2 of 3)

    Like Wallace Cole stories? 📚 Find more Appalachian horror by Wallace Cole on Amazon - Click Here ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- The bathroom light was on.  I had turned it off before I went to bed. I know that the way I know my own name. I've turned off the bathroom light in a thousand hotel rooms across this country.  It was on.  And it was moving.  Night Two at the Stanley Hotel in Estes Park, Colorado. Six guests in the entire building. Off-season. The week before partial winter closure. In Episode One, I gave every strange thing that happened a reasonable explanation. The notebook. The shoes. The sound in the hall.  Night Two, the explanations started coming harder.  In this episode: what a maintenance worker wrote in 1962 and then filed away and never mentioned again. A chef who won't go into his own basement after ten o'clock. A housekeeper who watched someone disappear from a fourth-floor corridor — and finished her shift anyway. A room that had been empty all week. And what happened at 2:17 in the morning when I finally ran out of reasonable things to tell myself.  I'm not a ghost hunter. I don't perform fear for an audience. I'm an investigator who goes to places that have things wrong with them and tries to explain what's there.  Night Two at the Stanley, I couldn't find the right explanation.  Episode Three drops soon. Subscribe so you don't miss it.  This episode is a work of narrative horror inspired by the history, folklore, and public reputation of the Stanley Hotel. Certain characters, conversations, events, and experiences have been fictionalized or dramatized for entertainment purposes.

  3. May 13

    DYATLOV PASS — The Horrifying Theory That Remains (Episode 3)

    Like Wallace Cole stories? 📚 Find more Appalachian horror by Wallace Cole on Amazon - Click Here ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Nine experienced hikers fled their tent barefoot into the snow. In Episode Three of Stuff That Scares Me, Wallace Cole reconstructs the final hours of the DYATLOV PASS incident and presents the conclusion he believes the evidence requires. This episode explores: What likely happened inside the tent on the night of February 1st, 1959Why the hikers cut through the walls instead of using the doorThe meaning of the footprints leading into the tree lineThe significance of the cedar tree and the ravineThe forensic reality of compressive crush injuries without external traumaThe Mansee accounts of the Menk and why similar descriptions appear across cultures worldwideThe unexplained radiation found on specific garmentsWhy the official investigation may have reached a conclusion they dared not openly stateBy the end of this episode, Wallace Cole presents the only explanation that holds up under all of the evidence.  Something came to the tent. If you enjoy wilderness horror, unexplained encounters, dark folklore, cryptid mysteries, and immersive narrated storytelling, be sure to follow Stuff That Scares Me for new episodes weekly. Listen on your favorite podcast platform and follow the channel on YouTube: @StuffThatScaresMe

  4. May 13

    DYATLOV PASS — What Chased Them Into the Frozen Night? (Episode 1 of 3)

    Like Wallace Cole stories? 📚 Find more Appalachian horror by Wallace Cole on Amazon - Click Here ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Nine experienced hikers entered the northern Ural Mountains in February of 1959.  None of them came back.  Their tent was cut open from the inside. Their bodies were found scattered across the snow — some barefoot, some with catastrophic internal injuries, and all under circumstances that investigators could never fully explain.  In Episode One of Stuff That Scares Me, Wallace Cole begins a deep investigation into the DYATLOV PASS incident — one of the most disturbing wilderness mysteries ever recorded.  This episode examines: The hikers themselves and why they were highly unlikely to panic The decision to camp on the exposed slope of “Dead Mountain” The strange condition of the tent and the footprints leading into the dark The unexplained injuries, radiation findings, and missing evidence Why the official explanation still leaves major questions unansweredThis is Episode One: The Event.  Episode Two will examine the competing explanations — avalanche, military testing, infrasound, and more — and test them against the actual evidence. (Spoiler alert: Only one theory holds.) Follow Stuff That Scares Me for new episodes weekly (or more often).  📺 Watch and listen on YouTube: @StuffThatScaresMe

About

I heard something move in the dark. And I wanted to hear it again. That's the problem. That's always been the problem. Some people hear a sound in the woods and walk the other way. I'm the kind who stands still and listens. I'm Wallace Cole. I grew up in the mountains of West Virginia, where the old folks knew things they wouldn't say out loud. Not because they didn't believe them. Because they did. I carried that with me. Into the hollows and the abandoned places. Into the fog that lays long and doesn't lift when it should. Into rooms where I was absolutely alone — until something moved at the edge of what I could see, and alone stopped being the right word. I collect the stories that people carry but don't tell. Appalachian folklore. Unsolved disappearances. Encounters that never made it into a report. Warnings that have survived for generations without anyone remembering why. I've followed the footprints. I've sat across kitchen tables from people who shook while they told me what they saw. I've studied the evidence and the closed investigations and the ground where the truth sits waiting for someone willing to look at it. Some of what you'll hear is documented. Some is drawn from real events. Some is simply possible. All of it is the kind of thing that stays with you after dark. This is Stuff That Scares Me.