Lives Of The Most Remarkable Criminals

Dark Stories

In 1735, a London publisher gathered the lives of the most notorious highwaymen, forgers, pickpockets and murderers of the age into one remarkable book: a criminal record of old England, written while the gallows at Tyburn were still busy. Remarkable Lives brings those stories back, one criminal at a time. Each week, Dark Stories, the people behind Australia’s true crime walking tours, retells a single life for modern listeners.  You’ll hear how each of them fell, the trial that followed, and how it ended, usually at the end of a rope. The old book’s own voice breaks through in short, sharp lines quoted exactly as they were printed. Each episode includes a Dark Lexicon of the old words you’ll hear, plus a full write-up on darkstories.com.au. New episodes every week. Follow so you never miss a remarkable life.

  1. 5d ago

    Episode 027: James Carrick: The Gentleman Highwayman of Finchley Common

    Send us your Feedback James Carrick is the youngest son of an Irish gentleman, a boy handed an officer's commission before he is old enough to truly understand it. He is beautiful, well-shaped, and something more than ordinarily genteel: exactly the kind of young man old England loves to watch destroy himself. After soldiering in Spain and losing his commission, Carrick drifts into London with empty pockets and expensive habits. Rather than accept his brother's plea to come home to Dublin, he chooses the road: a life of highway robbery fuelled by gambling, women and fine clothes, the kind of true crime story where charm is the most dangerous weapon of all. Dark Lexicon: Old words. Dark meaning.The past speaks its own dialect; here is what to listen for in this episode. Duenna: not a lover but her opposite: an older woman appointed to chaperone a younger one. In old England and across Catholic Europe, a duenna was the gatekeeper between a young woman and any man who wanted to reach her; in this story, she is the bait in a trap. Pieces-of-eight: Spanish silver dollars, the universal currency of empire. In old England, these coins circulated freely and carried real weight; two hundred of them was a handsome sum, enough to make a young officer feel whole again after a humiliating robbery. Taking a purse: the polite way of saying highway robbery in old England. The phrase sounds almost genteel, as if the money simply changed hands of its own accord; the pistol or blade that made it happen went unmentioned. Ordinary: today an ordinary is just an adjective, but in old England it meant a fixed-price eating house or tavern where men dined, drank and gambled together. A 'gaming ordinary' was essentially an illegal casino disguised as a dining room. Chair: not furniture but transport: a sedan chair, a small enclosed box carried on poles by two men through the streets. In old England, stopping a chair at night was a favourite method of street robbery; the passenger was trapped, visible and usually wealthy. Sparks: young men of fashion, lively and a little reckless. The word carried a note of admiration and a note of warning; in old England, a spark was someone who might set a fire he could not put out. The cart drove away: at Tyburn, the condemned stood in a horse-drawn cart with the noose already around their neck. When the cart was driven forward, there was nothing left beneath their feet; the phrase is plain, but what it describes is the final second of a life. About This Series Lives of the Most Remarkable Criminals (1735) is one of the earliest works of true crime in the English language. Each week this podcast retells one of its stories for today's listener, keeping the old book's most striking lines. Support the show

  2. Nov 10

    Episode 026: Nathaniel Jackson: The Soldier Turned Highwayman

    Send us your Feedback Nathaniel Jackson is a man who seems incapable of standing still. Born to a family of some means in Doncaster, orphaned young, apprenticed to a silk-weaver in Norwich, he runs from every structure placed around him and lurches toward whatever is reckless and ruinous. After a violent duel costs him his place in a regiment of dragoons in Ireland, Jackson drifts back to England with nothing but old habits and worse company. London swallows him whole, and a chance reunion with former comrades pulls him toward a road he cannot walk back from. Dark Lexicon: Old words. Dark meaning.The past speaks its own dialect; here is what to listen for in this episode. Broke him: nothing to do with money. When a soldier was 'broke,' his officers stripped him of his rank and expelled him from the regiment; a public humiliation that left him without pay, status or purpose. Drag net: today we picture a police dragnet closing in on a suspect. In the 1700s the image was literal: a heavy fishing net dragged along the bottom of a river, scooping up everything in its path. To say Jackson swept all impurities with a drag net means he gathered every available vice into his life, missing none. Sutler: a civilian merchant who set up shop near a military camp, selling food, drink and sundries to soldiers. Think of a camp follower with a licence to profit; the sutler's tent was part marketplace, part tavern, and often part den of scheming. Conversation of women: in old England, 'conversation' could mean far more than talk. Here it is a polite veil over sexual liaisons; 'criminal conversation' was in fact the legal term for adultery. Hair: among the items stolen from the victim Dennet was 'some hair,' almost certainly referring to a wig or hairpiece. Wigs were valuable personal property in the early 18th century, and stealing one was no small matter. Commitment: not a promise or a pledge. In legal language of the time, a commitment was the formal order sending a person to gaol to await trial; to hear of someone's commitment was to know they had been locked up. Interest: when Jackson's friends tried to make 'interest' on his behalf, they were pulling strings: lobbying powerful people, calling in favours, petitioning for mercy. The word carried the weight of patronage and connection, the unofficial currency of justice in old England. About This Series Lives of the Most Remarkable Criminals (1735) is one of the earliest works of true crime in the English language. Each week this podcast retells one of its stories for today's listener, keeping the old book's most striking lines. Support the show

  3. Nov 2

    Episode 025: Thomas Butlock: The Aspiring Thief Who Robbed His Master

    Send us your Feedback Thomas Butlock is a young man from Ireland with what he calls 'an aspiring temper': a restless hunger to look the part of a gentleman, even when his pockets are empty. He crosses the sea to London on the promise of connections and a future in the law, taking lodgings he cannot afford and living as though success has already arrived. In old England, appearances could be everything and nothing at once. For Butlock, the gap between the life he wants and the life he has is about to collapse in a single reckless afternoon: a true crime story of vanity, impulse, and a half-hour of fatal reasoning. Dark Lexicon: Old words. Dark meaning.The past speaks its own dialect; here is what to listen for in this episode. Vintner: not just someone who makes wine, but in old England a keeper of a wine house or tavern: a place where drink, company and trouble all mixed freely. Broke: when the text says his master 'broke,' it means went bankrupt. In old England, a ruined tradesman might flee to another country to dodge his creditors and start again under the radar. Louis d'or: a French gold coin stamped with the king's portrait, valuable and immediately conspicuous. Spending foreign gold in an English market town was practically a confession. An aspiring temper: not ambition in the modern, admirable sense. In old England, an 'aspiring temper' hinted at dangerous vanity: the compulsion to live above one's station, a moral failing the law had little patience for. Cut a figure: to make a striking impression in public, especially through dress. In old England, looking like a gentleman could open doors or, if the clothes were funded by crime, slam them shut. Fact: today it means something proven true, but in old England's courts, 'the fact' simply meant the criminal deed itself. When the text says 'the fact appearing plain,' it means the crime was obvious and undeniable. Suffered: in this context, not merely to endure pain but to undergo execution. When someone 'suffered' in old England, they met their death at the hands of the hangman. About This Series Lives of the Most Remarkable Criminals (1735) is one of the earliest works of true crime in the English language. Each week this podcast retells one of its stories for today's listener, keeping the old book's most striking lines. Support the show

  4. Oct 26

    Episode 024: James Booty: The Boy Ravisher of Holborn

    Send us your Feedback James Booty is barely into his teens when he is apprenticed to a cabinet-maker in Holborn, a fatherless boy left to a mother doing her best in old England. What happens next is a chain of ignorance, disease and violence that will make him one of the youngest people ever to face a capital charge in London. Infected by an older girl in his master's household, the boy acts on a piece of deadly folk wisdom passed along by workmen: that the cure for his condition is to lie with someone who is sound. The consequences of that belief are shattering. Dark Lexicon: Old words. Dark meaning.The past speaks its own dialect; here is what to listen for in this episode. Foul distemper: in old England this was the common, half-whispered term for venereal disease; most likely syphilis or gonorrhoea. It carried shame as heavy as its symptoms. Peruke-maker: a wigmaker. In old England, peruke-makers were skilled tradespeople who served everyone from judges to merchants; the word has vanished, but the powdered wigs live on in courtroom tradition. Made a shift: today 'making a shift' might suggest changing clothes, but in old England it meant managing with difficulty, scraping together an answer or a plan when none was obvious. Taken up: arrested. In old England, being 'taken up' meant you had been seized by the authorities; there was no polite knock at the door, just hands on your collar and a march to the nearest magistrate. Committed to Newgate: sent to London's most notorious prison to await trial. Newgate was a disease-ridden fortress where accused and condemned alike were crammed together in filth. Sessions: the regular sittings of the criminal court at the Old Bailey. In old England, trials were swift and grouped in batches; a prisoner might wait weeks in gaol only to be tried, convicted and sentenced in a single day. Ignominious death: a death steeped in public shame. The word 'ignominious' still exists, but in old England it carried a specific legal and spiritual dread: a death that marked you as dishonoured before God and your neighbours alike. About This Series Lives of the Most Remarkable Criminals (1735) is one of the earliest works of true crime in the English language. Each week this podcast retells one of its stories for today's listener, keeping the old book's most striking lines. Support the show

  5. Oct 19

    Episode 023: Richard Whittingham: The Young Footpad of Red Lion Square

    Send us your Feedback Richard Whittingham is a teenager with a good heart and a weak will, apprenticed to a hot-presser in old England, where the pressure to keep up with the women in his life pushes him out of honest work and into the streets. He runs from his master and falls in with a crew of pickpockets and footpads: Jones, Applebee, and Lee. Together they develop a system: one trips the victim, another shoves, a third moves in to finish the job. It is coordinated violence on the open streets of London, and for a while it works: until the gang begins to crack from within. Dark Lexicon: Old words. Dark meaning.The past speaks its own dialect; here is what to listen for in this episode. Footpad: a robber who works on foot, as opposed to a highwayman on horseback. In old England this was the lowest rung of the robbery trade: no horse, no romance, just ambush on dark streets. Hot-presser: not someone under emotional strain, but a textile worker who used heated plates to press and finish cloth. It was a respectable London trade, and exactly the kind of steady life Whittingham walked away from. Cutting off women's pockets: in old England, women's pockets were separate pouches tied around the waist beneath skirts. Thieves would literally slice the strings and walk away with the whole thing: a crime so common it had its own vocabulary. Impeached: today this word conjures political scandal, but in old England it meant something more desperate: one criminal formally accusing another in exchange for mercy. When Applebee was taken, he impeached his friends to save himself. Condemned hold: the section of Newgate Prison where those sentenced to death were kept in the days before execution. It was a dark, overcrowded pit, and as Whittingham discovered, even its last hours were not granted in peace. Fled for sanctuary: in old England, the word 'sanctuary' had lost its medieval legal power, but the instinct remained: Whittingham hid at his former master's house hoping the world would simply forget about him. Dissolution: we might use this word for a company winding down, but here it means death itself: the dissolving of body and soul. Whittingham used it to describe what he was trying to prepare for in his final days. About This Series Lives of the Most Remarkable Criminals (1735) is one of the earliest works of true crime in the English language. Each week this podcast retells one of its stories for today's listener, keeping the old book's most striking lines. Support the show

  6. Oct 12

    Episode 022: Thomas Reeves: The Highwayman Who Made His Own Religion

    Send us your Feedback Thomas Reeves grows up in old England as a tinman's son, indulged by a loving father who imagines a good life ahead for the boy. But young Tom falls in with freethinkers who mock religion and morality, and he swallows their philosophy whole: not because it enlightens him, but because it gives him permission to do whatever he wants. Bold, reckless, and hungry for extravagance, Reeves becomes one of the most striking figures in the annals of true crime from old England: a man who leads a gang of highway robbers while quietly constructing his own private theology to keep his conscience silent. His story is a collision between violence and philosophy that still disturbs. Dark Lexicon: Old words. Dark meaning.The past speaks its own dialect; here is what to listen for in this episode. Footpad: a robber who worked on foot rather than on horseback. In old England the distinction mattered: a highwayman rode, a footpad lurked in alleys and fields, and both could hang for the same offence. Tinman: not a figure from a fairy tale but a metalworker who made and mended household goods from tin. In old England it was a respectable urban trade, the kind of steady livelihood a father might hope his son would carry on. Priestcraft: a loaded word in old England, meaning the supposed manipulation of ordinary people by clergymen using religion as a tool of control. To call something priestcraft was to dismiss it as fraud dressed in vestments. Sceptical persons: today a sceptic is someone who questions claims and demands evidence. In old England, calling someone sceptical often carried a darker charge: it meant they rejected God entirely, which put them outside the moral order of society. Stand: when a robber cried 'stand' it meant 'stop where you are.' In old England this single word carried the full menace of a loaded pistol; it was the highwayman's signature command. Intermediate state: a theological idea that the soul might pass through a waiting place between death and final judgement, neither heaven nor hell. Reeves asked about this in the condemned cell; not out of fear, apparently, but curiosity. Suffered: today to suffer is to endure pain. In old England, when someone 'suffered,' it often meant they were executed: a grim euphemism that made the gallows sound like an act of passive endurance rather than state violence. About This Series Lives of the Most Remarkable Criminals (1735) is one of the earliest works of true crime in the English language. Each week this podcast retells one of its stories for today's listener, keeping the old book's most striking lines. Support the show

  7. Oct 5

    Episode 021: John Thomson: From Privateer to Street Robber

    Send us your Feedback John Thomson grows up wild in London, a boy drawn to the company of thieves and drinkers, never once cracking open a Bible or any good book. By the time a kind friend arranges an apprenticeship with a weaver, the pull of a rougher life already has its hooks deep in him. He ships out to war, returns, marries an honest woman, and then signs on as a privateer, where he learns that violence pays and pays well. What happens when a man trained in blood and plunder comes back to the streets of old England is the dark heart of this true crime story. Dark Lexicon: Old words. Dark meaning.The past speaks its own dialect; here is what to listen for in this episode. Listed: today you might list items for sale; in old England, to list yourself meant to enlist, to sign up for military or naval service. Thomson listed himself in the sea service the way a restless young man might walk into a recruiting office. Man-of-war: not a metaphor but a literal warship, armed and crewed for battle. Thomson served on one during Queen Anne's wars, and the miseries aboard; disease, flogging, hard rations; were notorious in old England. Prizes: in naval warfare, a prize was an enemy vessel captured at sea along with its cargo. Nineteen prizes in under a year was extraordinary plunder, and Thomson's captain was clearly an aggressive hunter. Cruise: forget leisure travel; a cruise in old England meant a privateer or naval patrol, sailing in search of enemy ships to seize. It was licensed violence on the open water, and it paid handsomely. Creditable method of life: a respectable, honest way of earning a living. In old England, creditable carried the weight of public reputation; a creditable man was one his neighbours could trust and vouch for. Fact: today a fact is a truth; in old England, it often meant a deed or an act, especially a criminal one. Being apprehended soon after this fact means being caught shortly after committing the crime. Subsistence: bare survival, the barest level of income to keep body and soul together. Thomson went back to sea not for adventure but because weaving could not feed two mouths; subsistence was all he sought. About This Series Lives of the Most Remarkable Criminals (1735) is one of the earliest works of true crime in the English language. Each week this podcast retells one of its stories for today's listener, keeping the old book's most striking lines. Support the show

  8. Sep 28

    Episode 020: William Burridge: The Highwayman Who Craved Applause

    Send us your Feedback William Burridge is a strong, handsome young man from Northamptonshire who cannot be made to work. Raised by respectable parents and apprenticed to his father's trade as a carpenter, he throws it all aside for the thrill of admiration: winning wrestling bouts and cudgel matches at country fairs, basking in the cheers of strangers. His restless hunger for praise carries him from petty theft to a man-of-war bound for Spain, where bravery in battle fills his head with a dangerous conviction: that he deserves more than honest labour can ever give him. It is one of old England's bleakest true crime trajectories: a man who mistakes applause for destiny. Dark Lexicon: Old words. Dark meaning.The past speaks its own dialect; here is what to listen for in this episode. Cudgel-playing: a rough sport of old England in which two men beat each other with thick sticks until one drew blood from the other's head. It was a fair-ground entertainment, and prizes went to the last man standing. Wakes: today a wake is a vigil for the dead, but in old England a wake was a parish festival: days of drinking, dancing and competitive violence that drew crowds from miles around. Junketting: feasting and merrymaking, often with a sly undertone of illicit pleasure. When the text says Burridge was junketting with servant-wenches, it means exactly what you think it means. Man-of-war: a warship belonging to a national navy. In old England, shipping aboard one was sometimes the last resort for a young man too wild for civilian life: a floating prison disguised as patriotic service. Went upon the highway: turned to highway robbery. The phrase sounds almost casual, and in old England it was: robbing travellers on the road was so common it had its own shorthand. Becoming evidence: turning informer against your accomplices in exchange for your own life. In old England, the law encouraged betrayal; a thief who gave up his partners could walk free while they swung. Bay gelding: a castrated horse with a reddish-brown coat. Horse theft in old England was a capital crime: the animal's value made it a hanging matter, no different from murder in the eyes of the court. Under sentence: condemned and awaiting execution. The days between verdict and scaffold were spent in a cell at Newgate, often visited by clergymen pressing for repentance and crowds paying a few coins to gawk. About This Series Lives of the Most Remarkable Criminals (1735) is one of the earliest works of true crime in the English language. Each week this podcast retells one of its stories for today's listener, keeping the old book's most striking lines. Support the show

About

In 1735, a London publisher gathered the lives of the most notorious highwaymen, forgers, pickpockets and murderers of the age into one remarkable book: a criminal record of old England, written while the gallows at Tyburn were still busy. Remarkable Lives brings those stories back, one criminal at a time. Each week, Dark Stories, the people behind Australia’s true crime walking tours, retells a single life for modern listeners.  You’ll hear how each of them fell, the trial that followed, and how it ended, usually at the end of a rope. The old book’s own voice breaks through in short, sharp lines quoted exactly as they were printed. Each episode includes a Dark Lexicon of the old words you’ll hear, plus a full write-up on darkstories.com.au. New episodes every week. Follow so you never miss a remarkable life.