Drop In: A Decision Drop College Admissions Podcast

Lisa Clay and Josh Hudley

The college process feels like chaos. Endless deadlines, conflicting advice, and pressure from every direction. Drop In cuts through it. Hosted by Lisa and Josh, two college admissions experts with over 25 years of experience each, this show delivers real talk on essays, GPA, financial aid, college lists, resumé, and everything in between. No jargon. No fear-mongering. Just honest, insider guidance that keeps your student's voice front and center. Each episode ends with a Hot Take or Hard Truth and a Drop the Mic moment you'll actually remember. New episodes every week-DROP IN and find your place.

  1. 3d ago

    EP22: Summer Programs for High School Students: What Actually Helps College Admissions?

    In Episode 22 of Drop In, Lisa and Josh tackle a question families start asking WAY earlier than they expect: What should my kiddo do this summer? And usually, buried underneath that question is another one: If we choose the “wrong” thing, are we putting them behind? So let’s compare two students. One spends the summer working at an ice cream shop. Another spends three weeks at a prestigious college summer program. Which student had the “better” summer? The answer is not nearly as simple as the college logo on the brochure. Lisa and Josh break down how families should actually think about summer opportunities, from university programs and research experiences to jobs, volunteering, online classes, shadowing, family responsibilities, and yes... scooping ice cream. The first question they want students to answer? What do you actually want to learn about yourself this summer? Maybe you love biology but have no idea whether you would enjoy working in a lab. Maybe you think you want to study law but come home from a mock trial program saying, “Absolutely not.” That can still be a VERY successful summer. Because sometimes discovering what you do NOT want is just as useful as confirming what you do. Lisa and Josh also explain how to evaluate expensive summer programs before paying the deposit. What does a typical day actually look like? How much time will students spend doing the thing they signed up to do? Who gives them feedback? Will they actually create, research, write, experiment, or revise? And one of the biggest questions: Does attending the summer program actually help with admission to that college? Do not assume the answer is yes just because the university’s name is printed across the brochure. They talk about programs including COSMOS, Research Science Institute, Iowa Young Writers’ Studio, Yale Young Global Scholars, and UChicago’s summer programs, including the separate question of how some programs may connect to specific application pathways. But the bigger message? Cover up the college name. Then ask: Would my kiddo STILL want to do this? Because sometimes the best summer experience is the one where your student is trusted with something REAL. A job can teach responsibility, problem-solving, communication, leadership, and confidence. Volunteering can matter. Taking care of a sibling can matter. A student who spends every afternoon making dinner for a younger brother is not “doing nothing.” And parents, please do not miss the ordinary details. Your kid may say: “I just worked at an ice cream shop.” But maybe they closed three nights a week, reconciled the register, trained new employees, handled unhappy customers, and learned how to keep moving when the freezer broke during a rush. That is a VERY different story. Lisa and Josh also talk about giving students two summer plans they would actually be happy with, especially when one depends on admission to a competitive program. Apply for the program. But also ask about the lifeguard job. Email the librarian. Look at the local opportunity. Build a summer where your kiddo still has choices. And please... Leave some SUMMER in summer. One of Lisa’s biggest reminders: She will take the ice cream shop over the fancy summer program if the shop is where your kiddo learns to be responsible for something real. And Josh’s? He would rather see a teenager spend six weeks seriously exploring ONE question than six weeks collecting activities just to fill a résumé. IN THIS EPISODE:• How to choose a meaningful summer experience • College summer programs vs. jobs • Whether prestigious summer programs help with admission • How to evaluate a summer program before paying • Jobs, volunteering, sibling care, and other underrated options • Examples of selective summer programs • Why students need more than one summer plan • How to turn summer experiences into meaningful application stories WANT LISA + JOSH IN YOUR CORNER?If your family is trying to figure out what your kiddo should actually do this summer, which programs are worth the money, or what opportunities fit their interests and goals, Lisa and Josh would love to help. Visit decisiondrop.com/contact to connect with Decision Drop.

  2. Nov 6

    EP21: What Happens After You Submit Your College Application?

    In Episode 21 of Drop In, Lisa and Josh answer the question every senior asks after hitting submit. Okay... now what? As former admissions officers at highly selective universities, the Decision Drop co-founders pull back the curtain on the college admissions review process and explain what really happens to your application at colleges and universities everywhere. Who reads your application? What does holistic review mean? Can you send an update or fix a mistake? What should you do while you wait? Your application file may still be incomplete after you hit submit. Colleges may need your transcript, school report, recommendations, or test scores before they can review it. WHY DOES MY PORTAL SAY “MISSING”? Do not panic. You see MISSING next to your transcript and assume something went wrong. Colleges process thousands of documents at once. Your transcript may be there waiting to be matched to your file. Check the college's processing timeline. Follow up if it's still missing after that window. And yes... check your spam folder too. WHO READS YOUR COLLEGE APPLICATION? Here comes our favorite answer... It depends. Your first reader may be the regional admissions rep who visited your high school or attended your local college fair. Regional reps may know your school, counselor, and curriculum. Your application may get a second read or go to committee. And yes, admissions officers can disagree. WHAT DOES HOLISTIC REVIEW REALLY MEAN? It means your application is not reduced to one number. Your academic record matters A LOT. So can course rigor, essays, activities, recommendations, and the opportunities your school offers. That word we use constantly? CONTEXT. Taking all three AP classes your school offers tells a different story when another school offers 25. Comparing schedules only tells you so much. At highly selective colleges, plenty of qualified students get denied. Admissions officers are building a class. That can look different every year. Academics, geography, athletics, and enrollment goals can all shape a class. That's why a balanced college list matters. CAN I SEND AN UPDATE AFTER I SUBMIT? Maybe. If something genuinely NEW and meaningful happens, some colleges may allow an update. A major award? Significant new leadership role? Possibly. But check the college's policy FIRST. Some schools welcome updates. Others do not. And please do not send admissions a weekly newsletter because you are nervous. Meaningful is the key word. WHAT IF I FIND A MISTAKE? A tiny typo? Try to let it go. No one is denying you because you typed “the” twice or suddenly hate a comma. But if you discover a REAL factual error, such as an incorrect grade, test score, or important piece of information, send a short, polite correction. Remember: changing something in the Common App after submitting generally affects future applications, not the one a college already received. WHAT ABOUT AI? There are two sides to this conversation. Students need to understand each college's policy before using AI. There is a big difference between using a tool to brainstorm or check something and asking it to write your application for you. Colleges themselves are also beginning to explore AI in different parts of admissions. But through all of it, one thing still matters....YOUR HUMAN VOICE. AI can make something polished. But admissions officers are trying to understand the PERSON behind the application. IN THIS EPISODE: • What happens after you submit a college application • How applicant portals work • Who actually reads your application • What regional admissions representatives do • What holistic review really means • Why qualified students can still be denied • When to send a college an application update • What to do if you find a mistake after submitting • How AI is affecting college applications Want Josh + Lisa in your corner? If you've hit submit and are wondering what happens next, how to handle an update or mistake, or how to survive the waiting, we would love to help. Visit decisiondrop.com/contact to connect with Decision Drop.

  3. Oct 30

    EP20: College Admissions for Student-Athletes... How Recruiting Really Works

    In Episode 20 of Drop In, Lisa and Josh are joined by Brian Plotkin, Head Men’s Soccer Coach at Army West Point, to talk about what college athletic recruiting REALLY looks like from the coach’s side. When should a student-athlete start reaching out? What makes a coach actually open an email? Should students wait to be discovered? Are families spending thousands of dollars on camps and showcases that do not actually help? What does “we’re interested” really mean? And what happens if recruiting does NOT end with an offer? Brian knows this world. Before becoming Head Men’s Soccer Coach at Army West Point, he played at Indiana University, helped the Hoosiers win back-to-back national championships, was named the 2005 Big Ten Player of the Year, played professionally in MLS, and coached at Loyola Chicago, Dartmouth, and Notre Dame. And his first big reminder for student-athletes? Grades open doors. Talent matters. But academics, course rigor, leadership, character, and what you bring beyond your sport can determine which opportunities are actually available to you. Brian also explains why students should NOT sit around waiting to be discovered. Coaches get a lot of emails. Being appropriately persistent matters. Following up matters. And making it incredibly easy for a coach to understand who you are matters. He walks students through exactly what belongs in that first recruiting email: graduation year, school, club team, GPA, test scores, position, highlight video, upcoming events, and WHY you are actually interested in that particular program. And please... Make sure you put the correct college name in the email. Then they tackle camps vs. showcases. Brian explains why showcases help coaches SEE athletes, while camps can help coaches actually KNOW them. Because coaches are watching more than your performance. How do you treat teammates? How do you respond to coaching? How do you interact with players who may not be as talented as you? What kind of person might you be in their locker room for four years? They also talk Division I vs. Division III, walk-ons, preferred walk-ons, athletic scholarships, NIL, recruiting red flags, highlight videos, and what parents should—and should NOT—be doing. Brian’s biggest red flag? Parents doing the communicating for the student. And for the kiddo whose recruiting journey does not end exactly how they dreamed? Those years were NOT wasted. The discipline matters. The resilience matters. The friendships matter. The person you became through your sport matters. In this episode: • When college athletic recruiting really starts • When student-athletes should contact coaches • What coaches want in a recruiting email • How often students should follow up with coaches • Camps vs. showcases • Does recruiting help with college admission? • Division I vs. Division III • Walk-ons vs. preferred walk-ons • Athletic scholarships and college costs • NIL • What belongs in a highlight video Want Lisa + Josh in your corner? If your student-athlete needs help building the right college list, understanding recruiting opportunities, navigating admissions, or figuring out what an offer actually means, Lisa and Josh would love to help. Visit decisiondrop.com/contact to connect with Decision Drop.

  4. Oct 23

    EP19: What Should High School Juniors Be Doing for College Right Now?

    In Episode 19 of Drop In, Lisa and Josh turn their attention to the Class of 2028. Hello, juniors. It is officially your turn. And before anybody panics: NO, you should not already be filling out the Common App. Junior year is not about doing senior year early. It is about making a plan now so next August does not feel like someone dumped the entire college process onto your kitchen table overnight. Lisa and Josh break down what juniors should actually be doing right now: testing, grades, activities, college visits, summer planning, getting to know their school counselor, and beginning to figure out what they actually want in a college. First? Make a college email address. Keep it boring. Check it regularly. And give yourself one place where admissions emails will not disappear underneath everything else in your inbox. Then they tackle testing. When should juniors take the SAT or ACT? Should they take both? And should they just show up for one “cold” to see what happens? Please don't. Lisa and Josh explain why students should use official full-length practice tests to establish a baseline, compare the SAT and ACT if needed, and then build an actual testing plan. They also talk about why junior-year grades matter, what rigor really means, when students need to ask for help, and why those junior-year teachers may become important recommendation writers. Then comes activities. Start the résumé NOW. Write down your roles, hours, weeks, responsibilities, accomplishments, impact, and what you actually did before future-you completely forgets. But please do not respond by joining six new clubs tomorrow. Junior year should be about depth—not adding more just to look busier. And finally: Start visiting colleges. Big schools. Small schools. City campuses. College towns. Even schools you may never apply to. Because junior year is about figuring out what you like and what you do NOT like. As Lisa says: You don't know what you don't know until you go experience it. And maybe the biggest reminder of the episode: Your junior-year college list SHOULD change. You are going to learn things. You are going to change your mind. You may discover a new major, fall in love with a completely different kind of campus, or stop loving the school whose sweatshirt you have worn since seventh grade. That is not something going wrong. That means the process is working. In this episode: • What juniors should be doing now • When to take the SAT or ACT • Why junior-year grades matter • What course rigor actually means • Why junior-year teachers matter for recommendations • How to start an activities résumé • What leadership really looks like • When to start thinking about summer opportunities • When juniors should visit colleges One of Josh's biggest reminders: Junior year should build a stronger student, not just a busier one. And Lisa's? Get curious, not competitive. Your friend's college process is theirs. This one belongs to you. Want Lisa + Josh in your corner? If you want help with testing strategy, course planning, activities, college visits, building a balanced college list, or making sure senior year does not start from zero, Lisa and Josh would love to help. Visit decisiondrop.com/contact to connect with Decision Drop.

  5. Oct 16

    EP18: College Auditions & Pre-Screens: How Performing Arts Admissions Really Work

    In Episode 18 of Drop In, Lisa and Josh are talking to the performers, singers, dancers, actors, musicians—and the parents who have spent years driving them to rehearsals, carrying garment bags, sitting through competitions, and finding dinner at 10:30 at night after a show. Because applying to college as a performing arts student? It is NOT the same as a traditional college application. Now you have pre-screens. Auditions. Repertoire. Headshots. Resumes. Dance calls. Unifieds. Callbacks. And sometimes an entirely separate set of deadlines that show up long before the university's regular application deadline. So Lisa and Josh brought in someone who actually lives in this world. Jacqui Touchet is an actor, writer, educator, audition coach, and member of the Decision Drop team. She studied theater and political science at Northwestern and has coached students through the college audition process. Jacqui explains why students should begin familiarizing themselves with audition requirements as soon as they know they may want to pursue a performing arts program—and why the summer before senior year is the absolute latest time to have a real school list and start preparing material. Because every program can ask for something different. One school may want a 90-second monologue. Another may want a Shakespeare piece. Another may want a song, a dance call, a resume, or a different type of pre-screen entirely. And one of Jacqui's biggest reminders: Follow the directions. Then they get into Unified auditions vs. individual college auditions, the advantages of each, and why families need to understand which schools require students to audition on campus. They also talk about what actually separates a strong audition from an average one. It is NOT just talent. Material matters. Jacqui explains why students should choose pieces that are age-appropriate, personally meaningful, and actually say something about who they are as an artist. And maybe do not walk into the room singing the exact same song the faculty has heard 20 times that day. From there, they talk about what faculty are really looking for. Yes, they care about talent and technique. But they are also asking: Do I want to teach this student? Do I want to work with them? Will they be a good collaborator? What unique perspective will they bring into this program? Because they are not just admitting performers. They are building an ensemble. In this episode: • When students should start preparing for performing arts admissions • What college pre-screens actually are • Unified auditions vs. on-campus auditions • How to choose strong audition material • What performing arts faculty are REALLY looking for • How to handle rejection and audition feedback • How younger students can start preparing now • Headshots, self-tapes, audition-day logistics, and more One of Jacqui's biggest pieces of advice: Control your controllables. Know the requirements. Know your material. Rehearse. Prepare. Get there on time. Follow directions. AND THEN? Bring your fullest self into the room. Want Lisa + Josh + Jacqui in your corner? If your kiddo is navigating performing arts admissions, college auditions, pre-screens, applications, or building a balanced college list, Lisa, Josh, and Jacqui would love to help. Visit decisiondrop.com/contact to connect with Decision Drop.

  6. Oct 9

    EP17: College Admissions Myths & Common Application Mistakes- What Actually Matters

    In Episode 17 of Drop In, Lisa and Josh are doing a little myth busting. Because college admissions is absolutely drowning in bad information. Your kiddo gets one B and suddenly somebody says their dream school is gone. They aren't taking every AP their high school offers, so obviously they aren't challenging themselves enough. They haven't launched a nonprofit, built an app, or created a massive “passion project,” so clearly their application isn't impressive enough. No. No. And no. There are already enough REAL things to manage during college applications. Families do not need to manufacture imaginary problems too. Lisa and Josh start by taking on three of the biggest college admissions myths: Does one B ruin your chances? Do you need to take every AP your school offers? Does every competitive applicant need a passion project? Then they move into the parts of the Common App that students stare at wondering: What am I actually supposed to put here? What belongs in the Additional Information section? What counts as an academic honor? Then Lisa and Josh get into the actual college application mistakes they see every year. Copying and pasting the wrong college name. Parents editing until the student's voice disappears. Building an unbalanced college list. Writing vague activity descriptions. Finally, they tackle one of the biggest sources of panic after applications are submitted: The student portal. Your counselor says the transcript was sent. The college portal says: MISSING. Before anyone starts sending emails in ALL CAPS, Lisa and Josh explain why college processing delays happen, how to confirm whether documents were actually submitted, when families should wait, and when it really is time to follow up. Because “missing” and “not processed yet” are two very different things. In this episode: • Does one B hurt your college admission chances? • Do students need to take every AP their school offers? • What course rigor actually means • Why students do NOT need a manufactured “passion project” • What belongs in the Common App Additional Information section • When you should leave Additional Information blank • What counts as an academic honor • Why parents should stop rewriting college essays • How to improve Common App activity descriptions • How long colleges may need to process application materials One phrase comes up again and again in this episode: CONTEXT. One grade is one grade. Rigor should make sense for the student. Activities do not need to be manufactured to impress an admissions office. And when that portal flashes MISSING three days after your kiddo applies? Verify before you worry. This process is not as fragile as it feels. Your student does not need every AP, five honors, a giant passion project, and a perfectly polished application to be what colleges want. Be thoughtful. Be honest. Pay attention. Do the boring stuff correctly. And when something looks scary, get the facts before deciding it's a disaster. Need help building a balanced college list, reviewing applications and essays, strengthening the Common App activities section, understanding deadlines, or figuring out what that terrifying red message in the student portal actually means? Visit decisiondrop.com/contact to connect with Lisa and Josh at Decision Drop.

  7. Oct 2

    EP16: College Interviews... What to Expect, How to Prepare & Do They Really Matter?

    In Episode 16 of Drop In, Lisa and Josh tackle one of the most OVERSTRESSED parts of the college admissions process: The college interview. A student gets an email offering an interview and suddenly everybody starts panicking. What are they going to ask? What if I say the wrong thing? What should I wear? Do I need to prepare answers? DOES THIS INTERVIEW ACTUALLY MATTER?! For most colleges? Probably not as much as you think. Lisa and Josh break down the different types of college interviews, how much admissions offices actually consider them, how students should prepare, the questions they are likely to hear, and what students should be asking the interviewer in return. And yes, there is actually a way to find out how much a college values interviews. The Common Data Set. Lisa and Josh explain how families can use Section C7 to see whether a college considers interviews very important, important, considered, or not considered at all. Because families should put the worry where the weight actually is. They also talk about schools like Georgetown and MIT, where interviews play a more meaningful role, and why students should generally accept an interview when a selective college offers one. Then they get practical. How much should you prepare? What should you wear? What happens during an alumni interview? What should you do differently for Zoom? Should you memorize answers? Absolutely not. The goal is not to walk into a college interview sounding like a perfectly rehearsed 17-year-old. The goal is to have a conversation. In this episode: • How to use the Common Data Set to see whether interviews matter • Why most college interviews will NOT make or break an application • Colleges where interviews may carry more weight • Georgetown’s alumni interview process • Common college interview questions • How to prepare for “Why this college?” • Questions students should ask their interviewer • What to wear to a college interview • How to prepare for a virtual interview One of our biggest reminders for kiddos: You are the expert on YOU. Think through a few stories. Know why you are interested in the school. Have a couple of good questions ready. Then stop rehearsing. Be warm. Be interested. Listen. Ask questions. Be you. And remember: you are interviewing the college too. That person sitting across from you can tell you things about the school that you will never find on an admissions website. Prepare enough that you can relax. Then go have the conversation. Want Lisa + Josh in your corner? Need help figuring out whether an interview matters, preparing for one, building your college list, working through applications and essays, or navigating the entire admissions process? Visit decisiondrop.com/contact to connect with Lisa and Josh at Decision Drop.

  8. Sep 25

    EP15: FAFSA, CSS Profile & Financial Aid: What Families Need to Know

    In Episode 15 of Drop In, Lisa and Josh are joined by Liane Crane of The College Dollar to tackle one of the most confusing—and important—parts of the college admissions process: How are we actually going to pay for college? FAFSA. CSS Profile. Financial aid. Scholarships. Grants. Loans. 529 plans. Net cost. It can feel like an entirely different language, and families are often expected to figure it out while they are already juggling applications, essays, deadlines, and everything else that comes with senior year. So we brought in an expert. Liane has spent the last decade helping families understand college finances and how to make college more affordable. She joins Lisa and Josh to break down the financial aid process in plain English and help families understand what they actually need to know before the bills start arriving. They start with the basics: What is the FAFSA? What is the CSS Profile? Who needs to complete them? And when are they actually due? Then they tackle one of the questions families are sometimes afraid to ask: Can applying for financial aid hurt my student’s chances of admission? From there, the conversation gets into the real math behind paying for college—including how to compare financial aid offers, why loans and work-study are not the same thing as free money, why the highest sticker price does not necessarily mean the most expensive college, and why families should think about the cost over four years, not just freshman year. Because the number on the college website is not necessarily the number YOUR family will pay. In this episode: What FAFSA means and what it actually does • Which colleges require the CSS Profile • When families should file financial aid forms • How missing a deadline can cost you financial aid • Does applying for financial aid hurt your chances of admission? • Federal student loans and Parent PLUS loans • Why families need a college budget BEFORE building the college list • How to calculate your true out-of-pocket college cost • How 529 plans can help families pay for college • Why sticker price does NOT equal actual price One of our favorite reminders from Liane: The most expensive college is not necessarily the one with the highest sticker price. It’s the one that makes you borrow the most. Parents, please have the money conversation early. Know what your family can comfortably contribute. Know what you are willing—or not willing—to borrow. Understand the deadlines. Ask questions when something does not make sense. You are making one of the biggest financial decisions your family may ever make. You are allowed to need help understanding it. And as Lisa says in this episode, the money piece is absolutely figure-out-able. Want help from Liane? Liane Crane works with families through The College Dollar, helping parents and students understand college costs, FAFSA, CSS Profile, financial aid, student loans, 529 plans, appeals, and strategies for making college more affordable. If you have questions about your family's college finances, visit thecollegedollar.com and click the link to schedule a FREE introductory consultation with Liane. Need help building a college list that fits both your kiddo and your family's budget? Visit decisiondrop.com/contact to connect with Lisa and Josh at Decision Drop for help with college lists, applications, essays, admissions strategy, and navigating the college process from beginning to end.

About

The college process feels like chaos. Endless deadlines, conflicting advice, and pressure from every direction. Drop In cuts through it. Hosted by Lisa and Josh, two college admissions experts with over 25 years of experience each, this show delivers real talk on essays, GPA, financial aid, college lists, resumé, and everything in between. No jargon. No fear-mongering. Just honest, insider guidance that keeps your student's voice front and center. Each episode ends with a Hot Take or Hard Truth and a Drop the Mic moment you'll actually remember. New episodes every week-DROP IN and find your place.

You Might Also Like