Relatively Insane Podcast

Relatively Insane Podcast
  • 0.0 (0)
  • Relationships
  • Updated Weekly

Relatively Insane Podcast is what happens when two siblings hand each other microphones and just enough confidence to be dangerous. Join Natalie and Matthew as they dive headfirst into their latest obsessions, unpack current events with zero shortage of opinions, explore the strange and fascinating world of true crime, and occasionally derail the conversation with some top-tier sibling bickering. From deep dives and hot takes to random tangents and questionable life advice, no topic is safe and no disagreement stays settled for long.

  1. 8h ago

    The Utah Internet Mystery That Had Reddit Convinced It Was a Hit Site

    A bizarre Reddit rabbit hole, a courtroom meltdown, and a horoscope that may or may not be running your life. If you love true crime, internet mysteries, and sibling banter that spirals in the best way, this episode is your next listen.Natalie and Matt start with the usual chaos—hunting updates, Trunk or Treat, and the kind of sibling back-and-forth that somehow turns into a full-blown theory session. But things get more interesting fast when Natalie dives into a wild case of internet lore and hidden HTML comments that led people to believe a Utah web page was connected to real-world assassinations and contract killings.You’ll discover: Why the Lake City Quiet Pills mystery had Reddit and 4chan spiraling for yearsHow a simple website, a vanished user, and cryptic page-source comments created an entire conspiracyWhat the Wayback Machine and digital forensics actually revealedWhy Natalie thinks she would absolutely go down a rabbit hole trying to solve a crimeHow horoscopes, confirmation bias, and “the phone is listening” paranoia accidentally become part of the debateAlong the way, the siblings argue over who talks more, who listens more, and whether Matt is actually paying attention to anything Natalie says. It’s funny, weirdly specific, and exactly the kind of conversation that makes this show feel like eavesdropping on your favorite family.Perfect for listeners who love off-the-rails storytelling, true crime-adjacent internet mysteries, and podcasts that can go from fart jokes to black-ops conspiracy theories without missing a beat.

  2. Oct 16

    How a Family Tree Led to an Unexpected Polygamy Discovery and Halloween Movie Rankings

    Join us as we explore a wide range of topics from court cases and family history to favorite Halloween movies and personal anecdotes, all delivered with humor and curiosity. This episode offers insights into family connections, mental health, and seasonal traditions, making it a must-listen for fans of diverse conversations.

  3. Oct 8

    A Little Bit of Everything: Honest Conversations and Unexpected Turns

    Matt and Natalie catch up on life, then wander through a lively mix of sibling banter and unexpected topics—from solo outings and Walmart shopping to POTS, comfort zones, and a serious discussion about the death penalty. It’s an unpredictable conversation that balances humor with honest reflections on health, friendship, and stepping outside your comfort zone.

  4. Oct 2

    A Little Chaos, A Lot to Talk About

    This episode jumps from everyday frustrations to unexpectedly chaotic stories, with plenty of sibling banter along the way. Natalie and Matt swap life updates, laugh about work and costumes, and recount a strange night out that took a spooky turn. It’s a relaxed, unpredictable conversation full of funny detours and the kind of stories that make you ask, “How did we get here?”

  5. Sep 25

    I Thought Poop Was Going to Be My Demise And Other Confessions

    Sunglasses, swollen eyes, a constipation crisis, ADHD revelations, true crime, and a round of “Two Truths and a Lie”—Natalie and Matt’s sibling conversation takes plenty of hilarious, unexpected turns. It’s an unfiltered episode full of chaotic stories, family banter, pop culture, and plenty of oversharing.

  6. Sep 18

    Why Normalizing Farts Became the Funniest Part of This Podcast

    Sibling chaos, bizarre overshares, and a sports rabbit hole collide when Natalie and Matt turn a regular catch-up into one of their funniest and most unfiltered episodes yet. From gambling regrets and bar people-watching to poop stories, bad friend energy, astrology readings, and a full-blown sports trivia showdown, this episode swings from ridiculous to unexpectedly revealing in all the best ways.Natalie and Matt, the sibling duo behind Relatively Insane, bring their signature back-and-forth into everything from football bets gone wrong to the strange social ecosystem of bars in your 30s. Natalie opens up about a stressful week, a toxic friendship she finally blocked, and the hair-dye spiral that ended with her cutting her own hair. Matt, meanwhile, gives his brutally honest take on everything from sports fandom to the internet’s weirdest algorithm obsessions.In this episode: Why Natalie feels like her brain is always running on two tracksThe wildest classroom and car poop stories you’ve probably ever heard on a podcastHow Natalie ended up reading a man’s Spanish text messages with Google Translate at a hockey gameWhat their astrology charts supposedly reveal about their personalitiesWhy Matt’s sports knowledge is both impressive and wildly specific, covering the NFL, MLB, hockey, tennis, NASCAR, and moreTheir opinions on a high-profile court case and why Natalie would make a surprisingly serious jurorA nostalgic tour of 2009, including the biggest pop culture moments, sports headlines, and TV releases from the year that shaped themPerfect for listeners who love sibling banter, over-the-top honesty, weirdly specific sports trivia, and conversations that feel like something you were never supposed to overhear—but absolutely can’t stop listening to.

  7. Sep 11

    We Took a Fifth-Grade Quiz and Somehow Made It a Disaster

    Mercury retrograde, missing cats, fantasy football, and a full-blown fifth-grade trivia showdown collide in this chaotic sibling episode. Natalie and Matt turn a normal catch-up into a hilarious fact-checking session, roasting astrology, debating zodiac signs, and proving that confidence is not the same thing as correctness

  8. Sep 4

    The Couch Edition: Chaos, Concerts, and 1999 Nostalgia

    A first-ever video episode, a couch full of family chaos, and one of the funniest, most unfiltered nostalgia trips you’ll hear all year. If you grew up before the 2000s, love sibling arguments, or miss the era of dial-up, mixed CDs, and $5 movie tickets, this one is going to hit hard. Natalie, Matt, and Maurlie turn their mom’s couch into a time machine and somehow make a conversation about Noah Kahan, court TV, concert souvenirs, breakfast for dinner, and 1999 pop culture feel like three different podcasts in one. Natalie can’t stop reliving the emotional high of seeing Noah Kahan live, Matt keeps the family grounded with deadpan commentary, and Maurlie brings the chaos, the hot takes, and the energy of someone who absolutely refuses to be the only one having fun. You'll discover: Why Noah Kahan turned into an unexpectedly emotional concert experienceThe family debate over whether breakfast for dinner is brilliant or just lazyThe weirdly specific rules of microwaves, shoes in the house, and favorite-child statusWhat 1999 actually felt like, from Y2K panic to Napster, sidekicks, TRL, and the best pop culture of the eraWhy everyone suddenly has strong opinions about water, bottled ice, starter jackets, and the return of frosted tipsThey also get into the reality of growing up in a house full of fighting, what family vacations looked like, and why old-school nostalgia hits differently when you’re old enough to remember it the first time. By the end, the episode becomes less about one topic and more about the hilarious, messy, painfully relatable way this family talks to each other.Perfect for anyone who loves chaotic family banter, 90s/2000s nostalgia, concert stories, and the kind of sibling chemistry that can only come from years of shared trauma and shared punchlines. If you want an episode that feels like eavesdropping on your funniest relatives, hit play.

See All (19)

About

Relatively Insane Podcast is what happens when two siblings hand each other microphones and just enough confidence to be dangerous. Join Natalie and Matthew as they dive headfirst into their latest obsessions, unpack current events with zero shortage of opinions, explore the strange and fascinating world of true crime, and occasionally derail the conversation with some top-tier sibling bickering. From deep dives and hot takes to random tangents and questionable life advice, no topic is safe and no disagreement stays settled for long.

Information

  • Creator
    Relatively Insane Podcast
  • Years Active
    2026
  • Episodes
    19
  • Rating
    Explicit
  • Copyright
    © Relatively Insane Podcast
  • Show Website
    Relatively Insane Podcast