The Horsemen

Matthew West, Dakota Leming, Curtis Ashmore, Jacob Nicoletti

The Horsemen is what happens when four pastors sit down for a quick chat and completely forget where the main point went. Equal parts theology, candid friendship, and unscripted tangents, this is a show about loving Jesus, serving the church, and genuinely loving people without taking ourselves too seriously. We are here to disrupt the status quo, challenge tired paradigms, and remind you that faith can be both deeply meaningful and deeply fun. Tune in for honest conversations, unexpected detours, and a raw look at life, ministry, and brotherhood.

Episodes

  1. 6h ago

    Thankful For All Things? Is that possible?

    In this episode, the guys kick things off with stories from hunting season and Thanksgiving family traditions before diving into a real conversation about what it takes to stay grateful when life gets tough. It’s easy to be thankful when everything is going right, so they unpack the reality of holding onto gratitude during hard seasons—and the sobering realization that the very things we used to pray for can sometimes become the things we complain about today. They talk honestly about how hard times are inevitable, but leaning on Scripture, good community, and a shift in perspective can build lasting spiritual resilience. They also tackle the everyday traps that steal our joy—like scrolling through social media and playing the comparison game—and share what it looks like to actually learn contentment in Christ right where you are. Key Takeaways: Gratitude in every season: Anyone can be thankful on the good days, but real growth happens when you find reasons to praise God in the middle of hardship.Watch your complaints: Take a step back and check your heart—are you complaining about something you once begged God for?Perspective changes everything: Leaning on Scripture and trusted friends helps pull you out of discouragement and reminds you of God's bigger plan.Kill the comparison trap: Social media is a highlight reel; true joy comes from stepping back and appreciating the everyday blessings right in front of you.Contentment is a learned skill: Being content in Christ isn't automatic—it's something you build through real-life experience and intentional thankfulness.Chapters: 00:00 Introduction and Hunting Season05:58 Thanksgiving and Family Traditions12:00 The Challenge of Gratitude19:55 Finding Thankfulness in Hard Times21:09 Finding Gratitude in Hardship23:32 The Role of Scripture and Community27:30 Perspective Shifts and God's Plan31:03 Rejoicing in Difficult Times36:40 The Comparison Trap and Joy42:26 The Power of Gratitude44:56 Navigating Social Media Comparisons47:56 Understanding Contentment in Christ52:04 Finding Joy in Everyday Life58:06 The Importance of Thankfulness

  2. Nov 6

    When Ministry Comes Home

    Can you really build a thriving church without destroying your own family in the process? 🏠💔 In this episode, we’re pulling back the curtain on the quiet pressure cooker of ministry life. It’s time to confront a hard truth: neglecting your spouse and kids to build a church isn't a holy sacrifice—it’s a recipe for burnout. We dive deep into the messy friction of turning off the "pastor" brain, breaking the myth of constant availability, and dealing with the toxic expectations placed on preacher's kids (PKs) and ministry spouses. If you’ve ever felt the soul-crushing guilt of choosing between a church emergency and your family dinner table, this conversation is for you. 👇 Drop a comment: What is the hardest boundary you’ve had to set in ministry? 🕒 TIMESTAMPS 00:00 - The Ministry vs. Family Tug-of-War 03:27 - The Friction of Switching Roles (Pastor vs. Parent) 10:37 - Why Physical Presence Isn't Emotional Presence 14:06 - Winning the Community vs. Losing Your Household 19:31 - The Toxic Myth of Constant Availability 24:53 - Delegation as a Family Protection Tool 32:06 - How to Draw Lines in the Sand 34:28 - Real Stories: Balancing the Chaos 56:39 - The Unspoken Expectations on Pastors' Wives 01:06:31 - Breaking the "Perfect PK" Stereotype 01:08:20 - Helping Your Kids Find Their Own Faith 01:09:13 - Free Church Labor? Service vs. Forced Responsibility 01:13:36 - How to Set Boundaries and Survive the Guilt 01:27:40 - What Actually Counts as a True Ministry Emergency? 01:43:31 - The Searing Cost of Calling vs. Family 🔔 Subscribe for more honest conversations on healthy leadership, ministry reality checks, and faith. #MinistryLife #PastoralBurnout #ChurchLeadership #FamilyFirst #PastorsKids #HealthyBoundaries #MinistryMarriage

  3. Oct 30

    Called, Compensated, Stretched Thin

    Summary This episode dives into the real-world dynamics of bivocational ministry and how it impacts both family life and church responsibilities. The hosts share personal stories and insights on balancing a secular career with ministry, emphasizing that obedience to God's calling matters far more than your specific ministry model. The conversation also tackles the financial realities pastors face across different church settings. From the urgent need for fair compensation to the unique sacrifices leaders make, this episode highlights how congregations and denominations can better support their pastors. Ultimately, the hosts call for a cultural shift within the church—one that moves toward deeply honoring, appreciating, and protecting the well-being of pastors and their families. Key Takeaways Bivocational ministry is entirely valid: Balancing a secular job and church leadership is a powerful, viable model for ministry.Obedience comes first: Answering God's calling is what matters most, regardless of how your ministry is structured.Financial stability is crucial: Pastors need adequate compensation and financial support to thrive.Context matters: Churches must take the time to understand the unique needs and pressures their specific pastors face.Honor and support are essential: Congregations need to actively care for their pastors' overall well-being.Cultural shifts are needed: Church organizations must change how they view and support pastoral families to prevent burnout.Chapters 00:00 Introduction and Overview09:45 Bivocational Ministry Dynamics15:39 Scriptural Foundations for Ministry26:50 Navigating Church Expectations31:38 Financial Considerations in Ministry34:46 Contextual Challenges in Pastoring40:26 Compensation Structures and Expectations43:56 Bivocational Ministry Dynamics (Deep Dive)51:20 The Importance of Honor and Compensation57:45 Organizational Support for Pastors01:05:01 Honoring Pastors and Their Needs01:10:34 Cultural Shifts in Ministry01:15:56 Balancing Family and Ministry01:20:56 The Guilt of Bivocational Ministry01:27:03 Appreciation and Support from Congregations

  4. Oct 23

    HolyWEEN: Holiness or Halloween? Or both?

    Can Christians celebrate Halloween? It is an annual debate that divides families, churches, and friendships. In this episode, the hosts dive deep into the tension between modern culture and Christian faith. We kick things off with our favorite fall traditions before digging into the messy history of Halloween—from its ancient roots to the modern holiday we see today. Through the lens of personal stories, scripture, and media influence, we explore what it looks like to live "in the light" while navigating the spooky season. Whether your family goes all-out with costumes, opts for alternative church festivals, or skips the holiday entirely, this conversation is all about replacing judgment with grace, understanding, and biblical wisdom. Key Takeaways The Halloween Debate: Unpacking why this holiday creates such a divide in the Christian community.History vs. Modern Culture: Separating historical facts from modern traditions.The Power of Backstory: How our own childhood upbringings shape our current views on the holiday.Conviction over Consensus: Why personal boundaries matter, and how to respect other believers who see things differently.Missional Mindset: How some Christians are reframing the night as an opportunity for community outreach and evangelism.Chapters 00:00 Welcome & Intro02:11 The Annual Halloween Headache: Personal Frustrations08:22 Fall Favorites & Saying Goodbye to Summer19:03 Where Did Halloween Actually Come From?24:20 The Christian View: A History of Tension26:18 How Modern Traditions Changed the Game29:50 Our Personal Stances on the Holiday33:08 How We Were Raised: Family Traditions44:22 The Theological Side of Spooky Season54:10 The Great Debate: Should Christians Participate?01:00:15 Walking in the Light vs. Embracing the Dark01:02:00 The Real-World Impact of These Traditions01:14:05 Monsters & Magic: Navigating Fantasy vs. Reality01:23:30 Where Do You Draw the Line? Conviction vs. Compromise01:26:58 Setting Healthy Boundaries for Your Family01:27:56 What Does Scripture Actually Say?01:28:41 Balancing Personal Convictions with Biblical Truth01:32:13 How Churches Deal with Halloween01:33:08 A Guide for Pastors and Spiritual Leaders01:37:17 Finding Common Ground (Even When We Disagree)01:41:02 Light in the Neighborhood: Using Halloween for Evangelism01:46:00 Final Thoughts: Faith, Freedom, and Autumn Fun

  5. Oct 16

    How Close is to Close: Pastoral Friendships

    Welcome to The Horseman Podcast! In this episode, four pastors—Dakota, Matt, Curtis, and Jacob—sit down for a candid, unfiltered discussion about the realities of modern ministry. To kick things off, each pastor uses just one word to encapsulate their current situation, sparking a deep dive into the messiness, steadiness, and necessary corrections that come with the calling. From analyzing how personal journeys shape our individual preaching styles to the challenges of adapting to different church environments, this conversation pulled no punches. We also explore the complex dynamics of pastoral friendships, the vital role of boundaries, and how true humility and authenticity can build genuine connections within a congregation—even when navigating the potential for hurt and misunderstanding. 📌 Key Takeaways From This Episode: Ministry experiences vary widely – no two seasons look exactly the same.Preaching styles reflect personal journeys and evolve over time.Friendship requires integrity, especially when balancing personal bonds with pastoral responsibilities.Boundaries are essential in pastoral relationships to protect both the leader and the church.Humility and authenticity in leadership foster the deepest, most genuine connections with your congregation.💬 Join the Conversation: What is one word you would use to describe your current season of life or ministry? Let us know in the comments below! Don't forget to Like, Subscribe, and hit the Notification Bell so you never miss an episode! #PastorsPodcast #MinistryRealities #ChurchLeadership #PastoralMinistry #AuthenticLeadership #TheHorsemanPodcast Chapters 00:00 Welcome and Introductions01:10 Current Ministry Reflections05:24 Describing Ministry in One Word10:48 Dynamics of Preaching Styles16:22 Superhero Defense Strategies22:35 The Foundation of Friendship in Ministry24:44 Navigating Relationships: Pastors and Congregants27:21 The Role of Boundaries in Pastoral Friendships30:13 Intimacy and Leadership: Finding Balance34:12 The Weight of Pastoral Responsibility39:01 Friendship Dynamics in Ministry44:20 Intentional Relationships: Building Community50:42 Accountability and Friendship: A Delicate Balance58:29 The Call to Humility01:01:26 Friendship and Connection in Ministry01:03:32 The Role of Authenticity in Pastoral Relationships01:07:14 Navigating Hurt and Building Trust01:10:48 The Nature of Church Relationships01:14:33 The Reality of Ministry Challenges01:18:00 Embracing Vulnerability in Leadership01:21:41 The Importance of Genuine Relationships

  6. Oct 9

    The Greatest Hits!

    The Horsemen Podcast's live episode titled 'Greatest Hits' features the hosts sharing their favorite memories, discussing pop culture, and engaging in a fun movie sequel draft. The conversation flows through various topics, including personal anecdotes, TV shows, and the significance of certain films in their lives. The conversation revolves around personal experiences and reflections on significant moments in life, particularly focusing on memorable days, childhood memories, and the importance of conversations with loved ones. The hosts share anecdotes about their lives, including moments of joy, bonding, and realizations that come with hindsight. The conversation reflects on the significance of personal relationships, shared experiences, and the profound impact of seemingly mundane moments in life. It emphasizes the importance of being present, cherishing memories, and learning from life's inconveniences while also discussing valuable life advice. Takeaways Engaging discussions on nostalgiaMovie sequels as cultural touchstones Significant moments often go unnoticedChildhood memories shape our lives Cherish everyday momentsLearn from life's inconveniences Chapters 00:00 Welcome to the Horsemen Podcast02:14 Pop Culture Highlights and Personal Anecdotes13:28 Greatest Hits of Our Lives15:22 The Movie Sequel Draft Begins27:13 Defending Our Sequel Choices33:27 The Importance of Connection43:54 Reflecting on Life's Greatest Hits52:14 Cherished Childhood Memories01:04:08 Realizations Through Hindsight01:07:57 The Importance of Shared Memories01:11:32 Cherishing Relationships and Conversations01:14:37 Life's Inconveniences as Opportunities01:17:01 Valuable Life Advice and Lessons01:29:25 Reflections on Life's Journey

  7. Oct 2

    Pastors on Pastors: Pastoral Burnout

    In this episode of the Horseman Podcast Matt, Curtis, Dakota, and Jacob interview John Mark Smithson. John Mark opens up about his personal battle with ministry burnout, shedding light on a struggle that many church leaders face but rarely talk about. The conversation dives into the heavy weight of pastoral expectations, the isolation that comes with the job, and why the church community needs to break the stigma around mental health. John Mark also shares his journey through faith deconstruction and reconstruction, explaining how he stepped away from traditional church structures to find rest. The discussion explores a shift toward organic home church movements, emphasizing that real ministry is built on authentic, vulnerable relationships and finding God outside conventional settings rather than chasing titles or traditional formats. Main Takeaways The hidden crisis: Pastoral burnout is incredibly common, making open conversations about mental health essential for church leaders.Redefining church: True ministry exists far beyond the pulpit and conventional church walls, often thriving in smaller, organic home settings.Prioritizing soul care: Leaders need genuine spiritual rest and authentic relationships over traditional church obligations.The power of stepping back: Finding a real encounter with God sometimes requires deconstructing old traditions to rediscover your foundational faith.Key Moments 10:06 – Facing Burnout: Diving into what burnout actually feels like in ministry and sharing personal experiences with isolation.26:51 – The Identity Trap: Discussing the heavy burden of expectations and how hard it is to balance a pastoral identity with real life.39:21 – Life After Ministry: Navigating the transition out of traditional church culture and redefining life beyond job titles.01:04:00 – The Home Church Shift: Exploring the home church movement as a more personal, organic way to build community.01:34:46 – Rebuilding Faith: A look at the journey of deconstruction, the power of vulnerability, and rediscovering a foundational love for faith.

  8. Sep 25

    Pastors on Pastors: Young Ministers

    Headline: What does it really take to carry the mantle of ministry at a young age? In this episode of Pastors on Pastors, The HorseMen are joined by special guest Jeremy Singleton for a transparent and powerful conversation about the realities, challenges, and adversities faced by young ministers in their respective fields. The guys dive deep into the heart of modern ministry, covering everything from the biblical basis for young ministers to navigating age-related pushback and doubt. They share personal insights on how to handle conflict with understanding and grace, the absolute necessity of structural mentorship, and why "tactical patience" and humility are your greatest assets when waiting on the Lord.Takeaways Youthful Ministry ChallengesAdversity in Ministry Mentorship is crucialDealing with pushback and challengesTactical patience and humility Mentorship and guidance are crucial for young ministersThe importance of being faithful and confident in one's calling Chapters 00:00 Introduction and Ministry Updates00:52 The Importance of Church Membership01:21 Preparing for UP Camp Meeting02:15 Revival Kickoff and Pressing Forward03:01 Unity and Fellowship in Church Planting03:30 Handling Adversity as a Young Minister04:27 Dealing with Age-Related Pushback07:00 Biblical Basis for Young Ministers09:16 Facing Challenges Due to Age in Ministry10:17 Handling Adversity and Pushback11:18 Overcoming Age-Related Challenges12:10 Addressing Age-Related Conflict13:04 Facing Pushback and Doubt in Ministry14:14 Understanding the Weight of Ministry15:09 Proving Qualification Through Example16:16 Demonstrating Leadership and Conduct17:14 Proving Readiness and Ability in Ministry18:11 Being an Example in Ministry19:18 Demonstrating Rootedness in the Word20:16 Proving Heart Posture and Ability21:13 Demonstrating Spiritual Conduct23:26 Facing Pushback and Challenges47:05 The Importance of Mentorship51:13 Tactical Patience and Humility55:10 The Role of Mentors and Guidance56:01 The Fear of Expectations and the Chip on the Shoulder59:29 The Maturity and Confidence of Young Ministers01:02:39 The Importance of Spiritual Maturity and Waiting on the Lord01:15:25 The Impact of Spousal Support on Ministry01:19:09 The Giveaway Announcement and Closing Remarks

  9. Aug 22

    Episode 1: Quantifying Leadership Ability

    # The Four Horsemen: Disrupting the Status Quo Exploring faith and fun with the Four Horsemen of Michigan. Welcome to the inaugural episode of our podcast featuring the Four Horsemen from Michigan! Join Matthew West, Jacob Nicoletti, Curtis Ashmore, and Dakota Lemming as they delve into meaningful conversations that blend humor, faith, and current events. ## Introduction to the Four Horsemen The podcast kicks off with an introduction to the group, affectionately known as the "Four Horsemen." Matthew shares, "It's good to finally be able to do this. We've been talking about it for a long time." This light-hearted banter sets the tone for a relaxed yet profound discussion. ## The Origins of the Name The group reflects on how they acquired their name during a camp last year. Jacob asks, "Where exactly did the Four Horsemen name come from?" Dakota humorously recalls their attempts to identify which horseman each of them represents, which remains an ongoing mystery. ## Disrupting the Status Quo As they settle into deeper topics, Matthew emphasizes their mission: "We like to push the status quo to disrupt what most people think is the easy way to go." This mission is rooted in scripture and aims to encourage each other and their listeners. ## Current Events and Faith Curtis shares his reflections from scripture, particularly from Second Timothy, highlighting God's grace amid chaos: "In the midst of division... we've been appointed to a calling to shepherd a flock of people in our brokenness." The discussion touches on pressing social issues in Michigan, encouraging a blend of faith and action in uncertain times. ## A Lighthearted Conclusion As the conversation wraps up, Matthew lightens the mood with jokes about their dynamic, reminding listeners that amidst serious discussions, there is always room for laughter and camaraderie. "If we're to choose a horseman, maybe he's Death because he's that much closer!" This podcast not only addresses serious themes but does so with a sense of community and humor, making it relatable and engaging. As you listen to the full episode, consider how you can reflect on your own journey amid life's chaos and uncertainties. Join us in this exploration of faith, fun, and the importance of community.

About

The Horsemen is what happens when four pastors sit down for a quick chat and completely forget where the main point went. Equal parts theology, candid friendship, and unscripted tangents, this is a show about loving Jesus, serving the church, and genuinely loving people without taking ourselves too seriously. We are here to disrupt the status quo, challenge tired paradigms, and remind you that faith can be both deeply meaningful and deeply fun. Tune in for honest conversations, unexpected detours, and a raw look at life, ministry, and brotherhood.