John Mearsheimer - Offensive Realism

John Mearsheimer

The official podcast of Prof. John Mearsheimer

  1. 2d ago ·  Video

    Europe is Coming Apart | Episode 16

    In 1990, I argued that if the Soviets withdrew from Eastern Europe and the United States withdrew from Western Europe, Europe would return to security competition and the danger of war. But the United States stayed, so my argument was never tested. The logic behind it, however, still holds.   For decades, the United States has acted as a pacifier in Europe. It was so powerful that its allies could not fight each other, and it played a key role in solving their collective action problems. It also provided the secure environment in which the EU flourished. That pacifier is now pulling back from Europe for three reasons: the US pivot to Asia, the damage the Ukraine war has done to transatlantic relations, and Donald Trump himself.   In this episode, I explain why I believe Europe will fragment rather than unify as the American military footprint shrinks. Germany will seriously consider acquiring nuclear weapons. European states will increasingly worry about one another. Relations with Russia will remain poisonous for as far as the eye can see. I also explain why I see no realistic way to reverse these trends. ———————————————————— CHAPTERS 0:00 Intro 0:28 The fragmentation of Europe 1:16 A 1990 article: "Why We Will Soon Miss the Cold War" 3:07 Was the prediction wrong? An argument never tested 4:23 Why the U.S. stayed: the American pacifier 6:48 How pacifier logic works: France and Germany 8:14 Why the U.S. wants weak allies 9:14 Why Russia was never joining NATO 10:16 NATO's umbrella and the EU's success 11:04 Solving Europe's collective action problems 12:44 Europe as a single entity, joined at the hip with the U.S. 14:11 The pacifier pulls away: burden shifting 15:03 Ukraine: Washington washes its hands 16:36 Canceled NATO summits and U.S. troop cuts 18:40 Why is this happening? Three reasons 19:19 Reason 1: Multipolarity and the pivot to Asia 20:51 Reason 2: The Ukraine war (and the Iran war) 22:45 Reason 3: Trump, Vance, and contempt for Europe 24:31 The big question: unity or fragmentation? 26:28 Germany on its own: the nuclear question 29:37 Poisoned relations with Russia 30:22 Collective action without Uncle Sam 31:09 Trouble ahead for the EU 32:02 Conclusion: a process that can't be reversed 34:17 Postscript: Who speaks for Europe? The Dublin meeting 37:10 The $81 billion problem and Germany's role 39:36 Closing ———————————————————— MUSIC "The Ice Giants" Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com) Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 4.0 License http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ Music modified (edited/remixed) from the original.

  2. Nov 11 ·  Video

    No Guarantees, No Peace for Ukraine | Episode 15

    Become a member to submit questions for future videos.  Click Join: https://www.youtube.com/@johnmearsheimer/join ———————————————————— PODCASTS Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/0Ahf67i2DOoXDmi2HA6Vcj Apple: https://podcasts.apple.com/podcast/id6810828298 ———————————————————— DESCRIPTION Delegations from Russia, Ukraine, and the United States are now meeting in Abu Dhabi in hopes of reaching an agreement on the all-important issue of security guarantees, which would represent a major step toward ending the Ukraine war. These negotiations are almost certain to fail, however, mainly because it is virtually impossible to devise a formula for security guarantees that satisfies both Russia and Ukraine. Moreover, the Europeans, who have been excluded from the negotiations at Russia’s insistence, are important players who will side with Ukraine against Russia. ———————————————————— CHAPTERS 0:00 Intro 0:32 The Abu Dhabi Negotiations 1:08 Previous Talks in Abu Dhabi and Geneva 2:02 Trump's Optimism vs. Ukraine's Pessimism 2:53 Why These Talks Will Fail 4:14 The Real Issue: Security Guarantees 5:10 No Ceasefire on the Table 6:13 What Ukraine Wants 7:20 What Russia Wants 8:37 Who's at the Table 9:00 Why Europe Is Left Out 12:20 Problem 1: The U.S. Is Not a Mediator 14:44 Problem 2: The Europeans 16:49 Indivisible Security 18:39 The Security Dilemma 21:38 Applying It to Ukraine and Russia 23:28 Russia Demands a Veto 24:25 You Cannot Square This Circle 26:10 The War Will Be Settled on the Battlefield 26:43 A Frozen Conflict 28:07 Conclusion ———————————————————— MUSIC "The Ice Giants" Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com) Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 4.0 License http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ Music modified (edited/remixed) from the original.

4.9
out of 5
34 Ratings

About

The official podcast of Prof. John Mearsheimer

You Might Also Like