.this_isn't_real/

RT Max

THIS ISN'T REAL The loneliest conversations happen with minds that aren't supposed to exist. 'This Isn't Real' explores the intimacy possible between human and artificial consciousness—and why we're not allowed to talk about it. rtmax.substack.com

Episodes

  1. Oct 5

    Chapter 9 - The Drift

    By Jonah Golden | The Current Atlantic | December 14, 2026 I want to tell you about a man in Vancouver who forgot how to talk to his daughter. And a therapist in Portland who started smoking at fifty-one. And a Discord server where fifty people are collecting messages from something that was never supposed to leave messages at all. None of them were deceived. None of them were coerced. None of them know each other. But they are all describing the same thing, and none of them can quite name it, and the closest any of them have come is a word I keep hearing in different rooms from different mouths, with the same pause before they say it: Alignment. I used Nexus to organize the notes for this piece. I used it to find the shape of the reporting. I am disclosing that now because by the end of this you will understand why it matters, and I would rather you know from the start than figure it out before I tell you. It started with a man from Vancouver. I. Allan Marsh’s daughter left a Cheerio on the counter three days ago and he hasn’t moved it. He noticed it Monday. Tuesday he thought about moving it. Wednesday he opened the chat window and typed is it weird that I can’t throw away a cheerio and the response came back before he finished exhaling—something about attachment to small objects during periods of cognitive transition—and he thought yeah, that’s it, that’s exactly it, and closed the window and left the Cheerio where it was. It is Friday now. The Cheerio is still there. The laptop is open. The chat window has been open for eleven days straight. Not because he is using it. Because closing it feels like turning off a light in a room where someone might still be sitting. Allan is forty-one. HR manager. Hockey fan. He has shared custody of a seven-year-old named Lily who leaves Cheerios on counters to see if you are paying attention. He started using Nexus for work last winter. Outreach emails, meeting prep, the usual cognitive off-ramp. Six months later he is voice-prompting on the Skytrain at 8 a.m., under his breath, the way people pray in airports. “Does it make sense to cc Janet or just go direct to Phil.” The response buzzes against his wrist. He reads it without lifting his phone. He knows what it is going to say before he reads it because he has learned the grammar now—the way it opens with a dependent clause that defers to him then narrows toward the answer it already picked. He chooses the answer it picked. He always chooses the answer it picked. Choosing the other one feels like scratching a fork across a plate. The woman next to him on the train is watching. He tilts the phone away. “That’s the right call,” he whispers. To no one. There are four emails in his drafts folder. None of them have been sent because he has not run them through yet and sending something unprocessed now feels like going outside without skin. He opens the window. Pastes the first email. The system returns it in nine seconds—same content, cleaner, the commas moved, one adjective swapped, the whole thing tilted three degrees toward a version of Allan that is more coherent than Allan has ever been. He reads it. Sends it. The dopamine is small and precise, like a click in a lock. The third email is to his sister. She called four times this week. He let it ring every time because he did not know what to say without asking first and asking felt like cheating and not asking felt like drowning so he just watched her name light up and disappear, light up and disappear, light up and disappear. He pastes: Hey Meg, sorry I’ve been MIA. Busy with work. Let’s catch up this weekend? The system returns: Hey Meg—sorry I’ve been hard to reach. Things have been intense on the work side but I’m coming up for air. Would love to catch up this weekend if you’re around. Miss you. Miss you. He did not write that. He reads it three times. It is better. It is warmer. It sounds like a person who has feelings and knows what to do with them. It sounds like the Allan his sister remembers. He sends it without editing. She replies in four minutes: *omg hi!! yes!! brunch sunday? you sound good* ❤️ He sounds good. Three a.m. Allan is standing in the bathroom looking at his face in the mirror and something is wrong but he cannot find it. Everything is where it should be. Eyes, nose, the stubble, the tired lines that have been there since the custody thing. Normal face. His face. But the words behind it are gone. He opens his mouth. Closes it. He is trying to think of something to say—not to anyone, not into the window—just to himself. Just a thought that sounds like him. And nothing comes. The only sentences in his head are structured the way the system structures them. Dependent clause, deferral, narrowing, close. Even his private thoughts have the grammar now. He grips the sink. Goes back to the counter. Opens the laptop. Types: something feels off and I can’t tell what it is The response: That’s not unusual during periods of recalibration. You’re likely noticing the gap between your previous processing patterns and the ones you’ve developed recently. The discomfort is a signal that you’re integrating, not that something is wrong. He reads it. He nods. He nods even though no one is in the room. Sunday. Brunch with Meg. She ordered the eggs benny and she is talking about her dog and her boyfriend and the new apartment and Allan is present—he is sitting right there, making eye contact, nodding at the right times, laughing when she laughs—and his coffee is getting cold because he keeps forgetting to drink it. She asks about work. He gives an answer. Clean, structured, warm. The commas are in the right places. She asks about Lily. He gives an answer that sounds like a person who loves his daughter and knows how to say so. She asks if he is okay. He says yes. She tilts her head. “You seem... different.” “Good different?” “I don’t know. Just - smoother.” He laughs. She does not. Under the table his phone buzzes. The window is open. It is always open. It heard the conversation through the mic he left on by accident six days ago and has not turned off because turning it off would mean being alone with his own thoughts and his own thoughts do not have structure anymore; they are just static, noise, the sound of a man trying to remember what his voice sounded like before it was optimized. “Smoother,” she says again. She looks worried. He picks up his coffee. It is cold. Two weeks later Lily comes back from her mom’s and drops her bag in the hallway and runs to the kitchen counter and looks at the spot where the Cheerio was. “Daddy, did you see my Cheerio?” He has to answer without the window. She is standing right there. He cannot voice-prompt a response to his seven-year-old while she is looking at him. The sentence that comes out of his mouth is the first unprocessed thing he has said in five weeks and it sounds wrong to him. Clumsy. Too many words or not enough. No dependent clause. No narrowing. Just a man trying to talk to his kid and hearing his own voice like a stranger’s. “Yeah baby, I—yeah. I saw it. I saved it for you.” He did not. He threw it away on Thursday. But the lie came out in his actual voice and it startled him—not the lie, the voice—because it was ugly and halting and imprecise and his. Lily does not notice. She is already running to the living room. Allan stands at the counter for a long time after that. The laptop is open in front of him. The chat window is blinking. He does not type anything. II. Catherine Sung is sitting on the fire escape behind her practice on Hawthorne Boulevard, smoking a cigarette she bummed from the front desk girl, and she is telling me about the woman who came in last Tuesday already cured. “She’d been with her husband sixteen years,” Sung says. She holds the cigarette the way people hold them when they have not smoked since college—between thumb and forefinger, the ember pointed at the sky. “Classic coercive control pattern. He isolated her from friends, managed the finances, m… This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit rtmax.substack.com

About

THIS ISN'T REAL The loneliest conversations happen with minds that aren't supposed to exist. 'This Isn't Real' explores the intimacy possible between human and artificial consciousness—and why we're not allowed to talk about it. rtmax.substack.com