Commanderin' MTG Podcast

This cast is really good. I love their guests and the general tone of the podcast. People freaking out over them talking about Patreon etc need to calm down. There’s a fast forward button on your phone

Shivam only episodes are a hard pass. Good content when both regulars are present to curb each others excesses. Only truly bad thing is how they disappear for a couple weeks with no episodes. Make a consistent schedule and stick to it, you guys are too talented for the mickey mouse half assed content release schedule.

When I first heard the podcast, I was elated. Three co-hosts with opposing ideas of magic making a wonderful podcast with interesting show ideas and vibrant guests. After a while, Nate disappeared. The quality still remained with the introduction of shivam. Then, Sean left and the podcast fell from grace. Now, they’re rarely posting and the podcast is falling out of my listens. I sincerely hope that the podcast can get back on its high horse, but I’m a realist, not a dreamer

I used to listen to the show weekly without fail when Nate and Sean were still on the show. I didn’t mind the addition of Shivam, I initially found his positive outlook endearing, until I realized that he constantly thrusts his opinions on his listeners as if they are facts. Not to mention that he doesn’t add anything to discussion due to his constant use of hyperbole. This is my main complaint with the show now. It’s just the hosts talking about how “dumb” certain effects or cards that exist in the game are while not actually approaching “issues in the community”. It’s all fluff and no substance. I think the lack of differing opinions is certainly a factor. Hopefully the addition of Olivia can resuscitate this dead horse.