Average Joe Nation

Damon Gilbert

Join Damon Gilbert as he shares his insights of todays wacky world with an "average joe" eye.

  1. Aug 27

    Evil Admits to Horror--But Wait There Is An Excuse

    When Does an Explanation Become an Excuse? In this episode, I discuss the possible ramifications of a not-guilty-by-reason-of-insanity verdict—or a jury unable to reach a verdict—in the Lindsay Clancy case. My concern goes beyond this single prosecution. At what point does explaining why someone committed a horrific act begin to diminish personal responsibility for committing it? Mental illness is real, and our legal system has long recognized that there are rare circumstances in which a person may be incapable of understanding the nature or wrongfulness of an act. But that standard should be extraordinarily high when innocent lives have been deliberately taken. If we continually expand the circumstances that reduce criminal responsibility, where does the principle stop? Could a violent offender someday argue that hormones, compulsions, psychological disorders, trauma, medication, or some other biological condition made his behavior beyond his control? That may sound extreme, but it illustrates the question I want to examine: Where should society draw the line between understanding behavior and excusing it? I have strong feelings about this case, but this episode isn't an argument against examining evidence or providing a legitimate defense. It is an argument for accountability. Some acts are so consequential that society must send an equally clear message: explanations deserve to be heard, but they do not automatically erase responsibility. Average Joe Nationyoutube.com/@avgjoenationInstagraminstagram.com/averagejoenationStubstackaveragejoenation.substack.com • • Twitterx.com/averagejoen1

    Evil Admits to Horror--But Wait There Is An Excuse

Ratings & Reviews

5
out of 5
3 Ratings

About

Join Damon Gilbert as he shares his insights of todays wacky world with an "average joe" eye.