69 episodes

But Make It Scary is a dark comedy podcast that twists hit romantic films into the horror movies you didn’t know you were missing. Tune in every other Wednesday to hear your host, Sequoia Simone, and some incredibly funny guests stretch, bend, and warp these stories of infatuation into chilling tales. A podcast for those who know there’s nothing more terrifying than love!

But Make It Scary Sequoia Thomas

    • Comedy
    • 4.8 • 99 Ratings

But Make It Scary is a dark comedy podcast that twists hit romantic films into the horror movies you didn’t know you were missing. Tune in every other Wednesday to hear your host, Sequoia Simone, and some incredibly funny guests stretch, bend, and warp these stories of infatuation into chilling tales. A podcast for those who know there’s nothing more terrifying than love!

    68. When Harry Met Sally (w/Elliot Davis)

    68. When Harry Met Sally (w/Elliot Davis)

    Go get your copy of Rom Com Drama Bomb RIGHT NOW!! TIME IS TICKING!!
    https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/moreblueberries/rom-com-drama-bomb
    Go check out Talk of the Table and My First Dungeon wherever pods are cast. But do the other thing first. As we clearly stated. 

    The show will be back on October 2nd! See ya then! 

    • 1 hr 15 min
    67. But Make it Lovely: Evil Dead 2 (w/Mike Dowd)

    67. But Make it Lovely: Evil Dead 2 (w/Mike Dowd)

    Go check out "The Other Side of Darkness"! 
     
    Find anything you might need at butmakeitscary.com
     
    One more episode before the long summer!

    • 1 hr 20 min
    66. Emma. (2020) (w/Pod and Prejudice)

    66. Emma. (2020) (w/Pod and Prejudice)

    Go check out Pod and Prejudice wherever pods are cast!

    The schedule for the end of season uhhh whatever this is:

    But Make it Lovely Feb 14
    When Harry Met Sally Feb 21

    Then I'll be back October 2nd!

    Find anything you might need at butmakeitscary.com

    • 1 hr 19 min
    65. Chocolat (w/Rae Reynolds)

    65. Chocolat (w/Rae Reynolds)

    Go check out It Was a Shit Show wherever pods are cast! 
    Okay so this is 1 week and almost one full day late, but really who even remembers I make this podcast? Certainly not me. 

    Visit patreon.com/butmaketi scary for a last chance at the bonus content before it's gone! 

    • 1 hr 23 min
    64. Ella Enchanted (w/Julianna Coughlin)

    64. Ella Enchanted (w/Julianna Coughlin)

    Go check out Into the Fold wherever pods are cast!

    Anything you might need at butmakeitscary.com

    • 1 hr 10 min
    63. Definitely, Maybe (w/Marcella Pereda)

    63. Definitely, Maybe (w/Marcella Pereda)

    Check out the back catalogue of Remedial Sex Ed!

    If you like this show, thank you so much for listening. Thank you especially to everyone who has been a patron, your support means everything! 

    • 1 hr 1 min

Customer Reviews

4.8 out of 5
99 Ratings

99 Ratings

rachelsusername ,

My beautiful, dark, twisted fantasy(?)

Oh, Sequoia, you absolute peach! The tee-up rom-coms provide for horror parallels is kind of too palpable. 'Sleepless in Seattle' and 'While You Were Sleeping' have always been deeply unsettling to me as is. *chef's kiss x infinity* yiiiiikes and LOL for real LOL <3

wizardgirl111111 ,

Love, love, love!!

I listen to sequoia’s other podcast, Fanatical Fics and where to find them, and love it so much. I need more of this lovely lady in my life, and I love her podcasts!

Logan.k1 ,

Best horror podcast

This is the best horror type podcast I have listened too highly recommend

Top Podcasts In Comedy

The Joe Rogan Experience
Joe Rogan
Call Her Daddy
Alex Cooper
SmartLess
Jason Bateman, Sean Hayes, Will Arnett
Conan O’Brien Needs A Friend
Team Coco & Earwolf
Wiser Than Me with Julia Louis-Dreyfus
Lemonada Media
The Lonely Island and Seth Meyers Podcast
The Lonely Island & Seth Meyers

You Might Also Like

The Villain Was Right
The From Superheroes Network
The Newest Olympian
Mike Schubert
Spirits
Multitude
I Hate It But I Love It
The From Superheroes Network
It Was A Sh*t Show
It Was A Sh*t Show
My Brother, My Brother And Me
The McElroys