Choose Your Fandom

Emily Christine Peterson

Each week on Choose Your Fandom, we dive headfirst into a different corner of the nerdy universe — from rom-coms to rebels, superheroes to sitcoms, Disney resorts to cryptids. Hosted by Emily Peterson, with a new guest every episode, this is your weekly passport to the multiverse of fandoms. Grab your emotional support water bottle (that's probably loaded with stickers) and get ready to nerd out with us.

Episodes

  1. 10/29/2025

    #11 - Ghost Stories with Jake & Madi

    Join Emily in a special Halloween episode of "Choose Your Fandom," where she invites friends Madi Scheuer and Jake Wallace to share spine-tingling ghost stories. From haunted hotels to eerie encounters, this episode promises to leave you both spooked and entertained. Grab your flashlight and a comfort item, and dive into the supernatural tales that will make you question the shadows around you. Happy Halloween!! 🎃👻 Guest Hosts: @madischeuer & @neverlanderjake Support the show Hosted, edited, and produced by: Emily Peterson Artwork by: Emily Peterson Theme Music by: Brandon Billings Instagram & TikTok: @chooseyourfandom Email: pod@chooseyourfandom.com

    2h 38m

  2. 10/22/2025

    #10 - The Twilight Zone with Elly

    In this episode of "Choose Your Fandom," Emily dives into the eerie and thought-provoking world of "The Twilight Zone" with guest Elly Arrendale. Together, they explore iconic episodes, discuss the show's timeless themes, and reflect on its impact on modern storytelling. From societal fears to the allure of old Hollywood, this conversation is a nostalgic journey through one of television's most influential series. Tune in for a blend of nostalgia, insight, and a touch of the supernatural. Guest Host: @ellya1 Support the show Hosted, edited, and produced by: Emily Peterson Artwork by: Emily Peterson Theme Music by: Brandon Billings Instagram & TikTok: @chooseyourfandom Email: pod@chooseyourfandom.com

    1h 20m

  3. 10/15/2025

    #9 - Mike Flanagan Shows (The Haunting of Hill House & More!) with Reilly

    In this episode of "Choose Your Fandom," Emily dives into the haunting world of Mike Flanagan's Netflix series. Joined by guest Reilly O'Connell, they explore the intricate storytelling and emotional depth of shows "The Haunting of Hill House," "The Haunting of Bly Manor," "Midnight Mass," "Midnight Club," and "The Fall of the House of Usher." From spine-chilling twists to heartfelt moments, discover how Flanagan masterfully blends horror with human connection. Whether you're a seasoned fan or new to his work, this episode offers insights and reflections on what makes these series unforgettable. Tune in for a journey through the eerie and the emotional, and find out which show tops their list! Guest: @reillylouise_ Spoiler Time Stamps: ~16:38 - The Haunting of Hill House ends at ~44:20 ~44:30 The Haunting of Bly Manor ends at ~55:38 ~55:38 Midnight Mass ends at ~1:11:30 ~1:11:38 Midnight Club ends at ~1:29:28 (only spoiler at 1:27:30-1:29:15) ~1:29:28 The Fall of the House of Usher ends at ~1:39:30  ~1:41:22 Talk of all 5 series ~Outro 2:18:54 Support the show Hosted, edited, and produced by: Emily Peterson Artwork by: Emily Peterson Theme Music by: Brandon Billings Instagram & TikTok: @chooseyourfandom Email: pod@chooseyourfandom.com

    2h 20m

  4. 10/10/2025

    #8 - Halloween Horror Nights with Davy

    In this episode of "Choose Your Fandom," Emily and Davy dive into their annual tradition of attending Halloween Horror Nights at Universal Orlando. They share their experiences, favorite houses, and tips for making the most of the event. This conversation is filled with personal anecdotes, house rankings, and a deep appreciation for the immersive storytelling and scares that make Halloween Horror Nights a beloved event for horror enthusiasts. Whether you're a seasoned attendee or a curious newcomer, this episode offers insights and excitement about the spooky season. Guest Host: @itsjustdavy (twitch) Support the show Hosted, edited, and produced by: Emily Peterson Artwork by: Emily Peterson Theme Music by: Brandon Billings Instagram & TikTok: @chooseyourfandom Email: pod@chooseyourfandom.com

    2h 11m

  5. 09/24/2025

    #7 - Emily Henry (and many other books) with Madi

    Join Emily and guest Madi Scheuer as they dive into the world of romance novels, focusing on the works of Emily Henry. From discussing their favorite books and characters to sharing personal anecdotes about their reading journeys, this episode is a delightful exploration of literature and friendship. Whether you're a seasoned book lover or new to Emily Henry's novels, this conversation is sure to inspire your next read. Tune in for a heartwarming chat filled with laughter, insights, and a shared love for books. 📖 Guest Host: @madischeuer Support the show Hosted, edited, and produced by: Emily Peterson Artwork by: Emily Peterson Theme Music by: Brandon Billings Instagram & TikTok: @chooseyourfandom Email: pod@chooseyourfandom.com

    1h 40m

  6. 09/17/2025

    #6 - Disney Resorts with Sami

    Join Emily and Disney resort expert Sami Betterly as they dive into the enchanting world of Disney Resorts. From nostalgic memories to insider tips, discover why these magical destinations captivate the hearts of Disney fans. Whether you're planning your first visit or a seasoned Disney traveler, this episode is packed with insights and fun stories that will inspire your next Disney adventure. Don't miss out on the magic! 🌟 @samantha.betterly Support the show Hosted, edited, and produced by: Emily Peterson Artwork by: Emily Peterson Theme Music by: Brandon Billings Instagram & TikTok: @chooseyourfandom Email: pod@chooseyourfandom.com

    1h 15m

  7. 09/03/2025

    #5 - Harry Potter with Barry

    In this week's episode of Choose Your Fandom, join Emily as she dives into the magical world of Harry Potter with special guest Barry Watson. In this episode, they explore the enduring legacy of the Wizarding World, share personal fan stories, and discuss the impact of Harry Potter on their lives. Whether you're a lifelong fan or new to the series, this episode is packed with nostalgia, insights, and a touch of whimsy. Tune in for a spellbinding conversation that celebrates the magic of fandom. Don't forget to subscribe and leave a five-star rating! Guest Host: @barryswatson @theretoldpodcast Support the show Hosted, edited, and produced by: Emily Peterson Artwork by: Emily Peterson Theme Music by: Brandon Billings Instagram & TikTok: @chooseyourfandom Email: pod@chooseyourfandom.com

    2h 31m

  8. 08/27/2025

    #4 - Twilight with Hayley

    In this nostalgic episode of "Choose Your Fandom," Emily dives into the glittery world of "Twilight" with guest Hayley Pellis. Together, they reminisce about their teenage obsessions, from Team Edward vs. Team Jacob debates to the iconic soundtracks that defined an era. Whether you're a die-hard TwiHard or just curious about the craze, join us for a fun-filled journey through the highs and lows of "Twilight" fandom. Get ready to laugh, cringe, and maybe even rediscover your love for those fictional monsters. Tune in and embrace your unapologetically nerdy self! Guest Host: @hayleyjopellis Support the show Hosted, edited, and produced by: Emily Peterson Artwork by: Emily Peterson Theme Music by: Brandon Billings Instagram & TikTok: @chooseyourfandom Email: pod@chooseyourfandom.com

    1h 50m

  9. 08/20/2025

    #3 - Bigfoot with Jake

    In this episode, Jake joins us to delve into the mysterious world of Bigfoot, exploring the fascinating theories and enduring myths that surround this legendary cryptid. From eyewitness accounts to scientific investigations, we uncover the stories that have captivated imaginations for generations. Whether you're a skeptic or a believer, this episode promises to intrigue and entertain. Tune in for a journey into the unknown! Guest Host: @neverlanderjake Support the show Hosted, edited, and produced by: Emily Peterson Artwork by: Emily Peterson Theme Music by: Brandon Billings Instagram & TikTok: @chooseyourfandom Email: pod@chooseyourfandom.com

    1h 23m

  10. 08/13/2025

    #2 - Musicals with Elizabeth

    In this episode of "Choose Your Fandom," Emily dives into the vibrant world of theater with Elizabeth Gentry, the social media manager for Theater Under the Stars in Houston. Discover how social media is revolutionizing theater promotion, connecting audiences, and creating a new wave of theater enthusiasts. Elizabeth shares her journey from theater kid to social media expert, offering insights into the power of digital platforms in bringing the magic of live performances to a broader audience. Tune in for a lively discussion filled with theater memories, industry insights, and the undeniable impact of social media on the arts. Guest Host: @elizabethcgentry Support the show Hosted, edited, and produced by: Emily Peterson Artwork by: Emily Peterson Theme Music by: Brandon Billings Instagram & TikTok: @chooseyourfandom Email: pod@chooseyourfandom.com

    2h 5m

  11. 08/06/2025

    #1 - MCU with Mark

    In this week’s episode of Choose Your Fandom, we assemble with guest host Mark Walton to dive deep into the Marvel Cinematic Universe — from Iron Man’s first suit-up to the new Avengerz (no, that's not a typo) and everything in between. We talk fandom origin stories, favorite characters, the most emotional MCU moments, and whether superhero fatigue is actually a thing (spoiler: maybe?). Plus, reliving some of the most iconic mid/post-credit scenes and who we think should join the MCU. Whether you’re a hardcore Marvel stan or a casual movie night attendee, this episode is packed with Avengers-level yapping and more Easter eggs than an end-credit scene. 🦸🏼‍♀️ Tune in, nerd out, and let’s assemble. Guest Host: @markmytrip Support the show Hosted, edited, and produced by: Emily Peterson Artwork by: Emily Peterson Theme Music by: Brandon Billings Instagram & TikTok: @chooseyourfandom Email: pod@chooseyourfandom.com

    1h 38m

  12. 07/31/2025

    #00 - The Origin Story

    Welcome to "Choose Your Fandom," where each week we dive into the vibrant world of fandoms with a new guest host. From movies and TV shows to book series and cultural moments, nothing is off-limits. Expect sleepover energy meets Comic-Con panel vibes as we share memories, rant about reboots, and celebrate the full spectrum of fandom obsession. Whether you're a casual watcher or a chaotic stan, there's a place for you here. Join us as we geek out over the things that make us happy and explore why fandoms are not just fun, but deeply human. Hit subscribe and be unapologetically nerdy with us!  New episode every Wednesday! Support the show Hosted, edited, and produced by: Emily Peterson Artwork by: Emily Peterson Theme Music by: Brandon Billings Instagram & TikTok: @chooseyourfandom Email: pod@chooseyourfandom.com

    4 min
  • 12 Episodes

Ratings & Reviews

5
out of 5
2 Ratings

About

Each week on Choose Your Fandom, we dive headfirst into a different corner of the nerdy universe — from rom-coms to rebels, superheroes to sitcoms, Disney resorts to cryptids. Hosted by Emily Peterson, with a new guest every episode, this is your weekly passport to the multiverse of fandoms. Grab your emotional support water bottle (that's probably loaded with stickers) and get ready to nerd out with us.

Information

  • Creator
    Emily Christine Peterson
  • Years Active
    2K
  • Episodes
    12
  • Rating
    Explicit
  • Copyright
    © 2026 Choose Your Fandom
  • Show Website
    Choose Your Fandom