Last night I fell asleep and I have no idea how I did it. There was a stretch where the day was still running its accounts in my head. And then I sent a text with an Australian joke. Then blackness! Well, not blackness but nothingness. Just absolute nothing. Then morning. Usually Milo would come over to my bedside and rub his face under my dangling hand. Then I’d remember where I am. Somewhere in the gap between the falling asleep and the waking up, the ‘one’ doing the worrying stops worrying. What’s crazy is ‘I’ didn’t authorize any of it. I couldn’t have. If you have laid wide awake in bed at 3am in the morning, you know precisely how much sleep obeys your ...free will. This is the closest thing I have to a working model of Grace. One can darken the bedroom, put the phone in the kitchen, take magnesium and all of the ashwaghanda gummies, keep the same bedtime for a month, all of that work and it not necessarily guaranty sleep. In fact, none of it is sleeping. Sleep arrives on its own three feet. Yet, sleep itself is not something one bestows on one’s self.I will argue that Seeing works the same way. For the sake of this conversation, Seeing is what I will call the seeing through suffering and the illusion of separation. The pit comes first You see, suffering isn’t noble and I won’t dress it up. If you’re like me, you’ve also spent most of your life dealing with one variant or the other of suffering. For me, the pit of suffering is where most of my Seeing has happened, and I think I understand why. When what I consider as ‘my life’ works according to plan, the mind has enough material to keep building. Everything is a hallelujah, every song is kumbaya, Grace is the sweetest nectar. Everything holds from the hand of Reality secure in the vice-like grip.But when the plans collapse! My gosh! The mind runs helter skelter, out of scaffolding. Sometimes in it, I catch sight of the ground it was standing on the whole time. Sometimes. My gosh! It is an existential mess- this being human! I’d love to tell you I live in absolute bliss. I don’t. A client goes quiet on an invoice or I remember the dates on a pending immigration case, or a conversation with someone I love goes badly and keeps replaying at 2 a.m. with better lines I didn’t say and a conditioned mind flutters like a butterfly that found milkweed. Three weeks of the same worry wearing the same groove, the clouds come in, thick and total, and the shutter closes, and there is no Seeing at all. Just gruesome terrible weather. But then, in all of this, I’ve come to think of the confusion as a privilege. Even that too is GRACE! On this contemplative path, something in us is stubborn enough to keep asking what all this gooey goo is! The difference between the me of then and now is that I no longer treat the closing as a failure of technique. It isn’t a sign I did the practice wrong either. It’s freaking Tuesday and the world seems to be falling apart— from one true viewpoint. What the books can’t do Friend, I have read all of the good books until the pages came loose(well, all the popular good books, the Spiras, John of the Cross, the Desert Fathers, Jean Klein etc).I have searched until my soles wore out. I have sat in meditation for hours daily. I can tell you with the weight of confident authority that I have, that none of these have any procedure for ending the Illusion of Separation or that moment of enlightenment where suffering ends forever. What all of the practice does is arrange the room neatly. The studying, the searching, the sitting for hours in meditation, all of it makes the individual more available just the way a darkened bedroom makes a person more available to sleep. But nothing will happen to wake you up to end suffering for good! Or something may happen. Doesn’t matter! It has always not been of anyone’s doing. It has always ONLY BEEN THE hand of Grace.And in those clear moments of insight, forgetting will still happen. Look at it! Who is it that forgets. If the Seeing belonged to anyone, won’t they just keep it? Wouldn’t I just keep it during the useful hours? Nobody sets an alarm to forget their own nature. The forgetting comes by itself as unauthored as the remembering of our true nature. See, what did you eat for dinner fourteen nights ago? Ah! You can’t remember? Notice the strain, the blank, the two or three candidate meals your mind offers as plausible. Now notice that if it comes at all, it comes later, at the sink, with the specific bowl and the specific person across the table. And if you even remembered, the remembering was not produced by the straining to remember. The straining was just the noise we made while waiting. I have spent years making that noise. I don’t regret it. The one practice I keep Whatever is in front of me, I turn attention back along the line to what it’s appearing to. And somehow there is some very strange joy in that. No, it’s not a joy. It’s a weirdness. No, it’s a gentle softening.Then I turn my attention to the computer screen, to the ache in my right shoulder and the sound of the fan. Milo shifting his weight against my right leg. Each of these is appearing somewhere, to something, and I look for the somewhere. It isn’t a search for an object. There’s no image to find and there’s no state to install. It’s more like noticing the one place attention never has to travel to reach. It takes a very skillful metaphoric tilt of the neck to find that sweet spot. I don’t see it all the time. It’s the center through which everything arises. It was there during the worst week of last month, unmoved and uninterested in my opinion of It. It doesn’t require good conditions. It doesn’t require me to be calm, or kind, or clear. It was there while I was arguing, while I stood in shame confessing my closest and darkest secrets. It still was there while I was asleep and not present for any of it. The whisper It, that It …is the ever-present standing through all of it. Call it God or the Universe, or Reality or whatever lingo honors the Unthinkable, Unknowable, Untouchable. That objectless object makes no promise that pain will stop, offers no timeline, and doesn’t seem interested in explaining itself. But it whispers, and it whispers to me the way it may for you: all may not be well, and you are in it, through it, out of it, for it, as it. There is no rescue from the mess. We are included so completely that there’s no seam where one ends and it begins. Grief happens inside it. Confusion happens inside it. The whole ugly stretch we’d erase if we could, is happening inside it and has never once been outside it. Back to the bed So, back to that bed. I fell asleep and cannot tell you how. Everyone falls asleep and thinks it’s their own doing, but when people are up at 3am staring, it’s their failure.But look at it again. Nobody authorizes the 3am either! The man lying awake, rehearsing better lines for a conversation that ended nine hours ago, did not sign up for that shift. It was handed to him. He could not put it down, and he could not have picked it up. Which means Grace has both hands in this thing. It opens the shutter. It also closes it. It hands out the clear morning, and it hands out the milkweed mind, and it does not beg for your opinion. That is the part I resisted all along. I wanted Grace to be the good weather. I wanted the Seeing to be the reward and the clouds to be our fault, because at least a fault can be corrected and a technique can be improved and I could stay in business as the one running the operation. But if the forgetting is not mine, and the remembering is not mine, and the falling asleep is not mine, then the pit is not mine either. Somebody put me down there. And the something in me stubborn enough to keep asking what all this gooey goo is, that too was issued, not earned. So Grace is not a thing that comes when the suffering ends. Grace is what the suffering is made of. It is the Seeing and it is the blindness. It is the voice of the client who goes quiet at the most critical moment of the project. It is the immigration date circled and the 2am replay. It is not around it, not underneath it, it is not waiting for the storm to pass so it can finally come out and be praised for its disappearing act(when all was good and rosy). It is in it, as it. And when I wake, Milo comes and rubs his face under my dangling hand, and I remember where I am. None of that was my doing either. This being alive, I did not create it. Did you? A contemplative prompt Will you join me in this exploration? Give this twenty minutes. Read a section, put the page down, and stay with it before moving on. Nothing here is meant to be figured out. Begin without repairs. Sit and let whatever is here be here. If you’re restless, be restless. If you’re grieving, grieve. IF you’re sitting with fear, sit with it. We are not wanting to be a better version. In fact, we will make this the new home. Take one thing that hurts. Bring up something currently painful. Let it be as sharp as it actually is. Now look for the one it’s happening to. For a bit, let’s temporarily pause the story about them. Look for the one who is going through it right now. What do you find when you look directly? Take one thing that delights you. Something small and recent. Sunlight on the wall, the thought of the laugh of your favorite person, the first sip of good wine. Ask the same question. Where is the one this is happening to? Notice whether the answer is in a different location than it was a moment ago. Find what is already fine. Without improving anything, locate one thing that is unproblematic at this moment. The weight of your hands. The breath doing itself. Notice contentment isn’t manufactured here. See whether it was already running underneath, unattended. Turn around. Whatever is arising, look back along the line to what it’s arising in. D