12 episodes

Two Midwestern lovebirds sit down every week to tell each other strange tales about murder, humanity, and anything else!

Cool & Unusual Punishment Tyler Haas and Jodie Arnold

    • Comedy Interviews

Two Midwestern lovebirds sit down every week to tell each other strange tales about murder, humanity, and anything else!

    12 - I Am Exceedingly Cold

    12 - I Am Exceedingly Cold

    This week of cool and unusual discussion is draped in a purple velvet cape! Tyler has the long, depressing journey of 36 vintage Corvettes and a hot tip to score one of them for yourself, then Jodie brings the story of Frozen Charlotte, and why you should always investigate a half-buried ivory face in the dirt. This week's episode brought to you by cheap whiskey and the promise of a Hot Bobby.

    Cool & Unusual Punishment is also a member of the Nerd & Tie Network! Find their website in our show notes.

    • 1 hr
    11 - Starlight VHS Rental

    11 - Starlight VHS Rental

    This week on the podcast, Jodie has a missing person's case with a million leads and a real lack of follow-up. Then, Tyler talks about the "custom of the sea" and whether or not Edgar Allan Poe is a prophetic genius. This week's episode brought to you by blueberry vodka that goes down frighteningly smooth.

    • 1 hr
    10 - Boogie Woogie Door-Flingers

    10 - Boogie Woogie Door-Flingers

    It's a new year and C&UP has found new ways to get weird. First, Tyler tells a beautiful, decades-long love story involving swords and gentlemanly custom. Then, Jodie has got a Wisconsin murder for the ages that has all the ingredients of a good caper: dismemberment, love triangles, and rubber stamps.

    This week's episode brought to you by a growler of Warped Speed! Cool & Unusual Punishment is also a member of the Nerd & Tie Network. Find their link in the show notes!

    • 1 hr 1 min
    9 - Nobody Can Catch Butterboy

    9 - Nobody Can Catch Butterboy

    Cool & Unusual comes to you this week with blistering festive energy fueled by cheap beer! Tyler brings the story of Dr. Brinkley, the man who almost took over the world with goat testicles. Then, we look to the skies for ominous signs of danger as Jodie brings firsthand accounts of the mythical, benevolent beast that is Mothman. This week's episode is brought to you by Hamm's: when you can't afford a ham, drink Hamm's.

    C&UP is also a member of the Nerd & Tie Network! Find the link in the show notes.

    • 1 hr 13 min
    8 - Miss Frizzle Goes to the Dentist

    8 - Miss Frizzle Goes to the Dentist

    This week on the podcast, Jodie brings a not-so-cold-case that was in our right in our backyard, and it is up to us to decide which Munster may have done it. Then, Tyler drags everybody down the terrible, traumatic rabbit hole of Youtube kids and ends up drunk, confused and scared.

    This week's episode is brought to you by the Elk Lake Tavern, where you used to be able to smoke. Cool and Unusual Punishment is also on the Nerd & Tie Network now! Find the link to other nerdy stuff in the show notes.

    • 1 hr 8 min
    7 - Accumulation of Stimulation

    7 - Accumulation of Stimulation

    This week on the punishment, Tyler has brought along extensive training resources on becoming a certified exorcist. What does the course load look like and what are the chances we end up paying for it ironically? Also, Jodie has a grisly campground story where everybody involved gets everything wrong at absolutely every step of the way.

    This week's episode is brought to you by Milkshake Malt Porter and Emily Post's thoughts on American's abroad!

    • 1 hr 9 min

Customer Reviews

Trae Dorn ,

This show is amazing

My wife and I started to listen to it over our holiday travels, and this show is great. Can't wait for the next episode.

Believeinthejimmy ,

My favorite podcast

If you love murder or any odd stories, this podcast is for you😉

Top Podcasts In Comedy Interviews