after getting caught up on another geekly inc podcast i decided to give this one a go and i’m HOOKED! booking my next ferry ride to that creepy island rn

Love Cthulhu but have no tolerance for virtue signaling.

I know there was some bad drama surrounding a certain you know who, but was burning your entire fanbase in order to erase that person from your life the best way of going about it? You created new canon yes, but you based roughly 90% of the new NPC’s, background lore, etc on the first, now missing, three seasons. I was a long time fan, and I tried, I honestly tried but I can’t continue. It’s like taking my DnD group and nuking everything they did and achieved because there was a “That Guy” at the table for the first year of a campaign.

This podcast is so amazing! Incredible storytelling, suspense, mystery, horror, drama, comedy - it has it all! The game master weaves such incredible tales, and the cast is so talented and has such amazing chemistry! Give it a listen - you won’t regret it!

Listen to find out moooooore!!!

Goodbye Cthulhu and Friends and to the first arc. Don’t even bother listening to the message about it just forget it ever existed. If you are a fresh set of ears just start at the first session and go from there because realistically these people’s content is really good, and despite there amazing start they all apparently hate it shouldn’t be ignored. I hope to come back to this when I’ve forgotten what it was.

I used to listen to this podcast exclusively for their wonderful dramatic readings of Lovecraft stories but when they rebooted, they pulled the episodes. Now I don’t listen at all. CaF, why were the readings pulled? And will you bring them back?

Character work, editing, acting, world building—this podcast excels at it all. This is funny, emotionally compelling pulp fiction storytelling in a tabletop game. I have listened to a lot of RPG and actual play podcasts and this is *The MOST Underrated RPG Podcast*. It honestly drives me crazy that they’re not raking in attention for this genuinely great work, but I feel lucky I came across it. Invest your time in listening, it’s worth it.

It’s just another day. You check your phone, computer, or perhaps some other listening device. You might have just finished some other good GeeklyInc shows. But your intuition has led you to this show, to this review. Listen to your intuition. Welcome to St. Paxton is hands down the best horror supernatural roleplaying game podcast you can find. Join Staci, Fred, Mike, Steph, and Veronica as they navigate the scenic St. Paxton. United in their search for an old friend, Clara, Bellamy, Todd, and Edward must navigate political responsibility, crows, and good books that you can really get lost in. Special mention to Rob, who did a wonderful job for the music in this very special podcast. I’ll say no more and leave it to you now. Trust your instincts. Book your ticket and get ready to roll for your sanity.

This is an update to my review. I can’t say how much I live this podcast. You are all amazing storytellers and I am loving Welcome to St Paxton! I live the direction that Veronica is taking this! Keep the can’t miss podcast coming!