Extinguished David McClam & LaDonna Humphrey

LaDonna Humphrey and David McClam,  discuss the troubling murder case of Deanna Stevison, who was fatally shot entering an apartment, a case that has raised significant questions about Florida’s stand your ground law. The law, which was not challenged in Deanna’s case due to its provisions, has been criticized for not improving public safety and potentially exacerbating racial disparities. The circumstances surrounding Deanna’s death—her estrangement from her fiancée and the involvement of a former police officer—underscore concerns about the potential misuse of such laws. Despite Deanna expressing fears for her safety, the motives behind her shooting, and the details of her visiting someone’s house to pick up a letter, suggest investigators may have overlooked key elements.

The broader misuse of stand your ground laws across the United States is highlighted, showing how they can lead to deadly outcomes in various scenarios, including disputes and custody battles. These laws have sometimes enabled aggressors and law enforcement officers to justify deadly force improperly. Furthermore, individuals such as women in abusive relationships and people of color often find it challenging to effectively use these laws in their defense. The case of Marissa Alexander is particularly noted, where her claim under the law was initially rejected despite facing violence, leading to a conviction later overturned on appeal.

The podcast also critiques the investigation efforts by the Escambia County sheriff’s office and calls for a reconsideration of stand your ground laws in Florida and elsewhere. They argue these laws might protect individuals who claim self-defense in situations where harm could have been avoided. With a focus on statistics from Florida and examples from Arizona and Tallahassee, the conversation underscores instances where claims of self-defense were questionable. The speakers express frustration over the lack of thorough investigation and proper application of the law in cases like Deanna’s, advocating for a reevaluation of such cases and a rewriting of the laws to prevent further injustices and ensure justice is served. The text concludes with an encouragement for listeners to engage with the content and stay updated on developments, hinting at future discussions on the topic.

Time Line

00:00 Introduction to Extinguished
David McClam and LaDonna Humphrey introduce the podcast Extinguished, focusing on sharing stories of the missing and murdered.

00:20 Deanna Stevison Murder Case Recap
A brief recap of the Deanna Stevison murder case, highlighting the tragic events leading to her death and the decision not to file charges under Florida stand your ground law.

01:28 Critique of Stand Your Ground Laws
Discussion on the ineffectiveness and harmful impact of stand your ground laws, with insights from a study and expert opinions.

02:15 Deanna’s Relationship Dynamics
Exploration of the complex relationships involving Deanna, Megan, and Amy, shedding light on the motives and tensions leading up to the tragic event.

03:41 Deanna’s Visit to Amy Plunkett’s Apartment
Analysis of the circumstances surrounding Deanna’s visit to Amy Plunkett’s apartment, raising questions about the intentions and actions of those involved.

04:57 Misapplication of Stand Your Ground Laws
Examination of various cases where stand your ground laws were misapplied, highlighting the disparities and injustices perpetuated by these laws.

07:17 Questioning the Fear Factor
Discussion on the lack of justification for fear in Deanna’s case, emphasizing the questionable actions and decisions made by those involved.

09:08 Lack of Investigation by Law Enforcement
Critique of the Escambia County...

Uncovering the complex layers of Deanna Stevison's case, LaDonna Humphrey and I, David McClam, return to the heart of a legal enigma—Florida's Stand Your Ground law. As we dissect the decision that left Deanna's death uncharged, we expose the critical nuances of her high blood alcohol content and its potential role in the fatal night's events. Deanna's BAC, well above the legal threshold, prompts us to challenge the accepted narrative and explore the broader consequences of driving under the influence. This episode unfolds a sobering discussion on the intricate dance between autonomy, accountability, and the law.

In our continued pursuit of truth, the episode shifts focus to the reopened door to Deanna, a pivotal moment enveloped in ambiguity. Listen closely as we trace the contours of Deanna, Amy, and Megan's tangled relationship through texts and emails, contemplating the possibility of provocation. The bullet's trajectory speaks volumes, questioning the self-defense claim and the application of the Stand Your Ground law. With forensic evidence in hand, we probe the implications of a door ajar and a car left running, piecing together a narrative that may just tip the scales of justice. Join us as we commit to shedding light on the darkness surrounding Deanna's story, with the hope of propelling her case back into the eyes of the law.

Time Line
(00:01) Alcohol Levels and Stand Your Ground
(10:51) Controversy Surrounding Stand Your Ground Law
(24:31) Stand Your Ground Defense Challenges


Get your tickets to True Crime Fest Arkansas HERE

Be sure to tune into Stand Our Ground with Kiah Penfield HERE

Get your tickets for True CrimeFest HERE

Get your tickets for Crime Con UK and use Code Extinguished for 10% off HERE

Check out our other podcast

Deep Dark Secrets With LaDonna Humphrey and Amy Smith

True Crime, Authors and Extraodinary People with David McClam


DON'T FORGET TO RATE, COMMENT AND SUBSCRIBE

JOIN US ON FACEBOOK

SIGN THE DEEP DARK SECRETS PETITION HERE

Sound Mixing and editing by David McClam

Intro and outro byJacqueline G. (JacquieVoice) From Fiverr.

Easter gatherings with family have a special way of putting things into perspective. As LaDonna and I exchange stories with our loved ones, we're reminded of the powerful narratives that each of us carries. This week, our podcast takes a momentary rest to honor these personal tales and the Easter holiday, but we're poised to renew our deep-dive into the intriguing and complex case of Deanna Stevison when we return. The saga's twists and unexpected turns demand our full attention, and we're committed to bringing you along for this important journey.

During this brief hiatus, it's the perfect opportunity for both newcomers and seasoned listeners to acquaint themselves with the details that make Deanna's story so compelling. Your unwavering engagement and thoughtful insights are the heartbeat of Extinguished, propelling us forward in our quest for justice. So, as we savor this time of reflection and celebration, we invite you to reflect on the episodes that have moved and challenged you. Come next week, we'll be ready to greet you with fresh resolve and the next chapter in our relentless pursuit of the truth.

Be sure to tune into Stand Our Ground with Kiah Penfield HERE

Get your tickets for True CrimeFest HERE

Check out our other podcast

Deep Dark Secrets With LaDonna Humphrey and Amy Smith

True Crime, Authors and Extraodinary People with David McClam


DON'T FORGET TO RATE, COMMENT AND SUBSCRIBE

JOIN US ON FACEBOOK

SIGN THE DEEP DARK SECRETS PETITION HERE

Sound Mixing and editing by David McClam

Intro and outro byJacqueline G. (JacquieVoice) From Fiverr.

Embark on a journey through the twists and turns of the Deanna Stevison case with LaDonna and I as we confront the wave of misinformation head-on. Prepare to witness our unwavering commitment to truth as we dissect the unsettling allegations thrown at us, and our podcast, by a mysterious email correspondent. We stand firm against intimidation and uphold the facts, offering clarity to you, our dedicated listeners, while emphasizing our dedication to the integrity of our investigative work.

This episode takes a deep look into the complexities surrounding Florida's 'stand your ground' law and its implications on the tragic shooting of Deanna. Through a careful examination of the evidence and the law's nuances, we aim to illuminate the shadowy lines between self-defense and unwarranted violence. The discovery of the weapon near the sink raises haunting questions, and we're here to ask them, ensuring that no stone is left unturned in our pursuit of the unvarnished truth.

Lastly, we address the controversy sparked by the enigmatic Marty and his/her relentless emails. Our investigation into his/her identity is more than mere curiosity; it's a quest to understand his/her connection to the case and the impact of his/her actions on Deanna's grieving family. With empathy at the forefront, we strive to honor Deanna's memory, seek answers for her loved ones, and navigate the legal and ethical responsibilities that accompany our role as storytellers in the true crime community.

Time Line
(00:01) Addressing Misinformation in Extinguished Podcast
(13:04) Stand Your Ground Law Discussion
(23:31) Deanna's Shooting
(35:05) Addressing Controversy Surrounding Marty's Emails
(44:41) True Crime Podcast Promotion and Reminder


Be sure to tune into Stand Our Ground with Kiah Penfield HERE

Get your tickets for True CrimeFest HERE

Check out our other podcast

Deep Dark Secrets With LaDonna Humphrey and Amy Smith

True Crime, Authors and Extraodinary People with David McClam


DON'T FORGET TO RATE, COMMENT AND SUBSCRIBE

JOIN US ON FACEBOOK

SIGN THE DEEP DARK SECRETS PETITION HERE

Sound Mixing and editing by David McClam

Intro and outro byJacqueline G. (JacquieVoice) From Fiverr.

Uncover the chilling truth behind Deanna Stevison's untimely demise as we scrutinize the perplexing decision to not press charges. The echoes of gunshots and a life lost too soon reverberate through our latest episode, challenging the self-defense claim under the controversial Stand Your Ground Law. We wrestle with the official narrative and the heartache of Deanna's family, who remember her as anything but confrontational. Join us on a journey through a labyrinth of legal nuances and gut-wrenching 911 calls that leave more questions than answers.

Feel the weight of the silence that followed the harrowing events of June 8, 2017, through the lens of critical 911 recordings we've analyzed. The eerie calm of a car left running, its driver never to return, paints a haunting picture of what was supposed to be a brief apartment visit. We scrutinize the inconsistencies between Ollie Plunkett's statements and the visceral reality that the emergency calls captured, shedding light on the enigma of Deanna's alleged aggression and the calculated decision to answer a door with a gun at the ready.

As the investigation unfolds, we dissect the puzzling movement of Deanna's body and the chaotic decision-making in those critical moments. Stitching together the fabric of Deanna's character with her intentions on that fateful day, we invite you to engage with us in a quest for clarity. Every layer of this mystery unraveled brings us closer to understanding the dire implications of Stand Your Ground Laws when lives hang in the balance. Stay tuned as we question everything and seek to keep the flame of justice burning for Deanna Stevison.

Time Line
(00:01) Investigating the Deanna Stevenson Case
(04:21) Discussion on Apartment Shooting Incident
(11:14) 911 Calls and Crime Scene Analysis
(22:12) Deep Dark Secrets Podcast Promotions


Be sure to tune into Stand Our Ground with Kiah Penfield HERE

Get your tickets for True CrimeFest HERE

Get your tickets for Crime Con UK and use Code Extinguished for 10% off HERE

Check out our other podcast

Deep Dark Secrets With LaDonna Humphrey and Amy Smith

True Crime, Authors and Extraodinary People with David McClam


DON'T FORGET TO RATE, COMMENT AND SUBSCRIBE

JOIN US ON FACEBOOK

SIGN THE DEEP DARK SECRETS PETITION HERE

Sound Mixing and editing by David McClam

Intro and outro byJacqueline G. (JacquieVoice) From Fiverr.

The quest for truth can often take us down the darkest of alleys, where the faintest glimmers of light beckon the brave. Today, we are joined by Kiah Penfield, whose tireless advocacy through her podcast Stand Our Ground brings us face to face with such a journey: the unsolved homicide of her cousin Deanna Stevison. As we explore Deanna's life, from her days as a corrections officer and devoted mother, to the chilling events leading up to her tragic death, we're reminded that every story is a tapestry of complexities, woven with threads of joy, pain, and sometimes, injustice.

The heart of our conversation lies in dissecting the turbulent relationship between Deanna and her partner Megan—a narrative marred by manipulation and control. We witness how the scales tipped with financial shifts and how Megan's interactions with Deanna's son sent alarm bells ringing. Kiah's poignant accounts cast a new lens on the case, urging us to consider the unseen battles fought behind closed doors. As we sift through the layers of this case, we cannot ignore the unsettling efforts to discredit our discussions, pointing to a larger web of manipulation extending beyond a single relationship.

Finally, we step into the shadows of a police investigation that appears to be riddled with more questions than answers. From missing files to interrogation discrepancies, the integrity of the Escambia Police Department's handling of Deanna's case is called into question. We grapple with the painful possibility of a cover-up and the painful implications it may have on the quest for justice. Kaya's determination to reopen and reinvestigate the case, coupled with our examination, serves as a clarion call for accountability and truth. The path to justice for Deanna may be fraught with obstacles, but it's a path we walk together, propelled by the hope that the truth will emerge from the shadows to honor her memory.

Time Line
(00:01) Unsolved Case of Deanna Stevenson
(05:34) Relationship Manipulation and Escalation
(17:36) Deanna's Shooting
(25:22) Mystery Surrounding Shooting Incident
(30:06) Confusion and Manipulation in Police Interview
(34:40) Uncovering Alleged Police Corruption in Escambia
(39:52) Investigative File Discrepancies and Concerns
(45:26) Potential Cover-Up in Murder Investigation
(54:08) Justice for Mishandled True Crime Case
(01:02:06) Seeking Justice for Deanna


Be sure to tune into Stand Our Grounf with Kiah Penfield HERE

Get your tickets for True CrimeFest HERE

Get your tickets for Crime Con UK and use Code Extinguished for 10% off HERE

Check out our other podcast

Deep Dark Secrets With LaDonna Humphrey and Amy Smith

True Crime, Authors and Extraodinary People with David McClam


DON'T FORGET TO RATE, COMMENT AND SUBSCRIBE

JOIN US ON FACEBOOK

SIGN THE DEEP DARK SECRETS PETITION a...