Eye for an Eye

Eye for an Eye

A look into the interdiction and sentencing of some of history's most infamous killers and criminals. Delve into the cases that have haunted headlines for decades and those left in the shadows of the justice system. Listen closely as you may find a new perspective on justice that, at times, you may be surprised you agree with. Join your hosts Lisa, Matt, and Jules while they answer the age old question, "Does the punishment fit the crime?"

  1. 1d ago

    Murdaugh's Second Chance: Did Power Corrupt Justice?- Murdaugh Update

    Join Lisa, Matt, Jules, and Noa as they dive into the latest shocking twist in one of the most infamous true crime cases in recent history—the granting of a new trial for convicted killer Alex Murdaugh. Once found guilty of murdering his wife, Maggie, and son, Paul, in a case that captivated the nation, Murdaugh is now seeking another chance in court. But this isn't just a story about murder. It's a story about power, privilege, political influence, and a legal dynasty that controlled a corner of South Carolina for generations. In this episode, we examine the allegations that helped secure Murdaugh's retrial, including claims that former court clerk Becky Hill improperly influenced jurors while allegedly pursuing a tell-all book and media opportunities connected to the case. We explore how these accusations have reignited debate about whether justice was truly served—or whether the system itself became compromised. The conversation goes beyond the courtroom as we unpack the extraordinary influence wielded by the Murdaugh family for decades and ask a difficult question: Would an average defendant ever receive the same opportunities and legal advantages? We also discuss how true crime documentaries, podcasts, social media, and internet sleuths have transformed modern criminal investigations and high-profile trials. Has public scrutiny improved accountability, or has it complicated the pursuit of justice? This episode explores the intersection of wealth, corruption, media influence, and the American justice system in a case that continues to raise more questions than answers. If you're fascinated by true crime podcasts, courtroom drama, criminal investigations, legal scandals, and the Murdaugh family saga, this is an episode you won't want to miss. *Please note all opinions in the show are our own and solely in regards to the specific case we are discussing in this episode* We made a one stop shop for all the Eye for an Eye links our listeners might want to check out whether its where to listen, our merch shop, all of our socials, our email, or ways to support the show,  we’d love for you to visit the link below!  https://msha.ke/eyeforeyepod/ Tired of Ads? Want to support our show? Please consider supporting Eye for an Eye with as little as $1 a month via patreon.com/eyeforeyepod Enjoy today's show? Don't forget to rate (those 5 stars are waiting to be clicked), review, subscribe and tell your friends!  Want in on the discussion?Join us on our Facebook page or group, Instagram @eyeforeyepod, twitter @eyeforeyepod or shoot us an email at eyeforeyepod@gmail.com and let us know your thoughts- does the punishment fit the crime? __ Cover Art Created by: Rachel Gregorino, dollbambino@gmail.com Music: GarageBand Mix made by Lisa  Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

    41 min

  2. May 25

    From Rural Roots to the Ruling the Bench: Justice, Integrity, and the Making of a Judge- Judge Michael Randazzo

    Join Lisa, Matt, and Noa as we sit down with Judge Michael Randazzo for an inspiring and thought-provoking true crime podcast episode that goes beyond the courtroom and into the life experiences that shape those who uphold the law. In this episode, Judge Randazzo shares his powerful journey from a challenging upbringing in rural Missouri to serving as a circuit judge. He opens up about early life struggles, the path that led him into the legal field, and how his family history—including his grandfather’s criminal background—helped shape his perspective on justice, accountability, and second chances. We explore the human side of the criminal justice system, diving into themes of empathy, moral integrity, and what it truly means to serve fairly from the bench. Judge Randazzo offers insight into how he approaches difficult cases, balances impartiality with compassion, and navigates the weight of decisions that directly impact people’s lives. If you’re interested in true crime podcasts, legal system insights, real-life courtroom perspectives, and meaningful conversations about justice and character, this episode offers a rare and honest look inside the mind of a judge. To get your hands on Judge Randazzo's book click here: https://amzn.to/4sX51d7 *Please note all opinions in the show are our own and solely in regards to the specific case we are discussing in this episode* We made a one stop shop for all the Eye for an Eye links our listeners might want to check out whether its where to listen, our merch shop, all of our socials, our email, or ways to support the show,  we’d love for you to visit the link below!  https://msha.ke/eyeforeyepod/ Tired of Ads? Want to support our show? Please consider supporting Eye for an Eye with as little as $1 a month via patreon.com/eyeforeyepod Enjoy today's show? Don't forget to rate (those 5 stars are waiting to be clicked), review, subscribe and tell your friends!  Want in on the discussion?Join us on our Facebook page or group, Instagram @eyeforeyepod, twitter @eyeforeyepod or shoot us an email at eyeforeyepod@gmail.com and let us know your thoughts- does the punishment fit the crime? __ Cover Art Created by: Rachel Gregorino, dollbambino@gmail.com Music: GarageBand Mix made by Lisa  __ Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

    56 min

  3. May 18

    Dick Flinging Dasher- The Door Dash TikTok Allegations

    Join Lisa, Matt, Jules and Noa as we unpack the powerful influence of social media algorithms and how they shape the way we see the world. In this episode, we explore how platforms like TikTok can create completely different realities for users, fueling echo chambers and reinforcing personal beliefs. We discuss why engaging with multiple perspectives is more important than ever in a world where your feed is curated to keep you comfortable—and sometimes misinformed. We also dive into a series of controversial cases involving nudity and privacy, breaking down the complex issues of consent, legality, and public reaction. From internet outrage to legal gray areas, we examine how quickly narratives can form—and spiral—online. A major focus of this episode is the viral DoorDash case that took over TikTok, involving serious allegations of sexual assault. We analyze how the story spread, the role social media played in shaping public perception, and the broader implications of trying highly sensitive situations in the court of public opinion. The conversation wraps with reflections on cultural attitudes toward nudity, personal boundaries, and the often-overlooked challenges faced by delivery drivers navigating unpredictable and sometimes unsafe situations. If you’re into true crime podcasts, viral case breakdowns, social media psychology, and discussions that challenge your perspective, this episode will definitely get you thinking. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

    58 min

  4. May 11

    Savage vs. Civilized: A Psychologist’s Fall from Power to Prison...and Back- Paul Smith Interview

    Join Lisa & Matt as we sit down with Paul, a former clinical psychologist whose life took a shocking turn from running a thriving private practice to serving time in federal prison for healthcare fraud. Get your copy of Paul's book 'Cruel and Unusual Punishment: A Memoir of the Psychological Realities of Federal Prison' here: https://amzn.to/3QHVs4c Paul shares how he built a successful psychology practice between 2007 and 2011 before everything unraveled, leading to his conviction and incarceration. Drawing from his powerful book, he explores the concept of “savage vs. civilized,” revealing how quickly societal norms can break down when survival instincts take over. We dive deep into his firsthand experiences navigating the federal prison system—from solitary confinement and unexpected transfers to the harsh realities inmates faced during COVID-19. Paul opens up about the unspoken rules of prison life, including how dominance and intimidation shape daily interactions and determine survival. In one striking story, Paul recounts a childhood moment on a farm where he learned the hard way asserting dominance can mean the difference between vulnerability and control. He shares how, despite initially trying to avoid conflict, he was forced to adapt quickly in situations that challenged his place within the prison hierarchy. This episode also explores bigger-picture conversations around criminal justice reform, questioning whether the system prioritizes punishment over rehabilitation. We discuss the urgent need for meaningful work, education, and reentry programs that can help break cycles of crime and give individuals a real second chance. If you’re into true crime podcasts, white-collar crime stories, prison survival insights, and deep psychological perspectives, this episode offers a rare, inside look you won’t hear anywhere else. *Please note all opinions in the show are our own and solely in regards to the specific case we are discussing in this episode* We made a one stop shop for all the Eye for an Eye links our listeners might want to check out whether its where to listen, our merch shop, all of our socials, our email, or ways to support the show,  we’d love for you to visit the link below!  https://msha.ke/eyeforeyepod/ Tired of Ads? Want to support our show? Please consider supporting Eye for an Eye with as little as $1 a month via patreon.com/eyeforeyepod Enjoy today's show? Don't forget to rate (those 5 stars are waiting to be clicked), review, subscribe and tell your friends!  Want in on the discussion?Join us on our Facebook page or group, Instagram @eyeforeyepod, twitter @eyeforeyepod or shoot us an email at eyeforeyepod@gmail.com and let us know your thoughts- does the punishment fit the crime? __ Cover Art Created by: Rachel Gregorino, dollbambino@gmail.com Music: GarageBand Mix made by Lisa  Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

    1h 10m

  5. May 4

    Power, Privilege, and Murder: Inside the Murdaugh Family Scandal- Alec Murdaugh

    Join Lisa, Matt, Jules and our newest cohost Noa as we delve into the deception and deaths surrounding the Murdaugh family in this gripping true crime podcast episode. From the shocking boat crash that first drew national attention to a string of suspicious deaths, alleged financial crimes, and decades of power-fueled cover-ups. In this episode, we break down the complex web of legal battles and criminal accusations tied to one of the most influential families in the South. We explore the challenges investigators face when dealing with wealthy, well-connected individuals, and how systemic corruption within the justice system can blur the lines between truth and protection. We also discuss the intense difficulty of selecting an impartial jury in such a widely publicized case, where media coverage and public opinion run deep. As we unpack the recent conviction of Alec Murdaugh, we reflect on what this case means for accountability among the powerful and whether justice can truly be served when influence runs so deep. We also dive into the broader implications for reopening and investigating historical family crimes that may have long been buried. If you’re obsessed with true crime, unsolved mysteries, courtroom drama, and deep dives into real-life criminal cases, this episode is one you won’t want to miss. *Please note all opinions in the show are our own and solely in regards to the specific case we are discussing in this episode* We made a one stop shop for all the Eye for an Eye links our listeners might want to check out whether its where to listen, our merch shop, all of our socials, our email, or ways to support the show,  we’d love for you to visit the link below!  https://msha.ke/eyeforeyepod/ Tired of Ads? Want to support our show? Please consider supporting Eye for an Eye with as little as $1 a month via patreon.com/eyeforeyepod Enjoy today's show? Don't forget to rate (those 5 stars are waiting to be clicked), review, subscribe and tell your friends!  Want in on the discussion?Join us on our Facebook page or group, Instagram @eyeforeyepod, twitter @eyeforeyepod or shoot us an email at eyeforeyepod@gmail.com and let us know your thoughts- does the punishment fit the crime? __ Cover Art Created by: Rachel Gregorino, dollbambino@gmail.com Music: GarageBand Mix made by Lisa  Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

    1h 7m

  6. Apr 27

    Vanished at Sea: The Amy Bradley Mystery- Amy Bradley

    Join Lisa, Matt and Jules as we cover the most chilling and perplexing unsolved disappearances at sea—the case of 23-year-old Amy Bradley. In 1998, Amy vanished without a trace from a Royal Caribbean cruise ship, leaving behind more questions than answers. In this episode, we break down the timeline of events and explore the leading theories: Did Amy accidentally fall overboard? Did she leave the ship voluntarily? Or could something far more sinister have happened—like being smuggled off the ship? We also dive into the investigative challenges surrounding the case, including the lack of passenger tracking systems at the time and the overwhelming complexity of searching a massive cruise ship filled with thousands of people. This case continues to haunt investigators and Amy’s loved ones decades later—and we want to know what you think happened. 🎧 Don’t forget to like, rate, review, and subscribe to Eye for an Eye so you never miss an episode. And be sure to share your thoughts and theories with us—where is Amy? *Please note all opinions in the show are our own and solely in regards to the specific case we are discussing in this episode* We made a one stop shop for all the Eye for an Eye links our listeners might want to check out whether its where to listen, our merch shop, all of our socials, our email, or ways to support the show,  we’d love for you to visit the link below!  https://msha.ke/eyeforeyepod/ Tired of Ads? Want to support our show? Please consider supporting Eye for an Eye with as little as $1 a month via patreon.com/eyeforeyepod Enjoy today's show? Don't forget to rate (those 5 stars are waiting to be clicked), review, subscribe and tell your friends!  Want in on the discussion?Join us on our Facebook page or group, Instagram @eyeforeyepod, twitter @eyeforeyepod or shoot us an email at eyeforeyepod@gmail.com and let us know your thoughts- does the punishment fit the crime? __ Cover Art Created by: Rachel Gregorino, dollbambino@gmail.com Music: GarageBand Mix made by Lisa  Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

    50 min

  7. Apr 20

    Behind the Screen: The Twisted Truth of “The Unknown Number”- Lauryn Licari

    Join Lisa, Matt, and Jules as we dive deep into the disturbing case featured in the Netflix documentary The Unknown Number—a chilling true crime story centered around cyberbullying, deception, and a shocking betrayal. A teen girl and her boyfriend face relentless harassment from an unknown caller, with months of psychological torment pushing them to their limits. As police begin to investigate, what starts as a mysterious case of cyberstalking quickly unravels into something far more disturbing—leading to a revelation that completely upends everything they thought they knew. In this episode, we unpack the haunting case of Lauryn Licari , a 13-year-old girl targeted in a calculated online harassment campaign. We break down the investigation, analyze the digital evidence, and explore the shocking possibility that the person behind it all was hiding in plain sight. Our discussion also takes a critical look at the documentary itself—questioning its authenticity, what may have been left out, and how the story was framed. We dive into the psychological complexity of the perpetrators alleged role, exploring potential motives, manipulation, and the long-lasting emotional impact on the victims. Beyond the case, we reflect on the real-world dangers of cyberbullying and the importance of community awareness, accountability, and intervention in protecting vulnerable individuals. If you’re into true crime podcasts, real-life mysteries, documentary deep dives, and cases that make your skin crawl, this is one episode you won’t want to miss. *Please note all opinions in the show are our own and solely in regards to the specific case we are discussing in this episode* We made a one stop shop for all the Eye for an Eye links our listeners might want to check out whether its where to listen, our merch shop, all of our socials, our email, or ways to support the show,  we’d love for you to visit the link below!  https://msha.ke/eyeforeyepod/ Tired of Ads? Want to support our show? Please consider supporting Eye for an Eye with as little as $1 a month via patreon.com/eyeforeyepod Enjoy today's show? Don't forget to rate (those 5 stars are waiting to be clicked), review, subscribe and tell your friends!  Want in on the discussion?Join us on our Facebook page or group, Instagram @eyeforeyepod, twitter @eyeforeyepod or shoot us an email at eyeforeyepod@gmail.com and let us know your thoughts- does the punishment fit the crime? __ Cover Art Created by: Rachel Gregorino, dollbambino@gmail.com Music: GarageBand Mix made by Lisa  Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

    41 min

  8. Apr 13

    Through the Gray: Science, Justice, and Reasonable Doubt- Interview with Tad Nelson

    Podcast Episode Description — Through the Looking Glass: Eye for an Eye Welcome back to Season 5 of Eye for an Eye! We’re excited to kick off a brand-new season filled with intriguing interviews, compelling cases, and even a new host we can’t wait to introduce you to. In this episode of Through the Looking Glass, hosts Matthew and Lisa sit down with Tad Nelson, a seasoned criminal defense attorney with more than 30 years of experience and a certified forensic toxicologist. Tad takes listeners through his unconventional path into criminal law—beginning at a probate firm before finding his calling after time spent working in a District Attorney’s office. Along the way, he discovered the critical role science plays in the courtroom, ultimately earning a master’s degree in forensic toxicology to strengthen his defense work. The conversation dives into the gray areas of the criminal justice system that define the Eye for an Eye series—exploring complex questions about fairness, evidence, and whether punishment truly fits the crime. Tad also reflects on the personal influences that shaped his journey, including the lasting impact of his father’s work ethic as a longshoreman. This episode offers a compelling look at the intersection of law, science, and justice—and the people working within it. ⭐ If you enjoyed this episode, don’t forget to rate, review, and subscribe to stay up to date with all our latest content. Be sure to check out the links in our bio for ways to support the show! *Please note all opinions in the show are our own and solely in regards to the specific case we are discussing in this episode* We made a one stop shop for all the Eye for an Eye links our listeners might want to check out whether its where to listen, our merch shop, all of our socials, our email, or ways to support the show,  we’d love for you to visit the link below!  https://msha.ke/eyeforeyepod/ Tired of Ads? Want to support our show? Please consider supporting Eye for an Eye with as little as $1 a month via patreon.com/eyeforeyepod Enjoy today's show? Don't forget to rate (those 5 stars are waiting to be clicked), review, subscribe and tell your friends!  Want in on the discussion?Join us on our Facebook page or group, Instagram @eyeforeyepod, twitter @eyeforeyepod or shoot us an email at eyeforeyepod@gmail.com and let us know your thoughts- does the punishment fit the crime? __ Cover Art Created by: Rachel Gregorino, dollbambino@gmail.com Music: GarageBand Mix made by Lisa  Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

    1h 24m
See All (185)

Trailer

3.9
out of 5
162 Ratings

About

A look into the interdiction and sentencing of some of history's most infamous killers and criminals. Delve into the cases that have haunted headlines for decades and those left in the shadows of the justice system. Listen closely as you may find a new perspective on justice that, at times, you may be surprised you agree with. Join your hosts Lisa, Matt, and Jules while they answer the age old question, "Does the punishment fit the crime?"

Information

  • Creator
    Eye for an Eye
  • Years Active
    2017 - 2026
  • Episodes
    185
  • Rating
    Explicit
  • Copyright
    © Lisa, Matt, Julia: Eye for an Eye Podcast 2017, All Rights Reserved

More From murder.ly

You Might Also Like