Year A – Pentecost 13; Lectionary 21 – August 23, 2026 Pastor Megan Floyd Matthew 16:13-20 Grace and peace to you from God, our Creator, from the Holy Spirit, our Sustainer, and from Jesus Christ, who guides us in our understanding of who he is for us. Amen. *** There is a question at the center of today's Gospel that I think Jesus continues to ask us, even now… "Who do you say that I am?" He's not asking, "Who does your pastor or your church say that I am?" or even, "Who does scripture say that I am?" Jesus is asking his disciples: "But who do you say that I am?" …And so, this morning, I want us to sit with that question. Who do we say Jesus is? Our Gospel takes us to Caesarea Philippi, a place where this question carries some significant political weight. Caesarea Philippi was a place filled with competing claims about power and divinity. It was associated with the worship of the god Pan, and it bore the name of Caesar. It was, in many ways, a place where people were being reminded of who was supposed to be in charge. And it is there, surrounded by all these competing claims, that Jesus asks his disciples: "Who do you say that I am?" Peter answers: "You are the Messiah, the Son of the living God." God in heaven revealed that answer to Peter… he gets it right… and Jesus tells him so… But what I actually find so encouraging is that Peter gets the answer right before he fully understands what that answer means. Because just a few verses later… which we'll dig into next week… Jesus begins explaining what it means for him to be the Messiah… he tells the disciples that he must go to Jerusalem, suffer, be killed, and be raised again. And Peter says… nope. Peter understands "Messiah" to mean victory… power… glory… and success. Jesus understands "Messiah" to mean… the way of the cross. Peter confesses Jesus correctly before he understands Jesus correctly. And, I don't know about you, but I find that kind of human fumbling incredibly comforting… because I think that is where many of us live. We come here, to church. We worship together. We pray together. We sing together. We hear God's Word and share in the holy meal together. We participate in the ministry and life of Faith Lutheran Church. And we confess our faith through the words of the creeds. Yet, I know that it is unrealistic to say that every person here fully understands and trusts Jesus… or feels completely certain about every aspect of their faith at every moment. That isn't human… and we're all human. Sure, there are moments when we are completely on board… when our faith feels alive and vibrant… when God's presence seems unmistakable… when we look around and think, "Yes. This is it. I know what I believe." And then there are those other moments… those moments when we have questions… and doubts. …Moments when something happens that makes us push back against what we have been taught. Moments when we say, "God… I don't understand this." …Moments when the teachings of Jesus ask something difficult of us, and we aren't sure we want to go there. Because confessing Jesus as the Christ isn't simply an intellectual exercise. …If we really believe Jesus is who we say he is, then that truth has consequences. …If Jesus is Lord, then our lives are shaped by that confession. If Jesus is the one who reveals God's love to us, then we are called to live lives shaped by that same love… and if Jesus teaches us to love our neighbors, including those who are difficult to love, then we have to wrestle with what that means. If Jesus reveals God's grace, then we have to consider what it means to extend grace to other people—and to ourselves. If Jesus reveals that every human being is beloved by God, then we have to learn to see that divine image in people we might otherwise overlook… dismiss… or even fear. That is not always easy. … and Peter discovered that very quickly. He was perfectly willing to confess Jesus as Messiah. But when Jesus explained what that actually meant, Peter wanted to push back. …but Jesus didn't give up on him. That's also comforting… and it's a reminder that our God is fully of mercy. Jesus didn't cast out Peter… he kept walking with him… kept teaching him… and loving him. …And eventually Peter's understanding deepened. The same is true for us. We don't come to church because we have everything figured out. …Quite the opposite! …we come because we don't. …We come because we are still learning… still becoming. We come because something in us longs to know God more deeply. One of our hymns in the All Creation Sings book sets the words of this longing to a haunting tune… I find it beautiful… The chorus is this… There is a longing in our hearts, O Lord, for you to reveal yourself to us. …There is a longing in our hearts for love we only find in you, our God. (ACS 1078) We keep showing up because somewhere inside us, we sense that there is something more. …We sense the presence of the Divine all around us—in creation, in beauty, in music, in acts of kindness, in forgiveness, in the stranger, in the person sitting beside us. And we want to draw closer to that presence. …We want to understand it. …We want to learn. …We want to deepen the relationship. And that is the work of a lifetime. …Faith is not a box we check off. We don't reach a certain level of understanding and say, "Well, that's done. I guess I can move on." There is always more. …God is always more. …God's full being is simply too much for us to comprehend in this life. …And that's okay. That's good! So, remember always… to yourself some grace. Give yourself permission to be a person of faith who still has questions. …who sometimes feels absolutely certain… and sometimes not so much. Give yourself permission to be like Peter. …Because the good news is that Jesus can work with Peter. …And Jesus can work with us. And also know… that this is one of the reasons we say the creed together. …When we stand together and join with the saints from every time and place, confessing the words of the creed… we aren't simply informing God about what we believe. …God already knows what's in our hearts. We do this… because we are reminding one another… and we are reminding ourselves. We are saying out loud, together, "This is the story we are part of. This is the truth toward which we are turning our lives." And there is something powerful about saying those words together… Even when we don't feel them completely. …Even when our understanding is incomplete, or when our faith is fragile… someone beside us is saying those same words… …and we say them with them… and then together, we carry the confession. Not alone… but always together. That is what it means to be the body of Christ. Sometimes your faith carries me… and sometimes my faith carries you. …Sometimes we are the ones who are certain, and sometimes we are the ones who need someone else to remind us. And together we keep walking. …Together we keep learning what it means to confess Jesus as the Christ. So… let's return to Jesus' question. "Who do you say that I am?" If Jesus were standing here among us today, asking you… What would you say? I can only tell you my answer. For me, I would say… Jesus, you are my redemption and salvation. You gave me everything… your whole life, and you hold me in love and care, even when I do not deserve it. You walk with me through the dark valleys, and you celebrate with me on the joyful mountaintops. You encourage me to live into a life of love and grace and mercy… a life that you yourself demonstrated for us… even knowing that I will never get it perfectly right. And in doing so, you help me understand that living according to your will brings your kingdom closer… heaven on earth …This way of living allows the divine light that is in all people… including in me… to shine. And when that light shines in all of us, the whole world becomes brighter. Jesus, you are the light, and Lord, I want to live in that light. You are the truth, and Lord, I want to live in your truth. …And so, Jesus, in you I place my trust and my love. That's my answer. …What's yours? Amen.