162 episodes

A look into the interdiction and sentencing of some of history's most infamous killers and criminals. Delve into the cases that have haunted headlines for decades and those left in the shadows of the justice system. Listen closely as you may find a new perspective on justice that, at times, you may be surprised you agree with. Join your hosts Lisa, Matt, and Jules while they answer the age old question, "Does the punishment fit the crime?"

Eye for an Eye Eye for an Eye

    • Society & Culture
    • 3.9 • 158 Ratings

A look into the interdiction and sentencing of some of history's most infamous killers and criminals. Delve into the cases that have haunted headlines for decades and those left in the shadows of the justice system. Listen closely as you may find a new perspective on justice that, at times, you may be surprised you agree with. Join your hosts Lisa, Matt, and Jules while they answer the age old question, "Does the punishment fit the crime?"

    Crippin' the Blues- Stanley "Tookie" Williams

    Crippin' the Blues- Stanley "Tookie" Williams

    Join Matt, Jules and Lisa as delve into the complex and controversial life of Stanley "Tookie" Williams. From his early years as a co-founder of the Crips, one of the most notorious street gangs in Los Angeles, to his transformation into a Nobel Peace Prize nominee, Williams' story is one of redemption, incarceration, and profound societal impact.
    Born in 1953, Williams grew up in South Central Los Angeles, a hotbed of gang activity and social unrest. At a young age, he became deeply involved in gang culture, eventually helping to establish the Crips in 1971. However, after spending years behind bars for various crimes, Williams underwent a remarkable transformation while on death row for multiple murders.
    Join us as we explore the life, legacy, and enduring impact of Tookie Williams. From his early days as a gang leader to his eventual quest for redemption, Williams' story challenges us to reconsider our notions of justice, rehabilitation, and the power of individual transformation.

    *Please note all opinions in the show are our own and solely in regards to the specific case we are discussing in this episode*
    We made a one stop shop for all the Eye for an Eye links our listeners might want to check out whether its where to listen, our merch shop, all of our socials, our email, or ways to support the show, we’d love for you to visit the link below! 
    https://msha.ke/eyeforeyepod/

    Tired of Ads? Want to support our show?
    Please consider supporting Eye for an Eye with as little as $1 a month via patreon.com/eyeforeyepod

    Enjoy today's show? Don't forget to rate (those 5 stars are waiting to be clicked), review, subscribe and tell your friends! 

    Want in on the discussion?Join us on our Facebook page or group, Instagram @eyeforeyepod, twitter @eyeforeyepod or shoot us an email at eyeforeyepod@gmail.com and let us know your thoughts- does the punishment fit the crime?
    __
    Cover Art Created by: Rachel Gregorino, dollbambino@gmail.com
    Music: GarageBand Mix made by Lisa 
    Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

    • 1 hr 29 min
    Unraveling Darkness: Casey Sherman on 'A Murder in Hollywood'- Through the Looking Glass with Casey Sherman

    Unraveling Darkness: Casey Sherman on 'A Murder in Hollywood'- Through the Looking Glass with Casey Sherman

    Welcome back to Season 4 Eye for an Eye family! Join us for an electrifying episode as we sit down with bestselling author Casey Sherman. Known for his gripping narratives and mastery of true crime storytelling, Sherman has taken us on unforgettable journeys through the pages of his books. Listen in as we explore the mind behind the bestsellers, from "The Finest Hours" to "Boston Strong," and delve into the art of crafting compelling narratives that transcend the bounds of reality. In this exclusive interview, we shine a spotlight on his latest masterpiece, "A Murder in Hollywood," delving into the shadows of Tinseltown's glamour to uncover a real-life crime that shook the city to its core.
    Casey takes us on a journey through the pages of his latest book, recounting the chilling details of a Hollywood murder that transcends the silver screen. In this riveting conversation, we explore the complexities of the case, from the shocking crime scene to the courtroom drama that followed. Sherman shares the challenges of piecing together the narrative, revealing the untold stories and hidden motivations that make "A Murder in Hollywood" a true crime sensation.
    As we unravel the layers of this gripping tale, Casey provides a behind-the-scenes look at his investigative process, offering keen insights into the relentless pursuit of truth. From the enigmatic characters involved to the dark underbelly of Hollywood's glitz and glamour, this episode paints a vivid picture of a crime that defies the illusions of the entertainment industry.
    Whether you're a true crime aficionado or a literary enthusiast, this episode promises a front-row seat to the mind of Casey Sherman, a storyteller who fearlessly dives into the depths of human darkness. A Murder in Hollywood comes out on February 13th and you can pre order it at your bookstore, online at Amazon ( here is the link https://www.amazon.com/Murder-Hollywood-Untold-Tinseltowns-Shocking/dp/1728276500 ) or any online retail.

    *Please note all opinions in the show are our own and solely in regards to the specific case we are discussing in this episode*

    We made a one stop shop for all the Eye for an Eye links our listeners might want to check out whether its where to listen, our merch shop, all of our socials, our email, or ways to support the show, we’d love for you to visit the link below! 
    https://msha.ke/eyeforeyepod/

    Tired of Ads? Want to support our show?
    Please consider supporting Eye for an Eye with as little as $1 a month via patreon.com/eyeforeyepod

    Enjoy today's show? Don't forget to rate (those 5 stars are waiting to be clicked), review, subscribe and tell your friends! 

    Want in on the discussion?Join us on our Facebook page or group, Instagram @eyeforeyepod, twitter @eyeforeyepod or shoot us an email at eyeforeyepod@gmail.com and let us know your thoughts- does the punishment fit the crime?
    __
    Cover Art Created by: Rachel Gregorino, dollbambino@gmail.com
    Music: GarageBand Mix made by Lisa 
    Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

    • 1 hr 6 min
    Damsel of Death- Aileen Wuornos

    Damsel of Death- Aileen Wuornos

    In this gripping episode, we delve deep into the chilling case of Aileen Wuornos, one of America's most infamous female serial killers. Known as the "Damsel of Death," Wuornos' tragic life and horrifying crimes have captured the attention of the world.
    Join Matt, Lisa and Jules as we uncover the haunting backstory of Wuornos' troubled childhood, marked by abuse, abandonment, and a relentless struggle for survival. Through extensive research and expert interviews, we explore the psychological factors that contributed to the making of a monster, examining the complex web of trauma, mental health issues, and societal neglect that ultimately shaped Wuornos' path.
    Drawing from court records, police investigations, and first-hand accounts, we piece together the chilling timeline of Wuornos' murderous spree. From her first victim to her subsequent targets, we analyze the patterns and motivations behind her cold-blooded acts, shedding light on the disturbing psychology of a killer.
    As we navigate through the legal proceedings and media frenzy surrounding the case, we examine the controversies that arose, including debates around Wuornos' mental state and claims of self-defense. We also explore the impact of her troubled personal relationships, particularly her tumultuous alliance with Tyria Moore, on her murderous rampage.
    Finally, we delve into the aftermath of Wuornos' capture, her trial, and the ultimate resolution of her case. We examine the legacy she left behind, both as a notorious criminal and as a symbol of the deeply rooted issues of abuse and neglect that plague society.
    Prepare yourself for a thought-provoking exploration into the mind of a killer and the complex societal factors that can shape a life toward violence. Tune in to this chilling episode as we uncover the dark saga of Aileen Wuornos, offering insight, analysis, and a sobering reminder of the harrowing depths of the human psyche.

    Special thanks to the producers of todays show, your support means the world! :
    Michael and Carolyn Y.
    Matt M
    Kimbrough's Coaching
    Elizabeth F. 
    Kate R. 


    *Please note all opinions in the show are our own and solely in regards to the specific case we are discussing in this episode*

    We made a one stop shop for all the Eye for an Eye links our listeners might want to check out whether its where to listen, our merch shop, all of our socials, our email, or ways to support the show, we’d love for you to visit the link below! 
    https://msha.ke/eyeforeyepod/

    Tired of Ads? Want to support our show?
    Please consider supporting Eye for an Eye with as little as $1 a month via patreon.com/eyeforeyepod

    Enjoy today's show? Don't forget to rate (those 5 stars are waiting to be clicked), review, subscribe and tell your friends! 

    Want in on the discussion?Join us on our Facebook page or group, Instagram @eyeforeyepod, twitter @eyeforeyepod or shoot us an email at eyeforeyepod@gmail.com and let us know your thoughts- does the punishment fit the crime?
    __
    Cover Art Created by: Rachel Gregorino, dollbambino@gmail.com
    Music: GarageBand Mix made by Lisa 
    Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

    • 1 hr 46 min
    A Sock and Silly String Reloaded- Darlie Routier

    A Sock and Silly String Reloaded- Darlie Routier

    Join Jules, Lisa and Matt on a thought-provoking and chilling journey as we explore the evidence, scrutinize the theories, and question the verdict that has left many perplexed and divided.
    In the quiet town of Rowlett, Texas, a seemingly idyllic suburban home transforms into a scene of unimaginable horror. On June 6, 1996, Darlie Routier, a young mother of three, claimed that an intruder had broken into her home, brutally attacked her and her children, and left her fighting for her life. Tragically, two of her sons did not survive the ordeal.
    But as investigators delved into the details, inconsistencies emerged, and Darlie soon found herself accused of a heinous crime: the murder of her own children. The case captured national attention, fueled by sensational media coverage and a series of shocking revelations that challenged the initial narrative.
    In this gripping podcast series, we explore the complexities of the Darlie Routier case, dissecting the evidence, examining the forensic analysis, and exploring the motives behind the prosecution's case. We delve into the courtroom drama, revealing the strategies employed by both the defense and the prosecution, and examine the role of public perception in shaping the outcome.
    We confront the lingering questions that continue to haunt this case: Did Darlie Routier commit these unspeakable acts? Or was she a victim of a flawed investigation and a rush to judgment?
    As we peel back the layers of this compelling story, we also explore broader themes of justice, the death penalty, and the impact of media on high-profile trials. We invite you to join us on this riveting exploration, where we seek to shed light on the Darlie Routier case and challenge your own perceptions of guilt and innocence.
    *Please note all opinions in the show are our own and solely in regards to the specific case we are discussing in this episode*
    Special thanks to the producers of todays show, your support means the world! :
    Michael and Carolyn Y.
    Matt M
    Kimbrough's Coaching
    Elizabeth F.
    Kate R.
    *Please note all opinions in the show are our own and solely in regards to the specific case we are discussing in this episode*
    We made a one stop shop for all the Eye for an Eye links our listeners might want to check out whether its where to listen, our merch shop, all of our socials, our email, or ways to support the show, we’d love for you to visit the link below!
    https://msha.ke/eyeforeyepod/
    Tired of Ads? Want to support our show?
    Please consider supporting Eye for an Eye with as little as $1 a month via patreon.com/eyeforeyepod
    Enjoy today's show? Don't forget to rate (those 5 stars are waiting to be clicked), review, subscribe and tell your friends!
    Want in on the discussion?Join us on our Facebook page or group, Instagram @eyeforeyepod, twitter @eyeforeyepod or shoot us an email at eyeforeyepod@gmail.com and let us know your thoughts- does the punishment fit the crime?
    __
    Cover Art Created by: Rachel Gregorino, dollbambino@gmail.com
    Music: GarageBand Mix made by Lisa
    Sources:

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VZcC0N9HZMM

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Darlie_Routier

    https://www.dallasnews.com/news/crime/2018/06/12/5-controversial-moments-case-sent-darlie-routier-death-row-sons-murder

    https://www.newsday.com/entertainment/tv/last-defense-review-1.19055255

    http://hcnews.com/pages/justice_for_all/family-of-darlie-routier-believes-that-dna-testing-could-prove-her-innocence/

    https://hcnews.com/pages/justice_for_all/forensics-expert-disagrees-with-states-version-of-events-in-routier-case/

    https://www.dallasnews.com/news/crime/2016/06/03/did-darlie-routier-kill-her-kids-doubts-remain-20-years-later

    https://darliefacts.files.wordpress.com/2012/08/911-call.pdf


    Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

    • 1 hr 36 min
    Interview with Vic Ferrari, A Retired New York City Police Department Detective and Author- Episode 100- Vic Ferrari, Through the Looking Glass

    Interview with Vic Ferrari, A Retired New York City Police Department Detective and Author- Episode 100- Vic Ferrari, Through the Looking Glass

    In our new series, Through the Looking Glass we will be interviewing the top minds in the true crime game- from criminal profilers, investigators, police officers, homicide detectives, true crime authors, and even experts on deviant desires- we will be covering it all.
    Join Matt, Lisa and Jules as we interview one of our most intriguing subjects to ever grace our sound waves. Vic Ferrari is a retired New York City Police Department Detective and Author, who served in the force during some of the most controversial and historical events in our countries history including but not limited to- dealing with the aftermath of 9/11, the height of stop and frisk, and much more. Vic openly discusses his time sharing in vice and auto theft, as well as his life in New York, and as a successful author, following his illustrious career. With NYPD tell all books with titles like- The NYPD’s Flying Circus: Cops, Crime & Chaos, Dickheads & Debauchery: and other ingenious ways to die, and Confessions of a Catholic High School Graduate— Ferraris books are on our must read list. This is an episode you are not going to want to miss.
    Make sure you check out Vic's books below:
    https://www.amazon.com/stores/Vic-Ferrari/author/B01IIQXLBC?ref=ap_rdr&store_ref=ap_rdr&isDramIntegrated=true&shoppingPortalEnabled=true

    Special thanks to the producers of todays show, your support means the world! :
    Michael and Carolyn Y.
    Matt M. 
    Kimbrough's Coaching

    *Please note all opinions in the show are our own and solely in regards to the specific case we are discussing in this episode*

    We made a one stop shop for all the Eye for an Eye links our listeners might want to check out whether its where to listen, our merch shop, all of our socials, our email, or ways to support the show, we’d love for you to visit the link below! 
    https://msha.ke/eyeforeyepod/

    Tired of Ads? Want to support our show?
    Please consider supporting Eye for an Eye with as little as $1 a month via patreon.com/eyeforeyepod

    Enjoy today's show? Don't forget to rate (those 5 stars are waiting to be clicked), review, subscribe and tell your friends! 

    Want in on the discussion?Join us on our Facebook page or group, Instagram @eyeforeyepod, twitter @eyeforeyepod or shoot us an email at eyeforeyepod@gmail.com and let us know your thoughts- does the punishment fit the crime?
    __
    Cover Art Created by: Rachel Gregorino, dollbambino@gmail.com
    Music: GarageBand Mix made by Lisa 

    Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

    • 1 hr 16 min
    The Unraveling Mind: Inside the Dark World of Austy Frosty- Austin Harrouff

    The Unraveling Mind: Inside the Dark World of Austy Frosty- Austin Harrouff

    Welcome back Eye for an Eye family! We've missed you while we were on our spring break!
    In this chilling episode of Eye for an Eye , we delve deep into the disturbing case of Austin Harrouff, a name that sent shockwaves through the nation. Join us as we unravel the intricate layers of this perplexing story that left an indelible mark on the community of Tequesta, Florida.
    Known for his seemingly normal life, Austin Harrouff's sudden descent into darkness sent shockwaves through his family and friends. We trace his path, exploring the early signs of a troubled mind and the warning signs that were tragically overlooked. 
    As the tale unfolds, we reveal the harrowing events that unfolded on that fateful night, leaving two innocent victims brutally attacked and killed, while the world watched in disbelief. We examine the forensic evidence, psychological factors, and the puzzling motives behind this shocking crime.
    Join Lisa, Jules and Matt as we examine the legal proceedings that followed, the gripping courtroom drama, and the question that still lingers: What truly motivated Austin Harrouff? Was it a case of an unstable mind, a moment of uncontrollable rage, or something far more sinister?
    Prepare to be captivated by this episode, as we navigate through the darkness surrounding Austin Harrouff's case, exploring the intricacies of a mind gone awry, and ultimately seeking answers to the haunting questions: What drives an individual to commit such heinous acts and most of all, does the punishment fit the crime?

    Special thanks to the producers of todays show, your support means the world! :
    Michael and Carolyn Y.
    Matt M
    Kimbrough's Coaching
    Elizabeth F. 
    Kate R. 


    *Please note all opinions in the show are our own and solely in regards to the specific case we are discussing in this episode*

    We made a one stop shop for all the Eye for an Eye links our listeners might want to check out whether its where to listen, our merch shop, all of our socials, our email, or ways to support the show, we’d love for you to visit the link below! 
    https://msha.ke/eyeforeyepod/

    Tired of Ads? Want to support our show?
    Please consider supporting Eye for an Eye with as little as $1 a month via patreon.com/eyeforeyepod

    Enjoy today's show? Don't forget to rate (those 5 stars are waiting to be clicked), review, subscribe and tell your friends! 

    Want in on the discussion?Join us on our Facebook page or group, Instagram @eyeforeyepod, twitter @eyeforeyepod or shoot us an email at eyeforeyepod@gmail.com and let us know your thoughts- does the punishment fit the crime?
    __
    Cover Art Created by: Rachel Gregorino, dollbambino@gmail.com
    Music: GarageBand Mix made by Lisa 
    __
    Sources:
    https://www.850wftl.com/austin-harrouff-internet-searches-attack-will-give-chills/
    https://cbs12.com/news/cbs12-news-i-team/austin-harrouff-face-eater-killer-trial-begins-michele-mishcon-john-stevens
    https://everipedia.org/wiki/lang_en/austin-harrouff
    https://www.cbsnews.com/miami/news/austin-harrouff-trial-man-who-randomly-killed-couple-chewed-victims-face-found-not-guilty-by-reason-of-insasnity/
    https://www.cnn.com/2022/11/29/us/florida-killings-face-biting/index.html
    https://nypost.com/2022/11/28/white-rich-boy-justice-family-rages-as-florida-cannibal-killer-may-be-free-again/
    https://people.com/crime/austin-harrouff-florida-man-killed-couple-tried-eat-victim-face-not-guilty-insanity/
    https://cbs12.com/news/cbs12-news-i-team/austin-harrouff-face-eater-killer-trial-begins-michele-mishcon-john-stevens
    https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-11478771/Cannibal-frat-boy-randomly-killed-Florida-couple-chewed-mans-face-not-guilty.html
    https://www.sun-sentinel.com/news/florida/fl-austin-harrouff-past-20161129-story.html
    https://www.sun-sentinel.com/local/palm-beach/
    https://www.tallahassee.com/story/news/2016/08/17/who-were-john-stevens-and-michelle-mishcon/88904898/
    Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

    • 1 hr 57 min

Customer Reviews

3.9 out of 5
158 Ratings

158 Ratings

jennincal ,

Natalie Bollinger

You guys should check out Shawn’s you give page. He makes videos all day every day about Natalie even in 2020

midewestmomster ,

So Good!

This group has got it going on. Collectively, I am blown away by the amount of intelligence and well researched cases. Keep it up:).

Thena T✨ ,

New!!

I love that there is cases I’ve never heard before. Sometimes true crime redoes the same things always but you guys bring new cases to the light and teach me new things!

Top Podcasts In Society & Culture

Inconceivable Truth
Wavland
This American Life
This American Life
Stuff You Should Know
iHeartPodcasts
Soul Boom
Rainn Wilson
Fallen Angels: A Story of California Corruption
iHeartPodcasts
We Can Do Hard Things
Glennon Doyle and Audacy

You Might Also Like

The Generation Why Podcast
Wondery
True Crime Garage
TRUE CRIME GARAGE
The Prosecutors
PodcastOne
MURDERISH
Cloud10
Crime Junkie
audiochuck
True Crime Couple
True Crime Couple

More by murder.ly

Obscura: A True Crime Podcast
Justin Drown
Corpus Delicti
CDM Productions
Based on a True Crime
murder.ly
The Brothers Commonplace
The Brothers Commonplace
Murder and Such
Murder and Such
Hell and High Horror Podcast
murder.ly