Movie HighLow

Movie HighLow | Movie Reviews & Film Analysis

Movie HighLow is a movie review and film analysis podcast about the best, worst, and weirdest movies cinema has to offer. Each episode, we revisit iconic films, cult classics, Hollywood disasters, bad movie masterpieces, and misunderstood flops to find the HIGHS, the LOWS, and the moments that deserve a second look. Some movies are great. Some are terrible. Some are both. From iconic classics to fascinating disasters, we’re here to figure out why. Film analysis • Movie breakdowns • Movie reviews • High vs Low • Film podcast

  1. 19h ago

    SCENT OF A WOMAN (1992) | Frank Was in the Dark Before He Went Blind (High)

    We went High on Scent of a Woman (1992), and we’re ready to defend a movie that has developed a surprisingly complicated reputation. Is Al Pacino going completely over the top? Absolutely. Is Colonel Frank Slade an arrogant, foul-mouthed, womanizing a*****e? Without question. Does Martin Brest’s movie occasionally confuse emotional intensity with emotional subtlety? Sure. But none of that means the movie doesn't work. Our central argument is that Frank Slade isn't miserable because he's blind. He was miserable long before he lost his sight. His blindness didn't destroy a wonderful life. It left him with fewer places to hide from the person he'd already become. When Frank screams, "I'm in the dark here," he's not just talking about his vision. He's talking about his soul. And what makes Scent of a Woman such a great movie isn't that a sweet young man magically fixes a broken older one. It's that two people with completely different problems discover they have exactly what the other needs. In this episode of Movie HighLow, we revisit Scent of a Woman, directed by Martin Brest and released in 1992, starring Al Pacino as Lieutenant Colonel Frank Slade and Chris O'Donnell as Charlie Simms. Pacino won his first Academy Award for Best Actor for this performance, and we spend a lot of time discussing whether the movie, the performance, and that Oscar have aged as poorly as some critics suggest. Charlie is a scholarship student at the prestigious Baird School, where wealthy students can afford to treat consequences like an inconvenience their parents will eventually solve. After witnessing a prank on the school's headmaster, Charlie faces a choice: identify the students responsible or jeopardize his own future. Meanwhile, Charlie takes a Thanksgiving job looking after Frank Slade, a blind, retired Army lieutenant colonel who has absolutely no intention of spending the holiday sitting at home. Instead, Frank drags him to New York City for an expensive weekend involving fine dining, beautiful women, a tango, a Ferrari, and a deeply disturbing final item on his itinerary: a loaded .45. The biggest High is Al Pacino's performance, and we think its excess is completely justified by the character. Frank has spent his life commanding attention, intimidating people, shocking everyone around him, and turning every conversation into a performance. His personality is enormous because it's the only weapon he believes he has left. The movie doesn't ask us to approve of Frank's behavior. It asks us to understand it. That's what makes the Thanksgiving dinner scene so important. When Frank visits his brother's family, we can immediately sense the history. This isn't the first holiday he's ruined. His nephew Randy, played by Bradley Whitford, finally starts tearing into him, revealing the ridiculous, self-inflicted circumstances behind Frank's blindness. Frank was already bitter and angry about his life. Then, after drinking too much, he tried to show off by juggling grenades and ended up destroying his own future. That story changes everything about how we understand him. Frank wasn't a good man who had something terrible happen to him. He was a self-destructive man who eventually suffered the consequences of his own behavior. And when Randy turns his cruelty toward Charlie, something important happens: Charlie stands up for Frank. For perhaps the first time in a long time, Frank experiences someone defending him without being asked. We also spend time defending Chris O'Donnell's performance. Charlie may seem like the innocent, wide-eyed kid standing beside a legendary actor working at maximum volume, but that contrast is essential. Charlie doesn't need to learn right from wrong. He already knows the right thing to do. His problem is that he's terrified of what doing it might cost him. Frank, meanwhile, has all the confidence in the world and absolutely nothing left that he believes is worth standing up for. That's the movie. One of our favorite scenes is the famous Scent of a Woman tango scene. We talk about how the dance works on several levels. Frank approaches a young woman who has always wanted to learn the tango, and for a few minutes, he creates a beautiful experience for someone instead of making their life more difficult. He's also teaching Charlie something about confidence: approach life, don't apologize for taking up space, and when you get tangled up, keep moving. But the tango isn't just about Frank teaching someone else. Because he's blind and his partner doesn't know the steps, the dance requires both people to trust each other. He guides her, and she guides him. Then comes the Ferrari test-drive scene, which takes the same idea and pushes it toward disaster. Where the tango represents Frank's grace, the Ferrari represents his recklessness. Charlie wants to delay Frank's suicide plan, so he finds something that might make him feel alive again. Frank gets behind the wheel because he desperately wants to experience control, speed, danger, and independence one more time. Once again, the experience only works because two people trust each other. And once the ride ends, the reality of Frank's situation comes crashing back. The hotel room suicide confrontation might be the movie's most powerful scene. Frank is ready to end his life, and Charlie refuses to leave him alone. Suddenly, the lessons Frank has spent the weekend teaching Charlie come right back at him. Charlie finally finds the confidence to stand his ground, even when he's terrified. He doesn't cure Frank's depression or somehow erase years of self-hatred. He simply gives him a reason to reconsider what happens next. That distinction is what makes the scene work. The biggest debate of the episode is the famous Baird School disciplinary hearing, where Frank delivers his explosive speech defending Charlie. We know the criticisms. The speech is theatrical, sentimental, melodramatic, and very, very loud. But we think it earns every decibel. Headmaster Trask has turned a school disciplinary matter into a public spectacle designed to humiliate Charlie and force him to betray his principles. Frank recognizes the performance for what it is and decides to fight theater with theater. For the entire movie, Frank has used his enormous personality to dominate people for his own benefit. At Baird, he finally uses that same force to defend someone who deserves it. That's his redemption. He doesn't become a different person. He finally does something worthwhile with the person he already is. We do have some Lows. The movie is too long, and we think a tighter edit could have removed 15 to 20 minutes without sacrificing its emotional impact. The Park Avenue sequence following the Ferrari scene feels unnecessary, and even the famous Baird speech makes its point before Pacino finishes making it. We also question Frank's borderline supernatural ability to identify every perfume, physical feature, and woman within smelling distance. The man is blind. He's not Daredevil. But subtlety isn't the only measure of emotional honesty. Scent of a Woman is a High because Frank and Charlie don't magically fix each other. Frank teaches Charlie to find his courage. Charlie teaches Frank that tomorrow might still be worth experiencing. One man learns how to stand up for what he believes in. The other finally finds something worth standing up for. Hoo-ah Scent of a Woman 1992 movie review Martin Brest's Scent of a Woman Al Pacino as Colonel Frank Slade Chris O'Donnell as Charlie Simms Al Pacino's Best Actor Oscar win Scent of a Woman ending explained The meaning of "I'm in the dark here" Frank Slade's blindness and backstory Scent of a Woman Thanksgiving dinner scene Bradley Whitford as Randy Slade Scent of a Woman tango scene explained Al Pacino's Ferrari driving scene Scent of a Woman hotel suicide scene Scent of a Woman Baird School speech Frank Slade's redemption arc Charlie Simms and moral integrity Why Scent of a Woman deserves its reputation Has Scent of a Woman aged well? Al Pacino's over-the-top performance Scent of a Woman movie highs and lows

  2. Nov 6

    DUTCH (1991) | The Thanksgiving Classic Nobody Talks About (Low)

    We went Low on Dutch (1991), but let's get something straight right away: neither of us thinks this is a Low. John Hughes' Dutch is one of the most underappreciated Thanksgiving comedies ever made, and we have been watching it every holiday season for years. Is it predictable? Absolutely. Is it basically Planes, Trains and Automobiles with a working-class guy and a spoiled kid instead of two grown men? Pretty much. But that is exactly why it works. You can see every piece of the John Hughes formula clicking into place: opposites forced together, increasingly ridiculous travel disasters, class conflict, unexpected friendship, and a sentimental payoff just in time for Thanksgiving. None of that bothers us. Being able to see the machinery does not mean the machinery isn't working. And in Dutch, the machinery works beautifully. In this episode, we revisit Dutch, directed by Peter Faiman, written by John Hughes, and starring Ed O'Neill as Dutch Dooley, Ethan Embry as Doyle Standish, and Christopher McDonald as Doyle's wealthy, manipulative father. The premise is pure Hughes. Dutch is a working-class regular guy dating Natalie, a divorced mother whose ex-husband has once again decided that being a father is somebody else's problem. When her 12-year-old son Doyle needs to get home from boarding school for Thanksgiving, Dutch volunteers to pick him up. What should be a straightforward drive from Georgia to Chicago becomes an escalating disaster involving BB guns, fireworks, a destroyed car, diner warfare, hitchhiking, a homeless shelter, and two people who would rather be anywhere than in each other's company. One of the first things we talk about is how badly this movie was received when it came out. Dutch was both a critical and financial disappointment, and we think its release date may have been a major factor. Why was a Thanksgiving road-trip comedy released in July 1991, competing with massive summer movies like Terminator 2 and Point Break? This is a movie that belongs in November, when audiences are thinking about family, travel, uncomfortable reunions, and getting home for the holidays. The biggest High is Ed O'Neill. He is basically playing a warmer, more emotionally intelligent version of Al Bundy, without losing any of the working-class attitude that makes him so funny. Dutch is blunt, stubborn, sarcastic, occasionally reckless, and completely unimpressed by wealthy people who think their money makes them better than everyone else. We love that O'Neill never feels like a traditional movie star. He looks and acts like somebody's dad.  But Ethan Embry deserves just as much credit. Doyle is a spectacularly obnoxious little kid, and Embry plays him with absolute conviction. He's articulate, smug, entitled, and convinced that Dutch is beneath him. But the performance becomes much more impressive as the movie progresses, because Doyle's transformation never feels completely fraudulent. We argue that even though the movie is called Dutch, it is really Doyle's story. Dutch does not change very much. Doyle is the one who has to stop imitating his father's worst qualities and start figuring out who he actually wants to be. That is the emotional heart of the movie. Doyle has spent his childhood being manipulated by a wealthy father who uses money and status to poison him against his mother. Dutch cannot compete with that wealth, but he can show Doyle something his father never has: genuine concern for other people. And naturally, John Hughes delivers those lessons through some absolutely ridiculous comedy. The boarding school confrontation is a perfect introduction to their relationship. Dutch shows up to retrieve Doyle and immediately gets attacked, karate-chopped, kicked, and shot with a BB gun. The whole sequence eventually ends with Dutch carrying the kid out tied to a hockey stick. Then there is the fireworks scene, which might be the first moment we realize these two could actually become friends. Dutch wants to show Doyle a good time, and Doyle cannot help enjoying himself, even while desperately pretending he isn't. Of course, Dutch accidentally blows up the entire bag of fireworks. We also spend plenty of time on the car accident, which is one of the movie's most important turning points. Doyle's attempt to get even with Dutch results in their car being destroyed by a truck. For the first time, his behavior has consequences beyond inconveniencing the person he hates. Dutch forces him to recognize that the truck driver could have been seriously hurt or killed. And because this is a John Hughes comedy, that serious lesson is followed by Dutch teaching Doyle how to throw a proper punch, only to get knocked flat on his ass. Then comes the diner scene, which might be our favorite scene in the entire movie. Dutch finally realizes he cannot keep matching Doyle's energy, so he lets the kid learn what happens when you cannot pay for your own breakfast. The payoff is glorious: Dutch walking out with a full stomach while Doyle watches him burp in satisfaction. Nothing burps better than bacon. One of the biggest reasons we love Dutch is that it never lets its emotional lessons completely overwhelm the comedy. The hitchhiking sequence with two women who turn out to be prostitutes is ridiculous, but it also exposes Doyle's hypocrisy about class and respectability. The gas station scene, where Dutch spectacularly tears his pants, is still hilarious after countless rewatches. And the homeless shelter sequence gives Doyle a genuine glimpse of people living without the advantages he has always taken for granted. We particularly love the moment when a little girl reaches for part of Doyle's dinner roll. His first instinct is to protect what belongs to him. Then he stops, thinks, and offers it to her. It is a small gesture, but it communicates more about his growth than a big speech ever could. We do have a couple of Lows. The movie rarely questions Dutch's methods, even when he makes decisions that are manipulative, dangerous, or wildly irresponsible. Because Doyle eventually improves, the screenplay seems to conclude that Dutch was right about everything. That is probably worth questioning. But our biggest Low is the end credits song. After delivering such a warm Thanksgiving ending, the movie suddenly launches into Ziggy Marley's “Give a Little Love.” We have nothing against the song, but it feels completely disconnected from the movie we just watched. Still, none of that changes our verdict. Dutch is funny, warm, nostalgic, ridiculously quotable, and much better than its reputation suggests. It knows exactly where it is going, and we know where it is going too. The pleasure comes from watching these two characters take the most entertaining possible route to get there. This isn't a guilty pleasure. It is an underappreciated Thanksgiving classic, and for us, an essential part of the holiday season. Dutch 1991 movie review John Hughes' Dutch Peter Faiman's Dutch Ed O'Neill as Dutch Dooley Ethan Embry as Doyle Standish Christopher McDonald as Doyle's father Dutch as an underrated Thanksgiving movie Dutch vs Planes, Trains and Automobiles John Hughes road-trip comedies Why Dutch failed at the box office Dutch's July 1991 release date Ed O'Neill and Al Bundy comparisons Dutch boarding school BB gun scene Dutch fireworks scene Dutch car accident and truck driver scene Dutch diner scene and bacon quote Dutch hitchhiking and gas station scenes Dutch homeless shelter scene Dutch ending and father-son relationship Ziggy Marley's “Give a Little Love” end credits song

  3. Oct 23

    THE SHINING (1980) | Stanley Kubrick, Stephen King and the Perfect Adaptation (High)

    We went High on The Shining, and this is not just a High because it is one of the most famous horror movies ever made. For us, Stanley Kubrick’s The Shining (1980) is a masterpiece because it understands something essential about fear: the scariest place in the world is not always the haunted hotel. Sometimes it is the family you are trapped inside. That is the central argument of this episode. Kubrick takes Stephen King’s novel, strips away explanation, changes the characters, changes the ending, and turns a supernatural story into something colder, stranger, and more psychologically suffocating. This is not adaptation as transcription. It is adaptation as transformation. Kubrick understands that sometimes respecting the source material means knowing exactly when to leave it behind. In this episode, we finally check into the Overlook Hotel and talk about The Shining, directed by Stanley Kubrick, starring Jack Nicholson as Jack Torrance, Shelley Duvall as Wendy Torrance, Danny Lloyd as Danny, and Scatman Crothers as Dick Halloran. This is one of Dom’s favorite horror movies, favorite Kubrick movies, and maybe favorite movies, period. It is the kind of film that feels less like something you simply watch and more like something you enter. We begin with the opening aerial shots, because the movie announces itself immediately. The music is dissonant and ominous, the landscape is massive, and the car looks tiny against the mountains. Before anyone says anything scary, the movie has already told us we are going somewhere wrong. A major part of the episode is the difference between King’s novel and Kubrick’s film. King’s version is warmer, more emotional, and more explicit about Jack Torrance as a man being corrupted by the Overlook. Kubrick’s version is colder. His Jack feels dangerous before the hotel ever gets its hooks into him. That has always been one of the big criticisms of the movie, but we argue that it is exactly why this version works. Kubrick is not telling a story about a good man who becomes evil. He is telling a story about a resentful, volatile man who is already standing at the edge and only needs a little push. We also dig into the idea that Jack may have the Shining too. Danny clearly shines. Halloran clearly shines. But Jack’s relationship with the hotel suggests that he may also be receptive to its energy, only he does not understand what he is receiving. Danny and Halloran know there is a signal. Jack mistakes the signal for himself. That may be why the Overlook gets to him so quickly. He is an open door that does not know something is passing through it. One of the biggest Highs is Shelley Duvall as Wendy, a performance that deserves far more respect than it has historically received. It is easy to reduce Wendy to someone who spends the movie crying and terrified, but that misses what Duvall is actually doing. Her Wendy is fragile, yes, but she is also deeply human. She is a woman who has spent years managing Jack’s rage, trying to hold the family together, trying to stay cheerful, trying to keep Danny safe, and slowly realizing that the person she has been protecting the family from is inside the family. We talk about how much information is buried in Wendy’s early conversation with the doctor. Jack injured Danny years earlier, but he has only been sober for five months. That detail tells us everything. This is not one isolated mistake. This is a pattern. Wendy is not naive because she does not know who Jack is. She is exhausted because she knows exactly who he is and has been trying to survive him. Jack Nicholson is, of course, one of the movie’s defining forces. His performance is huge, funny, terrifying, theatrical, and completely iconic. From the first interview with Ullman, Jack Torrance feels wrong. The smile is too wide. The charm is too forced. The resentment is too close to the surface. By the time he reaches the Gold Room and talks to Lloyd, it feels less like a man suddenly going insane and more like a man finally giving himself permission to stop pretending. Another major High is Dick Halloran, played by Scatman Crothers. He is the movie’s clearest force of warmth and goodness. His conversation with Danny about the Shining is one of the only scenes where an adult genuinely meets Danny on his level. He explains the gift, warns him about room 237, and takes him seriously. When Halloran senses Danny’s distress and fights his way back to the hotel, the movie trains us to believe he is the rescue. Then Kubrick brutally rips that hope away. One of the episode’s biggest adaptation discussions is fire versus ice. King’s novel ends with the boiler exploding and the Overlook burning. Kubrick throws that away and gives us the hedge maze, the snow, and Jack freezing to death alone. For this version of Jack Torrance, it is the perfect ending. He does not get redeemed. He does not fight his way back. He gets lost inside the maze, literally and psychologically, while Danny survives because he understands the pattern well enough to escape it. The maze is the movie. The Overlook is a maze. Jack’s mind is a maze. His resentment is a maze. His obsession is a maze. Danny does not overpower his father. He outthinks him. We do find a couple of tiny Lows. Halloran’s psychic ability has one very convenient blind spot when he walks into the hotel and does not sense Jack standing nearby with an axe. We also talk about “Here’s Johnny,” which is iconic, funny, and terrifying, but also one of the only moments that dates the movie because the Johnny Carson reference will not land the same way forever. But those are tiny objections in a movie we consider close to perfect. The Shining is a High because Kubrick creates something colder, stranger, and more enduring than a straightforward haunted hotel movie. He takes King’s material and turns it into a film about abuse, addiction, isolation, psychic sensitivity, inherited violence, and the way evil can become part of a place’s history.  Topics Discussed The Shining 1980 review Stanley Kubrick’s The Shining Stephen King vs Stanley Kubrick Jack Nicholson as Jack Torrance Shelley Duvall as Wendy Torrance Danny Lloyd as Danny Torrance Scatman Crothers as Dick Halloran The Overlook Hotel Room 237 Does Jack Torrance have the Shining? The Shining ending explained The hedge maze ending The Shining book vs movie Jack Torrance and alcoholism Wendy Torrance performance defense Dick Halloran’s death The Gold Room and Lloyd the bartender “All work and no play makes Jack a dull boy” “Here’s Johnny” The Shining as psychological horror

  4. Oct 13

    DREAMCATCHER (2003) | A Stephen King Mixtape Gone Wrong (Low)

    We went Low on Dreamcatcher, but this is a very particular kind of Low. This is not a boring bad movie. This is a wildly overstuffed, deeply strange, completely unfiltered bad movie that somehow has talented actors, a major Stephen King source, Lawrence Kasdan directing, William Goldman on the screenplay, a reported $68 million budget, and an alien that crawls out of somebody’s ass before Jason Lee fights it with a toilet brush. That is the central fascination of Dreamcatcher (2003). It often feels less like a new Stephen King story and more like somebody fed all of Stephen King’s previous work into a machine and asked it to generate the ultimate Stephen King mixtape: childhood friends, Maine, psychic powers, bullies, aliens, body horror, military quarantine, Derry, snow, telepathy, trauma, and alien ass monsters. In this episode, we revisit Dreamcatcher, directed by Lawrence Kasdan and based on the novel by Stephen King, as one of the strangest studio horror failures of the early 2000s. The movie stars Thomas Jane as Henry, Damian Lewis as Jonesy, Jason Lee as Beaver, Timothy Olyphant as Pete, Donnie Wahlberg as Duddits, Morgan Freeman as Colonel Curtis, and Tom Sizemore as Owen Underhill. That is a real cast. There is real money on screen. There are real filmmakers involved. And somehow all of that talent produced a movie where the phrase “shit weasel” becomes central to the mythology. The setup is not bad. Four lifelong friends reunite for their annual hunting trip in the Maine woods. Since childhood, they have shared a mysterious psychic connection tied to Duddits, a boy they defended from bullies when they were young. This year, something is different. A sick, disoriented stranger stumbles into their cabin, the woods go under military quarantine, and soon the group is dealing with alien parasites, telepathic possession, and an entity called Mr. Gray taking over Jonesy’s body. The first High is that the first act almost tricks us into thinking this might be a good movie. We meet each of the guys separately and immediately understand that something unusual connects them. Henry is using some kind of psychic ability with a patient. Jonesy shows empathy toward a student who cheated because he can sense there is more going on. Pete uses his strange gift to help a woman find her keys and tries to turn it into a date. Beaver is writing “SSDD,” same shit, different day, which becomes one of the movie’s repeated psychic signals. There is a real sense that something cosmic is pulling these guys back together. The cabin material also works better than it should. The guys irritate each other in believable ways. They have history. They talk like middle-aged friends who have been repeating the same jokes and rhythms for decades. There is a version of Dreamcatcher that stays with these four guys reconnecting in a cabin while something supernatural slowly closes in, and I would absolutely watch that movie. The biggest High, though, is the memory warehouse. Once Mr. Gray takes over Jonesy’s body, Jonesy retreats inside his own mind, which the movie visualizes as a warehouse filled with files, drawers, rooms, and stored memories. That is a genuinely cool idea. Jonesy is not gone. He is trapped inside the architecture of his own brain, watching Mr. Gray pilot his body from the inside. The movie suddenly becomes a psychological possession story, and for a little while, it feels like it has found something original. And honestly, we have to give Dreamcatcher credit for having no shame. Timothy Olyphant almost gets bitten by an alien that crawled out of a woman while he is writing his friend’s name in the snow with his own piss. There is something admirable about a studio movie this expensive being this weird. The biggest Low is obvious: shit weasels. The moment the movie reveals a monster in the toilet, everything changes. The first bathroom sequence is staged like horror, with Beaver holding the toilet lid shut while waiting for Jonesy to get tape. But then the toothpick drops, the compulsion kicks in, and suddenly Jason Lee is fighting a CGI ass snake with a toilet brush. What should be disgusting becomes silly. The movie’s larger problem is that it has too many ideas and no filter. It wants to be Stand by Me, It, The Tommyknockers, Alien, The Thing, a military quarantine thriller, a psychic drama, a gross-out comedy, and a sentimental friendship story all at once. Every 20 minutes, it shows us a version of itself that could have worked, then abandons it for another movie. Morgan Freeman’s military storyline is another major issue. The second he enters, Dreamcatcher transforms again. Suddenly we are in helicopters, quarantine camps, mass executions, speeches about alien infections, and a completely different tone. It is not that a military alien containment movie cannot work. It is that this one keeps elbowing the cabin movie, the body horror movie, and the memory warehouse movie out of the frame. The CGI also does the movie no favors. The creatures, the woodland animals, the explosions, the final alien confrontation, so much of it looks too fake to create the dread the movie clearly wants. And then there is the ending, which just stops. After more than two hours of psychic powers, alien parasites, Duddits, Mr. Gray, military conspiracy, childhood trauma, and Boston’s water supply, the movie smash cuts to black like it is fleeing the scene. By the end, Dreamcatcher is still a Low, but it is more interesting than we remembered. It is not a movie with nothing in its head. It is a memory warehouse full of better movies, better Stephen King ideas, and one great concept that deserved a cleaner film around it. The problem is that nobody decided which movie they were actually making. Dreamcatcher 2003 review Lawrence Kasdan’s Dreamcatcher Stephen King’s Dreamcatcher Thomas Jane as Henry Damian Lewis as Jonesy Jason Lee as Beaver Timothy Olyphant as Pete Donnie Wahlberg as Duddits Morgan Freeman in Dreamcatcher Mr. Gray explained Dreamcatcher memory warehouse Dreamcatcher shit weasels Dreamcatcher bathroom scene Stephen King movie adaptations Dreamcatcher and Stand by Me comparisons Dreamcatcher and The Thing comparisons Dreamcatcher CGI problems Dreamcatcher ending explained Why Dreamcatcher failed Dreamcatcher as a guilty pleasure Low

  5. Sep 29

    THE BABADOOK (2014) | The Monster You Keep In The Basement (High)

    We went High on The Babadook, because this is the kind of horror movie that gets scarier the more you sit with it. Jennifer Kent’s The Babadook (2014) is not just about a monster in a top hat with long fingers and a creepy children’s book. It is about the thing you lock in the basement, the thing you refuse to name, and the thing that gets stronger the longer you deny it. That is the central argument of this episode: there is the thing coming for you, and then there is the thing coming from you. The Babadook works because it collapses those two horrors into one. If you want to watch it as a literal boogeyman movie, you can. But for us, it becomes much scarier as a psychological horror story about grief, parental rage, resentment, exhaustion, and the terrifying thoughts good people are not supposed to admit they have. In this episode, we revisit The Babadook, written and directed by Jennifer Kent, starring Essie Davis as Amelia and Noah Wiseman as Samuel. Released in 2014, this is a movie that critics embraced but audiences have always seemed split on. We understand why. This is not comfort horror. This is not a funhouse ride. This is a movie that asks you to sit inside a house with a mother and child who are both drowning in grief, fear, loneliness, and emotional neglect. The story follows Amelia, a widow still haunted by the death of her husband Oscar, who died in a car accident while driving her to the hospital to give birth to Samuel. Six years later, Amelia is barely functioning. Samuel is intense, imaginative, loud, frightened, and obsessed with building weapons to fight monsters. Then a disturbing pop-up book called Mister Babadook appears on their shelf, and once they read it, the thing that has been buried in the house starts clawing its way out. One of our biggest conversations is whether the Babadook is real or whether it is inside Amelia. Our answer is basically yes. The movie is powerful because it refuses to make that separation clean. There may be a supernatural force in the house, but the monster also represents everything Amelia has spent six years refusing to feel: grief, anger, resentment toward her child, exhaustion, guilt, and the taboo thoughts that motherhood does not allow her to say out loud. We talk a lot about Jennifer Kent’s vision and how specific it feels. There is a lesser version of this story that could have been a straightforward domestic drama about an overwhelmed widow on the verge of hurting herself and her child. Instead, Kent gives that internal horror the shape of an old silent-film nightmare: the top hat, the cloak, the long fingers, the stop-motion movement, the German expressionist look. The Babadook feels like something ancient, like a monster that has always existed because the feelings it represents have always existed. The children’s book is one of the movie’s smartest choices. Amelia and Samuel do not buy it. It is not gifted to them. It is just there, sitting on the shelf like it was always in the house. That is the metaphor. The grief was already there. The rage was already there. The book just opens it. The biggest High of the movie is Essie Davis, who gives one of the great modern horror performances. In the first half, she is performing “good mother” with every ounce of strength she has left. She is gentle, patient, soft-spoken, and clearly decaying underneath the mask. We can see the effort it takes to keep the monster down. As the movie goes on, that mask starts cracking. Her line readings become sharper. Her face changes. Her body changes. There are moments where she feels like she is channeling Jack Nicholson in The Shining, especially once the Babadook is fully inside her. But the performance never becomes empty horror-movie madness. It stays rooted in the terrible truth of the character: Amelia loves Samuel, and she is also furious at what his birth is tied to. That contradiction is the movie. We also defend Noah Wiseman as Samuel, because the criticism that he is too loud, shrill, or irritating misses the point. Samuel has to be difficult. If he were a sweet, quiet movie child, the story would not work. His behavior is part of the horror, but it is also a symptom of the house he has grown up in. He is the carbon monoxide detector going off while everyone else keeps blaming the noise. He knows something is wrong before anyone else will admit it. And beneath the screaming, weapons, tantrums, and chaos, Samuel is heartbreaking. He loves his mother. He wants to protect her. The scene where Amelia is choking him and he strokes her face instead of fighting back is devastating. That moment only works because the movie understands Samuel as more than an annoying child. He is scared, traumatized, and still trying to save the only parent he has. We also talk about the importance of Amelia’s support system. Robbie, her coworker, and Mrs. Roach, her neighbor, are small but crucial points of light. Mrs. Roach especially breaks our hearts. She sees Amelia and Samuel with more compassion than Amelia’s own sister does, and her late-night speech, telling Amelia that she loves them and would do anything for them, is one of the few genuinely warm moments in the movie. Our one Low is that the metaphor may become too literal in the third act. When the movie starts behaving more like a possession film, with black sludge, physical attacks, and more conventional supernatural imagery, we can understand why some viewers might feel the internal logic gets shaky. The Babadook is scariest when it is hard to define. But even that Low opens up an interesting question: whose reality are we watching? If the movie shifts between Amelia’s point of view and Samuel’s, the more literal monster imagery starts to make more sense. Maybe Amelia is not literally vomiting black sludge. Maybe that is Samuel’s way of understanding that the bad thing inside his mother is finally coming out. The ending is why this movie becomes great. The Babadook is not destroyed. Amelia feeds it worms in the basement. She manages it. She acknowledges it. She stops pretending it is not there. That is what makes the ending both hopeful and haunting. The monster is still in the house. It just is not in control right now. The Babadook 2014 review Jennifer Kent’s The Babadook Essie Davis as Amelia Noah Wiseman as Samuel Mister Babadook children’s book The Babadook ending explained Is the Babadook real or a metaphor? The Babadook and grief Parental rage in horror movies Motherhood and resentment in The Babadook The Babadook as psychological horror Samuel’s behavior and trauma Amelia’s breakdown The basement symbolism The Babadook and The Shining comparisons Mrs. Roach in The Babadook “The more you deny me” meaning Why The Babadook is still scary

  6. Sep 22

    VIRTUOSITY (1995) | Denzel vs. Russell Crowe in Cyber Hell (Low)

    We went Low on Virtuosity, but this is one of those Lows where the movie is bad in ways that are still weirdly entertaining. Virtuosity (1995) is mid-’90s techno-thriller anxiety blasted through a Windows 95 screensaver: virtual reality, artificial intelligence, nanotechnology, serial killer databases, cyber gobbledygook, regenerative glass skin, and Russell Crowe grinning like he has decided to personally drag the whole movie into cyber hell. That is the central appeal of the episode. Denzel Washington is trying to ground this thing in grief, trauma, guilt, and redemption, while Russell Crowe is playing a homicidal computer program like a theater kid version of Agent Smith. They do not feel like they are in the same movie, and somehow, that is the best thing about the movie. Virtuosity is not good, but it has the kind of cable-movie energy where, if it is on, we are probably not changing the channel. In this episode, we revisit Virtuosity, directed by Brett Leonard and released in 1995, as part of that strange mid-’90s wave of technology thrillers that seemed equally fascinated and terrified by where computers, virtual reality, and the internet were going. This came out the same year as The Net, Hackers, Johnny Mnemonic, and Strange Days, and you can feel that cultural anxiety all over it. The movie is goofy, dated, and often incoherent, but there is something interesting about watching a 1995 movie panic about artificial intelligence escaping its own parameters. The setup is pure high-concept nonsense in the best and worst ways. Denzel Washington plays Parker Barnes, a former cop serving prison time after killing the man who murdered his wife and daughter. He gets pulled into a virtual reality police training program built around SID 6.7, played by Russell Crowe. SID is not just one killer. He is an artificial criminal made from hundreds of murderers, terrorists, psychopaths, and serial killers, including the man who destroyed Parker’s family. Then, through a beautiful pile of mid-’90s nanotech mumbo jumbo, SID gets a synthetic body and escapes into Los Angeles. The biggest High is Russell Crowe. He is enormous in this movie. He preens, dances, grins, poses, and devours every scene like he knows the only way to save Virtuosity is to make it more ridiculous. And honestly, he is right. SID should be over the top. He is artificial. He has no restraint. He is made out of other people’s violence and programmed to treat murder like play. When he says he could kill Parker but likes to play, that is the whole character. He is not trying to win. He is trying to keep the game going. The other High is Denzel Washington, for the exact opposite reason. Denzel does not wink at the material. He does not play Parker Barnes like a man trapped in a goofy sci-fi action movie. He plays him straight, as a guy whose life has been wrecked by real violence and who is now being used by a system that does not care whether he survives. That contrast is where the better version of Virtuosity lives: an artificial villain who only understands violence as entertainment colliding with a real man whose entire life has been shaped by grief. The problem is that the movie never fully builds itself around that collision. It keeps falling back into generic mid-’90s action beats instead of digging into the most interesting idea it has. SID entering the real world should be the movie’s turning point. When he comes out of that strange snake-egg birth pod and says “whoa, gravity,” we get a glimpse of a better movie. He was a digital god inside a simulation, and now he has to deal with weight, pain, temperature, balance, hunger, fear, and maybe even mortality. That could have been fascinating. Instead, the movie cannot decide what SID is once he becomes real. Is he bound by physical reality, forced to learn the rules of the human world? Or is he a cartoon cyber demon with supervillain powers? Virtuosity wants both, which means the rules get fuzzy fast. The movie needed to pick a lane: make him a real serial killer in a real world, or let the entire movie become Russell Crowe’s cyber circus. The biggest Low is how much Virtuosity feels like it is cribbing from Demolition Man. We have a theatrical super-criminal who does not fit the current system, law enforcement dragging a disgraced former cop back into service because he is uniquely equipped to stop him, a near-future bureaucracy overwhelmed by its own technology, and a villain treating the modern world like a playground. The difference is that Demolition Man knows exactly what kind of movie it is. It is confident, satirical, broad, and specific. Virtuosity keeps reaching for that energy without having the same clarity. We also talk about how underwritten the Kelly Lynch character feels, especially the half-hearted attempt to create romantic or emotional tension between her and Parker. The movie gestures toward a surrogate family dynamic with her daughter, played by a young Kaley Cuoco, but it never really earns it. By the end, Parker saving them feels more like genre math than emotional payoff. Another Low is the movie’s vague attempt at media satire. SID takes over a news station, murders people on the air, and the movie tries to say something about audiences being unable to look away from televised violence. That idea should land, especially with a villain made from humanity’s worst impulses. But Virtuosity does not have much to say beyond “people watch violence,” and the live demographic meters tracking viewers by age and income are hilariously silly. By the final act, the movie is borrowing from everything: Demolition Man, The Terminator, Jurassic Park, The Matrix before The Matrix even existed, Last Action Hero, The Lawnmower Man, and whatever Windows 95 visual effects package was lying around. But that is also part of its strange charm. Virtuosity is derivative, messy, and frequently dumb, but Russell Crowe understands the assignment, Denzel gives it a human center, and the contrast between them makes the movie more watchable than it probably deserves to be. Virtuosity 1995 review Brett Leonard’s Virtuosity Denzel Washington as Parker Barnes Russell Crowe as SID 6.7 Virtuosity as a Low episode Mid-’90s technology thrillers Virtual reality in 1990s movies Artificial intelligence in Virtuosity SID 6.7 villain performance Denzel Washington action movies Virtuosity and Demolition Man comparisons Russell Crowe as a cyber serial killer Parker Barnes grief and trauma Nanotechnology in Virtuosity SID 6.7 glass regeneration Virtuosity train hostage scene Kelly Lynch as Madison Carter Kaley Cuoco in Virtuosity Virtuosity news station scene Windows 95 movie aesthetics Virtuosity ending explained Why Virtuosity is a guilty pleasure

  7. Sep 15

    NINE DAYS (2021) | The Masterpiece Nobody Saw (High)

    We went High on Nine Days, but this is a very different kind of High for us. This is not a massive cultural touchstone, a blockbuster, or one of those movies everyone already agrees is a classic. Nine Days (2021) is a small, quiet, underseen film with an enormous idea: what if, before you were born, you had to interview for the chance to live? That premise could have turned into something overly abstract or painfully sentimental, but Edson Oda’s Nine Days does something much more powerful. It uses tube TVs, VHS tapes, one isolated house, and a vast salt flat to ask one of the biggest questions a movie can ask: what makes life worth living? And instead of answering with speeches about destiny or meaning, it answers through small human moments: a peach, a bike ride, a joke at dinner, a scream from the top of a mountain, someone seeing you clearly before you disappear. In this episode, we talk about Nine Days, written and directed by Edson Oda, as one of the best movies almost nobody talks about. The film stars Winston Duke as Will, Zazie Beetz as Emma, Benedict Wong as Kyo, Bill Skarsgård as Kane, Tony Hale as Alexander, Arianna Ortiz as Maria, and David Rysdahl as Mike. It is a high-concept drama with an indie-scale approach, and that combination is exactly why it works. The setup is simple and devastating. Will lives in an isolated house surrounded by salt flats, watching human lives unfold through old television screens. When one of those lives ends, several unborn souls arrive at his door and compete for the chance to be born. Over nine days, Will interviews them, tests them, studies them, and decides which one gets to enter the world. But the longer the process goes on, the more the movie shifts away from the question of who deserves life and toward the question of whether Will can remember why life mattered to him in the first place. We spend a lot of time talking about how original this premise feels, especially now. This is the kind of small, high-concept adult drama that used to have more room in the movie landscape. Today, it feels like films either get made for very little or get inflated into giant franchise products, with almost nothing in the middle. Nine Days feels like it belongs to that missing middle: thoughtful, emotional, strange, ambitious, and built for adults who want a movie to sit with them after it ends. One of the biggest Highs is the movie’s minimalism. It could have buried itself in explanations about heaven, purgatory, angels, souls, or the mechanics of the afterlife. Instead, it keeps the world grounded and almost mundane. Will and Kyo have a job. There are groceries. There are reports. There are tapes. There are TVs stacked in a little house. That normalcy makes the otherworldly elements feel more haunting, not less. The movie does not need glowing portals or enormous visual effects. Its mystery works because it stays intimate. We also talk about the POV footage on the televisions. The idea that Will watches lives from the inside, through each person’s direct experience, is beautiful and immersive. It makes life feel both ordinary and miraculous. The movie finds meaning in the images that pass by quietly in the background, which is really the whole point. Most of life is not the big defining event. Most of life is the stuff we barely notice while it is happening. The performances are another huge High. Winston Duke has to play Will as buttoned-up, clinical, wounded, and deeply compassionate all at once. He is detached because he has to be, but we can feel how much the work is destroying him. Every time he recreates a final wish for one of the souls who is not selected, the movie becomes almost unbearably tender. He is there to comfort them before they disappear, and then he breaks when they are gone. Zazie Beetz as Emma is the soul of the movie. Emma represents the thing Will has forgotten: curiosity, presence, openness, and awe. She shows up late because she is probably looking at the sky, the ground, the light, the air, and everything around her. She does not play the interview game the way Will wants her to. She asks questions. She notices things. She eats a peach not because she is hungry, but because she can. That is the whole movie right there. The central debate of the episode is whether Will makes the right choice. He chooses Kane because he believes Kane is better equipped to survive the harshness of the world. Will sees Emma’s openness as a kind of vulnerability, maybe even a fatal one. He is not trying to be cruel. He is trying to protect the world from swallowing another person like him. But that is what makes the choice so heartbreaking. Emma may not be armored, but she might be exactly what the world needs more of. She refuses to argue why someone else should not live. She refuses to turn existence into a competition built on tearing another person down. To Will, that means she is not ready. To us, it might mean she understands life better than anyone else in the room. We also talk about the ending, which is perfect. Emma’s final request is not for Will to create a fantasy for her. It is for him to perform the monologue from the one moment in his own life when he felt seen. When he recites Walt Whitman’s “Song of Myself” across the salt flats, the movie reveals that Emma’s gift to him is remembrance. She reminds him of the joy he once had, the art he once loved, and the life he has spent years reducing to a job. Our one Low is small but worth discussing. Late in the movie, another interviewer arrives with information that confirms Amanda’s death was suicide. We understand why the movie does it, because it gives Will a clear trigger for his spiral, but part of us thinks the uncertainty might have been stronger. Not knowing would have left Will trapped in the same painful space the audience is in: trying to make peace with something that cannot be fully explained. Still, Nine Days is a High because it is generous in a way very few movies are. It deals with grief, suicide, loneliness, and the terror of not getting the life you hoped for, but it is not really a movie about death. It is a movie about why life matters. It asks us to sit with pain, then gives us gratitude. Nine Days 2021 review Edson Oda’s Nine Days Winston Duke as Will Zazie Beetz as Emma Benedict Wong as Kyo Bill Skarsgård as Kane Tony Hale as Alexander Nine Days movie ending explained Nine Days as an underseen indie film Auditioning for life in Nine Days Tube TVs and VHS tapes in Nine Days Salt flats cinematography Nine Days and the meaning of life Emma’s final request Walt Whitman Song of Myself scene Will and Amanda’s death Grief and suicide in Nine Days Why life is worth living Small moments in Nine Days Nine Days as a high-concept adult drama

  8. Sep 8

    THE PRESTIGE (2006) | Nolan's Secret Hiding in Plain Sight (High)

    We went High on The Prestige, and this is one of those Highs where the movie almost feels built for this podcast. Christopher Nolan’s The Prestige (2006) is not just a movie about magic. It is a movie constructed like a magic trick, and the more you watch it, the more you realize Nolan has been showing you the secret from the beginning. He tells you what the trick is, puts the evidence in front of your face, and then waits for you to notice. That is why this movie keeps getting better every time we return to it. The secret impresses no one. It is the trick you use it for. That line is the whole philosophy of the movie. The Prestige is about obsession, performance, sacrifice, ego, grief, rivalry, and the terrible things people will do to be the one left standing when the audience applauds. In this episode, we revisit The Prestige, directed by Christopher Nolan, starring Christian Bale as Alfred Borden, Hugh Jackman as Robert Angier, Michael Caine as Cutter, Rebecca Hall as Sarah, Scarlett Johansson as Olivia, and David Bowie as Nikola Tesla. This is one of Dom’s favorite Nolan movies, and honestly, the case is not hard to make. It has everything Nolan does best: fractured timelines, obsessed protagonists, nested mysteries, a final reveal that changes the whole movie, and an ending that does not stop asking questions after the credits roll. The first big idea we talk about is that The Prestige is Christopher Nolan’s love letter to filmmaking. The three parts of a magic trick, the pledge, the turn, and the prestige, are basically the three acts of a movie. You show the audience something ordinary. You transform it into something impossible. Then you bring it back in a way that makes them wonder how you did it. Nolan understands endings better than almost anyone, and this movie is almost entirely built around the power of a final act that makes you immediately want to start the movie over. We also talk about how the opening image of the top hats in the woods becomes a perfect bookend with the final image of Angier’s bodies in the tanks. The movie begins with duplicates, death, and a mystery we do not yet understand. Then it slowly teaches us how to read what we have already seen. That is the magic trick. The movie is not hiding the secret so much as daring us to look closely enough. The performances are a huge High. Christian Bale has one of the most difficult jobs in the film because, on first viewing, he has to play Borden as a man divided by his own nature. On rewatch, once you know the truth, you realize he is playing two different men sharing one life. That makes every scene with Sarah more painful. When she says, “You don’t mean it today,” the line works one way the first time and a completely different way once you understand the trick. She is not married to a complicated man. She is married to a lie that keeps changing shape. That is where the movie’s emotional cost really lands. Sarah is not part of the trick by choice. She is collateral damage. She knows something is wrong, even if she cannot name it. The tragedy is that the person she loves is only partly available to her, and sometimes not even the right person at all. The same goes for Julia, Angier’s wife, whose death becomes the wound that drives the rivalry. These women are where the men’s obsession lands, and the movie is very clear that the cost of greatness, ego, and secrecy is not only paid by the men chasing applause. Hugh Jackman is just as strong as Angier because his performance shifts so carefully. At first, Angier feels like the more sympathetic character. He loses his wife in a horrible accident, and his anger at Borden makes emotional sense. But as the movie goes on, he becomes the more frightening figure. He is the showman who cannot invent the trick, so he steals, sabotages, and eventually builds his entire life around beating Borden. Jackman also gets to play Root, the drunken double, and that performance lets the movie show its own form of cinematic magic right on screen. We also get into Michael Caine as Cutter, who functions as the engineer, the conscience, and the father figure of the movie. His final confrontation with Angier is devastating because he realizes how deeply he has been used. When he tells Angier that the sailor who almost drowned lied, that drowning was not peaceful, that it was agony, the line reframes every version of Angier’s trick. It is one thing to build an illusion. It is another thing to build it out of repeated death. Then there is David Bowie as Tesla, which is almost too perfect. Tesla feels mythical before he even appears, and Bowie brings exactly the right strangeness to him. The Tesla and Edison rivalry mirrors Borden and Angier beautifully. Borden is the craftsman and illusionist. Angier is the showman. Tesla is the visionary. Edison is the man who knows how to sell the future. The whole movie is about incomplete men trying to steal the missing piece from someone else. The biggest debate in the episode is not whether the movie works. It clearly works. The real question is how many secrets the movie is actually carrying. Every rewatch turns into a game of figuring out which Borden we are watching, what Sarah truly understands, how much Cutter knows, and whether Angier ever really understood the cost of what he was doing. Our one Low is barely a Low. It is a nitpick about Tesla’s machine. The movie seems to establish that the machine creates a duplicate roughly 50 yards away, with the hats and the cat appearing outside the workshop. But when Angier first uses it, the duplicate appears close enough for him to shoot at point-blank range. It is probably done for visual clarity and storytelling economy, but in a movie this carefully built, even a tiny rule inconsistency stands out. Still, that is us looking for a flaw because we legally have to pretend the movie has one. The Prestige is a High because it is not just clever. It is emotional, cruel, elegant, and endlessly rewatchable. It is a movie about incomplete people, and maybe that is why it never feels completely finished in your head. Nolan shows us the trick. He tells us the secret. Then he leaves us wondering why we still wanted to be fooled. The Prestige 2006 review Christopher Nolan’s The Prestige Christian Bale as Alfred Borden Hugh Jackman as Robert Angier Michael Caine as Cutter Rebecca Hall as Sarah Scarlett Johansson as Olivia David Bowie as Nikola Tesla The Prestige ending explained The pledge, the turn and the prestige “Are you watching closely?” Borden and Fallon twist Angier and the Tesla machine Robert Angier’s clones The Transported Man trick Borden vs Angier rivalry Sarah and the cost of obsession Cutter’s “it was agony” reveal Tesla and Edison rivalry The Prestige as Nolan’s best movie Movie magic and magic tricks Why The Prestige gets better on rewatch

Ratings & Reviews

5
out of 5
3 Ratings

About

Movie HighLow is a movie review and film analysis podcast about the best, worst, and weirdest movies cinema has to offer. Each episode, we revisit iconic films, cult classics, Hollywood disasters, bad movie masterpieces, and misunderstood flops to find the HIGHS, the LOWS, and the moments that deserve a second look. Some movies are great. Some are terrible. Some are both. From iconic classics to fascinating disasters, we’re here to figure out why. Film analysis • Movie breakdowns • Movie reviews • High vs Low • Film podcast

You Might Also Like