So Supernatural

4.6 (22K)
SOCIETY & CULTURE
UPDATED WEEKLY

Most mysteries can be solved by looking at the facts. But sometimes, the truth lies somewhere in the unknown… Enter the realm of true crime’s most bizarre occurrences, and unravel all the possible explanations. No matter how strange or surreal they get.

4D AGO

From Root of Evil to So Supernatural: AMA with Rasha & Yvette

Surprise! In this bonus AMA, Rasha and Yvette answer your questions – from honoring the legacy of their mom, Fauna Hodel, to sharing the supernatural moments that shaped their lives. Come for the stories, stay for the sisterhood… and just a touch of the mystical!

42 min
APR 11

LEGEND: La Llorona

La Llorona – a haunting figure from Latin folklore – is said to be a ghostly spirit who wanders rivers and waterways, searching for her lost children. With her mournful cries and chilling presence, La Llorona serves as a cautionary tale of maternal love, loss, and the consequences of betrayal. But some believe “The Weeping Woman” is very real and very threatening…

33 min
APR 4

ALIEN: UFOs in the Hudson Valley

Since at least the 1980s, the Hudson Valley area of New York has been a hotspot for UFO activity. Here, various crafts have been spotted by hundreds of people, leading many to wonder what's so special about this part of the United States. Some think that underground cave systems might be drawing UFOs in. But with the recent unexplained drone activity, it's possible we may have answers sooner rather than later.

42 min
MAR 28

DARK WEB: Cicada 3301

In 2012, a series of complex puzzles appeared on the website known as 4Chan. Thousands took to the forums, trying to crack the codes and riddles written by an author known only as Cicada 3301. Some believed the puzzles were a recruitment tool for an unknown organization, others said they were part of a global cult. And while few have seen behind the curtain, even those who have solved the puzzles still aren't sure who or what Cicada 3301 is – or what their ultimate goals are.

34 min
MAR 21

DISAPPEARED: The Carroll A. Deering

In 1921, Carroll A. Deering, a five-mastered schooner, was found run aground off Cape Hatteras in North Carolina. While the ship was completely abandoned with no sign of the crew – there were other eerier signs something bizarre had happened. Theories about the crew's fate involved everything from piracy, to mutiny, to falling victim to the Bermuda Triangle.

37 min
MAR 18

INTRODUCING: Killer Minds

Formerly known as Mind of A Serial Killer, Killer Minds takes you deep into the psychology of history’s most chilling murderers—from infamous serial killers to ruthless cult leaders, deadly exes, and terrifying spree killers. Every Monday and Thursday, hosts Vanessa Richardson and Dr. Tristin Engels, a Clinical and Forensic Psychologist, blend gripping true crime storytelling with expert psychological analysis to uncover what drives people to kill. From the calculated minds of serial killers like Jeffrey Dahmer and Ted Bundy to crimes of passion and cold-blooded murders, Killer Minds goes beyond the headlines to explore the twisted psychology behind the crimes. What fuels their darkness? How do their minds work? And most hauntingly—could they have been stopped?

9 min
MAR 14

THE UNKNOWN: Taos Hum

Beginning in the early 90s, residents of Taos, New Mexico, began noticing a mysterious and constant hum. While the sound was perceived differently by everyone – all the residents who could hear it agreed – it was loud, disturbing, and driving them mad. Despite an extensive investigation, the source of the hum remains unknown, but theories range from psychological, to government experiment, to spiritual forces.

38 min
MAR 7

LEGEND: Black Eyed Children

For decades, people have reported being visited by Black Eyed Children who mysteriously appear unannounced on their doorstep, or trying to get into their vehicles. The encounters don't just leave people feeling uneasy or paranoid – they often cause bad luck and even leave physical symptoms like sudden illness. While their origins are unknown, many suspect they might be tied to demonology, or may even come from off planet.

35 min

See All (136)

4.6

out of 5

21,945 Ratings

Love the hosts

Apr 11

TTORRES.TR

The new so supernatural is great and I love how much more information is given. Finished listening to La Llorona and it’s so nice to hear them pronounce her name right and speak Spanish good! I also loved the night marchers episode too! You can tell it was close to the girls hearts. :)
New hosts ruin it for me

3d ago

ssull36

I have to agree with others. This was my husband and I’s favorite podcasts when Ashley hosted, and we were SO sad when she stopped. When I saw it was started back up we were seriously so excited, but I honestly just can’t get through any of the new episodes. The personal stories and little banter back and forth is so staged and feels forced. We still listen to the podcast all the time, but only the old episodes where Ashley is the narrator.
Is this real?

3d ago

Goldpackage23

Wait! Do these new hosts really think people want to hear about their personal lives? They were supposed to take the week off but they couldn’t resist getting back on the podcast to talk about themselves? And a whole episode of it?
Will no longer listen due to baseless weather conspiracies.

4d ago

LavenderHurricane

Thoroughly enjoyed the podcast until the April 4th 2025 episode Aliens in the Hudson Valley when the hosts decided to push weather related conspiracy theories on listeners. In this day and age when science (especially meteorology) is under attack pushing baseless conspiracy theories is dangerous and harmful. Fog forms in winter it is as simple as that. There is no conspiracy theory it was just fog. I’ve listened to this show since the original run but I’m unfollowing and will no longer be listening. I cannot support a show that encourages baseless conspiracy theories that only increase distrust in scientists.

Most mysteries can be solved by looking at the facts. But sometimes, the truth lies somewhere in the unknown… Enter the realm of true crime’s most bizarre occurrences, and unravel all the possible explanations. No matter how strange or surreal they get.