All Consuming Podcast

Gary and Tyler
  • 5.0 (21)
  • MUSIC COMMENTARY
  • UPDATED BIWEEKLY

Two best buds talking about their favorite bands, live shows, and albums in the Christian Heavy Music scene.

  1. Interview: Propositions

    4D AGO

    Interview: Propositions

    On this episode of All Consuming Podcast, we hang out with Justin from Propositions to talk about his new song “Death Plan” featuring Unworthy. Justin breaks down what it looks like to be the one-man force behind Propositions, writing the riffs, vocals, bass, drums, and bringing songs as far as he can before handing them off for that final production push. We also get into the origin of Propositions, how grief and loss helped push him toward creating heavy music, and how bands like Pipebomb helped him realize he could build something powerful on his own. The main focus of the episode is “Death Plan”, a heavy, deathcore-leaning track centered on the death, burial, and resurrection of Jesus. Justin talks about the song’s meaning, how the title came from his son, and how the feature grew from a vocal spot into having most of Unworthy involved in the track. We also talk about Christian heavy music, bold gospel-centered lyrics, the difference between being a Christian band and Christians in a band, the Heavy Collective, group shouts, dream tours, Bloodlines, Sleeping Giant, Holy Name, and why this scene still feels like a place where worship and heavy music can collide in a real way. Stream “Death Plan” by Propositions featuring Unworthy, and then come hang out with us for the conversation behind it.

    1h 4m
  2. Dead Poetic - New Medicines

    MAY 5

    Dead Poetic - New Medicines

    Gary gives Tyler homework: listen to three songs from Dead Poetic’s New Medicines and come ready to talk. In this episode of All Consuming Podcast, we dig into one of Gary’s favorite albums, why New Medicines stood out in the Tooth & Nail and Solid State era, and whether Dead Poetic fits the “Christian band” label or something more like Christians making music. We also get into the bigger conversation around what we consume, how music shapes us, parenting kids through music choices, Warped Tour-era sing/scream bands, comparisons to Underoath, Emery, Saosin, Chiodos, and why Taste the Red Hands is such a killer album opener. Tyler may not be a full Dead Poetic convert yet, but he walks away with a new respect for the album. Songs discussed: “New Medicines,” “Taste the Red Hands,” and “Vanus Empty.”

    56 min
  3. New Metal vs Old Metal: AI, Graphic Album Art, Trampolines?

    APR 14

    New Metal vs Old Metal: AI, Graphic Album Art, Trampolines?

    Most bands start faltering after a decade + in the game—unless they're on this episode! Lets jump into the latest metalcore heaters from August Burns Red, Haste the Day, Impending Doom, and Idle Threat! We also explore the world of AI-generated bands and overly graphic and violent art in Christian metal. Revealing how technology might reshape the scene—good or bad.

    50 min
  4. Cold Streets

    JAN 22

    Cold Streets

    In this episode, Tyler and Gary sit down with pop-punk band Cold Streets to talk about how the band formed out of longtime friendships, shared faith, and a love for early-2000s punk influences like MXPX, Relient K, and Blink-182. The band discusses their songwriting process, the making of their new single “Over and Over” and its music video, and how their sound naturally leans toward nostalgic, melodic punk. They also share plans for their first full-length album, reflect on what it means to be Christians in a band without labeling themselves a “Christian band,” and keep the conversation light with stories about tours, influences, and fandom moments.

    1h 24m
  5. Christmas Special 2025

    12/13/2025

    Christmas Special 2025

    Gary and Tyler build a Christmas playlist! From heavy covers and punk tracks to unexpected classics, they talk through what works, what surprises them, and why these songs stand out. It’s a casual holiday conversation, full of music picks, opinions, and Christmas vibes.#Elmo #metalcore #classic #hiphop #punk #rock #Skillet #metalchristmas #Rosieodonnell

    44 min
  6. 2010 Album Draft

    11/06/2025

    2010 Album Draft

    Gary and Tyler are joined by Chris from For The Rock and Michael from Diatheke for a special album draft episode! Each host builds their ultimate lineup of 2010 Christian heavy music albums—but only one can come out on top. Tune in for stories from 2010, plenty of laughs, and a nostalgic trip through one of the wildest years in heavy music history.

    1h 35m
  7. Interview: David and Jon of Hope Deferred

    10/06/2025

    Interview: David and Jon of Hope Deferred

    Gary and guest co-host Chris (from For The Rock) sit down with David Bunton and Jon Tooley of the Death Metal band "Hope Deferred". They dive into musical influences, how the band formed, the role their faith plays in writing music and the evolution of their sound from their previous bands (Embodiment, The Famine, and The Showdown). Takeaways David's gateway band was MXPX, leading him to the heavy scene.Jon's introduction to heavy music was through Cannibal Corpse in Ace Ventura.Hope Deferred was formed from a desire to create music together.The band members have a rich history in the heavy music scene.Lyrically, the band aims to be bold and clear about their faith.The name 'Hope Deferred' is inspired by a biblical passage.The band embraces their Christian identity without apology.They aim to mix heavy music with meaningful lyrical content.The band is excited to perform live and share their music with audiences. The upcoming single 'Brethren of Blood' drops on October 15th.Balancing music with family and careers is a challenge for many musicians.The importance of supporting underground bands is emphasized.Future plans include potential live shows and more music releases.Family involvement in music can be a rewarding experience.The conversation highlights the joy of creating music for the love of it.

    1h 6m

  8. 08/01/2025

    Core Values | 31 - New music, old music

    In this lively and deeply nostalgic episode of All Consuming Podcast, the hosts catch up on long-overdue shoutouts, swap hilarious stories (including one about a cat-poop-eating dog), and dive deep into the evolving landscape of Christian metal and hardcore music. The discussion weaves through classic pop-punk nostalgia with bands like Hawk Nelson to heavier sounds from bands like We Came As Romans, 6 feet deep, and Big Boy. The hosts reflect on how their tastes have changed—moving away from overproduced metalcore toward raw, emotional hardcore—and share a strong appreciation for the authenticity and grit in bands like The Wounds That Speak, a newer Christian metalcore band from Colorado with a powerfully gospel-centered message. Also highlighted are newer releases from Wolves at the Gate and Confessions of a Traitor, along with a nostalgic mention of Phinehas’ album The Fire Itself as a standout example of true modern metalcore. Expect laughs, laments, and lots of genre talk—plus a passionate encore shoutout to Six Feet Deep. If you’re a fan of raw, honest Christian heavy music, this episode is for you!

    40 min
See All (96)

5
out of 5
21 Ratings

About

Two best buds talking about their favorite bands, live shows, and albums in the Christian Heavy Music scene.

Information

  • Creator
    Gary and Tyler
  • Years Active
    2020 - 2026
  • Episodes
    96
  • Rating
    Clean
  • Copyright
    © Gary and Tyler
  • Show Website
    All Consuming Podcast

You Might Also Like