Puzzling: A True Crime Podcast

Tiffany Epp

Sarah, Tiffany, and Bailey take a deep dive into the most puzzling true crime cases, taking you for a wild adventure. Listen along to hear fun friendship banter, some truly insane stories, and facts that will make you question your existence. They try to take on lesser-known cases to bring awareness and justice to those who have been otherwise overlooked.

  1. 06/07/2023

    57. Tristyn Bailey

    This week Sarah talks about the actual senseless murder of 13 year old Tristyn Bailey. All murders are senseless, but this one hits a bit different on the senseless aspect. Listen in to understand what we mean by that! SOCIALS: Instagram: @puzzlingpod Facebook: Puzzling Podcast Gmail: puzzlingpod@gmail.com Tiffany’s Instagram: @tiffeppxo Sarah's Instagram: @sarahmariepierce EMAIL: to send suggestions to! puzzlingpod@gmail.com VENMO: @puzzlingpod

    49 min

  2. 05/24/2023

    56. Anthony Allen Shore

    Well, this guy SUCKS. Like seriously, royally sucks. They all do so here I am, trying to come up with a description just like every other week. Idk man, just listen and find out why he sucks so bad. You'll hate him as much as we do, for sure. SOCIALS: Instagram: @puzzlingpod Facebook: Puzzling Podcast Gmail: puzzlingpod@gmail.com Tiffany’s Instagram: @tiffeppxo Sarah's Instagram: @sarahmariepierce EMAIL: to send suggestions to! puzzlingpod@gmail.com VENMO: @puzzlingpod

    1h 2m

  3. 05/11/2023

    55. Jeff, Jason, and Jesse

    Every week we think that we come across the most senseless crime. Every week we are speechless. Every week it's hard to understand what the "worst crime" is because they're all senseless and horrible. Listen in to understand what we mean by this. SOCIALS: Instagram: @puzzlingpod Facebook: Puzzling Podcast Gmail: puzzlingpod@gmail.com Tiffany’s Instagram: @tiffeppxo Sarah's Instagram: @sarahmariepierce EMAIL: to send suggestions to! puzzlingpod@gmail.com VENMO: @puzzlingpod

    1h 31m

  4. 05/04/2023

    54. Rayna Rison

    Welcome back! This week Tiffany tells you the tragic story of yet another useless person ending the life of an absolutely beautiful soul. This young woman had already been through enough by the time this monster took her from the world. SOCIALS: Instagram: @puzzlingpod Facebook: Puzzling Podcast Gmail: puzzlingpod@gmail.com Tiffany’s Instagram: @tiffeppxo Sarah's Instagram: @sarahmariepierce EMAIL: to send suggestions to! puzzlingpod@gmail.com VENMO: @puzzlingpod

    54 min

  5. 04/26/2023

    53. Christina Benjamin and James *Brian* King

    This week Sarah talks about yet another absolutely senseless and horrendous crime that happened against 2 young children. Be warned, this is not for the faint of heart, unfortunately. Just like the Tiffany's, we understand if you now hate the name Jason. SOCIALS: Instagram: @puzzlingpod Facebook: Puzzling Podcast Gmail: puzzlingpod@gmail.com Tiffany’s Instagram: @tiffeppxo Sarah's Instagram: @sarahmariepierce EMAIL: to send suggestions to! puzzlingpod@gmail.com VENMO: @puzzlingpod

    1h 33m

  6. 04/21/2023

    52. Terrible Tiffanys

    This week Tiffany tells you 2 horrendous stories of murderers named Tiffany. I get if you hate the name now, it's fair. So many lives lost that did not need to be. Listen in to see why even Tiffany is ashamed to have the name! SOCIALS: Instagram: @puzzlingpod Facebook: Puzzling Podcast Gmail: puzzlingpod@gmail.com Tiffany’s Instagram: @tiffeppxo Sarah's Instagram: @sarahmariepierce EMAIL: to send suggestions to! puzzlingpod@gmail.com VENMO: @puzzlingpod

    1h 12m

  7. 04/12/2023

    51. Sinister Sarahs

    Sorry for the late episode! Life got ahead of us and we were unable to record on time. This week Sarah brings you 2 tales of 2 different Sarah's who were both murdering during the same time frame in the late 1800's. Both are serial killers who used poison as their weapon of choice. SOCIALS: Instagram: @puzzlingpod Facebook: Puzzling Podcast Gmail: puzzlingpod@gmail.com Tiffany’s Instagram: @tiffeppxo Sarah's Instagram: @sarahmariepierce EMAIL: to send suggestions to! puzzlingpod@gmail.com VENMO: @puzzlingpod

    2h 5m

  8. 04/04/2023

    50. William Reece

    Remember last weeks episode when Sarah talked about the tragic murder of a young woman named Sarah? Well, this week Tiffany took on the task to find the tragic murder of a young girl named Tiffany. Only this weeks.... had a lot more in store for us than expected. Listen in to hear about the senseless and terrible true crime stories of multiple young women. P.s. We don't like to name our episodes after the murderer. However, when it is a serial killer it is more logical to put the name of the killer instead of trying to listen every victims name in the title. If you have any information about any of these young women, please reach out to us at puzzlingpod@gmail.com so we can tell their stories better. SOCIALS: Instagram: @puzzlingpod Facebook: Puzzling Podcast Gmail: puzzlingpod@gmail.com Tiffany’s Instagram: @tiffeppxo Sarah's Instagram: @sarahmariepierce EMAIL: to send suggestions to! puzzlingpod@gmail.com

    1h 37m
See All (47)

5
out of 5
20 Ratings

About

Sarah, Tiffany, and Bailey take a deep dive into the most puzzling true crime cases, taking you for a wild adventure. Listen along to hear fun friendship banter, some truly insane stories, and facts that will make you question your existence. They try to take on lesser-known cases to bring awareness and justice to those who have been otherwise overlooked.

Information