TL;DR: Season 1 - hearing the sound of grass growing/paint drying is a better listen; Season 2 - very interesting story, presented in a 3d but (too) fast manner.
Season 1 should be renamed to "the factual opinion of an art critic's opinions on a tragedy". The tragedy being presented is incredibly interesting, rather unresolved, and is multifaceted at any point in time, and also, across the decades that have past. However, the host used it as a platform to share her opinion as if it were fact, on events and cultures she didn't live, times that she didn't participate, and sullying the narration of the people directly involved. There's a awkward few times that she directly inserts herself into it (eg looping an audio clip of her getting fired), or presents situations as only existing on some linear social justice dimension she's inventing in her head... which often felt like it was at the expense of the story that women, minorites, victims, and other intersectionalities, had wanted to have their voices and experiences heard on. Each episode was a slog, until the anticipated peak moment of the season — a direct confirmation with the season's antagonist. Which ended up being her going into his building and explaining to the building's doorman that she wants to go knock on this guy's door but she thinks she's not allowed to and he probably doesn't want to talk to her, and after explaining all this to the doorman, asks if she can write a note to him and have the doorman ask him if he wanted the note at some point. This tragedy could have been it's own entire podcast, but ends up being the backdrop for the aggrandizement of the hosts opinions in season 1.
Season 2 on the other hand, is the exact opposite experience! The new host zooms in and out of various points of the tragedy, life, and storyline, that weave together not just the death of an artist, but its place in its time, its movement, but also those around him. However, it all felt much too fast and I'm stuck between thinking that I wanted to hear way more, vs the short allocated runtime of the season can't satisfactorily cover so many dimensions. It wasn't hurried in the sense of corners being cut, but hurried cause we're covering so many bases and the host is also working on how to cohesively tie these aspects together, all in the same half hour or so time budget per episode!