2 Giant Goofballs: A NY Giants Podcast

Drew & Rob

Looking for a hilarious and informative podcast about the New York Giants? 2 Giant Goofballs has got you covered! Hosted by Drew and Rob, this podcast offers insightful analysis, lively debates, and plenty of laughs. With their infectious personalities and quick wit, Drew and Rob make discussing the latest Giants news and games an absolute blast. Whether you're a die-hard fan or just tuning in for the fun, 2 Giant Goofballs is the perfect way to stay up-to-date on all things Big Blue. So join the conversation today and see why this is one of the best NY Giants podcasts around!

  1. NY Giants Mock Draft - Stay at 5 or Trade Back?

    2D AGO

    NY Giants Mock Draft - Stay at 5 or Trade Back?

    Staying at No. 5 gives the Giants a shot at premium talent like Caleb Downs, but it sacrifices the extra picks that could patch multiple holes across the roster. Trading back creates flexibility and depth, but what if moving down costs them the cleanest difference-maker on the board at No. 5? Follow on Spotify so you don’t miss the next episode, and if you listen on Apple, leave a 5-star rating and review to help more Giants fans find the show. Drew and Rob run two full Giants mock drafts in this episode, and the whole argument keeps coming back to one question: is patience at No. 5 the smart move, or is staying put actually the wrong bet for a roster with too many holes to ignore? In the no-trade version, they work through the uncomfortable reality that the top of the board may offer high-end talent that still does not feel like a perfect fit. That leads to a real debate around Caleb Downs, Jeremiah Love, team needs, and whether helping the defense or helping Jaxson Dart matters more if the Giants refuse to move. The conversation is messy in the best way, because the value is clear but the fit is not. Then the trade version changes the tone of the whole show. Once they move off No. 5 and start stacking extra capital, the board opens up and the mock feels more like a real roster-building plan. That path lets them come away with Mansoor Delane at corner, Denzel Boston at receiver, Christian Miller and Lee Hunter up front, and more depth pieces later in the draft. It also sharpens the biggest takeaway from the episode: the Giants may be better off turning one premium slot into multiple answers instead of forcing a pick just because they are sitting in the top five. There is a lot of back-and-forth in here, plenty of live-chat influence, some classic Drew-and-Rob arguing over timing and tiebreakers, and a real push-pull between best player available and biggest need. Should the Giants trust the board and make the cleanest pick at No. 5, or should they attack the draft by moving around and fixing more of the roster at once? And if the trade-down path produces a fuller class, is staying put too costly even if the top talent looks better on paper? Merch: https://2giantgoofballs-shop.fourthwall.com/ Support: https://buymeacoffee.com/2giantgoofballs All episodes: https://2giantgoofballs.buzzsprout.com/ Send us Fan Mail Support the show

    1h 6m
  2. OBJ, JPP & Giants Nostalgia Debate: Smart or Stuck?

    3D AGO

    OBJ, JPP & Giants Nostalgia Debate: Smart or Stuck?

    The Giants get the buzz that comes with Odell Beckham Jr. and Jason Pierre-Paul resurfacing, but the cost is obvious — attention shifts away from building the next era and back toward players who are no longer what they once were. Is even entertaining these reunions a smart move, or is it exactly how teams get stuck repeating the past? Follow the show on Spotify so you never miss an episode, and if you’re listening on Apple, drop a 5-star rating and review to help more Giants fans find us. This episode turns into a full debate on whether the Giants are truly moving forward or still getting pulled backward by familiar names. OBJ meeting with John Harbaugh in Arizona sparks the annual cycle of speculation, but the reality discussed here is simple: he hasn’t played in a year, hasn’t produced in multiple seasons, and would not be walking into a meaningful role. Would bringing him back actually help the roster, or just bring the circus back to East Rutherford? The same conversation extends to Jason Pierre-Paul, who publicly said he’s ready to return. The numbers don’t support it. He’s played just six games over the last three seasons and logged minimal snaps. At what point does respect for what a player once was stop outweighing what they currently are? That question becomes the center of the episode. Beyond the nostalgia debate, the show breaks down the Giants’ offseason decisions and what they say about the direction of the roster. The mystery linebacker trade is revealed to be Drue Tranquill, leading to a discussion about whether the Giants made the right call sticking with Tremaine Edmunds instead of giving up draft capital. D.J. Davidson’s departure to Washington is covered as a depth loss, along with Isaiah Likely taking over the No. 9 jersey after Graham Gano’s release. The conversation also shifts to ownership, with Roger Goodell confirming Steve Tisch is no longer an owner after transferring his stake, while still remaining tied to the organization in a leadership role. Is that enough separation, or does it raise more questions than it answers? Finally, the episode closes with a full reaction to Matt Miller’s seven-round mock draft, including Caleb Downs at No. 5 and KC Concepcion in Round 2. The debate centers on whether taking a safety that high is justified in this class and whether the Giants are prioritizing the right positions as they try to build a competitive roster. Merch: https://2giantgoofballs-shop.fourthwall.com/ Support: https://buymeacoffee.com/2giantgoofballs All episodes: https://2giantgoofballs.buzzsprout.com/ Send us Fan Mail Support the show

    41 min
  3. Giants Hot Seat Debate: WhoCould Be Gone After 2026?

    5D AGO

    Giants Hot Seat Debate: WhoCould Be Gone After 2026?

    Cutting Graham Gano gives the Giants cap relief, but the bigger price is that it throws a brighter light on a roster full of players now fighting to prove they still belong in the long-term plan. If 2026 is really the prove-it year Drew and Rob say it is, which Giants are actually safe? Follow 2 Giants Goofballs on Spotify so you do not miss the next episode, and if you listen on Apple Podcasts, leave a 5-star rating and review to help more Giants fans find the show. This episode starts with the expected Graham Gano move and what it says about where the Giants are right now, but the heart of the show is the 2026 hot-seat debate. Drew and Rob go player by player through the roster and ask which names are entering a year that could decide whether they stay part of this team, slide into backup roles, or start running out of NFL runway entirely. Darius Slayton comes up first, with a real debate about whether his years of overachieving can survive one more season in a more crowded room. Theo Johnson gets put under the microscope for the same reason Giants fans keep getting stuck on him: the route running and flashes are there, but the drops keep turning opportunity into frustration. Andrew Thomas is the bigger-money version of that pressure conversation, because when he is healthy he changes the entire line, but if the injuries pile up again the questions will get louder whether anyone likes it or not. John Runyan Jr. and John Michael Schmitz also get framed exactly the way the show sees them now: not disasters, not long-term locks, just two linemen entering a season where “okay” might not be enough. The defensive side gets even more uncomfortable. Dexter Lawrence is still treated with respect, but the episode leans into the hard version of the question: if the production does not bounce back, how long do the Giants keep paying elite-money for something short of elite impact? Micah McFadden gets the prove-it treatment as well, because this year may decide whether he is viewed as a real starter or more of a useful rotational piece. In the secondary, Paulson Adebo, Deonte Banks, Tyler Nubin, and Jevon Holland all get hit from different angles, whether it is contract value, lack of ball production, poor coverage play, or the risk of getting jumped by cheaper competition. Drew and Rob do touch on the owners meetings, John Mara being there, John Harbaugh’s comments, the OBJ noise, and the low-risk swings on Evan Neal and Joshua Ezeudu, but those are supporting stories. The real episode is the Giants hot-seat conversation and the stakes attached to it. Which players are still pillars, which ones are hanging by a thread, and which ones may already be closer to the exit than fans want to admit? Merch: https://2giantgoofballs-shop.fourthwall.com/ Support: https://buymeacoffee.com/2giantgoofballs All episodes: https://2giantgoofballs.buzzsprout.com/ Send us Fan Mail Support the show

    1h 4m
  4. Top 10 WRs: Which WR Is Worth No. 5 for Giants?

    MAR 27

    Top 10 WRs: Which WR Is Worth No. 5 for Giants?

    If the Giants use No. 5 on a wide receiver, they could give Jaxson Dart another real weapon and find the best complement to Malik Nabers. But if this class is as tight from WR1 through WR5 as you argued on the show, are they wasting premium draft value when a similar fit could still be there after a trade down? Follow us on Spotify so you do not miss the next Giants draft episode. If you listen on Apple Podcasts, please leave a 5-star rating and review to help more Giants fans find the show. In this episode, Drew and Rob rank their top 10 wide receivers in the 2026 NFL Draft, but the real Giants question running through the show is fit versus cost. They open by saying wide receiver is one of the few true strengths in this draft, which is exactly why the decision gets tricky at No. 5. If the separation between the top tier is not dramatic, then the conversation stops being “who is the best receiver?” and becomes “which receiver is worth that pick for this roster?” That is why the show keeps circling back to the top of the board, the different archetypes in this class, and whether the Giants should chase size, explosiveness, polish, or flexibility. The rankings still matter, and the full board gives listeners the whole picture. You work through ten receivers because this is one of the deepest areas in a weak draft, and because teams are going to value these players very differently based on role. Some of these guys project as outside boundary targets. Some are cleaner separators. Some are more explosive-play threats. Some feel safer, while others feel like swing-for-the-fences bets. That is what makes the episode useful for Giants fans. It is not just a list for the sake of a list. It is a real argument about what kind of receiver this team should want if they are serious about helping their quarterback and building the room the right way. The Giants-specific tension is strongest near the top of the rankings. You make it clear that just liking a player is not the same as liking him at No. 5. That is the pressure point. If a receiver such as Carnell Tate is good but not clearly separated from the rest of the upper tier, then why force the pick there? Why not trade down and still land a receiver who fits what this offense needs? On the other hand, if one of these top prospects is truly the best stylistic match for what this roster lacks, passing on him could mean missing the cleanest answer at the position. That is the heart of the debate, and it gives the episode real stakes instead of making it just another draft board rundown. The show also digs into what different prospects actually bring. There are discussions about outside size, route polish, downfield production, slot value, special teams utility, injury concerns, and long-term upside. Some receivers feel like clean fits for what the Giants may want to do. Others may be talented but come with enough overlap or enough development risk that the value only makes sense later. That makes this a real Giants team-building episode wrapped inside a top-10 WR show, which is why the ranking conversation stays interesting all the way through. Merch: https://2giantgoofballs-shop.fourthwall.com/ Support: https://buymeacoffee.com/2giantgoofballs All episodes: https://2giantgoofballs.buzzsprout.com/ Send us Fan Mail Support the show

    1h 11m
  5. Should the Giants Risk Caleb Downs at No. 5?

    MAR 26

    Should the Giants Risk Caleb Downs at No. 5?

    The Giants could land a rare defensive weapon in Caleb Downs at No. 5, but they could also pass on help in the trenches or a safer draft path if the knee concern is real. If Downs is that special, is this the right swing for the Giants, or are they making the most important pick on the board harder than it needs to be? Follow us on Spotify and, if you enjoy the show, leave a 5-star review on Apple. That support helps more Giants fans find the show. This episode is built around the biggest argument from the live show: should the Giants even consider Caleb Downs at No. 5? Drew and Rob dig into the Ohio State pro day fallout, Downs pushing back on the knee rumor, and Pat McAfee’s report that multiple NFL teams were not deterred by what they saw medically. But that still leaves the real Giants question untouched: if you take a safety that high, he has to be a difference-maker on a rare level. That is the center of the debate here. Is Downs worth a bet this aggressive, or is the smarter move to avoid the risk and go another direction? That tension carries the whole episode. The show pushes back on the Francis Mauigoa-at-five idea, questions why the Giants would project a player to another spot that early, and leans harder toward the Field Yates path of Caleb Downs in Round 1 with interior offensive line help later. There is also clear trade-down support in the conversation, because if the Giants do not feel fully sure about taking a safety this high, moving back could be the cleanest answer. That is why this episode works: it is not just about whether Downs is talented. It is about whether he is the right kind of talent for this exact pick and this exact roster. The rest of the show supports that main debate instead of replacing it. The hosts cover Mansoor Delane’s big pro day and why he looks like the top corner in the class, the Shelby Harris visit and what it says about the defensive front, plus the quieter additions of Zach Triner and Cam Jones. There is also an update on Kayvon Thibodeaux, with the sense that the Giants are not looking to dump him, along with quick hits on James Hudson landing in New England and the possibility that the Giants open 2026 on the road because of the MetLife World Cup transition. Merch:  https://2giantgoofballs-shop.fourthwall.com/ Support:  https://buymeacoffee.com/2giantgoofballs All episodes:  https://2giantgoofballs.buzzsprout.com/ Send us Fan Mail Support the show

    51 min
  6. Did Giants Free Agency Reveal Their Draft Plan?

    MAR 24

    Did Giants Free Agency Reveal Their Draft Plan?

    The Giants can stay at No. 5 and force a premium pick, but that may be the exact mistake this front office is trying to avoid. If free agency already showed what this roster still lacks, is the smarter move to trade down, add picks, and attack the real holes instead of pretending this is a true top-heavy class? Follow us on Spotify so you never miss an episode, and if you listen on Apple Podcasts, please leave a 5-star rating and review to help more Giants fans find the show. Drew and Rob break down why the Giants’ free agency period may have already revealed their draft roadmap. They start with the Sam Roberts signing, discuss why it looks like a depth move more than a true answer in the trenches, and then work through what the rest of the offseason has shown about how this team may attack the draft. The core argument is simple: free agency was not random. It exposed what the Giants believe they fixed, what they still clearly have not fixed, and where John Harbaugh’s new staff may be pushing this roster next. The episode argues that wide receiver no longer feels like a true early-round need after the additions of Darnell Mooney, Calvin Austin III, and Isaiah Likely. Running back, on the other hand, still feels very much in play. Drew and Rob explain why this may not be a desperate need, but it is clearly a position the Giants are willing to upgrade if the right player is there. That conversation naturally leads into the bigger debate around No. 5 overall, including whether Jeremiyah Love would even make sense there if the Giants cannot find a trade-down partner. Cornerback gets major attention because the Giants clearly tried to address it and still do not look fully settled there. The show also makes the case that offensive line depth may not be the early priority many fans expect, especially if the staff is more comfortable with the current bodies than the fan base is. And hovering over everything is the same ugly truth: this team still has to fix the run defense. Whether that means defensive tackle, linebacker, or both, Drew and Rob make it clear that stopping the run should be one of the biggest goals of this draft. They also hit the latest Odell Beckham Jr. chatter, several draft visits and meetings, Madelyn Burke leaving for SportsCenter, the Giants’ rising franchise valuation, and the NFL’s latest 18-game-season idea. Merch: https://2giantgoofballs-shop.fourthwall.com/ Support: https://buymeacoffee.com/2giantgoofballs All episodes: https://2giantgoofballs.buzzsprout.com/ Send us Fan Mail Support the show

    49 min
  7. Giants at No. 5: Will Forcing a Pick Backfire?

    MAR 20

    Giants at No. 5: Will Forcing a Pick Backfire?

    The Giants can stay at No. 5 and take a premium prospect, but the tradeoff is obvious: they may be forcing a top-five pick in a draft that does not have true top-five value. Is that the wrong bet for this roster? If the board is weak at the top, why force a move that could backfire instead of trading down and building the team the right way? Follow us on Spotify so you never miss an episode, and if you listen on Apple Podcasts, please leave a 5-star rating and review to help more Giants fans find the show. Drew and Rob spend most of this episode working through the real problem with the Giants picking fifth overall: this is not viewed as a strong, top-heavy draft, and that makes the risk of forcing a pick much higher. They rule out the obvious non-starters first, including another quarterback after drafting Jaxson Dart and another edge rusher after investing so heavily in Abdul Carter, Brian Burns, and Kayvon Thibodeaux. From there, the conversation keeps coming back to the same question: if the Giants do not love the board, why act like they do? The linebacker debate gets real attention, especially with Sonny Styles and Arvell Reese, but even there the discussion comes back to value. The same thing happens at safety with Caleb Downs, where talent is acknowledged but the positional value and roster context make No. 5 feel rich. Running back gets the strongest pro-pick push because Jeremiyah Love is viewed as one of the few true difference-makers in the class, yet even that conversation is framed through the lens of board value, roster construction, and whether taking a back that high is actually the smartest use of the pick. Cornerback, offensive line, and wide receiver all come with some level of appeal, but the episode repeatedly questions whether any of those options are worth forcing at No. 5 in this specific class. That is why the trade-down angle dominates the show. The argument is simple: in a depth-heavy draft, the Giants may be better off moving back, adding picks, and still landing a player who fits what John Harbaugh and the new staff want to build. Instead of chasing a shaky top-five valuation, the smarter move may be stacking assets, filling real holes like corner, guard, or defensive tackle, and giving the roster more long-term help. Take the flashy name now, or avoid the bad priority and build this thing the right way? Merch: https://2giantgoofballs-shop.fourthwall.com/ Support: https://buymeacoffee.com/2giantgoofballs All episodes: https://2giantgoofballs.buzzsprout.com/ Send us Fan Mail Support the show

    1h 16m
  8. 2026 NFL Draft RB Debate: Is This Class Worth the Pick?

    MAR 19

    2026 NFL Draft RB Debate: Is This Class Worth the Pick?

    This 2026 NFL Draft running back class gives you burst, receiving value, and a few backs with real starter upside, but the sacrifice is using a meaningful pick on a group that also feels thin, injury-heavy, and full of role-player projections. If a team chases the wrong traits here, are they buying speed and flash while passing on better value somewhere else? Follow us on Spotify so you do not miss the next live-to-audio upload, and if you enjoy the show, give us a 5-star rating and review on Apple Podcasts. In this episode, Drew and Rob kick off their 2026 draft coverage by breaking down the running back class from the bottom up and asking the question that hangs over the whole show: is this actually a class worth investing in, or is it a bad year to force a pick at the position? The discussion keeps coming back to the same tradeoff. There is clear upside in this group, but there are also durability concerns, ball-security problems, pass-protection flaws, age concerns, and more than a few backs who feel like complementary pieces instead of true long-term answers. The show spends time sorting through the role-player and value tier first, including Seth McGowan, Kaelon Black, J’Mari Taylor, Kaytron Allen, Jaydn Ott, and Le’Veon Moss. Some bring size, some bring steady downhill value, and some have enough traits to stick in an NFL backfield, but most of them come with obvious limitations. Whether it is injury history, a capped ceiling, pass-protection concerns, or overlap with what the Giants already have, Drew and Rob make it clear that a lot of these backs feel more like depth options than players you should be excited to spend real capital on. Then the conversation shifts into the more compelling names in the class. Nicholas Singleton gets real respect for his size, speed, receiving value, and pass protection, but there are still vision and medical questions that keep him from being an automatic RB1. Mike Washington Jr. has the size-speed profile teams love, but the ball-security issue is loud enough to make the projection risky fast. Jonah Coleman gets praised as one of the safer all-around evaluations, even if the big-play ceiling is limited. The biggest praise in the episode goes to Emmett Johnson, Jadarian Price, and Jeremiyah Love. Emmett Johnson is framed as one of the most underrated backs in the class because of his workload, receiving production, consistency, and overall football value. Jadarian Price gets strong support for his burst, return value, and ability to maximize touches even while sharing a backfield. Jeremiyah Love lands at the top because of the explosive profile, home-run ability, and feature-back upside, even though Drew still pushes back on the idea that he should be treated like some untouchable generational prospect. By the end, the show is not just ranking backs. It is drawing a line between exciting traits and smart draft value. That is the real debate running through the whole episode: when this class has so many questions attached to it, how early is too early to take a running back, and which of these backs is actually worth betting on? Merch: https://2giantgoofballs-shop.fourthwall.com/ Support: https://buymeacoffee.com/2giantgoofballs All episodes: https://2giantgoofballs.buzzsprout.com/ Send us Fan Mail Support the show

    1h 17m
4.2
out of 5
22 Ratings

About

Looking for a hilarious and informative podcast about the New York Giants? 2 Giant Goofballs has got you covered! Hosted by Drew and Rob, this podcast offers insightful analysis, lively debates, and plenty of laughs. With their infectious personalities and quick wit, Drew and Rob make discussing the latest Giants news and games an absolute blast. Whether you're a die-hard fan or just tuning in for the fun, 2 Giant Goofballs is the perfect way to stay up-to-date on all things Big Blue. So join the conversation today and see why this is one of the best NY Giants podcasts around!

You Might Also Like