A few months ago, I had the absolute delight of hugging my kids goodnight after dinner and driving over to a friend’s house to hang out after their kids were asleep. It had been too long since I’d last seen them, which means I definitely rambled incoherently way too much. But in my defense, my friends had a relative visiting who 1) did not know me and 2) was one of those people who mixes questions with banter in precisely the way that makes one (me, at least) want to carry on endlessly. As our back and forth chatter took its detours, we waded into a series of grievances we each have with various Christian denominations, authors, pastors, and leaders. There is no shortage of material to lament, there. Somewhere between a hearty eye-roll over the state of progressive Christianity and a comment I made without hesitation about how I would happily fist fight Doug Wilson in a Waffle House parking lot, Visiting Relative (after reminding me that if it’s past midnight, I wouldn’t really need to go outside the Waffle House to fight whomever I pleased) asked me why I am still a Christian. It was an extremely fair question - since I obviously have major problems with just about every Christian denomination under the sun. Naturally, I completely blanked out in the same way I forget every movie I’ve ever seen in my entire life the minute someone asks which one my favorite is. (Or what kind of music do I like? What is music? Help! As if I haven’t been obsessed with music and lyrics as far back as I can remember.) I mumbled something about it being because of Jesus - knowing exactly how I sounded yet completely unable to form a full sentence. So much for St Peter’s admonition to “always be ready to give an account to anyone who asks you for the hope that is in you. With gentleness and respect.” For someone who talks so much, I’m really not great at talking sometimes. Obviously, that moment has passed. But I would like to try again. Welcome to my do-over. In which I make another attempt to articulate why I still claim Christianity even though I am an insufferable contrarian who is riddled with grief and anger issues when it comes to The Church. First of all, I am riddled with grief and anger issues when it comes to, oh, every little thing and institution my fellow humans have glanced at (much less, BUILT). Right and Left wing politics, public schools, private schools, homeschool orgs, higher level academia, the entertainment industry, the music industry, the sports industry, etc etc etc - I’ve got beef with all of it. I didn’t get an Oppositional Defiance Disorder diagnosis in 4th grade for nothing! If being alive on planet earth has taught me anything, it’s that in every country, under every government, and in every facet of life - human beings will be power hungry, controlling, self seeking little biznays who ruin good things and trample the innocent. I guess one might imagine The Church should be exempt from this because it’s allegedly a place people go to try to become good focus on grace (and still mess that up by succumbing to behaviorism or whatever), but I have some terrible news about all of that: The Church is also full of people. Wheat and Tares, if you will - and the wheat is still in a sanctification process, so. Humans are just messy, I don’t what to tell anyone. And let’s not forget that I am a messy human, too. Lest it sound like I would dare to leave myself out of all this criticism. If only. Alas. The cost of love is brutally high, but the cost of walling off from fellow humans is unimaginably higher. It is, I’m afraid, exactly as CS Lewis said it is in one of my favorite (if overplayed) quotes from him: “To love at all is to be vulnerable. Love anything and your heart will be wrung and possibly broken. If you want to make sure of keeping it intact you must give it to no one, not even an animal. Wrap it carefully round with hobbies and little luxuries; avoid all entanglements. Lock it up safe in the casket or coffin of your selfishness. But in that casket, safe, dark, motionless, airless, it will change. It will not be broken; it will become unbreakable, impenetrable, irredeemable. To love is to be vulnerable. C.S. Lewis, The Four Loves” But this doesn’t really answer why I am still a Christian, does it? Well, a little bit it does. Because part of still being a Christian is not abandoning the whole thing upon discovery that Christians can be awful. We can be. Of course We can be! More news at 10? People who claim to follow Jesus have been betraying Him since Judas. So what else is new. I must also confess that I feel a certain pressure (probably self-imposed) to present every shred of evidence that has convinced me throughout my life that Jesus of Nazareth was and is the Son of the all powerful, all knowing, and all loving creator God depicted in the Hebrew Bible. That He is who He said He is and that doing my best to surrender my life to Him is the best and most reasonable way to live. The high IQ, erudite thinkers closest to me have trained me to deeply value rationality and logic. So of course there have been many times in which I have nearly let go of all of this before I unearthed a satisfying answer to the doubts that surfaced. I am tempted to list them all out for you one by one along with the discoveries that made it impossible for me to let go, but: 1) I think you can and will find all of that type of information if you decide that you want to - and anyway, the likelihood that your sticking points (if you have them) are different than mine are high. It seems to me that everyone has their own specific objections. And 2) At this point, frankly, I’m bored by that part. Let me explain with a story that will truly (finally) bring us to the point! Sometimes I stumble across an important connection out here in the wilds of the internet. The ever elusive Internet Friend. But wait! How am I to know that said Internet friend is for real? I mean, have you seen the state of things? Bots, spam, and scammers abound! At this point, even if someone posts videos of themselves talking, how could we be totally sure it’s really them and not some more Ai generated slop? Whatever, though! I am an xennial harkening to this hellscape from the days of LiveJournal. I have had nothing if not plenty of time to become properly discerning. My ability to tell what’s fake and what’s real in these spaces has honed and fine tuned as years passed and I observed the exact ways everything changed around me. So, by the time Breezy Brookshire (subscribe to her page!) reached out to say hi and connect over a shared love of art - I had seen quite enough evidence that she was not only a real human person, but also the exact human person she claimed to be. And!! Listing out the evidence for these facts would be so boring in the exact same way that listing out evidence for my faith is boring. Do you really want to hear me carry on about social validation through networking and how much one can learn about another via voice memos etc etc?? You can find enough information about how to tell if someone online is who they say they are (in the same way you can find Christian apologetics, too!) to be reasonably sure that this is not only a real person, but also a treasured kindred spirit. I don’t want to dryly recite a bunch of Internet Friend Apologetics! I would much prefer to tell you that I know Breezy Brookshire is a real and lovely person because we are friends! I would much prefer to tell you that a little bit ago, I had another very dear old friend to meet up with and a job to do with said friend who was temporarily in Nashville, and I needed a place to spend the night on very short notice. So I reached out to Breezy - trusting that she was both real and who-she-said-she-was and asked if I could crash on her couch. And that’s how an Internet Friend became an In-Real-Life friend as we sat up to all hours excitedly talking over each other and sharing ideas, paintings, other various handmade things and the dreams we have for them. That’s how we spent the following day working alongside each other and a second evening trying to stretch the time as far as we could make it go before we had to say goodbye. Before I had to drag myself away to drive home in the thick fog full of the buzzing energy and encouragement that comes with genuine connection. If someone asks me why I am still a Christian, I am wont to say “it’s because of Jesus” in the same way that if someone asked me why I still think I can make real friends on the internet, I knee jerk to an example like, “Because Breezy is my friend!” I know how this will sound to the skeptic - I know. I hear it all through their ears as I say it, but the truth is that the skepticism I am met with over my faith feels exactly as absurd to me as someone insisting Breezy isn’t real when I know good and well that she welcomed me into her home and shared dried mango slices with me while she made us a cozy dinner and listened so well while I accidentally rapidfire told her one thousand of my life stories all at once. Of course, I understand why and how personal experience offered as evidence for Christianity is easily hand waved away by anyone who doesn’t already believe in it and/or simply isn’t interested in changing or even challenging their current worldview. Interestingly, I didn’t realize how hung up I am on all these reasons for unbelief that keep me up at night until a few days ago. I was at a lunch table with the other moms at our weekly homeschool co-op meeting, lamenting the longstanding unbelief of some of my most treasured (and respected and admired) friends. Confiding. I was carrying on about how brilliant they are. How practical and independent on the outside. How tender (nougat-y, even) inside. And then - a standard refrain for me - a good bit about how our culture sabotages belief in the Christian story. And how Chri