Underrated Favorites

Gem.In.Eyes Productions
  • 5.0 (2)
  • Arts
  • Updated Weekly

Movies you might've missed! Nique and Roost re-vist and re-examine movies you might've missed and declare if it's an underrated favorite or a flop. They apply their movie fandom and acumen to movies that are at least 10 years old and debate their hits or hard misses. A Gem.In.Eyes Productions podcast

  1. Copycat

    07/06/2025

    Copycat

    Sigourney Weaver vs. incels? Say less. In this episode, Rooster and Nique crack open the criminally underseen 1995 thriller Copycat, where agoraphobic criminologist Sigourney Weaver teams up with hard-nosed detective Holly Hunter to stop a serial killer who’s remixing the greatest (worst?) hits of American murder history. It’s part Mindhunter, part Scream, and all ahead of its time. The duo dives deep into proto-feminist leads, soft but solid men, and the eternal threat of mediocre white dudes with god complexes. Plus: shoutouts to Zoom before Zoom, a surprising lack of cop-aganda, and why this might be one of the best aging films they’ve reviewed. Is Copycat a copycat—or the original blueprint? Follow on IG @underratedfavoritespod and @gemineyesproducitons Checkout pod merch at gemineyesproductions.com/shop

    45 min
  2. Kiss, Kiss, Bang, Bang

    05/04/2025

    Kiss, Kiss, Bang, Bang

    This week, we dive into the chaotic, stylish, and weirdly ahead-of-its-time 2005 black comedy Kiss Kiss Bang Bang. Rooster and Nique break down the film’s strange mix of neo-noir tropes, sharp dialogue, and morally questionable characters—all while paying homage to Val Kilmer’s scene-stealing turn as Gay Perry. We unpack Robert Downey Jr.’s pre-Iron Man charm, the tangled murder mystery that somehow keeps unfolding, and how this movie helped usher in the era of the “s****y hero.” Is Kiss Kiss Bang Bang a misunderstood gem or a great bad movie that almost works? We talk about the film’s influence on movies like The Nice Guys, Burn After Reading, and The Other Guys, its surprisingly progressive takes on queerness and gender roles, and why sometimes the lesson is… closure is overrated. Plus, we rank it on the Underrated Favorites scale and give our best pairing picks if you’re planning a double feature. A Gem.In.Eyes Productions Podcast, follow on social @underratedfavoritespod and @gemineyesproductions Like, subscribe, rate, review, and support the pod by checking out the website and merch gemineyesproductions.com

    45 min
  3. Rock-A-Doodle

    04/06/2025

    Rock-A-Doodle

    Join Nique and Rooster as they crow their appreciation for the overlooked animated gem, "Rock-A-Doodle"! In this episode, the hosts break down the whimsical yet dark adventures of Chanticleer, a singing rooster convinced he's responsible for the sunrise, whose fall from grace sends the barnyard into chaos. They explore the film's vibrant animation, surprisingly deep themes of Hollywood exploitation, and hidden commentary on rural America. Plus, they debate character favorites (and frustrations—sorry, Edmund), highlight feminist icon Peepers, and reveal why critics missed the true heart of this psychedelic animated classic. Grab your popcorn, settle in, and find out why "Rock-A-Doodle" deserves another sunrise. Follow Underrated Favorites on social media to join the conversation and never miss an episode!

    54 min
  4. Death to Smoochy

    03/23/2025

    Death to Smoochy

    In this episode of Underrated Favorites, Nique and Roost shine a spotlight on the criminally overlooked dark comedy "Death to Smoochie." Joined by The Homie Chris, they explore how this satirical gem starring Robin Williams, Edward Norton, and Catherine Keener cleverly skewers the world of children's entertainment, corruption, and celebrity culture. Dive deep into the film's biting humor, unforgettable performances, and why it might have been misunderstood upon release. Whether you're revisiting the film or discovering it for the first time, find out why "Death to Smoochy" deserves its moment in the spotlight. Follow us on Instagram @underratedfavoritespod to join the conversation, suggest your own underrated favorites, and never miss an update! A Gem.In.Eyes Production, find out more and support the pod at gemineyesproductions.com

    37 min

  5. 03/09/2025

    The 2024 UF Awards!

    Underrated Favorites kicks off the new season with the 2024 UF (pronounced oof) Awards! Even tho these movies just came out last year, get the low down and hot takes on the movies history will surely come to know as Underrated Favorites! Follow us on Instagram @underratedfavoritespod and @gemineyesproductions and support the pod by checking out the merch at gemineyesproductions.com/shop Remember to like, subscribe, rate, and review to help other people find out about Underrated Favorites!

    44 min
  6. Nightmare on Elm Street 3: Dream Warriors

    10/31/2024

    Nightmare on Elm Street 3: Dream Warriors

    In this episode of Underrated Favorites, we step into the twisted dream world of Nightmare on Elm Street 3: Dream Warriors. Freddy Krueger is back, and this time he’s haunting a group of teens who won’t go down without a fight. With its blend of horror, surreal 80s effects, and iconic one-liners, Dream Warriors has become a fan favorite in the franchise. But does it truly stand up as a classic, or is it just nostalgic fun? Join us as we discuss the movie’s unique twist on the Elm Street formula, its memorable kills, and why Dream Warriors may be the boldest installment in the series. We’ll explore the film’s legacy, Freddy’s evolving personality, and the impact of its soundtrack, including the infamous Dokken theme song. Is Dream Warriors a true horror masterpiece or simply 80s cheese we can’t resist? Tune in to find out if Nightmare on Elm Street 3: Dream Warriors earns a place in our Underrated Favorites, and be sure to subscribe to stay updated on all our cult classic deep dives! You can buy merch and support the pod by going to gemineyesproductions.com Follow on social media @gemineyesproductions | @underratedfavoritespod

    1h 5m
  7. Identity

    10/17/2024

    Identity

    Identity – Mind-Bending Thriller or Forgettable Whodunit? Prepare to have your mind twisted into knots, because this week on Underrated Favorites, we’re diving into the psychological thriller Identity. This 2003 film, starring John Cusack, Ray Liotta, and Amanda Peet, has all the makings of a tense, classic whodunit: a group of strangers stranded at a motel during a violent storm, mysterious deaths, and a shocking twist. But does Identity stand out as a masterful thriller that keeps you guessing until the end, or does its convoluted plot twist collapse under its own weight? We’ll take a look at how Identity blends psychological horror with classic murder mystery vibes, discussing whether its twist ending delivers a satisfying payoff or leaves too many unanswered questions. With a talented ensemble cast and a script that toys with the very notion of reality, does this movie deserve more recognition, or is it rightfully forgotten in the shuffle of early 2000s thrillers? Plus, we’ll debate Identity’s influence on the genre—did it set a standard for the mind-bending mystery, or does it get lost among better-executed psychological thrillers? And as always, we’ll answer the ultimate question: Is Identity an underrated favorite that deserves a second look, or is it a forgettable flop? Join us for a journey through the twists and turns of Identity, and find out whether this movie leaves you thrilled or just confused. Subscribe to Underrated Favorites on your preferred podcast platform and follow us on social media to stay updated on what’s coming next. Spoiler alert: we’re tackling another horror classic next week and you won’t want to miss it!

    45 min
  8. The Descent

    10/08/2024

    The Descent

    Time to break out the flashlights and face your deepest fears, because this week on Underrated Favorites, we’re plunging into the pitch-black terror of The Descent. This 2005 British horror film isn’t just about claustrophobic caving expeditions; it’s about primal fear, survival, and some seriously nasty cave-dwelling creatures. But here’s the question: does The Descent deserve a spot on your horror movie Mount Rushmore, or is it an anxiety-inducing nightmare better left unexplored? Join us as we delve into what made The Descent such a standout in the horror genre. From its all-female cast of adventurers to the jaw-dropping tension that doesn’t let up, we’ll talk about how this film taps into some of our deepest, most primal fears. But is it all well-earned terror, or does the movie push too far, leaving viewers feeling more uncomfortable than entertained? Plus, we’ll unpack the film’s ending(s)—yes, plural!—and whether they add to its brilliance or just muddy the waters. And as always, we’ll answer the big question: Is The Descent a hidden gem of modern horror, or does it crawl its way into the flop category? Strap in, because this episode is going to take you deep—very deep—into the heart of horror. Don’t forget to subscribe to Underrated Favorites wherever you listen to podcasts! Follow us on Instagram @underratedfavoritespod for updates and a sneak peek into our next episode, where we tackle another questionable cult classic.

    44 min
See All (45)

Ratings & Reviews

5
out of 5
2 Ratings

About

Movies you might've missed! Nique and Roost re-vist and re-examine movies you might've missed and declare if it's an underrated favorite or a flop. They apply their movie fandom and acumen to movies that are at least 10 years old and debate their hits or hard misses. A Gem.In.Eyes Productions podcast

Information

More From Gem.In.Eyes Productions