The Poverty Trap

Joan DeMartin

A Podcast for those who are fed up with the inequality baked into America's system and want to collectively make change. povertytrap.substack.com

  1. 6h ago

    “New Medicaid Work Requirements Could Leave Over 5 Million People Without Health Insurance,” says Policy Expert

    Welcome to The Poverty Trap, a Newsletter and Podcast About the Politics And Policy Choices That Create a Cycle of Economic, Racial and Environmental Inequality...and What We Can Do To Change It. I recently had the pleasure of talking with Tim Shaw, Director of the Benefits Transformation Initiative, and Senior Policy Advisor to the Aspen Institute’s Financial Security Program. Mr Shaw and Aspen’s Benefits Team work to “provide policy, nonprofit, and market leaders with the innovative ideas, research, and networks of leaders they need to design and enact policies that help people weather financial shocks and comfortably afford everyday life.” Right now, Mr. Shaw is focused on the changes to the SNAP and Medicaid programs put in place by [The One Big Beautiful Bill Act] H.R.1 that make it harder for people in need to access these benefits and place a much greater burden on the states to implement their programs. I’ll just say as a top line… the changes from the One Big Beautiful Bill Act were one of the largest cuts to these major safety net programs that we’ve seen in a generation. …and they’ve placed real strains on households and families, and their ability to maintain financial stability and feed their families and go to the doctor. Tim Shaw, 11/4/26 NOTE: This conversation has been lightly edited and condensed for length and clarity.. Joan DeMartin: I’m thrilled that I get to talk with you, [Tim]. And I want to learn from you so that I can pass what I learn onto my readers. Tim Shaw: Yes, I’m excited to chat. I think that emphasizing the changes to SNAP and Medicaid that have come from H.R.1 (the One Big Beautiful Bill Act) is very important right now. Joan DeMartin: Yeah. I’d love to know more about what you, as Director of, you’re the Director of the Benefits Transformation Initiative with the Aspen Institute, what exactly you’re doing to help states navigate these rather onerous requirements. Tim Shaw: Yeah. I’m happy to. So, I’m Tim Shaw. I’m the Director of the Benefits Transformation Initiative, the Aspen Institute Financial Security Program. So our focus is on helping convene leaders, create tools and do research that helps the public and policymakers better understand and build a better benefit system. And so we think about two things when it comes to benefits and SNAP and Medicaid in particular right now especially because of H.R.1, and that’s the design of benefits. Do we have the right policies in place? Is the eligibility right? How does that affect delivery, which I think is an under appreciated part of what really impacts people’s daily lives and whether or not they get the benefits they need to feed their families and go to the doctor. And so we’ve been doing a few things in that vein. One is that we convene a set of state human services and labor executives. When the federal government passes a new law or sets up a new regulation, they’re the ones who have to go on the ground and actually implement it. We meet with them on a regular basis to hear how things are going and what challenges they had and connect them to better resources to actually do some of the implementation on the ground. We also convene a set of nonprofit technical assistance providers. This is about a dozen,primarily policy and technology nonprofits, whose expertise is in going in and helping states with implementation in a cost-free way and giving them really good objective advice about how to make sure that, as you’re implementing these challenging policies: one, you’re doing it well, but two, you’re making sure you’re not creating a situation where many more people end up unenrolled or dis-enrolled from the program even when they remain eligible, which is one of the big challenges here. Those are a couple of the main ways we’re doing work on this now. But I’ll just say as a top line, the changes from the One Big Beautiful Bill Act were one of the largest cuts to these major safety net programs that we’ve seen in a generation. And they’ve placed real strains on households and families, and their ability to maintain financial stability and feed their families and go to the doctor. But also part of the story here is the implementation challenges, and the big shift in both responsibility and funding — the bill moves funding from states to the federal government while at the same time increasing the burden on states to do more. That’s created a really harmful cycle of pain when it comes to the delivery of benefits and made it more difficult to do. Joan DeMartin: What was that first part again? That shifting to the federal government versus… Tim Shaw: So the One Big Beautiful Bill Act has a number of provisions that basically increases the administrative costs for these programs that states are responsible for. For example, for a long time, the federal government has covered 50% of the implementation costs of SNAP. Joan DeMartin: Right. Tim Shaw: Now the federal government will only cover 25%. And so there’s that piece which now states have new requirements and also have less money from the federal government to do it. Joan DeMartin: 75%? Tim Shaw: So their new share is 75%. There are also the new penalties that relate to “error rates”. And so if a state’s error rate is above 6% there are new penalties that they will have to pay for the first time, a portion of benefits. And that is actually bigger than the new administrative cost to states. That is a huge amount of money that states are not ready to pay. Joan DeMartin: Well, you know what? I didn’t do another lookup of when this law goes into effect entirely. I thought it was October 1st that the work [requirements] kicked in. Tim Shaw: There are new work requirements for SNAP that already went into effect, and then there are Medicaid work requirements that are going into effect on January 1, which is what most folks are talking about. Joan DeMartin: I was personally on food stamps and Medicaid for four or five years. I think that long, I’m not even sure. I blacked it out of my memory. But I saw it, the application process from a view, you know, not everyone who’s on, um, SNAP and Medicaid is an attorney, you know, and then I’m thinking, what is going on with this process? The one thing I wanted to just say [is] how exhausting the process itself is. And then these work requirements. Are you kidding me? Tim Shaw: Mhm. Joan DeMartin: Volunteer? They want someone to volunteer when they should be looking for a job full-time… Tim Shaw: Yeah. Joan DeMartin: What is the Aspen Institute, what is your program doing to— are you factoring that in? Tim Shaw: Yes. I think one of the things that we have been pretty focused on is the idea of that in the literature people would call administrative burden, but as a normal person I would call paperwork. Like, what is the effect that paperwork has and a complicated process has on the day-to-day experience of people applying for benefits, and also what barriers does that create to actually participating? Joan DeMartin: Yeah. Tim Shaw: So one of the things that we have worked with our states on, and we have published a blog on calling for, is a set of standard customer experience outcomes or north stars. Basically, if you get your health care from the government or if you get it from your employer, you shouldn’t have to jump through more hoops. You should have a good experience and a smooth experience accessing, applying for, and receiving benefits. And so, we are calling for things like you should be able to apply for any program in 20 minutes. You should hear back within a day. You should receive services within a week. Right? So, these sound like super as… Get full access to The Poverty Trap at povertytrap.substack.com/subscribe

  2. Nov 1

    Americans Can’t Afford Their Lives...

    Welcome to The Poverty Trap, a Newsletter and Podcast About the Politics And Policy Choices That Create a Cycle of Economic, Racial and Environmental Inequality...and What We Can Do To Change It. Thinking about subscribing? Here’s what one paid subscriber recently had to say about The Poverty Trap: “You do great work, Joan. I don’t always get to read your newsletter, but when I do, I leave more informed and more compassionate…” Amy B. With today’s Halloween celebrations and the mid-term elections just days away, many Americans are having downright spooky feelings, uneasy, fearful vibes, like a dark cloud is hovering directly over them and their communities… What could it be? It’s not just that over 60% of Americans worry about paying their bills and bare necessities each month. It’s that every headline declares that prices of fuel for their cars and food for their table are increasing more sharply than in the recent past. Health care and health insurance costs on the ACA exchange will jump by double digits again starting in 2027, with reduced subsidies to help pay for the premiums. There is no proposal to end the Iran war that costs taxpayers an average of $66 million to $100 million each day, and the entire social safety net has been slashed and made more difficult to access. Americans are known to have a strong sense of fairness, and anything even resembling fairness has being upended in the last few years: During the 2024 presidential campaign, they were promised prices would go down, but instead they have soared. No wars would be started, and now 23 military members have died, 865 have been wounded and the cost of the Iran war has reached $47 billion. Look at these percentage increases for goods and services from an article written by The Hill and published in the Washington Post on October 21: …millions feel absolutely strapped due to the exploding cost of living, with which wages have simply not kept up in many key categories. Home prices are up nearly 60 percent. Rent is up 33 percent. Groceries are up 32 percent. Electricity is up 46 percent. Gas is up 69 percent. Health care is up 20 percent. These just aren’t budget items you can opt out of . In other words, Americans don’t just feel broke — they are broke. Meanwhile, the rich are getting richer. Billionaire wealth grew 22% in 2025 alone: A new Americans for Tax Fairness (ATF) analysis of Forbes data shows billionaire wealth grew 22% in 2025, from $6.7 trillion to $8.2 trillion. The number of billionaires increased from 814 to 935. Due to the Buy, Borrow, Die loophole, this wealth growth may never be taxed. [Loophole link added] And the wealth of the top 0.1% of Americans has soared compared to the bottom 50% of the population, according to a September 2026 analysis from “The Center For American Progress”: Federal Reserve data show that from the fourth quarter of 2024 through the first quarter of 2026, the wealthiest 0.1 percent gained an average of $9.6 million in wealth per household, while households in the bottom 50 percent gained just $1,200. The top 1 percent, meanwhile, gained an average of $1.8 million per household. And then we learn from an article published in yesterday’s New York Times that “the U.S. oil industry earned over $130 billion in profit during the Iran war…” Yet 60% of Americans have financial worries, and their number one problem is the ability to pay for gas to make it to work every day. Perhaps the most spooky of all is the wild increase in President Trump’s wealth since the beginning of his second term. He has raked in about $2.2 billion—this interview with NPR’s Terry Gross and New York Times journalist Eric Lipton explains how Trump pulled it off: https://www.npr.org/2026/08/05/nx-s1-5919997/how-trump-made-an-estimated-2-2-billion-during-the-first-year-of-his-second-term This fascinating, interactive piece recently published in The New York Times shows what the average American is giving up today just to survive. We all know how humans need to reward themselves with simple pleasures after a hard day’s work: a movie in a theater on the weekend, dinner out, a steak at home, maybe even a vacation. But millions don’t even have the luxury of treating themselves to a small reward. Then what happens? The inequality gap has gone beyond “not fair” and is careening into absurdity—exactly the space where the electorate becomes discontented, then fed-up. And a discontented, fed-up electorate turns angry. They can choose protest, civil disobedience and even violence to restore balance and something akin to fairness, but right now they have the ballot box. ______________________________ What do you think about America’s raging inequality and the feeling of unease so many of us have? Share your ideas with our community in the Comment Section below. And don’t forget to “Like”, Share and Re-stack this post—it really helps! The Poverty Trap is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. Get full access to The Poverty Trap at povertytrap.substack.com/subscribe

  3. Oct 13

    September—Mid-October 2026 Reading Round Up:

    Welcome to The Poverty Trap, a Newsletter and Podcast About the Politics And Policy Choices That Create a Cycle of Economic, Racial and Environmental Inequality...and What We Can Do To Change It. Thinking about subscribing? Here’s what one paid subscriber recently had to say about The Poverty Trap: “You do great work, Joan. I don’t always get to read your newsletter, but when I do, I leave more informed and more compassionate…” Amy B. With the mid-term elections fast approaching, there is a lot of physical campaign work to be done by the candidates, and both paid staff and volunteer workers. But we voters still need to “read up” on the issues the candidates discuss, so our votes reflect the issues we care about individually and have the greatest, positive impact on our communities . That’s why I’ve put together a short list of recent articles by reporters and other writers who are whipped into a frenzy, facing massive amounts of pre-election information to pull together and analyze. Let’s start with some good news first. — According to several recent polls, the number of likely voters who support “medicare for all” has gone up considerably in the last few years and now has reached about two-thirds or approximately 66% of those surveyed. The Kaiser Family Foundation (KFF) conducted a tracking poll in September of this year and released this report detailing the top voter concerns heading into the mid-term elections. No surprise that health care costs and gas prices lead the way: Although Senator Bernie Sanders (I.,Vt.) was not the first elected official to propose a single payer health care system, he certainly has been the most persistent and consistent proponent in the last 25+ years. Congressman Bernie Sanders Introduces National Health Care HR 2530 JUNE 17, 1991 — I’m going to count this next issue as one of several “October Surprises”, adding insult to injury for three quarters of a million Americans. As if eliminating Affordable Care Act (ACA) enhanced subsidizes that helped lower and middle class Americans pay for their skyrocketing insurance premiums wasn’t enough, the Trump Administration proudly announced it had canceled the health insurance of 750,000 people registered on the ACA exchange: for alleged “fraud”. According to an article published by NBC on September 22: Vice President JD Vance and Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services Administrator Mehmet Oz — who have teamed up on a broader push to root out fraud in government health programs — said Tuesday that roughly 750,000 people have had their ACA coverage canceled. The administration did not provide details about who lost coverage or how those individuals were informed. The cuts, Vance said, would save U.S. taxpayers $2.2 billion. Seven hundred and fifty thousand people committing fraud? And Dr. Oz doesn’t have enough to do running Medicare and Medicaid that he spends his time trying to root out alleged fraud in a totally separate health insurance program? We, the people should be demanding proof of this “fraud” for each of the 750,000 people now without health insurance.. — Let’s not forget the legal immigrants being booted from Medicaid while waiting over a year for their Green Cards. The New York Times reported in an article published September 30, that nearly 150,000 currently legal immigrants, mostly the humanitarian population of refugees, have green card applications pending. Because these immigrants are refugees fleeing persecution, and sex trafficking victims, they were previously entitled to receive health insurance under Medicaid until their Green Cards were approved. The so-called “One Big Beautiful Bill Act” passed last year terminates Medicaid coverage for these vulnerable populations as of October 1, 2026. The irony of this cruel situation is that the Trump Administration also slowed approval of Green Cards to a crawl, from 8 months approval time in 2024 to currently 18 months time to receive a Green Card after application. Where will these refuges go for even routine health care? They’ll clog either local urgent care clinics or emergency rooms, possibly delaying immediate treatment for the hundreds of thousands of Americans who visit emergency rooms across the country each day…for emergency medical care. I’ve mentioned this forced overcrowding of emergency rooms for people without health insurance numerous times, most recently here and here. — Finally for today’s reading round-up, let’s circle back to the fast-approaching mid-term elections, where the”affordability” issue looms for the Democrats’ taking—President Trump promised he would lower the price of everything, but instead his administration’s policies have increased the price of everything. According to recent polls, the top voter affordably concerns they will be taking into the voting booth are health care costs and transportation costs. And the astronomical price of diesel fuel has reverberated throughout the economy to increase the price of food, goods and services to the highest level in decades, ensuring that everyone but the wealthiest feel the pain. According to a NYTimes opinion piece published on September 28, the author, Tim Wu, “a law professor who worked in the Biden administration on economic competition and tech policy", agrees that hammering home the affordability message is a winning strategy for Democrats in the mid-terms. But Mr. Wu suggests an even more important strategy for Democratic messaging, and that is what underlies affordability: inequality caused by a system rigged to favor the wealthy. I agree and so do you, judging by the popularity of this post published on The Poverty Trap in January 2024. Here’s a quote from Mr. Wu’s opinion piece in The Times, just a few weeks ago: A recent CBS News poll found that some 60 percent of Americans think the economy is “unfair” and that most people under 45 say they have fewer economic opportunities than their parents did. In a recent Economist/YouGov poll, 66 percent of Republicans said that the gap between rich and poor is a “big problem.”…. To run a proper affordability campaign — one that taps into a discontent even deeper than that over high prices — Democrats should cater to this widespread sense of unfairness. The key message is rebalancing: a promise to level out a lopsided economy that favors huge concentrations of wealth. _________________________________ I’d love to hear what you think about these issues. The affordability crisis: healthcare, gas prices, food, goods and services out-of-reach for most Americans, whether affordability and baked-in inequality are winning messages for Democrats in the upcoming mid-term elections. Please share your ideas with The Poverty Trap Community in the Comment Section below: The Poverty Trap is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. Get full access to The Poverty Trap at povertytrap.substack.com/subscribe

  4. Sep 27

    How Older Homeowners Are Losing Their Biggest Asset...

    Welcome to The Poverty Trap, a Newsletter and Podcast About the Politics And Policy Choices That Create a Cycle of Economic, Racial and Environmental Inequality...and What We Can Do To Change It. Thinking about subscribing? Here’s what one paid subscriber recently had to say about The Poverty Trap: “You do great work, Joan. I don’t always get to read your newsletter, but when I do, I leave more informed and more compassionate…” Amy B. Before I get to the meat of this post, I’d like to introduce my new research and writing assistant. I’ve been “training” him the last month, thus my delay in posting. With his help, we should return to weekly posts starting today. Meet Willie — a very good boy! Meanwhile, I bookmarked an article published a few months ago in The New York Times titled: “Retirees Expect Their Home to Be a Financial Safety Net. They Shouldn’t” because it resonated with me and the financial situation I was in when I sold my home. I did not have the money to make needed repairs, sold it at the worst possible time near the beginning of the Covid shutdown when home prices had plummeted, and for exactly the amount I owed on the mortgage. This outcome left me with no money to pay rent, except what I borrowed from friends and charged on credit cards. I can’t help but believe many Americans over 55 will relate to this scenario as do their grown children who desperately try to convince their parents or grandparents to make needed repairs, or if possible, update the home to 21st century tastes. But many either can’t afford it, or don’t see the relationship of even a modest upgrade to resale value. And as a result, older sellers get less equity and consequently have less money to pay for assisted living care, often the next step after leaving their home. The Times article makes a good case that elderly homeowners should not rely on their home as a financial fall-back, even if it is mortgage free. It lists several reasons, culled from real estate specialists, financial advisors and data from the Federal Reserve Bank of Philadelphia: A paper from the Federal Reserve Bank of Philadelphia found that older homeowners, particularly those 70 and up, earn lower prices when they sell than their younger counterparts [and] One reason behind the age-price gap identified by researchers is that, compared with younger homeowners, older homeowners don’t invest as much in their properties. This can take the form of less renovation, more deferred maintenance and higher rates of disrepair. About 25 percent of the difference in sale prices is attributable to this discrepancy. The Times article also notes that older homeowners sometimes just want out of their homes with an immediate need to get into assisted living, or are just too tired or impatient to go through a traditional real estate broker that comes with listing, showings and inspections. That’s where housing “investors” enter the picture and offer cash for an “as is” sale, often if not always, with a much lower sale price: A bigger issue identified by researchers is that older homeowners are more likely to sell to investors paying cash, or via “pocket” listings, which bypass real estate multiple listing services. While these methods may yield quicker, more straightforward sales, less competition can mean a lower selling price. But there are more issues that complicate home sales for the elderly, especially for those with little money. Costs to complete even minor repairs, let alone updates, have soared because of the Iran war-related rise in fuel prices and the cost of goods. Some have to sell their homes to just keep up with today’s soaring inflation, and as mentioned earlier, to meet the increasing costs of retirement, assisted care, or nursing home facilities. Last week, CNBC published a good analysis of the ripple effect of rising diesel prices on costs of goods and services, which hasn’t yet fully kicked in. Here’s an excerpt: It can take awhile for the diesel cost to work its way through the economy and into your bank account. “Consumers feel it last but not least,” Glik [Carmit Glik, CEO of Ship4wd] said. “It shows up in grocery prices, delivery fees, and anything seasonal that depends on trucking to move fast, usually a few weeks after the spike, once surcharges work their way through the supply chain. That’s different from gas, where drivers see the pain immediately at the pump,” Glik added. In addition to maintaining their home, affordability of pretty much everything “is the Top Stated Concern [of American adults] age 50 plus” according to an AARP Foundation report from this spring. Share of Low-Income Adults 50+ (LI50+) Reporting Each Financial Concern, Spring 2026 Affordability is the Top Stated Concern. This horizontal bar chart shows the share of low-income adults age 50 and older (LI50+) who reported each financial concern in Spring 2026. Rising prices was the most commonly reported concern at 88%, followed by retirement savings (80%) and medical debt or care (72%). Smaller shares reported concern about losing public benefits (56%) and housing costs (54%). Source: AARP Foundation Economic Security Monitor, Spring 2026. (Note: I was not able to copy the “horizontal bar chart”, but included the data in text form.) Source: AARP Foundation Economic Security Monitor, Spring 2026 Why It Matters: According to an NPR piece published days ago, the fastest growing segment of Americans in poverty are seniors, age 65 and older: The poverty rate among seniors rose for the fifth straight year in 2025, “a trend no other age group experienced,” according to an AARP Foundation analysis of a new Census Bureau report. And because more seniors live in poverty, they are the fastest growing segment of the homeless population in the United States, according to several reputable sources, including the most recent report from the United States Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD). Although most seniors own homes, 27% or so still have a mortgage, but regardless, pay property taxes, home insurance and HOA fees in certain areas. And each of these costs is increasing, as is the cost of needed repairs and renovations. At the same time, rising prices of food, utilities and other necessities are eating into seniors’ fixed incomes. Millions of senior citizens, most of whom have worked their entire adult lives and paid into the government system end up in poverty, and worse yet, homeless? In the richest country on Earth? Why isn’t every elected official and those running for office discussing their plans to end this embarrassment? ________________________________ What are your ideas to stem the rising number of senior citizens living in poverty and without a place to live? I would love to see a discussion with your thoughts in the Comment Section below. Another photo of my new assistant hard at work on The Poverty Trap… I’ve trained him well! The Poverty Trap is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. Get full access to The Poverty Trap at povertytrap.substack.com/subscribe

  5. Sep 6

    Corporate Welfare — Explained for Everyday Folks

    Welcome to The Poverty Trap, a Newsletter and Podcast About the Politics And Policy Choices That Create a Cycle of Economic, Racial and Environmental Inequality...and What We Can Do To Change It. Thinking about subscribing? Here’s what one paid subscriber recently had to say about The Poverty Trap: “You do great work, Joan. I don’t always get to read your newsletter, but when I do, I leave more informed and more compassionate…” Amy B. I’m including the “trailer” for the 2021 PBS documentary, “Corporate Welfare, Where’s The Outrage” again, along with the direct link to the hour long, PBS documentary here: https://www.pbs.org/video/corporate-welfare-ptwdrw/, because it is essential viewing if you want to sort out the ‘double talk” leading up to the mid-term elections and make better choices as you go to the polls this November. It’s even more important to understand why our system continues to favor subsidies to businesses (aka Corporate welfare) over help to individuals and communities, and how the numbers actually break-down, so you have a better idea of where your tax dollars are going and who benefits from this windfall. I don’t believe it’s as simple as corporations benefit and individuals and communities suffer. Although this is true, it’s more complicated and maybe more insidious than that statement implies. Take this data from a Good Jobs First article published a little over a month ago: The [list below shows] September 2025 data from 11 states, [Government Accounting Office ] GAO identified 46 companies that ranked among the top 25 employers of Medicaid or SNAP recipients in at least two states. Seventeen were among the 50 largest Fortune 500 employers. The state data are not nationally representative, but the pattern is unmistakable: large, profitable corporations are among the leading employers of workers who need public assistance. Good Jobs First’s Subsidy Tracker adds another dimension. Eight prominent companies appearing in GAO’s employer tables have received at least $16.5 billion in disclosed state and local subsidies. This data are from both the GAO and the Good Jobs First data research team. Here’s how it breaks down according to the Good Jobs First article: Corporation Disclosed Subsidies: Examples From GAO Employer Lists: Amazon $15.16 Billion—Major Employer Of Medicaid And SNAP Recipients In Multiple States FedEx $660.5 Million—Among Tennessee’s Top Employers Of SNAP Recipients (The Company Has A Huge Hub In Memphis) Walmart $287.2 Million—Top Employer Of Medicaid Recipients In Georgia And Oklahoma Target $189.8 Million—Appears Among Large Employers Of Benefit Recipients Kroger $87.4 Million—Appears Among Major Grocery-Sector Employers Dollar General $59.7 Million—Among Tennessee’s Top Employers Of SNAP Recipients Dollar Tree $55.8 Million—Appears In State Employer Rankings McDonald’s $11.8 Million—Among Tennessee’s Top Employers Of SNAP Recipients Total $16.51 Billion Source: Good Jobs First Subsidy Tracker and GAO-26-108703. Subsidy totals are cumulative disclosed awards nationwide and exclude awards for which dollar values were not disclosed. And here are recent numbers from the GAO (Updated and released on July 22, 2026) that shows more specifically how many American workers are employed (both part-time and full-time) and still qualify for Medicaid and/or SNAP: This is a taxpayer double whammy. We are paying corporations directly to continue to exist in our communities in the hope they will provide jobs. As I wrote in my previous post on corporate welfare, not only don’t the companies provide all the jobs promised, they many times abandon their factory and its community for cheaper locales, ripping away their meager paying jobs with little notice. And here is the second insult, speaking of meager pay: The jobs pay so little that millions of workers who are employed by these companies across the country— even full-time workers— qualify for and receive Medicaid and SNAP food benefits. The taxpayers pay twice, while the corporations raking in billions of dollars in profits a year on the backs of low wage workers and inflated prices, get even more money…from you. Although the United States has been using direct incentives, tax breaks and tariffs on imported goods to protect its businesses since the late 1700’s, this help usually resulted in investments for the general public and the public good, like railroads, sewage treatment and later, highways as good examples. Today, corporate subsidies benefit companies much more than the general public. Fortunately, Robert Reich has written (and produced clever and informative videos) about this issue. The first video below was produced in 2019 during the first Trump Administration, but holds true today. The second video explains how and why government subsidies and incentives to big business have changed over the years, and why a clear understanding of “corporate welfare” helps us cut through the double talk of politicians today. You also should read this post from Substack’s own Judd Legum, author of Popular Information who published this post in July, discussing exactly how much taxpayers subsidize two of the biggest employers in the United States: Amazon and Walmart.: The amount of taxpayer money paying just for Medicaid alone annually is $2 billion! ———————————————— Thoughts on your money subsidizing big corporations…twice? Please share your ideas in the Comment Section, below. All are welcome! The Poverty Trap is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. Get full access to The Poverty Trap at povertytrap.substack.com/subscribe

  6. Aug 22

    The Real Welfare Queens

    Welcome to The Poverty Trap, a Newsletter and Podcast About the Politics And Policy Choices That Create a Cycle of Economic, Racial and Environmental Inequality...and What We Can Do To Change It. I originally published this post a few months after I started The Poverty Trap, way back on September 15, 2021. I’m re-posting it today with a few tweaks and an updated preface because it remains a major topic of discussion as our mid-term elections approach, but it’s rarely acknowledged directly. In fact, the concept of corporate welfare is the argument that clearly counters the conservative rantings against the progressive agenda, an agenda that the majority of democrat and independent voters seem to favor. An updated post, following shortly, will detail why the democrats should use our “corporate welfare system” like a battering ram against the current conservative agenda to slash social safety net programs. In the meantime, enjoy re-reading or reading for the first time this discussion of our real “welfare queens”. JOAN DEMARTIN DEC 09, 2021 This is the trailer for the PBS film that explores the concept of Corporate Welfare and how it helps corporations to thrive, and allows average, working taxpayers to suffer. I first heard the words “corporate welfare” when Senator Bernie Sanders was campaigning for President in 2015, although the concept had been discussed for easily 50 years before I heard it put into context. Although I had closely followed politics for decades and worked on a few campaigns, I never heard this concept mentioned, let alone explained and made an integral part of a presidential campaign. Senator Sanders described how workers for Walmart, as an example, made so little in wages as full time employees, that they still qualified for food stamps and other forms of government aid for the poor. In other words, the taxpayers were subsidizing Walmart’s low wages with taxpayer funded government programs. I probably hadn’t heard of corporate welfare because I was watching and reading what now is dubbed “mainstream media”, which not only didn’t cover this issue, but repeatedly branded Senator Sanders as a socialist “kook” for daring to call attention to our government’s hypocritical entanglement in this scheme. What I did know is that our government’s social safety net was too lean, and the constant complaining, mostly from the right, that cuts had to be made to these “handout” programs, and the talk of “welfare queens” were thinly-veiled, racist code. But this disingenuous scapegoating of the poor continues today with Senator Joe Manchin (D-WV), for one example, and many others. “I don’t believe that we should turn our society into an entitlement society,” Manchin said, as he was whittling down the “Build Back Better” bill of his own party’s President. And then I learned about the grotesque amount of money in the form of tax abatements, incentives and bailouts that federal, state and local governments provide large companies for the pleasure of gracing their communities with factories, warehouses and mega stores. This 2020 article from Business Insider cites a Princeton study that “finds that most states and local governments offer $30 billion a year in welfare — as a ‘low-end estimate’ — to corporations, and in some states the outgoing incentives exceed corporate tax revenues.” So our government is losing money — your money — on these “incentives” to draw businesses to local communities. But wait, there’s more. This 2014 article from Forbes, probably one of the antecedents to this year’s PBS film “Corporate Welfare: Where’s the Outrage?”, gives a few frightening examples of government subsidies to corporations. Here’s just one: “The 965 companies in the [ Good Jobs First Report prepared in 2014] received over $110 billion of public money. Berkshire Hathaway, a company with $485 billion in assets and $20 billion in profits, received over $1 billion of that money. Its chair, Warren Buffett, is worth about $58 billion.” It’s true that at least some of these companies never provide the jobs and tax base they promise in exchange for the subsidies they receive. In 2019, for example, General Motors decided to close its auto making plant in Lordstown, Ohio, allegedly because of the decline in demand for the small cars it was making there. But the state had signed several economic development agreements with GM which specified that the Lordstown plant would remain open until 2027 in exchange for tens of millions in tax breaks. As early as 2017, however, GM started cutting jobs and shifts at this plant and “announced it would build its new Chevrolet Blazer in Mexico.” The partial good news from this scenario is that Ohio’s Tax Credit Authority demanded its $60 million back, and in September 2020, GM agreed to repay $28 million and contribute $12 million in community support where the plant was located, presumably leaving the state about $20 million in the hole from it’s broken economic development agreements. Now that’s an entitlement society, Senator Manchin. You can watch this excellent film: “Corporate Welfare, Where’s the Outrage” on PBS by checking your local PBS guide for days and times or by accessing specific segments here: https://www.google.com/search?client=safari&rls=en&q=PBS+corporate+welfare&ie=UTF-8&oe=UTF-8 ________________________ Let me know what you think about the idea of corporate welfare, and whether we should continue on this path. Is it outlandish to suggest our government help individuals a bit more and corporations quite a bit less? Leave your ideas in the Comment Section below: The Poverty Trap is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. Get full access to The Poverty Trap at povertytrap.substack.com/subscribe

  7. Aug 2

    July Reading Round-Up...

    Welcome to The Poverty Trap, a Newsletter and Podcast About the Politics And Policy Choices That Create a Cycle of Economic, Racial and Environmental Inequality...and What We Can Do To Change It. Thinking about subscribing? Here’s what one paid subscriber recently had to say about The Poverty Trap: “You do great work, Joan. I don’t always get to read your newsletter, but when I do, I leave more informed and more compassionate…” Amy B. The Poverty Trap’s most recent post laid out a slew of statistics about the impact of ending the enhanced premium subsidies on the Affordable Care Act insurance marketplace. These extra subsidies are what made health insurance actually “affordable” for millions of Americans. And now this help is gone. Here’s what I (and other dedicated prognosticators) said would happen when millions went without health insurance: When adults are sick and can’t receive medical treatment, they work less, maybe even get fired from their jobs, qualify for other types of government assistance, burden already overcrowded emergency rooms and contribute much less to the overall economy. — And first up for our July reading round-up is what is actually happening right now as millions more people go without health insurance, reported in this New York Times article posted on July 30: More and more uninsured patients are showing up in hospital emergency rooms and clinics, having lost their coverage under the Affordable Care Act. Executives running some of the biggest hospital systems, including large for-profit chains spanning many states, expressed concern over the unexpectedly sharp rise in uninsured patients and the costs associated with treating them…And many executives said that the hospitals were also reporting more unpaid medical bills and providing more in the way of charity care. I’m struggling to understand why this rise in uninsured patients was seen by hospital executives as “unexpectedly sharp”. The ACA statistics are public and a massive loss of coverage was predicted last year. Where else will people go except an urgent care or hospital emergency room when they have no doctor and no money to pay for medical services? — And then there is the increasing number of people losing their access to food stamps because of new work requirements, increased paperwork to prove employment hours and routine household information like the number of people living in a household (can you say letters from neighbors attesting to the number of people living in a residence?) Mr. Rogers and his neighbors would be appalled. A New York Times article published July 20 discusses the impact of the major changes to the food stamp program (now known as the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP), enacted through the so-called One Big Beautiful Bill Act. The changes now require proof of 80 hours a month work for 19-64 year olds to remain on or obtain food benefits, more paperwork to prove nearly every bit of information required on the application and large monetary penalties on states for error rates in awarding too little or too much benefits. The article focuses on residents of Arizona struggling to keep alive without enough to eat, like a cancer survivor weighing 69 pounds who has to skip meals, a deaf woman and her hearing impaired children whose eldest daughter sells her plasma each week to buy food and a young mother who “fantasizes’ about stealing a grocery cart loaded with food. Both those seeking the benefits and officials call it “bureaucratic chaos”: Alarmed at the caseload [of food stamp applicants] decline, Arizona rehired some staff and relaxed some paperwork demands, and the rolls grew modestly in May and June. Still, Michael Wisehart, who runs the Arizona Department of Economic Security, which administers SNAP, said, “It’s frankly sickening to me the number of individuals that continue to struggle with the added bureaucracy.” — Adding insult to much injury, the manufacturing jobs President Trump promised would return while campaigning are in fact fleeing from the small towns in states like Ohio and heading to China. A Washington Post article published August 1 described the last day of operations in the Conn Selmer factory (whose parent company was Steinway) in Eastlake, Ohio, a town northeast of Cleveland. The factory made some of the best brass musical instruments in the world, was in operation for over 61 years and in its heyday, employed 334 workers. On June 30, it closed its doors, laying off 150 remaining workers and transferring almost all of its production to a 21 million dollar manufacturing facility in Jiangsu province, China. …there was something inside the plant that Hines [Rob Hines, the current union president] had not experienced elsewhere. In a word, it was pride.He saw it in his co-workers, who would stop and stare in appreciation at a finished French horn or sousaphone. He saw it in the schoolchildren who sometimes toured the factory, where instruments used in the Cleveland Orchestra and the Ohio State University Marching Band were made. “It’s truly amazing, what we do here,” Hines said. ____________________________________ Join The Poverty Trap community and share your thoughts about this reading round-up in the Comment Section below. What do you make of emergency rooms across the country overwhelmed with uninsured patients, the cruelty of the added work requirements and paperwork burdens that are throwing hundreds of thousands of otherwise eligible people off food assistance, and the factory closings that leave people and their communities bereft? The Poverty Trap is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. Get full access to The Poverty Trap at povertytrap.substack.com/subscribe

  8. Jul 22

    Rising Health Care Premiums And Deductibles Equal...

    Welcome to The Poverty Trap, a Newsletter and Podcast About the Politics And Policy Choices That Create a Cycle of Economic, Racial and Environmental Inequality...and What We Can Do To Change It. Thinking about subscribing? Here’s what one paid subscriber recently had to say about The Poverty Trap: “You do great work, Joan. I don’t always get to read your newsletter, but when I do, I leave more informed and more compassionate…” Amy B. One (Maybe Two) Big Things: The enhanced premium tax credits expired at the end of 2025, thanks to the “One Big Beautiful Bill Act”. As a result, ACA monthly premiums have soared an average of 58% from 2025 to 2026. ACA insurers also raised premiums in 2026 by an average of 18%, with another 14% raise expected in 2027. Plus, ACA plan deductibles rose about 37%, or more than $1,000 per individual policy on average. Older and middle-income adults will be hit the hardest because of the “subsidy cliff”, which leaves all ACA enrollees making 400% or more of a state’s poverty level ($62,600—$63,840 for an individual) without any government subsidies to help pay premiums. Analysis of data gathered by the Kaiser Family Foundation (KFF), the Center for Medicare and Medicaid Services and other organizations show a precipitous drop in 2026 enrollment within the ACA marketplace, largely attributable to the shocking increase in insurance premiums from both insurer premium increases and loss of premium insurance credits, together with rising deductibles for various policies: * Based on reports to date of sign-ups and premium payments, average monthly effectuated ACA Marketplace enrollment could fall to about 17.5 million people in 2026 and could be as low as 16.5 million people, down from 22.3 million people in 2025. * Premium payments from enrollees increased by an average of 58% from $113 to $178 per month. This is lower than the 114% increase KFF projected if everyone had stayed in the same plan because many people bought down to higher-deductible plans and because those just past the subsidy cliff with the steepest increases dropped ACA coverage at higher rates. * Average ACA Marketplace deductibles increased by 37% (or $1,027 per person) to a record high of $3,786 in 2026. This is the steepest increase in deductibles ever seen in this market and largely reflects the shift from silver plans with reduced deductibles for lower-income enrollees to bronze plans with very high deductibles. A report published by Wakely Consulting Group early this year analyzed the impact of falling enrollment in the ACA market place. Although the reduction in enrollment so far in 2026 was less than projected in 2025, many who stayed with an ACA plan traded premium costs for higher deductibles by switching from higher cost plans like the most popular Silver tier, to Bronze plans with lower out-of-pocket premiums and less coverage, but much higher deductibles. The Wakely report also projected additional enrollment losses throughout this year: Effectuated enrollment (the number of people who pay premiums and maintain effective coverage) is expected to fall even further than previous years as 2026 unfolds and many enrollees are unable to afford higher premium payments without enhanced tax credits, signaling significant mid-year attrition on top of already declining sign-ups. Why It Matters: The massive jump in 2026 premiums and deductibles for health insurance purchased through the ACA Market Place (with another planned 14% increase in 2027) is not affordable for tens of millions of Americans, now or in the future. These individuals and families with children already have dropped health insurance altogether, or switched to ACA plans that have less coverage and higher deductibles, setting them up for massive medical debt if they dare to get sick or have an accident. When adults are sick and can’t receive medical treatment, they work less, maybe even get fired from their jobs, qualify for other types of government assistance, burden already overcrowded emergency rooms and contribute much less to the overall economy. And they will die. The U.S. Senate Committee on Finance says that 8, 811 Americans will die each year from this Administration’s failure to extend the ACA premium tax credits, alone. Here’s more on what the U.S. Senate Committee on Finance had to say about American deaths resulting from this year’s changes to the ACA, after analyzing studies conducted by the University of Pennsylvania’s Leonard Davis Institute of Health Economics (Penn LDI) and the Yale School of Public Health’s Center for Infectious Disease Modeling and Analysis: * 11,300 deaths per year from the loss of Medicaid or Affordable Care Act Marketplace coverage due to 7.7 million people losing coverage. * 18,200 deaths per year due to the loss of Medicaid coverage among 1.38 million low-income Medicare beneficiaries, causing loss of access to low-income prescription drug assistance. * 13,000 deaths per year among Medicaid enrollees in nursing homes due to the rollback of the 2024 nursing home minimum staffing rule. * 8,811 deaths per year from the proposed bill’s failure to extend the enhanced ACA premium tax credits. What We Must Do: We must expand Medicare to cover every American citizen and those people living in the United States legally. We also must expand Medicare to include dental, vision, hearing and full coverage of prescription drugs. There must be no more subsidies paid by taxpayers to insurance companies in a vain effort to keep prices down and keep their profits up, no uninsured people, no one forced to declare bankruptcy for medical debt only billionaires could pay, and most importantly, no one dying because they can’t afford health care. This is the least we must do in the wealthiest country on Earth. ——————————————————— The question for this post is: Are you in favor of an expanded Medicare system that covers all of our citizens and legal residents? Please feel free to leave any thoughts and ideas in the Comment Section below. And please don’t forget to share, like and restack this post as you can—every share helps grow our Poverty Trap community—thanks! The Poverty Trap is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. Get full access to The Poverty Trap at povertytrap.substack.com/subscribe

About

A Podcast for those who are fed up with the inequality baked into America's system and want to collectively make change. povertytrap.substack.com