The Professor's Bayonet

Jason Dew

Book reviews and social commentary

  1. 1d ago

    Episode 144 - Manatee

    On vacation in Florida a few years ago, we paid good money to have a guide take us out on a boat to see dolphins and manatees.  We cruised around for the allotted hour and a half but to no avail.  Nothing.  Nada.  Of course, the disclaimer given to us before we put on our lifejackets and boarded the boat was that nature can be capricious; there was no guarantee that we would see anything.  But even so, we were disappointed. We got wet because it rained. The sea was choppy.  This for thirty dollars each.    The next day, we went swimming.  The skies had cleared up, and the water was warm.  My wife and I were chest deep.  Our daughters were nearby.  Suddenly, I spied a dark mass moving beneath the surface mere feet away from her.  I called it out.  She saw the same thing.  We had no idea what it was.  Sharks are common in this area.  We both struggled to put distance between us and whatever it was that was swimming near us, but the going was slow, very slow.      We eventually got clear enough to see that what was lazily making its way through the water was a full-grown manatee, a harmless creature known for its docility.  What we had paid to see the day before suddenly showed up.  A surprise.  An exhilarating surprise.    To Florida residents, especially those who live on the coast, manatees and dolphins are part of the everyday fauna.  Sightings are common.  These creatures to them are like squirrels and deer to folks who live in the wooded interior.  Nothing special.  But to those who live in a suburb of Atlanta, especially little girls, dolphins and manatees are almost magical.  My daughters certainly thought so.  And they were disappointed at not seeing them on our chartered tour.  However, what we experienced that day, paddling around in the water, was even better.  It was unexpected.  Out of nowhere.  But way more intimate.  And, I hasten to say, dear listeners, infinitely better.  What is the lesson here?  We yearn, oftentimes desperately, for mountaintop experiences.  We want magic.  We are hungry for the highs we get by escaping the mundane, the routine, the ordinary.  That is why I swiped my card and got the tickets for the boat ride – why everyone was looking forward to the adventure of seeing a manatee or a dolphin, and, yes, for us, that would have been an adventure.  But it was not to be, and we walked away unfulfilled.  But there was another plan in place – a plan that, when fulfilled, was more "mountaintop" than we could have imagined.  As an educator, I am always looking for the underlying lesson in pretty much every event, and this was no different.  What was I being taught?  What is the major takeaway?  As a Christian, though, my instinct is to see any lesson as part of Providence.  God was teaching me something.  And I have to wonder if it had anything to do with my desire to create mountaintop experiences on my own versus His desire to deliver even better ones so long as they align with His timing.  I am not saying that boats should never be chartered or vacations, planned.  For us to experience the manatee, we had to be in the water in the first place – had to be in Florida.  But there is something to say about forcing the magic, forcing the mountaintop experience.  It speaks to our current state, the mundaneness of our lives, the inescapable typicalness of it all.   What are manatees, then, but God breaking into the everyday on His terms and according to His timetable?  Perhaps we need to remind ourselves that there is a heaven and that it is not here.  Right now.  When we choose to create it.  In fact, desperately trying to create mountaintop experiences is akin to believing that we can create heaven here on earth.  This is a fool's errand, of course.  But if we are patient and if we have faith, God will give us a foretaste of what is to come.  A hint.  A brilliant light, surprising us by its presence, encouraging us to keep plodding forward so that there will be manatees ... and dolphins forever.

  2. Nov 10

    Episode 143 - Not the Boss of Me

    The sheer genius behind the writing of The Office, that hilarious program featuring the antics of Michael Scott, Dwight Schrute, Jim Halpert, and Pam Beasley, just to name a few, is that the writers knew one thing about human beings: when it is all said and done, we are just children.  Forty-year-old children.  Fifty-five-year-old children.  Sixty-year-old children.  This is the running thesis of The Office.  That is why it remains so funny.  The audience recognizes something of themselves in each character – perhaps something that we would prefer to remain behind the veneer of adulthood but something familiar nevertheless.  The characters are all kids pretending or, at least, doing their best to appear grown up, but the comedy comes through when they fail, when their true selves peek through.  I have to wonder if we would do well by applying this thesis to our daily interactions.  What if we were able to see the child in our co-workers, our supervisors, our neighbors, the people we see at the gym, the park, in church.  The curious little idiosyncrasies might come into better relief.  We might even be more forgiving or, at least, wiser when folks subtly remind us of their titles or positions in the course of casual conversation.  Is this the playground kid who is trying to assert some control – the ones we remind that they are not the boss of me?  Or the many folks I see at Simpsonwood Park with their dogs.  In their offices, they are "somebody"; on the dirt trail in the park, they are playmates with their pets, speaking to them in funny voices and, sometimes, in a special, secret language.  When I caught on to what the writers of The Office were doing, it was difficult not to go about my day, looking at everybody I encountered as kids.  Truth be told, it was a fun and very revealing exercise.  To be sure, I saw how vulnerable everybody really was and how there really is no point in anybody's life when they have it all together.  We are still learning, still falling down and going boom.  Only our appearance changes and the expectations others have of us and we have of ourselves.  Scripture tells us that we must be like children in order to enter the Kingdom of Heaven.  When we die, many like to note that we can't take our wealth with us, but I wonder if dying also means leaving behind any pretense that we were anything but children of God.  No titles.  No positions.  No special roles.  We must be stripped of these along with any material wealth in order to pass through the narrow gate.  This is a prerequisite to regaining innocence, a requirement for entry into paradise.  As I write this, the weather in Georgia is spectacular.  The temperature is perfect, and the leaves on the trees are ablaze in color: reds and yellows.  After I do my work, I take Arrow, my dog, to Simpsonwood Park where I remove the earbuds and enter the woods in silence.  I am merely a man with his dog.  When I make it to the trail along the Chattahoochee River, I locate the marble bench, and I sit.  I look at the flowing water.  I spy a squirrel here and there.  I marvel at how the sunrays light up the autumn leaves.  Today, I watched trout rise for a bite to eat.  And Arrow sits before me, sure that some part of his body is touching mine.  Simple.  At ease.  Peaceful.  Not an ounce of pretense.  Just me and the Poobrador AKA Arrow AKA Smitty AKA Apple Sauce.  The last, a new one, just because it makes me chuckle.  www.48bconsulting.com

  3. Nov 3

    Episode 142 - Endurance

    Under the leadership of Sir Ernest Shackleton, the Imperial Trans-Antarctic Expedition set out in 1914 aboard a ship named the Endurance, its last port of call in Buenos Aires, Argentina.  Their mission was to cross the Antarctic overland.  In October of 1915, however, the ship was trapped and destroyed by ice, leaving the men no choice but to abandon ship.  For the next five months, 28 men were subjected to below freezing temperatures, gale force winds, capricious ice floes, near starvation, and a ferocious sea all while being drenched with the elements.  But the reality was that they were hundreds of miles away from any outpost when the Endurance gave up the ghost.  The men could have easily given in to despair, mutinied, or just willed themselves dead.  But in Shackleton there was real, unwavering leadership.  He developed a plan, and he rallied his men to follow it. They plotted a course. They maintained their professional bearing despite the massive odds against them. After weeks of living on ice floes, they boarded the two smallish vessels that came with the Endurance and eventually found land – Elephant Island.  From there it was decided that a smaller crew should set out for South Georgia Island where a whaling station was located.  This leg of the journey alone was treacherous, and the chances that this crew would make it was small.  But go, they did, back into the icy sea to search for help, leaving half of the expedition crew there to wait.  It took weeks, but they finally landed on South Georgia Island and had to trek across a jagged and dangerous land to reach the whaling station.  Three men, Ernest Shackleton, Frank Worsley, and Thomas Crean limped into the station, emaciated, covered in blisters and soars, beards matted, clothes in tatters, wet but alive. They survived the ordeal, and soon enough, gathered a rescue crew for the others.  Every single man survived.  Not one person perished.  A miracle.  A testament to grit and the power of hope. Shackleton's voyage occurred at a time when the place of nature in determining the actions and choices of man was being debated in intellectual circles around the globe.  What came to be known as naturalism was a worldview that went something like this: never mind a person's education, refinement, social background, or notions of himself, his base animal nature will eventually rule the day.  Man is governed by instinct more than he is by conscience.  We can see how this was the confluence of Darwin and Freud; we are sexual, and we are animals.  Put the two together to get a better picture of the truest quality of man. It is not flattering. Shackleton's voyage, however, paints a different picture.  Sure, the men despaired and fought amongst themselves.  They doubted and feared and likely did mean and base things; however, in the fact of nature itself, they persevered.  They overcame.  They rose above.  Indeed, they did not let themselves be governed by their instincts save that to survive, showing the world a nobler side to human beings, a side that was expressly not being championed in the halls of the academy. Perhaps this is why Shackleton's voyage is so captivating.  In a situation where men could let themselves be ugly, they, instead, chose to be men of determination and, yes, faith.  They endured.  Should we look at the rough waters, the constant wet, the frigid temperatures in our own lives and do the same?  Should this account of 28 men surviving everything the Antarctic threw at them inspire us to walk taller, knowing that we were made for this fight called life on earth, this pilgrim voyage, doing our best to land in the eternal peace and comfort of heaven? Perhaps this is the real takeaway of Alfred Lansing's book, Endurance: Shackleton's Incredible Voyage.  The men were heroic.  We, too, can be heroic, our eyes set, not on the tips of our own noses, but on the horizons before us.  Therein lies the glory.  Therein lies the One true hope.  www.48bconsulting.com

  4. Oct 27

    Episode 140 - Ghosts

    In a 1990 interview on NPR's "Fresh Air," Anne Rice, author of Interview with the Vampire shared that she had never experienced anything supernatural.  She believed that the claims that others had experienced the supernatural were valid; however, she herself could not be counted among them.  I found this strange, dear listeners, that Rice would make this claim, given the fact that she was raised Catholic and surely received Holy Communion during Mass.  What is transubstantiation – the turning of bread and wine into the body and blood of Jesus Christ -- but supernatural?  In this same interview, Rice said that she had lost her faith.  In 1998, she would reenter the Catholic Church.  As a Catholic, I understand that there are two realms – the physical and the spiritual – and that they regularly blend as when we ask saints to intercede for us or when we ask Saint Michael the Archangel to "defend us in battle."  On the subject of ghosts, however, Church teaching seems to suggest that these are individuals who somewhere in between the world as we know it at present and the world to come: the afterlife.  In fact, I often wonder if this is what purgatory is.  Purgatory, after all, is that place some souls go in order to be cleansed of or "purged" of any lingering impurities. Ghosts, in this light, may be the souls of those who, upon dying, still had some leftover issues to work through.  These issues prevent the soul from seeing the "light" of God's face, so they stick around for a spell to smooth out the wrinkles of their lives.  The very heart posture of a practicing Catholic is such that the lines are open between the two realms.  One night, aunt Nelly put a pot of water on the stove for it to boil.  She left the kitchen for a moment, but on her return, she found the pot on the floor, water spilled everywhere.  Strange, she must have thought.  So she filled the pot again and placed it back on the stove.  She left the kitchen again and came back to find the same messy scene.  This happened so often that the wooden floorboards in front of the stove got damaged, so uncle Gerald had to replace them.  He pulled up the water-soaked boards, but before he installed the new boards, he spotted something white in the hole he had made.  He reached down and pulled out an object wrapped in white linen, and when he peeled back the cloth, he discovered something horrific: the skeletal remains of a baby.  The previous owner had a daughter who got pregnant out of wedlock.  Not wanting the baby, she became desperate, so when it was born, she boiled it to death and hid her crime beneath the floorboards.  Or the time my grandmother had a dream that her brother, Alvin, was staying in a pretty little cabin at the base of a hill but was not allowed to leave.  He was not ready.  He had to wait.  But why?  He shot himself and died leaning against the trunk of a great tree.  His reasons were straightforward.  His wife had left him, and he had cancer.  He was also tired of the nightmares.  Alvin had fought at the Battle of the Bulge in World War II. Alvin was a man who shouldered a lot of pain, and while his actions can never be justified, it might explain why he had to stay in a pretty little cabin until he was better.  Purgatory?  Perhaps.  One would hope that God's grace was extended to him.  You, dear listeners, likely have your own unexplainable tales of the supernatural: disembodied spirits manifesting in the physical world.  Remember, though, that you yourself are spirit, though embodied, which means that the spiritual realm is a part of you and you apart of it.  So Anne Rice, great writer though she was, was myopic in her thinking about the supernatural.  What she claims not to have experienced was all around her, was, indeed, inside her.  How much more bold would we be if we simply embraced this fact?  The physical is brief; the spiritual is eternal.  Practically speaking, then, which language is better for us to invest in learning?

  5. Oct 20

    Episode 139 - I Pity the Fool

    Picture this, dear listeners: Hulk Hogan and Mr. T are training in New York City's Central Park.  They are running up hills, doing pull ups, shadow boxing, getting ready for the big fight otherwise known as Wrestle Mania.  They are pumped up and doing all they can to get the crowd just as excited.  In the gym they take turns on the punching bag.  Hulk Hogan gives it a few good hits.  Mr. T all but tackles it.  And all around them, the crowd cheers, runs up the hill, too.  Does some pull ups.  They are getting ready as well.  But the interesting fact about the crowd is that it is made up entirely of children.  We are not talking about adults.  No.  Middle schoolers and even younger.  Two enormous men, wearing muscle shirts and sweat bands are leading a crowd of children, getting them pumped, excited.  I recall watching this spectacle in the 1980s when I was the very age of most of the members of the crowd and feeling the excitement at home in rural Pennsylvania.  I was particularly drawn to Mr. T.  He was also, after all, B.A. Baracas from the A-Team.  On the playground at Youngsville Elementary, I was Faceman.  A bulkier friend was always B.A. Baracas, and he did well enough being afraid of flying.  If you know that detail about the character, then you know.  If not, do some research.  As a father looking back on that training sequence for Wrestle Mania, I am struck by how dad-like Hulk Hogan and Mr. T really were.  I can see what they were up to.  They were playing with the kids, having loads of fun, even.  They were modeling what manhood looked like albeit in an over-the-top caricaturist way.  They were strong and motivated.  They were no pushovers.  They were ready for battle.  Motivated.  Resilient.  How come on their heels we see the likes of Homer Simpson who debuted in the late 80s/early 90s?  He was and remains a laughingstock, a clown.  And then Peter Griffin from Family Guy.  Dim-witted, fat and foolish.  Remember Al Bundy from Married with Children?  Also fat and foolish.  Dimwitted.  A dolt.  Why did fatherhood come under such synchronized attack?  How do we explain this emerging trope in fatherhood that has the supposed head of the household look so pitifully stupid?  Ideas that begin in the academy eventually make their way to popular culture.  I have spoken before on the significance of the Frankfurt School in shaping Western culture in that proponents saw everything through either a Marxist lens – have and have nots – or a Freudian lens where everything is sexualized.  What we see as an end result of that way of looking at and understanding the world is the breakdown of the nuclear family beginning with the father.  Remove him from the equation, and everything falls like a row of dominos.  If he can't be removed, just make him look like an incompetent idiot, put him on a public stage – i.e. television – and mock him collectively.  In the end, power and influence is concentrated with the state, and the Marxists win.  But I wonder if we might be seeing a pivot in our culture toward Mr. T and men of his ilk.  And it is germinating in the vocation of fatherhood.  Men are taking a stand.  They have had enough of the mockery.  If this is the case, then I suppose we really are getting ready for a big contest.  We might not be running up hills in Central Park or pummeling a punching bag will all our strength, but we are moving the conversation onto the sports fields as coaches, into schools as mentors, and into homes as dads who refuse to give up their posts.  They are in it for the long haul.  Quitting is not in their vocabulary.  They are guys who got no time for jibber jabber.

  6. Oct 13

    Episode 138 - Curious Parallels at an Ed Sheeran Concert

    I certainly do not aim to be a killjoy.  A good friend had two extra tickets to an Ed Sheeran concert, so my wife and I rused home from a Homecoming event for two of our daughters, ordered an Uber, and made our way to the Mercedes Benz Stadium in downtown Atlanta.  Seconds after we sat down, Ed Sheeran appeared on stage and began to perform for thousands of fans.  I simply took it all in, made some observations. h A machine spewed smoke over the fans and the stage.  During the slower songs, hundreds of fans turned on their phone’s flashlight and waved it back and forth.  Those who knew the lyrics sang along with Ed Sheeran, and at times, Ed Sheeran would ask the large crowd to engage in a little call and response: he said one thing, the audience said another.  On another occasion, he asked the crowd to jump at a certain part of the song, and at the end of the show, he took a long bow before the lights came up.  No beer was thrown.  At the concert my youngest attended the night before, there was.  The crowd was doused in it.  Sitting at the Ed Sheeran concert, I could not help but consider other parallels, specifically between rock concerts and the celebration of the Mass.  At Mass, the altar is oftentimes incensed.  Incense or smoke is distributed around the altar and the worshipers.  Just like the smoke machine at the concert.  Were the fans and the stage being incensed?  Candles are also lit during Mass, and for special occasions such as baptisms, other candles are lit.  Very similar to flashlights on cellphones being waved back and forth.  During Mass, the priest says things, and the worshipers respond in kind.  At my parish, the Our Father is actually sung, and those who “know the lyrics” sing along.  This is not much different than what happens at concerts.  When Ed Sheeran asked his fans to jump during a particular part of a song, I thought of the times when we kneel and stand during the Mass.  Physical movement, for both, is part of the experience.  And, in the end, he bowed.  Is not bowing also a part of the Holy Mass?  As for the beer, none was thrown during the Ed Sheeran concert, but plenty was thrown at the concert my daughter attended.  On some occasions, Holy water is thrown onto the worshipers during Mass as a reminder of their baptism and a blessing for spiritual protection.  What was going on at the concert my daughter attended?  Naturally, I tested my theory on my wife and daughter, and if I am being honest, the theory was not well-received.  Folks are just having fun.  Ed Sheeran in all likelihood has no idea such parallels exist.  The notion that he might is simply ludicrous.  I am overthinking this way too much.  Perhaps.  But the behaviors and accoutrements at the concerts are eerily the same as the behaviors and accoutrements at Mass.  Surely, this is more than a coincidence.  The dots connect.  But are we comfortable with the picture?  I am not saying that the fans and the performers alike are willingly participating in some weird inversion of the Mass, but I do wonder why it is that thousands upon thousands of individuals enjoy music in a particular way – a way that mirrors what happens at a Catholic Mass.  How did it come to be this way?  What is more, isn’t it interesting that nobody seems to be talking about it – that even devout Catholics deny that there exists a parallel at all?  It is likely, dear listeners, that discussing it here in this episode of The Professor’s Bayonet will not win me any more invitations to attend concerts, and this is fine.  I can enjoy music in other ways.  However, if the aim of this project called The Professor’s Bayonet is to pursue what is true then I have to accept the consequences of that posture.  Even if it means quizzical looks, shaking heads, and at least one “Oh, dad” from a teenage girl.

  7. Oct 6

    Episode 137 - Schwarzer Humor

    In Episode 51 of The Professor's Bayonet, I explored Shirley Jackson's famous short story, "The Lottery," for how it points toward humanity's shared concupiscence or tendency to sin.  The story takes place in an orderly small town populated by orderly citizens who, once a year, stone to death one of their peers.  Violence is built into their community.  It is what keeps their society stable.  The yearly murder is a safety valve to let off steam. Naturally, this short story lends itself to a conversation about the place of violence in our society.  It is in the movies we watch, the teams we support.  It is in our music and politics, the television series we binge, the sometimes attitudes we take with the others, the outsiders, the strangers we feel are trying to cut in on our resources. When I teach Jackson's "The Lottery," I sometimes pair that discussion with a discussion on a popular Saturday Night Live parody of the famous scene at the end of the film, "Dead Poet's Society."  You, dear listeners, might know it.  Mr. Keating, played by Robin Williams, is an English teacher at an elite prep school for boys.  His teaching style is not appreciated, so the administrations sacks him, tells him he must leave.  While gathering his belongings from his former classroom, his students, swept up in a spirit of rebellion, express their disapproval by standing on their desks and proclaiming, "O captain, my captain!"  The SNL writers offer a much darker version.  The canned English teacher is Mr. Bunting, and while he is collecting his personals from the classroom, his students also choose to express their disapproval.  Instead of saying, "O captain, my captain," they proclaim, "I sing my song for all to hear."  The live studio audience begins to giggle.  One after another student stands on their desk, proclaiming the same words until one hapless student stands on his desk, and immediately gets decapitated by the ceiling fan above. Blood spurts everywhere as the student's head is clumsily passed from one horror-stricken person to another until it is tossed outside where a lawnmower chews it to bits, splattering what is left on the window. What is notable, dear listeners, is the reaction of the audience.  They are roaring with laughter.  They love the dark humor or what the Germans call schwarzer humor: something that should not by any account be funny yet still tickles the funny bone nevertheless. Why is this display of gore and death so hilarious?  Why did the community in Jackson's short story have a lottery at all – this once-a-year stoning to death of a randomly-chosen person?   I have had numerous discussions on this very topic, but it occurred to me while working out at the Y that, perhaps, dark humor is the only thing that can satisfy the itch we all have concerning our own mortality.  Allow me to explain:  We are all going to die.  We all know this, and the sheer weight of this knowledge can be extraordinary.  What if the only way to deal with this reality is to laugh?  Reasoning with it won't make it change.  Indeed, reasoning with it might tip us toward insanity.  It cannot be negotiated with.  We might deny it for a while, but life has a way of reminding us of its presence.  What can we do with the reality of our common mortality but have a laugh?    The Absurdists of the 20th century certainly had this in mind when they decided that the universe was indifferent and that trying to find meaning out of it was a fool's errand.  But how are we to look at schwarzer humor if we believe that the universe is not indifferent?  Perhaps we might see dark humor as a way to take ourselves with all of our deep and complex questions less seriously.  This might seem to be a tall mental order, but our emotions clearly have another response.  Laughter.  What cannot be beat or negotiated or denied can only be laughed at, for, in truth, it is the only response we really have.  It is all that is left after we wear ourselves down.

Ratings & Reviews

5
out of 5
7 Ratings

About

Book reviews and social commentary