No Former Athlete

No Former Athlete

Welcome to the No Former Athlete Podcast, where we explore the challenges retired athletes face as they transition from sports to a new identity. Most athletes spend more time retired than playing, often feeling lost and confused. It's not about sports. Hosts Erin McGinnis and Alex Gasaway delve into the emotional hurdles of leaving competitive sports. Through personal stories and insights, they discuss the search for new validation and maintaining confidence and purpose. Tune in as we highlight these hidden challenges and reshape life after sports.

  1. Jul 9

    The Day She Got Her Jersey Was The Day Her Career Ended

    What happens when the sport that shaped you is taken away in a second? In this episode of No Former Athlete, Erin sits down with Ciara — former volleyball player, Navy veteran, coach, content creator, and founder of The New Mix — to talk about athlete identity, career-ending injury, mental health, and rebuilding confidence after sport. Use code CIARAPOD to get a special discount to get lifetime access on the NFA Breathe Here Now Virtual Breathwork session. https://www.noformerathlete.com/bhn Ciara grew up as a volleyball player through and through. After receiving D1 and D2 offers, she made the unexpected decision to join the United States Navy instead of playing in college. But volleyball was still part of the plan. After years of waiting for the chance to play for the All-Navy volleyball team, she finally made the roster and got her USA jersey. Then, on the same day she got her jersey, she suffered a career-ending injury. Ciara opens up about the reality of nerve damage, relearning everyday tasks like tying her shoes and turning a doorknob, coaching while she was still grieving the loss of playing, and realizing later that she had been struggling with depression. She also shares how being in the military impacted the way she processed mental health, why stepping away from volleyball eventually helped her heal, and how the athlete in her still shows up today. The conversation also explores Ciara’s life after sport — from coaching and content creation to fashion, modeling, social media, personal style, and building a brand rooted in confidence and representation. She talks about growing up in the South, not seeing herself reflected in fashion, learning to get in front of the camera, being recognized online, and why little C would be so proud of the person she has become. This episode is about losing the version of yourself you thought you’d always be — and realizing the athlete never really leaves. It just finds a new place to go. In this episode, we talk about: Choosing the Navy over college volleyballPlaying for the All-Navy volleyball teamThe day Ciara got her jersey and suffered a career-ending injuryRecovering from nerve damage and relearning basic movementsDepression after sport and injuryMental health stigma in the militaryCoaching while grieving the ability to playAthlete identity after retirementCompetitiveness, leadership, and intensity after sportBuilding a career in content creation and fashionRepresentation, confidence, and personal styleWhat parts of the athlete still show up in Ciara’s work today Use code CIARAPOD to get a special discount to get lifetime access on the NFA Breathe Here Now Virtual Breathwork session. https://www.noformerathlete.com/bhn Listen to this episode if you’ve ever had to let go of a version of yourself — or if you’re still figuring out where the athlete in you belongs now.

  2. May 8

    From 3rd ACL Tear to Everest Base Camp in 13 Months

    What happens when you stop playing the sport that shaped your entire identity? In this episode, we’re talking about the very real transition from college athlete to “normal life” — and why so many no former athletes struggle with losing structure, purpose, validation, and identity after sports end. Jen, a retired Division III soccer player turned physical therapist and business owner, shares her experience navigating athlete identity, ACL recovery, burnout, perfectionism, and the mental side of life after college sports. After tearing her ACL three separate times, including once during her senior season of college soccer, she opens up about grief, rehab, resilience, and learning how to channel her competitive mindset into new challenges outside of athletics. We also dive into: The pressure of chasing athletic scholarships and playing college sportsChoosing Division III athletics over the D1 grindRecovering from multiple ACL tearsThe emotional side of sports injuries and rehabNo former athlete identity and post-college depressionBurnout, hustle culture, and productivity addictionLearning how to rest without guiltTransitioning from student-athlete to working professionalBuilding confidence outside of sportsFinding purpose through fitness, movement, and entrepreneurshipHiking to Everest Base Camp after ACL surgeryIf you’ve ever struggled with life after sports, missed the structure of being an athlete, or wondered why achievement and productivity became tied to your self-worth, this conversation will hit home. Whether you’re a no former athlete, college athlete, physical therapist, runner, soccer player, or someone figuring out who you are after a major life transition — this episode is for you.

  3. Feb 14

    She Built One of the First Women’s Sports Platforms — Now She’s at ESPN

    From Competitive Cheerleader to Women’s Sports Broadcaster | Athlete Identity After Sport with Ari Most people assume Ari played basketball. She’s 6 feet tall. She covers women’s sports. It feels obvious. But her athletic background? Taekwondo. Gymnastics. Competitive all-star cheer. Volleyball. Use code ARIPOD to get a special discount to get lifetime access on the NFA Breathe Here Now Virtual Breathwork session. https://bit.ly/Ari-Breathwork In this episode of the No Former Athlete Podcast, Ari shares her full athletic journey — from earning a black belt at 4 years old to competing in Division I cheer, to navigating a medical situation that abruptly ended her volleyball career. We talk about: The physical reality of competitive cheerleading (and why it’s one of the most demanding sports)Growing up tall in gymnasticsLosing a sport unexpectedlyTransitioning out of team athleticsRedirecting competitive energy into career and entrepreneurshipFounding Highlighter and building a platform for women’s sportsThe perfectionism that follows athletes into adulthoodWhy women’s sports advocacy is her life’s workThis conversation goes deep into athlete identity after sport, chasing perfection outside of competition, and what it means to still be an athlete long after the uniform comes off. If you’ve ever struggled with life after sports, leaving a team environment, or redefining what winning looks like — this episode is for you. Are you an athlete? Ari’s answer: Always. Forever. Even if it looks different now. Use code ARIPOD to get a special discount to get lifetime access on the NFA Breathe Here Now Virtual Breathwork session. https://bit.ly/Ari-Breathwork

Trailer

Ratings & Reviews

5
out of 5
17 Ratings

About

Welcome to the No Former Athlete Podcast, where we explore the challenges retired athletes face as they transition from sports to a new identity. Most athletes spend more time retired than playing, often feeling lost and confused. It's not about sports. Hosts Erin McGinnis and Alex Gasaway delve into the emotional hurdles of leaving competitive sports. Through personal stories and insights, they discuss the search for new validation and maintaining confidence and purpose. Tune in as we highlight these hidden challenges and reshape life after sports.