The Horseshoe Hangover

Tom Connolly & Chris Dyer
  • 5.0 (6)
  • Football
  • Weekly

Join two passionate Colts and NFL outsiders every week as we break down the latest Indianapolis Colts news, analyze key NFL matchups, and share unfiltered takes on all things football. From game recaps to league-wide insights, *The Horseshoe Hangover* offers a fresh, weekly perspective on the highs and lows of Colts Nation. Saddle up and tune in each week as we ride through the season with a drink in hand and plenty of football talk! We call it how we see it and will not hold back.

  1. 20h ago

    2026 Week 8 recap: The Curse Continues! Colts Get Demolished in Jacksonville

    00:00 – Intro01:14 – Opening Thoughts & Social Media Update03:49 – Colts Game Recap: Where Do We Even Begin?04:43 – An Old-Fashioned Beatdown: The Colts Get Embarrassed06:43 – Should Shane Steichen Still Have a Job?09:42 – Tyler Warren12:04 – Josh Downs: His Performance and Future in Indy18:04 – Young Players Step Up, but the Results Stay the Same26:25 – From Playoff Hopes to Rock Bottom in Just One Year27:45 – Why Hasn't Shane Steichen Been Fired?30:49 – Anthony Richardson to the Rescue? Is It Time for AR?39:00 – Fire Shane Steichen and Move On From Daniel Jones!42:23 – What's Keeping Carlie Irsay From Firing Shane?46:09 – Colts Trade Rumors: Who's Next to Go?50:45 – Jonathan Taylor's Trade Value: What's JT28 Worth?55:30 – Colts Nation Deserves Something Worth Cheering For57:01 – The Outside Perspective: How the NFL Views Indianapolis1:00:05 – Where's the Excitement? Give Colts Fans Something to Believe In!1:02:40 – Does Carlie Irsay Deserve Some of the Blame?1:06:05 – A Defining Moment: The Future of the Indianapolis ColtsThe Indianapolis Colts have hit ROCK BOTTOM! After another embarrassing beatdown, Colts Nation is left asking one question: How much worse does it have to get before something changes?On this episode of the Horseshoe Hangover, Chris and Tom break down another disastrous Colts performance and why the time has come for serious decisions about Shane Steichen, Daniel Jones, and the future of this franchise.Despite flashes from young players like Caden Curry and CJ Allen, the results remain the same. Is it time to give Anthony Richardson another shot? Why hasn't Carlie Irsay pulled the trigger on Shane Steichen? And with trade rumors swirling around Jonathan Taylor, is this organization heading toward a complete rebuild?We also tackle the bigger picture: How did a team that looked ready to compete for the AFC South just a year ago fall this far? Does Carlie Irsay deserve some of the blame? And what will it take to give Colts Nation something worth cheering for again?This isn't just another disappointing season. We're witnessing a defining moment in Indianapolis Colts history, and the decisions made now could shape this franchise for the next decade.We're just two fans who love football, calling it like we see it!Colts Nation, we want to hear from YOU! Should Shane Steichen be fired immediately? Should Anthony Richardson get another opportunity? Or is it time to blow the whole thing up?Drop your thoughts in the comments, subscribe, and join the conversation!#Colts #ColtsNation #IndianapolisColts #NFL

  2. 4d ago

    2026 Week 8: The Jacksonville Curse, Locker room interviews, & Josh Downs requests a trade.

    Episode Chapters00:00 – Intro01:18 – Social Media Update04:00 – The Jacksonville Curse: Can the Colts Break It?14:46 – Colts Locker Room Interviews17:00 – Tom's Grover Stewart Story27:31 – Chris Ballard's Draft Mistakes35:30 – Positional Value: Are the Colts Building a Team the Wrong Way?42:00 – Simmons vs Buckner: Comparing Trade Value48:00 – Josh Downs Requests a Trade55:50 – Maximize Trade Value or Respect the Player's Wishes?1:00:00 – The Faces of Colts Nation1:08:10 – Weekly NFL Picks1:12:48 – OutroIs it time for the Colts to break the curse, or are we headed for another Jacksonville nightmare? This week on Horseshoe Hangover, Chris and Tom dive into the Colts' struggles in Jacksonville, the latest locker room interviews, and the decisions that have put this franchise in its current position.We revisit Chris Ballard's draft mistakes and discuss why draft picks are GOLD in today's NFL. Are the Colts investing in the right positions, or have they spent years misunderstanding positional value?We also compare the Jeffery Simmons and DeForest Buckner trades, break down the Josh Downs trade request, and debate one of the toughest questions facing NFL front offices: Do you maximize a player's trade value or let him choose his next destination?Plus, Tom shares his personal encounter with Grover Stewart, we discuss the faces of Colts Nation, and wrap things up with our weekly NFL picks!Episode Chapters00:00 – Intro01:18 – Social Media Update04:00 – The Jacksonville Curse: Can the Colts Break It?14:46 – Colts Locker Room Interviews17:00 – Tom's Grover Stewart Story27:31 – Chris Ballard's Draft Mistakes35:30 – Positional Value: Are the Colts Building a Team the Wrong Way?42:00 – Jeffery Simmons vs. DeForest Buckner: Comparing Trade Value48:00 – Josh Downs Requests a Trade55:50 – Maximize Trade Value or Respect the Player's Wishes?1:00:00 – The Faces of Colts Nation1:08:10 – Weekly NFL Picks1:12:48 – OutroWe're just two fans who love football, telling it like we see it!Join Chris and Tom for another episode of Horseshoe Hangover, where Colts Nation gets the unfiltered conversation it deserves!Like, subscribe, and tell us: Should the Colts focus on accumulating draft picks or keeping their proven veterans?#HorseshoeHangover #ColtsNation #ForTheShoe #BleedBlue #IndianapolisColts #NFL #ColtsFootball

  3. Oct 28

    🚨EMERGENCY POD: THE COLTS ARE BLOWING IT UP! Nelson & Buckner TRADED! 🚨

    The Chris Ballard era is officially being dismantled in Indianapolis! 💣🏈Just days after firing Chris Ballard, the Colts have reportedly traded two of the biggest cornerstones of the franchise: Quenton Nelson and DeForest Buckner!Chris and Tom jump on the mic for an emergency episode of Horseshoe Hangover to break down what these blockbuster moves mean for the future of the Indianapolis Colts.Two proven leaders. Two All-Pro talents. Two players who gave everything to the Horseshoe through years of quarterback chaos, coaching changes, and disappointing seasons.We discuss:What the Colts received in return and whether it was enough.Why Carlie Irsay is tearing down the foundation of the Ballard era.What losing Nelson and Buckner means for the locker room and Colts Nation.Who could be the next big name on the trading block.Is this a complete rebuild or the beginning of something better?The Lost Decade is over. Now comes the cleanup!🎙️ Chris and Tom aren't holding anything back in this emergency edition of Horseshoe Hangover!By the fans. For the fans. ALWAYS. 💙#ColtsNation #ForTheShoe #BleedBlue #NFL #HorseshoeHangover

  4. Oct 27

    2026 Week 7 Recap: Colts fall to the Vikings & Lose 3 Straight!

    Episode Chapters 00:01 – Intro & Horseshoe Hangover Social Media Updates 03:10 – Chris Explains What It Means to Be Colts Nation 03:51 – The good and the bad! 09:11 – Which Current Colts Players Deserve ContractExtensions? 11:00 – The Colts' Biggest Problem: Hint, it's not JonathanTaylor or Adetomiwa Adebawore! 19:05 – Tom Unloads on Daniel Jones: The Sample Size Is BigEnough! 21:51 – Why Chris Is Officially OUT on Shane Steichen 24:00 – Tom Explains Why Steichen Can't Develop Players 29:10 – Anthony Richardson: The Person, the Player & HowShane Failed Him 36:30 – Why Is Steichen Using JT28 Wrong? 40:48 – Jonathan Taylor's Wife Speaks Out! 44:10 – Chris Calls Out Shane Steichen's Arrogance 47:10 – Will Daniel Jones Finally Get Benched?   Three straight losses, and Colts Nation has had ENOUGH! The Indianapolis Colts fall to the Minnesota Vikings,extending their losing streak to three games. The frustration is boiling over,and Chris and Tom aren't holding anything back on this week's HorseshoeHangover! Is Daniel Jones really the answer at quarterback? Has ShaneSteichen's reputation as an offensive guru been completely exposed? And whycan't this coaching staff figure out how to properly utilize Jonathan Taylor,one of the NFL's most talented running backs? Chris explains what it truly means to be part of ColtsNation, while Tom unloads on Daniel Jones and his growing sample size ofdisappointing performances. The guys also discuss why Anthony Richardson deservesbetter, how Steichen has failed to develop his players, and why the biggestproblems with this team go far beyond individual performances. Plus, we dive into Jonathan Taylor's wife's recent socialmedia comments, Shane Steichen's arrogance, and the biggest question facingIndianapolis: Is it finally time to bench Daniel Jones? Chris and Tom bring the passion, frustration, and unfilteredopinions you've come to expect from Horseshoe Hangover! Colts Nation, we want to hear from YOU! Is ShaneSteichen the biggest problem in Indianapolis? Should Daniel Jones be benched?Or is it time to completely rebuild this organization? Drop your thoughts in the comments! Please remember to LIKE, SUBSCRIBE, and SHAREHorseshoe Hangover as we continue riding through the highs and lows ofIndianapolis Colts football together! #ColtsNation #ForTheShoe #BleedBlue #IndianapolisColts#NFL

  5. Oct 23

    2026 Week 7 Colts vs Vikings: How do the Colts respond after their GM is fired?

    https://linktr.ee/horseshoehangover horseshoehangovermailbag@gmail.com Removing the Stench of the Ballard Era: What's Next for the Colts?The Chris Ballard era is OVER, and it's time to disinfect the Indianapolis Colts organization!With Ballard out, Carlie Irsay-Gordon has an opportunity to reshape the future of this franchise. But while the on-field product has been disappointing, is there a strong culture behind the scenes worth building around?Everything is on the table, Colts Nation! It's time to use your imagination because nothing should be off-limits!🏈 Blow it up or build around the stars? Could Jonathan Taylor (JT28) be traded? Or should the Colts build their foundation around JT28 and Quenton Nelson (Q56), giving the next GM two cornerstone players to work with?🏈 Is Brian Flores auditioning for his next job? With the Vikings coming to town, could this matchup double as a sideline interview for Flores? If the next GM decides to move on from Shane Steichen, should Flores be a serious head coaching candidate?🏈 The players feel the heat! With Ballard fired, Colts players are acknowledging their responsibility. But will that accountability finally translate into better effort and results on Sundays?🏈 Carlie's next chapter! The Colts may have a strong internal culture, but can Carlie find the leadership needed to restore the winning standard established during the Manning era?The Ballard era is history. The excuses are running out. And the future of this franchise is wide open!All this and more on this week's Horseshoe Hangover Podcast!Colts Nation, let us know what YOU would do! Don't forget to like, subscribe, and drop your thoughts in the comments!#ColtsNation #ForTheShoe #HorseshoeHangover #IndianapolisColts #NFL

  6. Oct 20

    Chris Ballard is fired after an embarrassing loss to the Titans

    COLTS HIT ROCK BOTTOM! BALLARD FIRED! ISPEYTON MANNING THE ANSWER?   The Indianapolis Colts have officially hita breaking point! After an embarrassing loss to the previously winlessTennessee Titans, the Chris Ballard era is OVER! Nearly a decade of mediocrity,disappointment, and excuses has finally come to an end.   In this episode of the Horseshoe Hangover,Chris and Tom break down one of the biggest turning points in Colts franchisehistory!  CHRIS BALLARD FIRED! Was this move long overdue,and what does it mean for the future of the franchise?       CARLIE IRSAY MAKES HER FIRST BIG DECISION! TheColts' owner sends a powerful message that losing and mediocrity will no longerbe accepted in Indianapolis. BRING BACK PEYTON MANNING? We debate if theSheriff deserves serious consideration for the Colts' vacant GM position.  MEETING COLTS NATION! We share our experiencemeeting fellow Colts fans and supporters of the Horseshoe Hangover at the game!  TIME TO BLOW IT UP? Is anyone untouchable onthis roster? We discuss potential trades, and YES, that includes JonathanTaylor (JT28), DeForest Buckner, and Quenton Nelson! Nobody is off the table!   The Ballard era is over, but the harddecisions are just beginning. Is this finally the reset Colts Nation has beenwaiting for, or are we headed for another decade of disappointment?   Colts Nation, we want to hear from YOU! Whoshould be the next GM? Would you trade JT28, Buckner, or Big Q?   Like, subscribe, and leave a comment! Welove hearing from Colts Nation!   #Colts #ColtsNation #IndianapolisColts #NFL#HorseshoeHangover

  7. Oct 16

    2026 Week 6 Colts vs. Titans: A Must-Win Against the 0-5 Titans!

    Twitter /X : @SOUTHBOUNDUKPOD(3) Southbound - YouTube The Colts are desperate for answers, and apparently, one of them is signing Germaine Pratt straight off the couch! How does a guy who hasn't played all season walk into Indianapolis and potentially become our best linebacker? Meanwhile, we ask the uncomfortable question: Are the Indianapolis Colts really any better than the Tennessee Titans? After years of mediocrity, questionable leadership, and disappointing football, the two franchises might have more in common than Colts Nation wants to admit. The Titans are 0-5, and this is a game the Colts absolutely MUST win. If you can't beat the winless Titans, what does that say about your own franchise? Chris and Tom break it all down on this episode of the Horseshoe Hangover! Don't forget to like, subscribe, and let us know your thoughts, Colts Nation!

  8. Oct 13

    2026 Week 5 recap: Steelers beat the Colts, Same Mistakes & Same Results!

    Do you have questions for Chris and Tom? Send them our waythrough the Horseshoe Hangover Mailbag! We want to hear from Colts Nation!  horseshoehangovermailbag@gmail.com   Colts vs. Steelers: Same Mistakes, Same Results | Week 5Recap Another trip to Pittsburgh, another disappointing loss. TheColts fall 34-22 to the Steelers, dropping to 2-3 on the season, and this onewas filled with missed opportunities, defensive breakdowns, and plenty offrustration.   Jaylen Warren torched the Colts with explosive touchdowns of80 and 50 yards, while Aaron Rodgers picked apart the defense. Is Lou Anarumo'sdefense becoming this team's biggest liability? From questionable play-calling to an ineffective runninggame, the same problems keep showing up. At what point do we stop calling thesemistakes and start questioning the people responsible?   The Colts had opportunities to win this football game butcouldn't capitalize when it mattered most. Are we watching a talented teamunderperform, or is this simply who the Colts are? Grab your favorite beverage and join Chris and Tom foranother frustrating edition of the Horseshoe Hangover!   #Colts #ColtsNation #NFL #Steelers

See All (115)

Ratings & Reviews

5
out of 5
6 Ratings

About

Join two passionate Colts and NFL outsiders every week as we break down the latest Indianapolis Colts news, analyze key NFL matchups, and share unfiltered takes on all things football. From game recaps to league-wide insights, *The Horseshoe Hangover* offers a fresh, weekly perspective on the highs and lows of Colts Nation. Saddle up and tune in each week as we ride through the season with a drink in hand and plenty of football talk! We call it how we see it and will not hold back.

Information

  • Creator
    Tom Connolly & Chris Dyer
  • Years Active
    2024 - 2026
  • Episodes
    115
  • Rating
    Explicit
  • Copyright
    © Tom Connolly & Chris Dyer
  • Show Website
    The Horseshoe Hangover

You Might Also Like