Mystery Pie

Jesse Jaymz & Outcast
  • 5.0 (8)
  • Society & Culture
  • Weekly

Welcome to Mystery Pie, where the bizarre becomes reality and the hidden is revealed. You're not crazy for what you've experienced, there are countless others who share your encounters but remain silent, afraid of ridicule. This podcast is a sanctuary for those fringe stories. We explore the unsettling: interdimensional travel, government coverups, military secrets, ancient technology, and conspiracies buried deep within society. These are the stories that nightmares are made of. In a world that has programmed us to forget ancient truths, we find ourselves trapped in a Darwinistic, materialistic age that has deliberately distanced us from the deeper realities of our existence. At Mystery Pie, we unravel the tangled web of deception, searching for answers in a supernatural realm filled with paranormal activity. Join us as we pray together, sharpening one another as remnant warriors standing against the darkness. We contemplate the feeling of homesickness for places we’ve never been and the longing for people we’ve never met, echoes of something lost but not forgotten. Until we find the answers, everything remains a mystery.

Episodes

  1. Oct 23

    Case File #5 "The More Lost I Became, the More I Saw" - Evan’s Story

    Text the show Please stay up to date with us on our Instagram page. https://www.instagram.com/mysterypiepodcast?xtok=azM4eDZqYmJuY2Iw&utm_source=qr What happens when a lifelong fascination with the dark, the paranormal, and the unexplained leads you into experiences you can’t forget? On this episode of Mystery Pie, Evan joins us to share a deeply personal story that spans childhood paranormal encounters, shadow figures, sleep paralysis, unexplained orbs, and one unforgettable night when a massive black triangular craft appeared overhead. It was silent, dark, and close enough that he says he could have hit it with a slingshot. But the strangest part of Evan’s story isn’t just what he saw. It’s where his journey eventually led. Growing up fascinated by the macabre and spending years immersed in Detroit’s punk scene, Evan describes a period of searching, experimenting, and feeling increasingly disconnected from his faith. He shares the experiences that haunted him, the encounter that left him shaken, and the moment that began his journey back to Jesus Christ. We also discuss the questions these experiences raise about the paranormal, spiritual deception, the unknown, and how our worldview shapes the way we interpret what we encounter. We don’t claim to have every answer. We’re here to ask the questions, examine the stories, and explore the unknown through a biblical lens. Have you experienced something you can’t explain? We want to hear your story. 📧 Email us at mysterypiepodcast@protonmail.com Join us for Evan’s remarkable journey from darkness and unanswered questions toward faith, hope, and a renewed relationship with Christ. This is Mystery Pie—and there’s always another slice of the unknown. Outro message by Jenjo. Outro music by Slasher Dave Support the show SUPPORT THE SHOW Buzzsprout https://bit.ly/3m50hFT Paypal http://bit.ly/3Gv3Zjp Grubterra Dried Black Soldier Fly larvae are a healthy alternative to dried mealworms. Black Soldier Fly Larvae contain 75 times more calcium than mealworms and have the perfect calcium to phosphorus balance for chickens, turkeys, ducks, and pet birds. You're going to get stronger eggshells, healthier feathers, and a stronger ability to fight sickness due to Black soldier Fly antimicrobial benefits. Use discount code JESSE10 for 10% off the entire website!

    Case File #5 "The More Lost I Became, the More I Saw" - Evan’s Story

  2. Oct 21

    Case File #4: (part 2) "The Hat Man" - Jake's hat man visitation, shadow figures, curse over Oxford, hole in the wall, time slip, the old cowboy hat, a witch's curse, a knock on the door, the orange cat, the booms, suspended in air, cave systems, ley li

    Text the show Tonight we are back with Jake's part 2 of a 2 part episode that might make it challenging to fall asleep tonight. When mysterious events happen upon you will you be able to recognize them for what they may be? If you have a testimony to share please email us at mysterypiepodcast@protonmail.com we would love to chat with you. Follow us on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/mysterypiepodcast/ Take no part in the unfruitful deeds of darkness, but rather expose them. Ephesians 5:11 Music by our friend Slasher Dave music. https://open.spotify.com/artist/65PBVU3exQq9I0dKWaF8Zp?si=ZXDxhOTOSK-apcKeqX1OXA Support the show SUPPORT THE SHOW Buzzsprout https://bit.ly/3m50hFT Paypal http://bit.ly/3Gv3Zjp Grubterra Dried Black Soldier Fly larvae are a healthy alternative to dried mealworms. Black Soldier Fly Larvae contain 75 times more calcium than mealworms and have the perfect calcium to phosphorus balance for chickens, turkeys, ducks, and pet birds. You're going to get stronger eggshells, healthier feathers, and a stronger ability to fight sickness due to Black soldier Fly antimicrobial benefits. Use discount code JESSE10 for 10% off the entire website!

    Case File #4: (part 2) "The Hat Man" - Jake's hat man visitation, shadow figures, curse over Oxford, hole in the wall, time slip, the old cowboy hat, a witch's curse, a knock on the door, the orange cat, the booms, suspended in air, cave systems, ley li

  3. Oct 21

    Case File #4: (part 1) "Angel of Death" - Jake's stricken childhood, trauma & anxiety, serpent mound, nephilim giants, lady without a nose, premonitions, Indian artifacts, the floating furniture, Reiki grandma

    Text the show Tonight's story is from Jake, this is part 1 of a 2 part episode that will have you contemplating many things. Does childhood trauma open you up for future events that you can't seem to understand? If you have a testimony to share please email us at mysterypiepodcast@protonmail.com we would love to chat with you. Follow us on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/mysterypiepodcast/ Take no part in the unfruitful deeds of darkness, but rather expose them. Ephesians 5:11 Outro song by our friend Slasher Dave music. https://open.spotify.com/artist/65PBVU3exQq9I0dKWaF8Zp?si=ZXDxhOTOSK-apcKeqX1OXA Support the show SUPPORT THE SHOW Buzzsprout https://bit.ly/3m50hFT Paypal http://bit.ly/3Gv3Zjp Grubterra Dried Black Soldier Fly larvae are a healthy alternative to dried mealworms. Black Soldier Fly Larvae contain 75 times more calcium than mealworms and have the perfect calcium to phosphorus balance for chickens, turkeys, ducks, and pet birds. You're going to get stronger eggshells, healthier feathers, and a stronger ability to fight sickness due to Black soldier Fly antimicrobial benefits. Use discount code JESSE10 for 10% off the entire website!

    Case File #4: (part 1) "Angel of Death" - Jake's stricken childhood, trauma & anxiety, serpent mound, nephilim giants, lady without a nose, premonitions, Indian artifacts, the floating furniture, Reiki grandma

  4. Aug 19

    Case File #3: "That's Not Our Mother You're Talking To" - Kristen's Story, Spirit Boxes, Demonic Deception & Spiritual Warfare

    Text the show Kristen thought she was talking to the dead. She eventually realized she was talking to something else. When Kristen moved into an older home, strange things began almost immediately—doors slamming, unexplained voices, a child seeing something in the house, a mysterious phone ringing with no phone there, and an overwhelming feeling that she was constantly being watched. But Kristen had always been fascinated by the paranormal. So when she discovered a way to communicate with what she believed were spirits in the house, she didn't run from it. She leaned in. Until one phone call changed everything. "Kristen... that's not my mother you're talking to." What follows is a remarkable story of deception, spiritual warfare, fear, faith and ultimately transformation. Kristen recounts her experiences with psychics, spirit boxes, an apparent entity claiming to be a deceased family member, a terrifying nighttime encounter, and the moment she began to understand her experiences through a completely different lens. But the story doesn't end with the haunting. It ends with Kristen turning toward Scripture, Jesus and the people who helped her confront what she believed was in her home—and finding a peace she says she had never experienced there before. This is Case File #3. If you have a testimony to share please email us at mysterypiepodcast@protonmail.com we would love to chat with you. Take no part in the unfruitful deeds of darkness, but rather expose them. Ephesians 5:11 Outro song by our friend Slasher Dave music. https://open.spotify.com/artist/65PBVU3exQq9I0dKWaF8Zp?si=ZXDxhOTOSK-apcKeqX1OXA Support the show SUPPORT THE SHOW Buzzsprout https://bit.ly/3m50hFT Paypal http://bit.ly/3Gv3Zjp Grubterra Dried Black Soldier Fly larvae are a healthy alternative to dried mealworms. Black Soldier Fly Larvae contain 75 times more calcium than mealworms and have the perfect calcium to phosphorus balance for chickens, turkeys, ducks, and pet birds. You're going to get stronger eggshells, healthier feathers, and a stronger ability to fight sickness due to Black soldier Fly antimicrobial benefits. Use discount code JESSE10 for 10% off the entire website! Support the show SUPPORT THE SHOW Buzzsprout https://bit.ly/3m50hFT Paypal http://bit.ly/3Gv3Zjp Grubterra Dried Black Soldier Fly larvae are a healthy alternative to dried mealworms. Black Soldier Fly Larvae contain 75 times more calcium than mealworms and have the perfect calcium to phosphorus balance for chickens, turkeys, ducks, and pet birds. You're going to get stronger eggshells, healthier feathers, and a stronger ability to fight sickness due to Black soldier Fly antimicrobial benefits. Use discount code JESSE10 for 10% off the entire website!

    Case File #3: "That's Not Our Mother You're Talking To" - Kristen's Story, Spirit Boxes, Demonic Deception & Spiritual Warfare

  5. 11/06/2024

    Case File #2: "Don't Mess with Ouija Boards" - Greasy Dave, calling spirits, haunted house sleep over, psychic medium, seven years bad luck

    Text the show Join Jesse, Outcast and our special guest Greasy Dave as they take a trip back to the early 80's to walk through a real life encounter with the supernatural through the use of a Ouija board. This is a next level encounter that gives a dire warning of why no one should ever mess with this type thing. This isn't your typical random ghostly encounter but rather a cautionary tale with an incredible beginning middle and end. Sit back, relax and get ready for a goosebump trip down memory lane. If you have a testimony to share please email us at mysterypiepodcast@protonmail.com we would love to chat with you. Take no part in the unfruitful deeds of darkness, but rather expose them. Ephesians 5:11 Outro song by our friend Slasher Dave music. https://open.spotify.com/artist/65PBVU3exQq9I0dKWaF8Zp?si=ZXDxhOTOSK-apcKeqX1OXA Support the show SUPPORT THE SHOW Buzzsprout https://bit.ly/3m50hFT Paypal http://bit.ly/3Gv3Zjp Grubterra Dried Black Soldier Fly larvae are a healthy alternative to dried mealworms. Black Soldier Fly Larvae contain 75 times more calcium than mealworms and have the perfect calcium to phosphorus balance for chickens, turkeys, ducks, and pet birds. You're going to get stronger eggshells, healthier feathers, and a stronger ability to fight sickness due to Black soldier Fly antimicrobial benefits. Use discount code JESSE10 for 10% off the entire website!

    Case File #2: "Don't Mess with Ouija Boards" - Greasy Dave, calling spirits, haunted house sleep over, psychic medium, seven years bad luck

  6. 11/01/2024

    Case File #1: "Jennifer, Open Your Eyes" sleep paralysis, shadow figures, Freemasonry, premonitions

    Text the show Tonight we offer you a look into the paranormal and supernatural as we chat with Jennifer and hear her story about unknown visitations that seem to stem from the freemason connections of her grandfather. If you have a testimony to share please email us at mysterypiepodcast@protonmail.com we would love to chat with you. Take no part in the unfruitful deeds of darkness, but rather expose them. Ephesians 5:11 Outro song by our friend Slasher Dave music. https://open.spotify.com/artist/65PBVU3exQq9I0dKWaF8Zp?si=ZXDxhOTOSK-apcKeqX1OXA Support the show SUPPORT THE SHOW Buzzsprout https://bit.ly/3m50hFT Paypal http://bit.ly/3Gv3Zjp Grubterra Dried Black Soldier Fly larvae are a healthy alternative to dried mealworms. Black Soldier Fly Larvae contain 75 times more calcium than mealworms and have the perfect calcium to phosphorus balance for chickens, turkeys, ducks, and pet birds. You're going to get stronger eggshells, healthier feathers, and a stronger ability to fight sickness due to Black soldier Fly antimicrobial benefits. Use discount code JESSE10 for 10% off the entire website!

    Case File #1: "Jennifer, Open Your Eyes" sleep paralysis, shadow figures, Freemasonry, premonitions
  • 6 Episodes

Ratings & Reviews

5
out of 5
8 Ratings

About

Welcome to Mystery Pie, where the bizarre becomes reality and the hidden is revealed. You're not crazy for what you've experienced, there are countless others who share your encounters but remain silent, afraid of ridicule. This podcast is a sanctuary for those fringe stories. We explore the unsettling: interdimensional travel, government coverups, military secrets, ancient technology, and conspiracies buried deep within society. These are the stories that nightmares are made of. In a world that has programmed us to forget ancient truths, we find ourselves trapped in a Darwinistic, materialistic age that has deliberately distanced us from the deeper realities of our existence. At Mystery Pie, we unravel the tangled web of deception, searching for answers in a supernatural realm filled with paranormal activity. Join us as we pray together, sharpening one another as remnant warriors standing against the darkness. We contemplate the feeling of homesickness for places we’ve never been and the longing for people we’ve never met, echoes of something lost but not forgotten. Until we find the answers, everything remains a mystery.

Information

  • Creator
    Jesse Jaymz & Outcast
  • Years Active
    2024 - 2026
  • Episodes
    6
  • Rating
    Clean
  • Copyright
    © 2026 Mystery Pie
  • Show Website
    Mystery Pie

You Might Also Like