RMZ Science Works

Robert K. Merton Zentrum für Wissenschaftsforschung

Der Podcast des Robert K. Merton Zentrums für Wissenschaftsforschung

  1. Nov 5

    Jacqueline Sachse: Nudging attention & shaping relevance. How citation rates influence academic literature assessment

    Citations and altmetrics are prominently displayed in academic search systems, but what role do they actually play when researchers decide which literature deserves closer attention? Drawing on an exploratory user study with fifty researchers from the life and social sciences, this talk traces how researchers use scientometric indicators alongside other relevance clues when assessing scholarly articles. Participants evaluated predefined search results while thinking aloud, allowing their interactions with experimentally modified indicators to be examined across the search process.The findings suggest that indicators shape attention more than final relevance judgements. Highly cited articles attracted more attention during search-result inspection, with participants often interpreting indicators through a simple “more-is-better” heuristic. At later stages, however, relevance judgements were grounded mainly in topical criteria. Increased attention to highly cited articles therefore did not automatically translate into a corresponding increase in perceived relevance.The talk argues that scientometric indicators function as stage-dependent relevance clues rather than straightforward proxies for relevance. They can shape researchers’ attention without necessarily determining what they ultimately consider relevant. This highlights the importance of examining relevance assessment as a process in which attention and relevance are closely connected, but not interchangeable.

  2. Jul 22

    Cornelia Schendzielorz /Justo Serrano-Zamora /Staffan Edling: Science under pressure: Engaging with science and democracy in hybrid sites

    Informationen zum Master-Studiengang Wissenschaftsforschung der Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin: https://hu.berlin/ma_wifo Science and politics are becoming increasingly intertwined. Our project starts from two related expressions of this development: increasing political expectations on science and the proliferation of sites that hybridize science and politics. Against this background, we seek to understand (i) how the potentially conflicting demands that scientists face as they engage with political actors feed back into epistemic practice, (ii) how epistemic practices of scientists interact with other epistemic practices and modes of representation at hybrid sites and (iii) how democratic organizational governance interact with epistemic practices. To explore these questions, we have selected 4-6 hybrid sites, including think tanks, political research institutes, NGOs, and social movements for an empirical multi-method analysis combining participant observation with qualitative interviews and document analysis. The project aims to develop a concept of epistemic-political orientations (EPOs) and generate innovative theoretical analysis of the influence of political actors on epistemic practices. Through empirical work, it explores convergences and divergences of democratic and epistemic practices in hybrid organizations in order to gain leverage on broader theoretical questions on the interaction between democracy and the sciences.

  3. Jun 10

    Susanne Wollin-Giering & Markus Hoffmann: Epistemic factors affecting the (dis)continuation of research with missing resources

    This talk discusses the possibilities of researchers to continue their work in situations where access to previously held resources is constrained. We start from the assumption that academic researchers rely on specific resources to be able to work. While many of these resources are usually provided by research organizations like universities, scientific communities remain the primary reference point for the work of researchers. The result is that some resources need to be acquired from elsewhere and that research can in some cases be continued without organizational support. The resulting situation is undertheorized by both organization and work studies (because they treat the full provision of resources for employees as a given and the content of work as unproblematic) and science studies (because of their focus on funding as the primary type of resource). We propose to fill this gap by treating the provision of resources as a variable on the one hand and by establishing a link between conditions of research, planned and conducted research processes, and necessary adaptions of researchers to changes in their conditions on the other hand. We present results from interviews in projects investigating two situations where previously secured access to resources becomes constrained: the unemployment of researchers and the COVID-19 pandemic. The two situations can be compared through conceptualizing their effect on researchers as a change of access in resources. We focus on a comparison of two fields, plant biology and ethnology, to show how different career stages, the timing of research processes, and field-specificity impact the possibilities of researchers to continue working during these situations.

About

Der Podcast des Robert K. Merton Zentrums für Wissenschaftsforschung