Exhuming the Truth

Asha Carmody

Exhuming the Truth is a True Crime podcast hosted by a forensic biologist, toxicologist, criminologist, and forensic investigations research student, Asha Walther. With several years of experience in cold case analysis, Asha explores cold cases, current cases, missing persons, no-body murders, sexual assaults, domestic violence-related crimes, and more while discussing old, current, and emerging forensic techniques that detail many crimes. You will hear from expert guests, victims of crime, and other special guests.   So, get comfortable while we open our next case file and attempt to Exhume the Truth.

  1. 5d ago

    Field Notes with Chris D'Arcy - President of Search Dogs Sydney Part Two

    This conversation goes where many avoid. In Part Two of Exhuming the Truth Presents: Field Notes, we continue our discussion with Chris D’Arcy, President of Search Dogs Sydney, moving beyond search operations into the deeper realities of missing persons work rarely spoken about publicly. This episode explores the systemic barriers in the missing persons space, the challenges that can affect search efforts, and the difficult conversations around advocacy, resources, coordination, and the realities of frontline work. We also take an in depth look at the extraordinary lengths search teams go to in their efforts to help families searching for answers. The physical demands, emotional toll, unseen work, and unwavering commitment behind the mission to locate missing people. These are conversations many avoid. Conversations that can be uncomfortable. Conversations that matter. This episode offers a rare insight into the complexities behind missing persons investigations and search operations from someone living that reality. Because understanding the system is part of improving it. Exhuming the Truth Presents: Field Notes with Chris D’Arcy Part Two is out now.

    1h 3m

  2. May 21

    Field Notes with Chris D'Arcy - President of Search Dogs Sydney Part One

    EXHUMING THE TRUTH PRESENTS: FIELD NOTES Episode One: Chris Darcy – President of Search Dogs Sydney What happens behind the scenes when someone goes missing? In the first episode of Exhuming the Truth: Field Notes, we step into the world of search operations with Chris Darcy, President of Search Dogs Sydney, for a conversation exploring the critical work undertaken by specialist search teams and the remarkable partnership between handlers and highly trained search dogs. In this episode, Chris shares insight into the realities of search work, the challenges faced in the field, and why collaboration, training, and community involvement can play such an important role when vulnerable people disappear. This is Part One of our discussion, an introduction and preview into a much deeper conversation still to come. Due to technical issues during recording, this interview has been released in two parts, with Part Two delivering an extended deep dive next week. Field Notes is a new Exhuming the Truth series that brings listeners closer to the people working on the ground, the searchers, specialists, advocates, and professionals who help shape investigations, support communities, and pursue answers. Views expressed are those of the individuals involved and are intended for educational, awareness, and advocacy purposes. You can find more about Chris and Search Dogs Sydney at: https://searchdogssydney.org

    18 min

  3. May 19

    The Strongsville Crash: What Happened to Dominic Russo and Davion Flanagan

    In the early hours of July 31st, 2022 in Strongsville Ohio, 17-year-old Mackenzie Shirilla drove her Toyota Camry carrying her boyfriend, 20-year-old Dominic Russo and friend 19-year-old Davion Flanagan into a brick building at 100mph, that's around 160kmph. What was initially considered a tragic crash, forensic and reconstructive evidence began to show otherwise. Today, Asha unravels the complexity of this case that recently showcases on Netflix documentaries, "The Crash", going into great detail of how and why the evidence is stacked on one side of the fence. This episode is dedicated to the lives of Dominic Russo and Davion Flanagan.

    57 min

  4. May 14

    No Justice for Isla Bell

    Isla Bell was 19 years of age with the world at her feet when she went missing in October of 2024. Come November 2024, her remains were found at a waste facility in Dandenong, Victoria. But this was just the beginning of a nightmare for Isla's family seeking justice for her life, when forensic science met challenges that seemed to hinder her case when it finally faced court. As of May 2026, the accused is facing no charges. Sit with us and listen to Asha discuss this case from beginning to end, including what evidence is available that the prosecution believes is not enough for a conviction.

    39 min

  5. May 5

    Where is Gus Lamont? Missing SA

    Four year old Gus Lamont vanished without a trace from his family’s remote outback property in South Australia, sparking one of the largest missing person searches in the state’s history. Hundreds of searchers, specialist trackers, drones, helicopters, and police scoured the rugged landscape, yet not a single trace of Gus was found. What began as a desperate search for a missing child has since evolved into a major crime investigation, with police ruling out the possibility that Gus simply wandered away and identifying a suspect known to him. In this episode of Exhuming the Truth, we examine the timeline of Gus’s disappearance, the forensic and investigative challenges posed by the remote environment, the search strategies employed, the inconsistencies that shifted police focus, and the disturbing questions that remain unanswered in one of Australia’s most haunting recent child disappearance cases. Where is Gus Lamont, and what really happened on that isolated station? Sources and case background include publicly available reporting on the investigation and police updates.

    32 min

  6. Apr 30

    Justice for Shandee Blackburn and how her case exposed QLD Forensics

    In this episode of Exhuming the Truth, we examine the devastating murder of Shandee Blackburn and the extraordinary failures that followed in the pursuit of justice. What should have been a straightforward forensic investigation instead became one of Australia’s most confronting examples of systemic forensic failure. Shandee’s case exposed serious deficiencies within the Queensland DNA laboratory, raising national concerns about testing standards, quality assurance, contamination risks, and the handling of critical biological evidence. We break down the timeline of Shandee’s murder, the investigation that followed, the controversial forensic issues uncovered during the case, and how those failures ultimately triggered widespread scrutiny of forensic practices in Queensland. We also explore the broader implications for the criminal justice system and what happens when the science intended to secure justice instead undermines it. This episode is not only about the tragic loss of a young woman, but about how one case forced an entire forensic system into the spotlight and ignited urgent calls for reform. Listener discretion is advised due to discussion of violence, homicide, and systemic justice failures.

    28 min

  7. Apr 21

    Exposing a Global "Rape Academy"

    In this episode of Exhuming the Truth, Asha breaks down CNN’s investigation into a global online “rape academy” network and explores how digital spaces can facilitate real-world sexual violence. Drawing on the Dominique Pelicot case in France and institutional findings in Australia, this episode examines how abuse is enabled through systems, culture, and silence. Content warning: sexual violence. This episode also contains an audio excerpt from ABC WA Regional Drive radio station with Annie Gaffney from 21-04-2026.

    34 min

  8. Apr 14

    Why Can You Watch Trials in the U.S....But Not in Australia

    In the United States, you can watch a trial unfold in real time—witnesses, evidence, and verdicts broadcast to millions through networks like my favourite, Court TV. But in Australia, courtrooms remain largely closed to cameras. So why the difference? In this episode of Exhuming the Truth, we break down the key distinctions between the U.S. and Australian criminal justice systems—from televised trials and jury dynamics to sentencing laws and the role of media in shaping public perception. We explore how high-profile cases, like the defamation trial between Johnny Depp and Amber Heard, have blurred the line between justice and entertainment—and why that level of exposure is unlikely to happen in Australia. But beyond the surface, this episode asks a deeper question... Does justice work better when the public can see everything… or when the system protects the process, even if we can’t? This is a conversation about transparency, fairness, and the evolving relationship between media and the law.

    31 min
See All (59)

Ratings & Reviews

5
out of 5
2 Ratings

About

Exhuming the Truth is a True Crime podcast hosted by a forensic biologist, toxicologist, criminologist, and forensic investigations research student, Asha Walther. With several years of experience in cold case analysis, Asha explores cold cases, current cases, missing persons, no-body murders, sexual assaults, domestic violence-related crimes, and more while discussing old, current, and emerging forensic techniques that detail many crimes. You will hear from expert guests, victims of crime, and other special guests.   So, get comfortable while we open our next case file and attempt to Exhume the Truth.

Information

  • Creator
    Asha Carmody
  • Years Active
    2025 - 2026
  • Episodes
    59
  • Rating
    Explicit
  • Copyright
    © Asha Carmody
  • Show Website
    Exhuming the Truth

You Might Also Like