Wickedly Judged

Rebecca Watkins
  • 4.2 (5)
  • True Crime
  • Updated Weekly

What if the system meant to protect us is the one that fails us the most? Wickedly Judged is a true crime podcast exposing wrongful convictions, broken justice, and the people whose lives are forever changed by the system. Hosted by Rebecca, the show dives deep into real cases and the human stories behind them — the families, the loved ones, and the empty seats that are never forgotten. Inspired by her husband’s wrongful conviction, Rebecca brings truth, heart, and fearless advocacy to every episode. This is more than a podcast — it’s a mission, a voice for the unheard, and a fight for justice reform.

  1. The Knife, The Witnesses, and The Missing Weapon

    3d ago

    The Knife, The Witnesses, and The Missing Weapon

    “THE KNIFE” In the opening episode of this investigative series, Rebecca breaks down one of the most disputed and troubling aspects of the Johnny Watkins case — the knife. This episode focuses on: Conflicting witness statements surrounding who possessed the knifeTestimony placing Caleb Angel in possession of the knife before, during, and after the stabbingContradictions involving who allegedly disposed of the weaponStatements suggesting Billy Robinson admitted to disposing of the knifeWhy the alleged murder weapon was never recoveredThe importance of forensic evidence in homicide investigationsHow conflicting narratives affect witness credibility and reliabilityWhy the absence of physical evidence matters when testimony becomes the centerpiece of a prosecutionRebecca walks listeners through the inconsistencies found throughout witness statements, interrogation materials, and trial testimony while explaining why these contradictions became central constitutional concerns in the motion for leave. The episode also examines how witness credibility becomes critically important when there is no recovered weapon, limited forensic corroboration, and conflicting narratives from multiple witnesses. Topics Covered Missing weaponWitness contradictionsKnife possession inconsistenciesDisposal inconsistenciesWitness credibilityForensic limitationsReliability concernsConstitutional questionsInvestigative inconsistenciesSupport & Follow the Case Visit: www.wickedlyjudged.com Support investigations, purchase merchandise, donate, and help spread awareness surrounding wrongful convictions and justice reform.

    22 min
  2. Voices They Tried to Silence

    May 28

    Voices They Tried to Silence

    The Rob McCoy, Tony Viola, Dawn Pasela, and the Fight Against Wrongful Convictions” In this powerful episode of Wickedly Judged, Rebecca is joined by Rob McCoy for an emotional and eye-opening discussion surrounding allegations of wrongful convictions, prosecutorial misconduct, coercive plea tactics, and the suspicious death of Dawn Pasela. Rob shares his personal experience becoming entangled in a federal mortgage fraud investigation connected to the Tony Viola case and explains how aggressive prosecution tactics, financial destruction, and threats against families can pressure innocent people into guilty pleas. The conversation dives deep into: The federal mortgage fraud prosecutions tied to Tony ViolaAllegations of prosecutorial misconduct and witness coercionThe emotional and financial devastation caused by wrongful convictionsHow plea deals are often driven by fear rather than guiltThe suspicious circumstances surrounding Dawn Pasela’s deathConcerns regarding investigative irregularities and lack of transparencyThe long-term effects wrongful convictions have on families and communitiesConviction Integrity Units and the issue of “self-policing”The need for independent conviction review boardsWrongful Conviction Day and growing national advocacy efforts“A New Dawn for Justice” and efforts to support wrongfully convicted individuals and their familiesThroughout the episode, Rebecca and Rob discuss the larger systemic failures within the justice system and why public awareness, advocacy, and accountability are critical in preventing innocent people from being lost inside the system. This episode contains discussions involving wrongful convictions, family trauma, incarceration, alleged misconduct, and death investigations. If you believe in justice, transparency, and accountability, this is an episode you do not want to miss. Topics Discussed: Wrongful ConvictionsJustice ReformTony ViolaDawn PaselaPlea Deal CoercionProsecutorial MisconductConviction Integrity UnitsAdvocacy for the Wrongfully ConvictedIndependent Review BoardsCriminal Justice ReformWrongful Conviction DayFamily Impact of IncarcerationEvidence Review & Investigations Support Wickedly Judged and the Wickedly Judged Justice Activation Project by sharing this episode, spreading awareness, and helping amplify the voices of families fighting for justice.

    1h 16m
  3. Forgotten Warriors: Veterans Behind Bars

    May 21

    Forgotten Warriors: Veterans Behind Bars

    Episode Notes Wickedly Judged Podcast Military Appreciation Month Special “Forgotten Warriors: Veterans Behind Bars” During Military Appreciation Month, we honor the men and women who served this country — but tonight we focus on the veterans America too often forgets. In this powerful episode of Wickedly Judged, Rebecca explores the connection between military service, trauma, PTSD, addiction, incarceration, and systemic failure inside the criminal justice system. This episode dives into: The psychological impact of combat and military conditioningPTSD, traumatic brain injuries, addiction, and hypervigilanceThe pipeline from untreated trauma to incarcerationHow prison can mirror survival environments veterans experienced during combatThe alarming number of veterans currently incarcerated in the United StatesHow military service and combat training are sometimes used against veterans in courtroomsTrauma responses being misunderstood as guiltWrongful convictions involving veteransVeteran treatment courts and systemic gaps in supportThe impact incarceration has on veteran familiesWhy society celebrates veterans publicly but often abandons them privatelyThis episode is not about excusing crime. It is about asking difficult questions: How does someone go from serving their country… to serving time? And what responsibility does society have after the uniform comes off? This conversation also connects directly to the mission of the Wickedly Judged Justice Activation Project — advocating for justice, exposing systemic failures, supporting families, and helping bring attention to the people society often forgets. If this episode impacted you: Share this episodeStart difficult conversationsSupport veteran mental health advocacySupport prison reformSupport wrongful conviction awarenessBecause honoring veterans means more than saying “thank you for your service.” It means caring about what happens after deployment. #WickedlyJudged #MilitaryAppreciationMonth #Veterans #PTSD #WrongfulConvictions #VeteranAdvocacy #JusticeReform #MentalHealthAwareness #PrisonReform #WJJAP

    34 min
  4. Why I Went Silent-Building Something Bigger

    May 7

    Why I Went Silent-Building Something Bigger

    Episode Notes Wickedly Judged — “Why I Went Silent — Building Something Bigger” Episode summary In this personal update episode, Rebecca shares why Wickedly Judged went quiet—and why that silence wasn’t the end of the mission, but the foundation of something bigger. Behind the scenes, she has been drafting legal motions connected to her husband’s case, building a parole packet for an upcoming June hearing, and carrying the emotional and financial weight that so many wrongful-conviction families live with every day. Rebecca also explains a critical turning point: after a case became serious and a family began receiving threats, she removed prior episodes to protect people’s safety. That decision led to a deeper realization—this work can’t survive as a one-person effort without structure. Out of that reality, the Wickedly Judged Justice Activation Project (WJJAP) was born: an advocacy and justice reform organization focused on wrongful convictions, education, investigative advocacy, and community action. The episode closes with a clear call to action for listeners to volunteer, share, learn, and help build an organized movement that supports impacted families. In this episode · Why the podcast went silent (and what was happening off-mic) · Writing motions and learning legal procedure without formal training · Building a parole packet for a June parole hearing · The emotional labor of advocacy and secondary trauma · The financial barriers families face in post-conviction fights · Safety concerns and why episodes were removed · Why the mission needed structure beyond one person · Introducing WJJAP and its focus: education, advocacy, investigation, and action · Volunteer opportunities and how listeners can help Key themes · Truth vs. procedure · Emotional imprisonment of families · Access to justice and access to resources · Responsible advocacy and safety · Building sustainable, organized reform work Resources & links (placeholders) · Volunteer / Get involved: volunteer@wickedlyjudged.com · Contact: info@wickedlyjudged.com · Website: wickedlyjudged.com Calls to action · Share the episode with someone who cares about justice reform · Volunteer your skills (research, organizing, outreach, fundraising, media) · Educate yourself on wrongful convictions and post-conviction barriers · Support impacted families by amplifying responsibly and safely

    23 min
  5. Wickedly Judged: “No Cash Bail” & Bail Reform Interview with Ken W. Good

    Mar 12

    Wickedly Judged: “No Cash Bail” & Bail Reform Interview with Ken W. Good

    Episode Summary In this episode of Wickedly Judged, Rebecca sits down with Ken W. Good, a Texas bail attorney and board member of the Professional Bondsmen of Texas, for a pre-recorded conversation about “no cash bail” and the realities of bail reform. The discussion explores what bail is supposed to do, what reform is trying to fix, and why accountability and real-world outcomes matter when policies change. Guest Ken W. Good — Texas bail attorney; Board Member, Professional Bondsmen of TexasWhat This Episode Covers What people mean when they say “no cash bail”The purpose of bail and how it functions in real casesThe goals of bail reform and the problems it’s trying to addressConcerns, tradeoffs, and implementation issues that get missed in headlinesWhy reform must be rooted in facts, fairness, and accountabilitySponsors (Thank You) Veteran Alliance — supporting those who have served and their familiesYarntherapy4me — crocheting beautiful, handmade bags with heartJust an Apron — creating sweet treats that bring a little joy to every dayLiberty First Radio — a veteran-owned online radio station giving a platform to voices that need to be heardNDVLB (No Disabled Veteran Left Behind) — helping veterans fill out paperwork for benefitsPrimeLedger Group — bookkeeping, taxes, payroll, and CFO advisory servicesSpecial thanks to JP Verse of Versefire Records for the intro/outro musicCall to Action Follow/subscribe to Wickedly JudgedShare this episode with someone who cares about justice reform (or needs a fuller conversation about bail reform)Leave a rating and written reviewJoin the conversation on social media: What should bail reform look like in practice?Support the mission via donations or advocacy merch (see show notes links)Have a case, documents, or leads? Reach out—submissions are reviewed seriouslyClosing Message “As always, stay informed, stay vigilant, and stay hopeful. Because NOBODY deserves to be Wickedly Judged.”

    51 min
  6. Thanksgiving Without Them: Standing with Families of the Wrongfully Convicted

    11/27/2025

    Thanksgiving Without Them: Standing with Families of the Wrongfully Convicted

    This week on Wickedly Judged, we’re taking a brief pause from our regular case coverage for the Thanksgiving holiday. In this short, heartfelt message, Rebecca shares: Why there is no new case episode this weekHow holidays can be especially painful for families living with wrongful convictionsHer own experience of facing an empty chair at the table while her husband remains wrongfully incarceratedA message of solidarity for every family who feels that same ache this seasonA reminder that grief and gratitude can exist together—you can be thankful and still deeply miss the person who should be homeRebecca also takes a moment to thank the incredible sponsors who help make Wickedly Judged possible: Veteran AllianceYarntherapy4meJust an ApronLiberty First RadioJP Verse of Versefire Records – and a special thank you for creating our intro and outro musicEven though we’re not releasing a new case this week, our mission of Reform through Advocacy continues. We’ll be back next week with more stories, more truth-seeking, and more fight for justice. In the meantime, we invite you to: Revisit past episodes you may have missedShare Wickedly Judged with someone who cares about justice reformHold space in your heart for the families with empty chairs this holidayFrom all of us at Wickedly Judged: Happy Thanksgiving. You’re not alone.

    8 min
  7. Weaponized Justice: The Case of Joshua Lee Mosher and the System That Failed Him

    11/20/2025

    Weaponized Justice: The Case of Joshua Lee Mosher and the System That Failed Him

    In this special full-length episode, Wickedly Judged unpacks the complete story of Joshua Lee Mosher—a man whose life was shattered by a wrongful conviction fueled by revenge, police tunnel vision, and a justice system obsessed with conviction rates over truth. Host Rebecca guides listeners through the timeline of Josh’s case, revealing how a toxic relationship with his ex, Jackie, spiraled into a calculated plot for revenge. When Jackie vowed to “make him pay for crossing the wrong woman,” the justice system became her weapon. With Detective Tamminga at the helm—an investigator who secured convictions in every sexual assault case he touched—Josh never stood a chance. Instead of seeking truth, the investigation zeroed in on guilt from the start, ignoring alternative leads and motives. Listeners will hear the emotional voices of Amanda (Josh’s sister) and Bethany (his partner and advocate), who share the heartbreak, hope, and relentless fight for justice that have defined this journey. Their advocacy uncovers evidence of a social media revenge plot, exposes the dangers of unchecked police power, and highlights the devastating impact of a system where a 100% conviction rate is rewarded with a promotion to Sheriff. Key Moments The revenge plot: Jackie’s vow and the weaponization of the justice systemDetective Tamminga’s tunnel vision and 100% conviction rateThe legal rollercoaster: trial, conviction, and years of denied appealsAmanda and Bethany’s fight—new evidence and hope for JoshReflections on systemic failure and the urgent need for reformSponsors Special thanks to our sponsors: Veteran Alliance | Yarntherapy4me | Just an Apron | Liberty First Radio And to JP Verse of Versefire Records for our intro/outro music. Take Action Share this episode to raise awarenessVisit: wickedlyjudged.com for Josh’s full story and ways to helpContact your representatives and demand wrongful conviction reviewSupport our sponsors and advocacy effortsThank you for listening and being part of the movement for justice.

    18 min
  8. Timeline of Injustice: The Case of Joshua Lee Mosher Continued

    11/13/2025

    Timeline of Injustice: The Case of Joshua Lee Mosher Continued

    In this follow-up episode, Wickedly Judged continues the powerful exploration of the wrongful conviction of Joshua Lee Mosher. Host Rebecca recaps the crucial details of Josh’s case—a story marked by a toxic home environment, a controversial investigation, and years of denied appeals. Picking up with the second half of a moving interview, listeners hear directly from Amanda (Josh’s sister) and Bethany (his girlfriend and advocate) as they share the emotional toll of Josh’s conviction and their ongoing fight for justice. This episode is a testament to the resilience of families and the importance of advocacy in the face of injustice. With renewed hope from new evidence and relentless support, Amanda and Bethany’s voices remind us why exposing wrongful convictions matters now more than ever. Key Moments Standardized Introduction: Rebecca reiterates the mission to expose wrongful convictions and thanks all sponsors.Recap: A concise summary of Josh’s case timeline and the previous episode’s highlights.Interview (Part 2): The conclusion of the heartfelt conversation with Amanda and Bethany, revealing new insights and personal reflections.Host Reflections: Rebecca shares takeaways on the human cost of wrongful convictions.Expanded Call to Action: Clear, actionable steps for listeners to support Josh and justice reform.Sponsors A heartfelt thank you to our sponsors for making this episode possible: Veteran Alliance: Supporting those who have served and their families.Yarntherapy4me: Crocheting beautiful, handmade bags with heart.Just an Apron: Creating sweet treats that bring a little joy to every day.Liberty First Radio: A veteran-owned online radio station giving a platform to voices that need to be heard.JP Verse of Versefire Records: Providing our powerful intro and outro music.Resources & Links Learn More About Josh’s Case: wickedlyjudged.comSupport Our Advocacy: Donate or shop merchandise to help us keep fighting for the innocent.Contact Your Representatives: Urge them to support wrongful conviction review and justice reform.Got Information? Reach out via our website if you have tips or resources that could help Josh or others.Connect with Us Website: wickedlyjudged.comFacebook: facebook.com/wickedlyjudgedInstagram: instagram.com/wickedlyjudgedTwitter/X: twitter.com/wickedlyjudgedCall to Action If you were moved by Josh’s story, please share this episode, leave a review, and subscribe to Wickedly Judged. Every listen, share, and donation helps us keep fighting for the innocent and pushing for real justice reform. Thank you for listening and for being a part of the movement for justice.

    50 min
See All (46)

Trailer

4.2
out of 5
5 Ratings

About

What if the system meant to protect us is the one that fails us the most? Wickedly Judged is a true crime podcast exposing wrongful convictions, broken justice, and the people whose lives are forever changed by the system. Hosted by Rebecca, the show dives deep into real cases and the human stories behind them — the families, the loved ones, and the empty seats that are never forgotten. Inspired by her husband’s wrongful conviction, Rebecca brings truth, heart, and fearless advocacy to every episode. This is more than a podcast — it’s a mission, a voice for the unheard, and a fight for justice reform.

Information

  • Creator
    Rebecca Watkins
  • Years Active
    2025 - 2026
  • Episodes
    46
  • Rating
    Clean
  • Copyright
    © Wickedly Judged 2025
  • Show Website
    Wickedly Judged